News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:22AM (#25109379)
I did something very similar with an old strategy game called Age of empires II. Over the course of two years I went from a 1300 rating to 1850. I don't play chess, so it's hard for me to compare the scales, but I will say the highest players were rated around 2600. I think being 1850 put me around 90-95th percentile for active players-- there were less than 50 players over 2300, and only a few hundred over 2000.

My only real commentary is that trying to follow a progression like this can be profoundly, profoundly frustrating. You need to really make sure you're enjoying this hobby before you try to dedicate yourself to a trajectory like this. It can really make you feel like shit a lot of the time, as you find yourself continually repeating mistakes that other people breeze past without issue. It takes true love of the game and a great deal of patience and persistence to push through all the downspells.

Eventually I decided that I no longer wished to prioritize the game over other things. The enormous time investment was no longer a worthwhile trade-off for me, and I stopped playing almost all together. I haven't regretted it since. There's just so many things to do in life. I gave it thousands of hours of my time, and now the door is closed on that. Now I'm learning Ruby on rails!

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by _the_inflator on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:45AM (#25109521)
Hey there fellow AoE II player!

Cool, to hear from some decent player. What time did you play? Around 2002?

Since I was a 2k player at the time, let me assure you, that the top dudes at the time (Koven, Sheriff for example) were already so called pro gamers who got payed/sponsored and they were exceptionally good.

The true story is, that many folks above 2k+ did what was called "points trading" back then. Koven once stated, that they got payed according to their rank in the official ladder.

So he also had to defend against cheaters, un-sync games etc. He was always top notch, but he had to adjust his rating accordingly, due to cheaters.

Almost all at the top did points trading. Smurf accounts, the system, some refusing to play against weaker players, or some playing DM to get points faster. Also some game "hacks", like the farming bug etc. that gave you the edge in early FLUSHing games.

So take this: 1850 is extremely good in RM 1vs1. 2k+ players are exceptionally good at micro-management. A skill to be learned.

I was part of CN, you might remember this clan from our most famous player, Lightning_CN. Greets to Force, Gwenny etc. where ever you are! :)

PS: There is a book from L_Clan_Chris at Amazon. Some knowledge bites to digest.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by rubidium on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:15AM (#25111833)
Played and followed the AoE scene many times: 2002-2004, 2013-2014, and now playing again on AOE 2: DE. The new training scenarios in DE are quite helpful and I'd recommend them to new or returning players.

DE has led to a massive resurgence of interest and a 3rd generation of players. First gen was AoE2 (CD), 2nd gen was the forgotten empires continuing things, 3rd is DE. Some players have spanned all 3. My current favorite streamers are Viper and Hera.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by thisisnico on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:23AM (#25112771)
AoE2:DE Player here as well. It's a fantastic game and I love the current community.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by peterburkimsher on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:05PM (#25117613)
Do real-world maps work with DE? I had fun making a map of Taiwan, with actual locations of gold, stone, fish, wild animals, etc.

https://github.com/peterolson/AOE2-Real-Map-Creator

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:10AM (#25112568)
Oh yeah the twitch scene has really made a massive difference to this generation and to the modern-day level of interest. Viper's stream was what got me into competitive play.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by spurgu on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:26PM (#25115163)
Is DE (or AoE in general) available on Mac and/or Linux?
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by dcist on Friday November 20, 2020 @12:10PM (#25162454)
It works on Mac but you have to use Boot Camp or Parallels (or a similar system). Kind of a pain but totally works.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by khrbrt on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:28PM (#25115908)
I play AoE2 (non-DE) on Linux with Steam and its compatibility tool.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by xuki on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:07AM (#25110366)
As someone who could never break 1750 on Zone, hat off to both of you. Even though I no longer play, I did follow the scene closely for a while until a few years ago. To my surprise DauT is still a top player, although one of his teammate is clearly the indisputable No. 1 by a distance compare to anyone else.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by _the_inflator on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:49AM (#25110983)
Yes, the Viper is truly the Hamilton amongst his fellow peers. Impressive! And he is now showing his tricks to his already AoE II infected girl friend Debbie! This is so cool! Way too few women play this game.

