News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by Spooky23 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:48PM (#25172641)
Are you ok? I’ve never heard any anyone this thrilled about an ad experience in my life.
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by jedberg on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:08PM (#25172786)
I'm fine, thanks. :)

The purpose of ads is to inform people of things they wouldn't otherwise know about. In that regard, I appreciate good ads that tell me about things I would want to know about and didn't already.

For example, some of the ads I get are for live shows (back in the before times). These are live shows that I enjoy going to, but would never have known about, because I don't know where to look for them. Having it pushed at me helps me.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by switch007 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:27PM (#25172890)
> The purpose of ads is to inform people of things they wouldn't otherwise know about

That's cute. I've never seen an ad for a wikipedia page though.

The real purpose of ads is to convince people to buy things that they otherwise might not have, so that companies can make a profit.

Take the https://www.theguardian.com/. I've got adverts for:

- an electric toothbrush. I already have one. But surely the new model is better!11!

- London apartments. I live 170 miles away and have no desire ever to live in London. But maybe I should because London is so amazing!11!!

- Remitly ("send money to India online"). I do not know anyone in India and have no need to send money there.

- "70% off" "Store Clothing", whatever the hell that is. I have plenty of clothes. But maybe I need more and to be more fashionable!11!!

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by jonas21 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:44PM (#25172972)
So what you're saying is that better ad targeting would improve your experience?
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by Dylan16807 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @06:12PM (#25173453)
"Better" in the same sense as a "sufficiently smart compiler"? Sure.

But it shows that access to state-of-the-art targeting isn't helping at all. So right now it's clearly not worth a privacy tradeoff.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by x4j91 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:55PM (#25173031)
Better ad targeting definately can improve the user experience ... but the path to get there is insidious ...
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by 6510 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @05:39PM (#25173287)
The entire ad database would have to be client side with payments per product sold. (I'm only half joking)
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by jedberg on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:34PM (#25172920)
The example I gave elsewhere are ads for live shows (back when that was a thing). I like live shows and sometimes the ads are the only way I learn about new ones.
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by est31 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:42PM (#25172954)
Not a fan of targeted ads, but which ad to show you is only half of the part. The other part is tracking conversions, aka finding out if you actually bought some item after you saw the ad.

Also, ads don't have to work for everyone. If they work for some folks, it's already profitable for the platforms. And they do work.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by fingerlocks on Saturday November 21, 2020 @08:00PM (#25173936)
I would say tracking conversions is the most important part. There’s always a lot of attention on targeting because it’s user-facing, creepy, and strikes a nerve with the HN crowd. But anyone that has spent five minutes working with their marketing people or implementing adTech would know the true story.

“Are these ads effective? Should we spend more money on them?” Without conversion data the answer is one big shrug emoji.

I don’t believe most companies in the tech industry care about tracking/fingerprinting users for the sake of collecting & reselling their data. First hand experience, I’m just not ever seeing that. They just want to know if their ads are working or not.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by est31 on Sunday November 22, 2020 @04:05AM (#25176062)
> I would say tracking conversions is the most important part. There’s always a lot of attention on targeting because it’s user-facing, creepy, and strikes a nerve with the HN crowd.

It doesn't help that people try to sell conversion as something that benefits the ad viewer because if it increases sales, it must also be good for the people doing the buying or something like that. That argument of "better ads" then gets easily misunderstood as targeting but it is only indirectly about that.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by 6510 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @05:42PM (#25173302)
CPC scales with how well ads work. Seller and viewer benefit from working ads. It seems ad platforms benefit most from ads that don't work.
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by jedberg on Saturday November 21, 2020 @05:47PM (#25173332)
Ad platforms benefit from ads working because then advertisers spend more money on the platform.
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by santraginean on Saturday November 21, 2020 @06:21PM (#25173491)
> The real purpose of ads is to convince people to buy things that they otherwise might not have

In particular, things they otherwise might not have and don't need enough to look for actively on their own.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by GeekyBear on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:13PM (#25172820)
The reality of ads is that you can target them via the content of the page without all that reprehensible spying on people.

It's just less profitable.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by qwertox on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:19PM (#25172847)
This is specially true for any kind of news websites or blogs, where it's obvious what content a specific URL contains. The fact alone that a visitor is on that page makes him the best candidate for a targeted ad which refers to the content of the page.

