[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biodiversity#Human_health
Re-reading my comment I realize it sounds like low-key creationism BS which was not my intention.
I suspect whether to draw the line to make 'nature' include or exclude humans is very similar to whether to include or exclude the observer in quantum mechanics.
Both perspectives are entirely reasonable, but they are useful in different circumstances.
Sure, but now that we have this evolutionary mechanism we also have more responsibility than cyanobacteria (which is what my original comment was about).
But my point here is more that we are not consciously-created products, at least not yet. For now, we're still the results of a "natural" evolutionary process.
> existing in or derived from nature; not made or caused by humankind.
So when you are trying to say that what is caused by humans is natural too, then you are clearly contradicting the dictionary definition of the word. Which is what I was trying to draw your attention to when I asked the question.
I recommend Adam Curtis' "All watched over by machines of loving grace" as an exploration of the theme.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Watched_Over_by_Machines_o...
The point of my comment (and of Curtis' series) is that there is no magical "natural balance" that we could strive to return to. It just doesn't exist, and never has. However, and without wanting to make this into a flamewar: the concept of a natural order of things is very convenient for people in power, or even just people in comfortable, moderate luxury, to justify their privilege over others' misery.
The idea that there is a "sweet spot" for ecosystems that they return to was unfortunately firmly established in the mind of many while it was "scientific consensus" (scare quotes to indicate what a fraught concept that is).
While the idea was being popularized, the idea of natural balance was already being scientifically dismantled, but by then the "damage" was done, and now we get to still discuss this...
To further internalize your point, rather than talking about "ideal" wolves, which as you established is not a thing, I will think of it as the ideal change in wolves. That number could be positive or negative as a function of time and location.
So what would you rather have? A few sheep gone missing or the lurking danger of a debilitating, potentially life threatening condition carried by an insect the size of a needle pin?
Interestingly, parasites with complex lifecycles are good indicators of biodiversity in general, because they lodge in multiple different hosts across the different levels of the ecosystem.
Wolves hunt deer. Deer carry ticks. Ticks threaten humans.
https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2019/02/ticks-ca...
And whether humans like wolves depends on whether eg we'd want to hunt deer for food.
Sure, ticks may kill deer and I guess you can call that a predator but not in the same way as a wolf. Ecosystems are incredibly fragile. The consequences of replacing one species with another are completely unpredictable.
I am saying that the changes in Yellowstone are pleasing to humans eg because we value diversity, but it's hard (or impossible) to make an absolute judgement call.
This is a very big if and of great consequence to humans. We make conscious decisions but we are not omniscient.
There is indeed a cosmic doom awaiting us if we blindly follow our hubris. We can't know the consequences of life without wolves. Our ability to realize that and acknowledge what we do not know then override our instincts is what separates us from the cyanobacteria.
A desert is at equilibrium, if we plant stuff and water it, it's more diverse and ecologically better.
Often conservation requires active maintenance to keep the benefits. Usually this maintenance occured as a side effect of historical human activity (resource extraction, grazing, hunting, fire).
As humans do less interaction with the environment as they progress in cities they make nature less bio diverse paradoxically.
Perhaps we can stake a claim to this when the modern civilization building, terra-forming human has existed for million years. Meanwhile natural processes have been at it for billions.
I don't really think this theme was sustained through the article, but it just starts off in the wrong spot. Nature isn't balanced in any meaningful sense. It lurches from one equilibrium to another in a haphazard way [0]. Equilibriums only appear because all the many unequilibriums die out, so by evolution everything rapidly reaches equilibrium.
Also this idea that humans are somehow above nature is not realistic. We are nature, in the same way everything else is. What we are doing is pushing the world to a new equilibrium. The history of everything will class us in the same pool of "sorta-terraforming" species as cyanobacteria. If we can make the world work without wolves, that is the new natural and there is no particular reason to believe there is some sort of cosmic doom awaiting us for our hubris.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotka%E2%80%93Volterra_equatio...