1750: This is also a great ranking. Competition there is pretty tough. Congrats! I remember playing lots of 1700er dudes whenever I started out with my smurf accounts, and I had plenty off em.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by dreamer7 on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:20AM (#25110770)
To me, DauT is the Mikhail Tal of AOE while Viper is Bobby Fischer.

I've watched endless videos of DauT and Viper playing AoE. ZeroEmpires has done a lot to popularize AoE streaming. Here's his YouTube channel if anyone is interested - https://www.youtube.com/user/ZeroEmpires

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by _the_inflator on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:00AM (#25111080)
T90official is also suuuuupercool!

He also started as a pretty mediocre player and now deserves his rank among the best players! He shares a lot of his secrets and is also #1 commentator now for AoE II:DE related games: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZUT79WUUpZlZ-XMF7l4CFg

Also watch his Twitch account.

Spirit of the Law is also a great resource: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UChzLZJo-SxuPHz-oYKAIC_g

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:15AM (#25112650)
T90 to me is such a confusing phenomenon. I've never understood why a low-rated player who (to me) did not have a particularly entertaining personality was the most-subscribed AoE2 player on twitch. Is he actually good now? How high-rated is he compared to Daut and Viper and so on?
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by creamynebula on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:05PM (#25117616)
T90 is on the 2000-2100 range currently, he just reached top 100.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by _the_inflator on Monday November 16, 2020 @11:03AM (#25113250)
He already beat Viper: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Tkf-BMMq-8

T90 is doing great. Also improved massively his commentator skills. Give him a try! :)

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:38PM (#25114537)
Ah, yeah, I kind of meant in a serious match though. In that match viper made 3 docks on a land map and no feudal army.

As T90 himself said, "The trouble with playing viper is that if viper memes me, and I win, people just say oh T90 isn't good, viper wasn't trying. And if I lose, well, T90 can't even beat viper when he's not trying. So it's a lose-lose situation." Too true.

I see he is #96 on rankings right now though, that's terrific. Being able to beat #1 isn't the only measure of success and I don't mean to imply otherwise.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by seg_lol on Monday November 16, 2020 @11:14AM (#25113378)
Maybe because

> He shares a lot of his secrets

? Teachers don't have to be the best at the _thing_, they should be really good at explaining concepts. Maybe T90 is the people watch when then want to go from zero to average?

I don't want to be coached by the best tennis player in the world, it would be a waste and I couldn't do any of the things they could teach me.

A solid above average player that knows my limits and can explain how to correct flaws would be much better (for me).

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by friendlybus on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:54PM (#25120113)
He's likeable, non-offensive and casual. Watching people try too hard at a game is draining sometimes.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by MaxBarraclough on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:07AM (#25111145)
Here's a long video of them facing off: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLNu7ELg4mk

(Their first round runs up to the 39:00 mark.)

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by xuki on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:03AM (#25112450)
Nilpferd is my favorite: https://www.twitch.tv/nili_aoe
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by ouid on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:56PM (#25117487)
Viper is pretty defensive and grindy. I think Carlsen is a much better comparison.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:08AM (#25112539)
Much more recently, actually-- I peaked last year, in 2019. The game is alive and well in the Definitive Edition on steam, and players are still pushing the skill envelope. The meta has changed a lot with all the new civs they've added (they've doubled the number of civs overall).
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by safog on Monday November 16, 2020 @11:08AM (#25113321)
Hey - this is pretty amazing. I have learned a lot about AOE from watching L_clan (mostly L_Clan_Chris but others as well!) replays back in 2004-2008 when I was playing a lot of Age. Never had Zone access, so we lived in a little bubble in our university of LAN AoE players with outside ideas, build orders etc. coming from watching pro replays.

No twitch obviously and very few blogs going around for strategy as well. It's amazing to see how far gaming has come in 15 years.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by creamynebula on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:03PM (#25117583)
Just to let you know that Chris came back to the game recently, he streams on twitch as iamchris_age2
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by defertoreptar on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:29PM (#25114396)
As someone who was in the thick of it, what do you think could've been done differently to improve the problems with the rating system?
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by ZephyrBlu on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:49AM (#25109542)
> Eventually I decided that I no longer wished to prioritize the game over other things

This is what I unfortunately found as well. I reached Legend in Hearthstone (The top rank, no clue what percentile it was) a while back and top 3-5% in StarCraft II a couple of years ago.