No need to have over a dozen of trackers on that page so that advertisers create a profile of you.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by Spooky23 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @08:45PM (#25174184)
The problem is the audience is global as well as the content in many cases.

My local Hearst paper operates a templates website full of crap trackers and ads that are brokered at a central point. They aren’t selling the inventory with local sales managers etc. To keep costs down, everything is aggregated.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by ksec on Saturday November 21, 2020 @11:04PM (#25174843)
On HN there seems to be a notion that ALL Ads are bad. No Ads should be allowed. And yet at the same time they are enjoying all the free tools and website build upon this business model.

And then also the notion that ALL data gathered intrude privacy. And somehow anyone on the Internet should be anonymous, may be that is not even the right word, may be invisible could be used to better describe it.

Privacy means people know what they're signing up for, in plain language, and repeatedly.”

There should be a middle ground somewhere. Not all Ads are bad. I love useful Ads, but I hate bad ads, whether that is placement or the actual ads itself. And I know people gets to discover new Games, Clothes, Shows, or other product they like through these ads.

It cant be an all or nothing world. Which the Internet in general likes to encourage, and there is no middle ground. We need to start looking at Ads as part of UX, and not just money / target optimising tools.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by lowdose on Sunday November 22, 2020 @07:12AM (#25176837)
> ALL Ads are bad. No Ads should be allowed. And yet at the same time they are enjoying all the free tools and website build upon this business model.

And then also the notion that ALL data gathered intrude privacy. And somehow anyone on the Internet should be anonymous, may be that is not even the right word, may be invisible could be used to better describe it.

Let's name it the Thiel paradox. Maybe then this flavor of cognitive dissonance is better captured and told further.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by catlifeonmars on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:37PM (#25172931)
Instagram is actually pretty good at displaying only ads for things I’m interested in. Maybe I’m an easy mark, but it doesn’t really bother me, and occasionally I’ll buy something. I’ve also had the opposite experience on other platforms, where the targeting is shit and the ads make me stop using a product/app/site.

I think this is great. By putting tracking in the control of the user, the user can decide if they want shitty, generic ads or targeted relevant ads. What’s missing now is a built in ad blocker for iOS.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by amcoastal on Saturday November 21, 2020 @06:04PM (#25173414)
Did you buy the floppy fish? The cat on Instagram seems to love that shit.
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by jetpackjoe on Saturday November 21, 2020 @06:14PM (#25173462)
My cats (kittens, really) couldn't care less about it.
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by catlifeonmars on Saturday November 21, 2020 @11:12PM (#25174872)
My cats are also extremely indifferent, but I actually bought 20 of them and used them in lieu of packing peanuts for a box of birthday presents for my partner.
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by bryanrasmussen on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:45PM (#25172983)
I would be just as thrilled if companies gave me ads for things I wanted to buy, as long as the ad was not stopping me for doing what I was doing at the moment.

As it is the closest I get is ads for something I looked at 20 days ago and decided not to buy.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by quest88 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @07:46PM (#25173880)
I love the Instagram and Facebook ads. They're always well targeted for me. And sometimes I go back to look for one I saw earlier in the day.
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by innagadadavida on Saturday November 21, 2020 @05:03PM (#25173078)
Ironically I had the same experience with Apple News app - I was seeing the same ads over and over again. I can not block the ads and I didn’t want to subscribe. I just gave up and toggled the setting to show personalized ads - hoping to at lease see something different.
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by maneesh on Saturday November 21, 2020 @05:53PM (#25173359)
I enjoy the ad content on FB far more than the posts on FB. Especially over the last six months.
[dead]
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by jedberg on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:06PM (#25172774)
Heh, it's funny you mention that. For the longest time I refused to run Adblock because it felt hypocritical. But eventually the experience got so bad I relented.

I wouldn't say I have an incentive for internet ads to be successful. From the very beginning I advocated for revenue streams other than ads. And reddit is fairly diversified. I don't work there anymore anyway.

I guess I just don't mind advertising if done well and is relevant.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by na85 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @08:57PM (#25174242)
I guess I just can't, no matter how hard I try, imagine why a person would think ads are good, especially targeted ads. The only reason I can come up with is that a person would willingly look past how odious advertising is because it pays their bills.

If as you say that's not the case then can you help me understand why?

