News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by savanaly on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @07:49PM (#25144879)
It's just insane enough that I want to wait and hear "the other side" before passing judgement. Are there any other details that might have been left out for example that make it a less clear cut case of theft than what is depicted in the letter?
Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by marktangotango on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @08:12PM (#25145051)
SFFWA is a well known professional organization, that has been around a long time, why would one not accept the gravity and import of this news conference and announcement? I mean, the details are plainly presented! Is any institution to be trusted or taken at face value? Are we all to be completely bereft of common sense and decency in face of such rampant equivocating and hand waiving!

Splinter of the minds eye may not have been the best novel, have mercy please!

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by sigzero on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @08:33PM (#25145203)
I loved that book actually.
Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by webmaven on Thursday November 19, 2020 @10:17PM (#25157029)
> I loved that book actually.

I liked it too, Alan Dean Foster did some nice worldbuilding there (that ended up very non-canon) that you don't usually see in franchise novels.

Another good example of this that comes to mind is 'Spock's World' by Diane Duane (though I think most of the worldbuilding there did become canon).

The other ADF movie novelization I recall fondly is 'The Last Starfighter'.

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by stanrivers on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @08:02PM (#25144987)
Agree this sounds so beyond believable - will be interesting to hear Disney’s response
Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by stanrivers on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @10:17PM (#25145831)
To clarify - I'm saying this is a terrible situation and it will be interesting to hear Disney's side because it is so unbelievable to me that a company would just literally argue this line of logic without there being something we are missing.

If there is nothing missing, then shame shame shame

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by vmception on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @08:27PM (#25145168)
The other side is the question "is this news?"

Everyone thinks their circumstance is "precedent setting" and something to pay more attention to than other things, but the question here being is it?

You can buy assets without liabilities. There isn't something to find out... or is there? Yes, you and them just noticed that this could undermine all royalties by just shuffling them off to a shell company that has no ability to pay. But are you sure it hasn't always been like that?

For example, many jurisdictions require a tax when a car is sold. But you can always buy the LLC that happens to own a car and no tax event occurred. The only point of this example - not as an analogy to this case - is that the feature was always present and it avoids a transaction. Could this deprive the state of revenue? Yes, yes it could, astute observation, moving on.

This article and complaint makes it seem like it is groundshaking, but did the earthquake really come decades ago and nobody used their platform to notice?

I am reserving judgement on the legal side for that purpose. Can we shame Disney for taking that approach, sure. But attempting to get a reputable legal advocacy foundation involved for a reality that already has existed for an unknown amount of time seems like misdirection.

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by cptskippy on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @08:48PM (#25145298)
The asset in this case is a license agreement. By choosing to publish the licensed material, they're agreeing to pay royalties. Otherwise it's theft.

Otherwise what's stopping me from selling my Disney BluRays to someone but not the liabilities of adhering to the copyright agreement?

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by JackFr on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @09:07PM (#25145412)
So it might not be quite that cut and dried. A little digging shows that Alan Dean Foster was contracted to write two novels. Despite writing them, he never held the copyright on those novels.

That being said, it’s still quite likely Disney is in breach of contract. But it’s not quite as simple.

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by Mtinie on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @09:17PM (#25145465)
It is if the contract says he’s owed royalties on those works, as it is presented. I can’t imagine he’d have done the work pro Bono for Lucasfilm out of the kindness of his heart, do you?

The reasonable interpretation is that someone at Disney is attempting to shore up their revenue this year and is using Mr. Foster’s due proceeds as a way to attempt to make their balance sheet look better.

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by JackFr on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:12AM (#25146725)
I imagine that 100x Alan Dean Foster’s back royalties wouldn’t even be noticeable on Disney’s balance sheet.

The only reason I can really think of them doing this is that they don’t actually believe they owe him the money.

It’s reasonably clear that he never held the copyright to the works and it’s not public what his actual contract was.

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by webmaven on Thursday November 19, 2020 @10:28PM (#25157068)
> I imagine that 100x Alan Dean Foster’s back royalties wouldn’t even be noticeable on Disney’s balance sheet.

Disney could be doing this at scale to many authors, this announcement by SFWA may bring a bunch of other complainants out of the woodwork.

The other aspect is that while what you say is certainly true of Disney as a whole, the amounts may be more meaningful for some subsidiary or division, (like, you know, their publishing arm) and the exec(s) that head it.

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by vmception on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @10:13PM (#25145806)
That was my understanding. This is work for hire meaning the copyright holder was the prior company and was the only one with an asset that would require a usage license. They chose to pay Alan, which is not a statutory agreement.

The copyright holder (the company) is the only one that can levy usage licenses aka royalties that other people need to pay it.

Disney became the copyright holder and so Disney is owed royalties from whomever has a usage license that the previous company negotiated.

Anything else is a liability that was shed or simply stayed in the now defunct company. If the contract was irreconcilably tied to the company then Disney would opt not to buy the shares and instead by all the assets and network and trademark.

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by nikanj on Thursday November 19, 2020 @03:05AM (#25147246)
What's stopping you is your lack of access to white-shoe law firms vs Disney's excellent access to same
Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by michaelmrose on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @09:08PM (#25145419)
Please provide some precedents for shedding liabilities while retaining assets.
Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by cool_dude85 on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @10:06PM (#25145771)
There are some tricks. "Spin off" a new company with all your pension liabilities and your unprofitable assets, whaddaya know, the new company goes bankrupt. Then the courts can give the pensioners a haircut since the debt they're owed isn't secured.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-patriot-bankruptcy/bankru...

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by anilakar on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:45AM (#25147140)
In the US pension system, are the pension payments somehow delayed from the actual date that liability is accrued, i.e. the day the employee gets paid the first time? Is it legal for a company to pay a salary to their employees without having the financial assets to back all other liabilities? I can somehow see the twisted reasoning behind this, but it still feels wrong.

Asking this as a foreigner and because such a system sounds so ripe for abuse that it would have already been fixed if it really was flawed and affected those pensioners' lives.

Re:DisneyMustPay Alan Dean Foster by michaelmrose on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @10:27PM (#25145889)
Peabody may have spun off unprofitable operations and let them crash but how did it sepate assets and liabilities for the same operation?