In both games I stopped playing shortly after reaching that level because the time investment just didn't seem worth it to me. I love games, but playing at a very high level requires a lot of practice and focus.

I don't really think it's possible to play competitively and do much else because of the time investment required just to stay at your current level, let alone improve. I love games, but it's hard to justify when I could be doing something more productive with my time.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by MperorM on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:22AM (#25109742)
I think there's something to be argued that reaching a high level in any competitive game or sport has merit.

I've learned more valuable lessons from competing in Starcraft than I can count. Without knowing the exact opportunity cost, I think trading my highschool grades for the competitive experience was worth it.

The biggest mistake I think I made was not cutting games out completely after having learned those lessons.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by ZephyrBlu on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:29AM (#25109789)
I definitely agree and also feel like I've learned valuable lessons from SC2. It sucks to give a game up though :/.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by fakedang on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:54AM (#25109954)
I play Starcraft for the story only, and I loved it. Still play the campaign from time to time. I feel like a savage amongst civilized men on this thread.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by Sherwoodcs on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:34AM (#25110876)
Please don't feel like "a savage among civilized men". Video games are made to have fun with.

I experienced both sides. First trying to become a professional CS:GO player, and after just having fun playing the Starcraft 2 story.

Some of my friends still deeply enjoy the competitive aspect. Sometimes I just want to see big stonking robots blow up aliens :)

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:06AM (#25112504)
This was how I played AoE and StarCraft as a kid! I think the vast majority of players play them this way, actually. If you're in the competitive multiplayer scene, it's easy to forget there are millions or tens of millions of single player / campaign-only players.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by fakedang on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:30PM (#25117207)
Campaigns seem to have a bad rep among most gamers online, but honestly they are the most satisfying aspect of strategy games. One of my favourite games growing up was Rise of Nations and its Conquer the World maps - remove that and you get a worthless husk.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:19PM (#25118888)
I absolutely loved rise of nations. I didn't play the campaigns though, I played random map 1v1 matches versus the AI. Had a great time!
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by friendlybus on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:58PM (#25120133)
The majority of players come for the campaign and the space fantasy narrative.

The competitive scene has been stable and has kept sc going forever.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by MperorM on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:49AM (#25112278)
I wouldn't frame it as 'giving up' when you stop playing, rather you achieved what you set out to do.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by _the_inflator on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:57AM (#25111049)
I sacrificed around 1 year during university to Age of Empires. Wasn't my most productive year at uni.

Anyone remembers DBD_Jinx? For very long the only western dude to compete with the Koreans in 1vs1. However he also confessed, that he had partly sacrificed his private life for it.

I trained a lot. I trained hours a day on 2X speed hunting, build order. I played under many smurf accounts, to then foster my primary account(s). MrFixIt forums as well.

I played 1vs1, team games, I played DM as well.

After intense 2 years (time zone shifts as well, many sleepless nights) I decided to never ever play online in a community again in order to prevent my lazy/fun loving side to be sucked in again in clans, games etc.

No Warcraft nothing. To this day I keep the vow. Only game I play still from time to time is AoE II: DE.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by gutter_rat on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:38PM (#25116710)
In 2000, I came out of my first retirement to play a couple tournaments. The first time I heard of DBD_Jinx was when he beat me in the second round of the BattleTop NYC Challenge. He went on to win the tournament and became widely recognized as a top player.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by imtringued on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:38AM (#25109855)
It's the nature of competition and it's the same with physical sports. Lots of effort to gain minor benefits over the others.

Browser games tend to respect your time more by making you login every day but limit how much you can do. You won't see players who play the game 24/7 because the game tells you to stop after you ran out of action points or scheduled your base, etc.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by erfgh on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:46AM (#25111529)
Actually no, most physical sports are not like that because the human body has limits and exceeding them is counter-productive because it leads to injuries.