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by jedberg on Saturday November 21, 2020 @10:15PM (#25174645)
TL;DR: It gives me ideas of ways to spend money I was already going to spend, but now I have a place to start my research with some concrete ideas.

Well, I've given the example of live shows a couple of times. I've been to a few live shows that I learned about from targeted ads. Those were experiences I enjoyed and would not have learned about otherwise.

I'll pull up my Insta feed right now and list the targeted ads:

Osmo -- This is a game system for my kids that I already own. The ad isn't super useful, except I just learned about a new game they're releasing that I might want to get for my daughter. I may have eventually seen this elsewhere, but this is the first I'm seeing it.

Osmo again. But from a different vendor.

Lego -- They have some new sets that I didn't know about. I enjoy building legos with my kids, so now I know about a few new sets we might enjoy together.

Something called Soundbrenner. It's a gadget for musicians. I'm not a musician so this doesn't interest me. None the less, I am glad I know about this because I have musician friends who might be interested in something like this, so maybe the next time I talk to them I'll mention it, and they may be appreciative of me telling them because it can give them an idea of a new way to improve their play. Maybe they'll buy the gadget, maybe they'll find something similar, maybe they'll build something similar.

A charity for helping teachers during Christmas. This interests me. I support education and there is a good chance I'll make a donation to this cause. Now I'm happy that I found out about this charity.

An ad for a service that turns pictures of your pets into hand done oil paintings. I don't have pets, but one of my best friends does as do my parents, so there is a possibility I'll use this service as a Christmas gift.

A contest to win a Lamborghini featured in a lady gaga video. This is mistargeted and I have no interest.

A food sealing kitchen gadget. I'm going to forward this to my wife, who loves cooking gadgets, and then she'll check her cooking forums for someone who had a DIY version, but now she has a new idea to ask about.

Bed Bath and Beyond. Meh, don't really care.

A clothing company that follows the Tom's model of buy one give one. I don't like the clothes, but if I did, this is the kind of thing I might support if I need new clothes.

Some sort of prescription drug. The ad doesn't even say what it cures. So I have no interest in this. However, if it happened to be for an ailment that I actually have, I'd probably click through to find out more and be a jumping point for my own research.

Quicken Loans. I actually hate this ad because it encourages people to refinance their 30 year mortgage into a 15 year mortgage which is a terrible idea.

Another ad for musicians, this time an app. Same comment as above -- not interested but I may mention to a friend.

An ad for a new star wars game in VR. As it turns out, I recently bought an Occulus (from someone on HN actually) so this might be a game I would be interested in. I probably would have found out about this later when looking for new games, but this is the first I've heard of this game.

Another Lego ad, this time a different set.

Anyway, I could keep going, as the ads are endless (although they start to repeat). The point is, in most of these cases, I learned something new that I didn't know before.

Yes, in every case, they are trying to get me to spend money. But it's money I probably would have been spending anyway (Christmas presents, games my kids and I can play together, games I can play alone, charity donations). So I'm glad that I now have some ideas and places to start looking.

In a lot of cases, the ads are just jumping off points for research, but they give me new ideas I wouldn't have thought of.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by na85 on Sunday November 22, 2020 @01:13AM (#25175359)
Here's what I don't get: Why not just block the ads, which has two benefits:

1. Reduces profitability of advertising companies 2. Makes browsing the web sane (not to mention 30000% more pleasant)

And then after you've blocked all the ads you can just search for $subject_or_product_genre_that_interests_you, on your own terms, without worrying about scumbags tracking you and mining crypto via javascript in your browser?

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by jedberg on Sunday November 22, 2020 @03:39AM (#25175955)
I do block ads in my browser. I only have them in the apps on my phone, where they are unblock able anyway.

Also, a lot of sites I like exist because of ads. If everyone had them off, they wouldn't exist anymore.

And because I wouldn't even think to search for those topics in the first place. It's the act of seeing that ad that gets me to start thinking about that topic in the first place.

Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by mikeyouse on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:18PM (#25172839)
Courteous of you to point out that for about the same length of time you worked for Reddit, you worked for Netflix - so are you really a shill for "big subscription"? I think the world needs to know (/s)
Re:FTC commissioner met with Apple regarding Facebook’s iOS ... by justapassenger on Saturday November 21, 2020 @04:58PM (#25173045)
You never heard about anyone being excited about any commercial product? Never heard about people learning about new product, and being happy about it?