It was like a dam broke over night. Everything clicked and I was so pissed off that it took so long to find such a stupid issue. Better late than never I suppose...
At that age it took me a while to understand where the problem was and too late to ask my teacher to reconsider it.
Well, was so intense that I remember it until today, 30 and some years later.
He said something similar to you, "I'm not a doctor writing prescriptions, I need to be precise. If my writing is precise, its easier to read, easier to understand now and later."
Personally, the +/t handwriting issue has never been an issue for me: make sure you get a good tail on the t, and it's pretty easy to distinguish from a +. It's the x/× distinction that was always the most painful to distinguish for me.
I also draw a y with one stroke so that it has a visible curve. That keeps a bad y and bad times from looking like each other.
I'm 45 and finally discovered I like softer lead. It's easier to read and smudging isn't a problem for me. I took drafting in high school but never retained any of the knowledge or put it to good use when writing.
Do you have a big contrast between your screen and your room? That's a big deal. I run a blue light filter at night.
I do prefer eink and anything oled looks fantastic, but the fire looks really good, well beyond its $150 price tag. Better than my computer monitors (which are nice).
Are you reading tiny, detailed print? Is it just a resolution thing?
Lastly, are you getting older (40ish) and need reading glasses? That happened to me when crossing 40. I could still focus sharply at reading/screen distance, but I got tired. I went through that a couple years and got reading glasses -- actually just weaker versions of my nearsighted glasses. I had the doctor dial in the focal distance for screen distance, then got another pair for 12 inches are so (for a reading a book up close).
So I have three pairs of glasses, one for distance (everything sharp from 3 feet outward). These strain my eyes from 3 feet inward. You don't need reading glasses if your arms are long enough...
I have computer classes dialed in at roughly 28 inches. I can read up close, and see nearly perfectly at distance. I'm probably 20/20 at distance, but with my regular prescription I'm around 20/10.
Then the reading glasses for up close things. These are fine for computer as well, and just slightly more blurry at distance.
Resolution seems ok - I zoom in when needed, which is rare. Some pdf's have lines too long to fit on the screen, for the text to be large enough - but they are also rare. I think a 10" would solve that (held lanscape, 10" is basically A4 portrait width, if you zoom out the margins). So it doesn't feel like resolution is a problem - although some people say fuzzier text tires eyes.
If I were doing math I would prefer to use the 0.28 version and make sure my paper is good. Anything smaller and it feels like I'm drawing and not writing. I think the 0.2's are mostly used for art.
A crossed out line followed by a legible one is better than a line written over gray mush. Or mush from papers rubbing against each other over months.
But pens also assume that scratch space isn’t a limitation.
Pens seem crazy until you get used to writing that way, then you can’t turn back.
I did everything in pen, bc of handwriting issues and pencils. I simply burned through sheets and sheets of paper with my preliminary work- then copy everything to something both legible and presentable.
I did get a rather funny look from a professor in grad school when I turned in a fully typeset document on a timed take-home exam.
Nowadays I mostly use markdown with inline latex as formatting with latex can be a pain.
At age 40 I started taking a masters in stats and had situations where I had exponents on exponents. This lead me to buy a higher resolution tablet for reading pdf's with tiny math.
I also bought a finer point pen and this helped me improve my handwriting a lot. Closing loops on "o's" or backtracing the upward line of a cursive "t" to not make a loop. With the finer point, I was able to see my imprecision and improve it.
I used to rewrite my finished work in undergrad and now my writing was improved to the point where the first draft was entirely legible.