Most professional soccer players spend about 1-2 hours per day on training. Off-season they will spend slightly more but that's only for about 3-4 weeks.

Doing anything more leads to injuries.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by jniedrauer on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:13PM (#25115003)
1-2 hours of training per day is incredibly low for a professional athlete. Professional cyclists are on the bike for over half the day, and there is even more work to be done on active recovery and strength training. Even runners, who are more limited by their body than nearly any other sport, spend 15+ hours a week just on running. It's a full time job.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by ksdale on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:37PM (#25116697)
I agree, there's no way professional soccer players only practice 1-2 hours a day. I'd guess 1-2 in the gym plus another few hours at least actually practicing soccer. Even something that's fairly brutal like American football involves an hour or two per day in the gym, plus practice. Professional athletes figure out how to practice as much as possible in a way that doesn't lead to long-term injury and "as much as possible" is almost always way more than a couple hours per day.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by megameter on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:17PM (#25119272)
I also agree. There's a common tendency to overtrain to injury in sports, and it's mostly self-driven, even at amateur level. You look at people training something strenuous every single day, and you'll see a bunch of people who are constantly working around minor injuries, looking for a way to keep getting in the practice. The proliferation of PEDs in sports is not just about enhancing the on-field outcomes but also a quest to recover from this intense, high-volume training faster.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by perfect_wave on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:06PM (#25116998)
Also a Hearthstone player here- I used to regularly hit top 200 legend on ladder. I think one of the biggest lessons that I got out of starting to get more into the competitive scene is that there's more to games than trying to be the absolute best and that I need to set my limits and figure out where I can have fun without letting something take over my life.

I've since cut back significantly on my Hearthstone playing and been able to apply similar thinking to other games I've picked up (for example Magic The Gathering: Arena). Games are for having fun not for endlessly trying to get better. That was probably a mentality that I picked up from years of MMORPG (Runescape) addiction.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by speeder on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:44PM (#25116093)
I stopped playing RTS entirely some years ago because of that.

I used to love RTS but...

1. Rushing is stupid, all RTS seemly suffer from allowing it even when devs attempt to curb that down, I remember in AOE for example people training on how to build towers on the enemy base in 2 minutes or how to win with villager rush. (also knew a guy that relentlessy tested ways to rise to the second age faster)

2. Singleplayer often the AI is super cheaty, after a while I got bored with that, because I couldn't use actual strategy to win, for example the match that made me realize that was when the last AI was on an island, I conquered the rest of the map, was careful in my usage of the market to stockpile all resources for myself and deny the AI... then whenever I attacked with the 200 unit limit, the AI defended itself successfully, after I got bored of hours stuck on this stalemate, I used cheats and found out the AI stripped the whole island bare but was still pumping units non-stop AND knew where I was going to attack, so they always had perfect defense.

3. Multiplayer is a matter of how fast you click and how good you are with pattern matching and some other training-related things, intelligence for example isn't that important, rote learning, time to practice, etc... that is.

So I concluded that basically multiplayer RTS is a huge timesink, and to me, unfun. And singleplayer RTS after the campaign is done is or too easy (because the AI is utterly dumb) or too hard (because the AI cheats), I never found out a difficulty I enjoyed playing against the AI.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:31PM (#25116636)
> 1. Rushing is stupid, all RTS seemly suffer from allowing it even when devs attempt to curb that down, I remember in AOE for example people training on how to build towers on the enemy base in 2 minutes or how to win with villager rush. (also knew a guy that relentlessly tested ways to rise to the second age faster)

I have to politely refute this. "Rushing" is the word inexperienced players use for "playing in a more optimal way that prepares you to attack sooner." If you call it "rushing," what you're really saying is that you need other players to deliberately play worse to give you extra time to prepare. All of these strategies have counterplay and usually lead into long games. Using a vil rush or tower rush is not a way to end the game, it's a way to begin it.

> 3. Multiplayer is a matter of how fast you click and how good you are with pattern matching and some other training-related things, intelligence for example isn't that important, rote learning, time to practice, etc... that is.

