Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by danaris on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @08:06AM
(#25123269)
This article is from 2017. More recent research (though sadly, I do not have the link handy) has indicated that the magma reservoir beneath Yellowstone is something like 90% solid, and thus vanishingly unlikely to cause an eruption any time soon.
Sure, it's still hot, especially by our fragile human standards, but it's not going to go "BOOM".
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by mattferderer on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @09:07AM
(#25123852)
I once curiously asked this to Richard Campbell after a couple great Geek Out podcasts on geothermal & super volcanoes.
I was told the difficulty in volcanoes vs other popular geothermal sources is that volcanoes are an "unstable magma chamber" which makes it very difficult, expensive & risky.
Of course if this could be perfected, it could be a huge source of energy not just on Earth but places like Mars as well.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by suifbwish on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @11:41AM
(#25125801)
Yea except for one problem. You can’t possibly predict what the caldera would do when you interact with it because we can’t simulate it with any model we currently have. You could cause it to erupt in the process of trying to extract energy or cool it
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by api on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @08:36AM
(#25123541)
Heh... I wonder how much of the USA you could power by extracting energy from that thing?
Unfortunately it's a park, so you'd have to find a way to do it very unobtrusively. Maybe tunnel and drill into it from outside the park? Call the Boring Company. :)
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by rbanffy on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @06:30AM
(#25122508)
It'd be awesome if we could use that heat to generate electricity. All the planet's needs wouldn't make a dent in calming down the supervolcano but, at least, there would be free energy for everyone.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by _Microft on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @08:22AM
(#25123414)
Sure! Iceland for example has so much geothermal energy that they can clear their sidewalks from snow by heating them. Amazing, isn't it? (Searching for "iceland heated sidewalk" should bring up enough results if you are interested)
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by steve_adams_86 on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @10:43AM
(#25125027)
There’s a Science vs. Podcast which pretty much defuses the fears around this volcano. I’m not sure if it’s completely correct, but a guy who actually measures and observes the volcano says it’s not a concern and if it was, we’d probably know well in advance.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by mchusma on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @05:14AM
(#25122001)
Supervolcanoes and asteroid collisions are good reasons to support nuclear power, not just solar, as a diverse energy source. What happens if the sun gets blocked out?
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by elorant on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @07:33AM
(#25123000)
If significant portion of the population starts starving then there will be all out wars, social instability, chaos, anarchy and whatnot. This could send us back to the stone age.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by elorant on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @10:24AM
(#25124779)
I don't have one, and it's not my job to. All I know is that civil order is a very fragile thing. We saw how things evolved with covid. A virus with a 0.2% fatality rate was enough to bring the worst recession in recent history, millions of dead, and hospitals to the brink of collapse. What do you think would happen if suddenly half the world's population can't find food to survive? They'll sit back and wait while you develop your contingency plan, or they will fight for their survival with all means in their disposal? In case of nations this means an all out war.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @02:57PM
(#25128850)
I mostly agree, but:
> A virus with a 0.2% fatality rate was enough to bring the worst recession in recent history, millions of dead, and hospitals to the brink of collapse.
The worst recession in recent history? I regard 2008 as recent, and as a recession, this is definitely not worse than that was.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by elorant on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @04:10PM
(#25129890)
The writing is on the wall. We just have to wait a few months for the shockwave to reach us. A lot of small businesses that closed due to lockdowns won't open again, especially in the entertainment industry.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by JulianMorrison on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @07:31AM
(#25122991)
Things that would screw up if the sun got blocked: all photosynthesizing life, the hydrological cycle (it would freeze solid), the atmosphere (it would precipitate out).
Merely having a fallback power solution would be the least of our problems.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by JulianMorrison on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @09:49AM
(#25124297)
Yeah, in vast airtight geothermally heated caverns that don't yet exist, using a closed cycle ark-ship ecology that has neither been perfected nor really even seriously tried, and with an "outside" that would be as ferociously hostile to human life as the surface of Pluto.
Good anime setting, not really a plausible human future.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by FooHentai on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @03:10PM
(#25129058)
I'm not sure how you'd bootstrap any of the measures you describe in an environment of extreme environmental hostility and complete societal breakdown. Reads like futurism blind to practical reality.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by Someone on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @10:28AM
(#25124837)
I think temperature on earth would eventually drop to a few kelvin. The earth’s heat and heat generated by the moon’s gravity stretching the planet would increase that, initially, but I doubt it would be over 100 kelvin. That’s not cold or even cold cold, but cold³. If there still would be oceans, they would be a mix of nitrogen and oxygen.
I’m not sure living on it would be much easier than living in space. You would have better radiation protection and more raw materials, but staying warm might be harder.
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by Wildgoose on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @12:22PM
(#25126449)
I think air pressure (the weight of air above us at sea-level) compresses the air sufficiently for it to reach a temperature much greater than you would expect, e.g around negative 20 degrees Celsius.
(This figure needs verification, I'm going from memory).
Re:The Supervolcano Under Yellowstone Is Alive and Kicking (...
by macspoofing on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @08:41AM
(#25123583)
I'm a fan of nuclear power, but if the sun gets blocked out, nuclear isn't going to help you. Sure you'll keep your lights on, for a short time, and you get to watch total environmental and civilization collapse.
I don't know if it is this one https://science.sciencemag.org/content/sci/348/6236/773/F4.l...
The paper is from 2015, should match https://science.sciencemag.org/content/348/6236/773/tab-figu...
Sure, it's still hot, especially by our fragile human standards, but it's not going to go "BOOM".
Unfortunately being the Discovery Channel they spent more time animating the end of the world (in the US anyway) aspect than anything.
And ending on the ominous message that's is a only a matter of time before it blows. Could be tomorrow or in 100,000 years, we're not sure.
I was told the difficulty in volcanoes vs other popular geothermal sources is that volcanoes are an "unstable magma chamber" which makes it very difficult, expensive & risky.
Of course if this could be perfected, it could be a huge source of energy not just on Earth but places like Mars as well.
/s
Unfortunately it's a park, so you'd have to find a way to do it very unobtrusively. Maybe tunnel and drill into it from outside the park? Call the Boring Company. :)
http://prosecraft.io/library/robby-akart/yellowstone-hellfir...
I wonder how effective it'd be for desalination.
https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20170817-nasas-ambitious-...
This might be the report that the coverage refers to: https://scienceandtechnology.jpl.nasa.gov/sites/default/file...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geothermal_power
https://gimletmedia.com/shows/science-vs/8wh748k
We all starve to death.
Significant portion of population will starve though. But energy unused by them could help grow food for remaining fraction.
What's your contingency plan, everyone commits suicide the day the volcano erupts?
> A virus with a 0.2% fatality rate was enough to bring the worst recession in recent history, millions of dead, and hospitals to the brink of collapse.
The worst recession in recent history? I regard 2008 as recent, and as a recession, this is definitely not worse than that was.
Merely having a fallback power solution would be the least of our problems.
Good anime setting, not really a plausible human future.
Also, you kind need complex societies to function to not have them melt down. After a super volcano or asteroid collision, that one could be dicey.
I’m not sure living on it would be much easier than living in space. You would have better radiation protection and more raw materials, but staying warm might be harder.
(This figure needs verification, I'm going from memory).