Again, you could only say this if you had not made it to a competitive level. Intelligence is pattern-matching. And of course playing anything at a competitive level involves "training-related things," that's a kind of meaningless statement if I'm being honest. And I can't speak for StarCraft, but in AoE2 APM is not essential. To prove the point, the top-rated player has beaten other top 200 players without using his keyboard. It's about decision-making. Even at my level, I can beat other players rated a couple hundred points beneath me without using keyboard shortcuts just because my decision-making is better.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by neckardt on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:44PM (#25119755)
> I have to politely refute this. "Rushing" is the word inexperienced players use for "playing in a more optimal way that prepares you to attack sooner." If you call it "rushing," what you're really saying is that you need other players to deliberately play worse to give you extra time to prepare. All of these strategies have counterplay and usually lead into long games. Using a vil rush or tower rush is not a way to end the game, it's a way to begin it.

For less experienced players, rushes like these tend to end the game early rather than begin it in an interesting way. Either the defender knows how to hold the strategy and shuts it down, or hasn't seen it before and gets destroyed. While these strategies are certainly part of the game and make high level competitive games far more interesting, it is often a frustrating experience for low/mid level players. Many of those players are looking for an experience where they build their army for a while and attack once they're satisfied with what they've built. Certainly not strategically optimal, but that's often what they find fun.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:54PM (#25119817)
I totally understand that. It's how I played from 1999-2015.

I'm just saying that rushing isn't a flaw or a problem, rather it's a matter of perspective. Players who want to build up for a while nearly always want to do that because they haven't learned any other way to play. And they're not under any obligation to do so, either-- but it's not fair to say the game is flawed on that basis.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by jaggederest on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:18AM (#25110106)
If you're ever stuck on Rails stuff or want suggestions about where to go next, feel free to ping me, email in my profile. I've enjoyed tutoring/mentoring a lot over the last few years, would be a privilege to do more. That goes for any anonymous readers, as well. Anything from a one liner email all the way up to screensharing, helping people to learn is a gift.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:04AM (#25112469)
Thank you very much for the invitation, really appreciated!
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by johnnycerberus on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:38AM (#25110541)
As a chess player I could never get into RTS games though my friends were playing them alot, especially Warcraft 3, but even then they switched to mods like Dota). Instead, I'm pretty good at turn-based games like Civilization V and VI. It feels very cumbersome to control all these units in real time. I could never get used to it and I played many games in that RTS genre: Rise of Nations, C&C: Generals, AOE 2 and 3.

Nowadays, I'm not a PC gamer anymore, I have Chess.com, Hearthstone and Civilization on my iPad, it is amazing how a tablet can be a very good medium for turn-based gaming.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by pms on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:45PM (#25119765)
Try Heroes of Might and Magic 3 (HD version with Horn of the Abbys). This turn-based strategy game is excellent. It's 20 years old, and yet it has a larger average Twitch viewership than AoE, because of its awesome competitive scene.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by gutter_rat on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:41PM (#25116066)
I got into AOE soon after it was released in 1997. Especially early on, when we didn’t know much, it provided a rich universe of interesting economic, tactical, and strategic problems to solve. I spent countless hours studying the game, practicing, competing, and hanging out on the MrFixit forum. I once played one AOE game after another nonstop for 33 hours. Like you and many others, I eventually concluded it was too much of a distraction and uninstalled it permanently in order to focus on other endeavors. That was about 18 years ago. It’s nice to see there are still plenty of people enjoying the game.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by RhodoYolo on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:24PM (#25117857)
I don't know if you've ever played runescape but it has a very similar experience to the one you are describing.

It's interesting you compare your time spent in a game to time spent productively outside the game. One of the things driving the 'investments' in those style of games(MMO's) is that you get this feeling of progress and can compare your progress to your friends 'skills'. I've been writing alot in my personal journal on how to turn runescape skills into real life skills with achievements.

Ruby on rails would be a 'skill' and based on time spent doing pomodoros to earn xp for a 'Ruby on Rails' Skill, combined with certain projects awarding XP and achievements would turn real life into a game. Think like a self defined 'Khan Academy meets Facebook'.

You could see your friends skills and see what they are working on. Maybe a bulletin board/ social media style GUI that would say ' x just completed a pomodoro in Piano'. You could post to your linkedin account all the 'skills' you've obtained to show your various interests.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by megameter on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:11PM (#25118306)
I agree with this assessment: MMOs are very good at getting a person into a skill-acquisition mindset. I've been off-and-on with Planetside 2 for a few years now(it's been getting good updates lately, and I've been seeing new players popping up - good time to get in) and while not every part of it is as deep as it could be, it's got an absolutely huge surface area to study - MMO, FPS, vehicle gameplay, construction, leadership, strategy, and all the edges where these things meet - which means you can feel you've hit your limit in one area and simply shift over to another instead of quitting the game entirely.

Unlike many MMOs the grind is not heavily stat-focused either: while you can get unlocks and upgrades, most of them constitute "sidegrades" into a specialty role. On the field, your effectiveness still comes down to knowing the ins and outs of the gameplay. And there are leaderboards to motivate competitive players, but it's widely acknowledged that playstyles are not represented equally on these boards: it is straightforward to get a very high K/D by learning one of the various kill-farming techniques, and to get a lot of experience points with a support role around a meatgrinder battle. But those things don't necessarily contribute the most to your faction.

It's things like that that suggest where the model breaks down on application to real world skills. Generally, once a person is aware of the things they need to focus on, through good feedback, they can stay on the task. But if you look at a thing like programming, it's like, "where's the feedback?" It's not the butt-in-chair hours that are doing the lifting here. And it isn't reducable to lines compiled or issues cleared or other single-number metrics either. "Speedcoding" is only good in rare circumstances. It's more like a finished project is a series of quests that build on each other, with each quest having some checklist pass/fail requirements. But each one is bespoke, and hard to compare to others even if it's applying the same skills.

Indeed I actually do write down pass/fails conditions as a checklist in the comments to start with a complex implementation, and to create a kernel of documentation. Having tools helps, but it's that early conceptual/goal-setting where I put down boundaries that seems to make the biggest difference.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by Pelic4n on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:40AM (#25109490)
That's amazing. I love that game dearly and have been playing on/off for more than 15 years, so I get routinely obsessed with it, play a lot a few weeks, get good against the AI (usually using cheese like huskarl spam or massed mangudai), then get my ass handed to me online & ends up quitting. Then I don't play for a year or so.

At which point were you able to reliably not fail the boar lure ?

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:03AM (#25112447)
While I disagree with the other comment gatekeeping RTS's, which can be played however you want (my father pauses the game in between every action in order to keep up with the gamestate), I do agree that ~15-25 games of dedicated boar lure practice, just restarting the game after each attempt, should be enough to get it right in tandem with watching some videos on how to do it.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by rubidium on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:43AM (#25112202)
If you’re dying to the boars you should just be playing the first 9 min of the game on repeat against the AI. If you can’t master that after 15-30 games, then RTS are not for you :)
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by castaweh on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:21AM (#25110119)
I can relate to this. I was briefly around 1800 in HD and DE, but found that if I didn't play for a while that I'd come back and find myself outclassed. I uninstalled and reinstalled the game about five times over a couple of years because I found myself putting too much time into it to try to maintain a competitive skill level.

I actually tried to get into chess after quitting AoE2, to fill that strategic urge, but found the same thing - if I wasn't dedicating time and thought to it regularly I couldn't retain the advances I'd made in skill without going through a "warm up" period all over again (usually of losses).

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by dcist on Friday November 20, 2020 @12:02PM (#25162356)
I play AOE2 as well (the Definitive Edition is really great), but I never got that serious about it. I play with relatives and friends mostly. I've watched some videos about how to increase my efficiency and some basic strategies (killing the boar, fast castle, etc.) but never really dedicated myself to it. Really brilliant game. It just gets everything right and the graphics are timeless. I can't think of another game that still gets regular updates and has a big online following 21 years after it was released.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by tibbar on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:26PM (#25119989)
Hey, OP here - thanks for this wonderful comment. I'd like to hijack this thread to say that I respond to this comment and several other questions here - https://jacobbrazeal.wordpress.com/2020/11/17/the-touching-r.... Thank you all for such a warm reception.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by the_only_law on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:38AM (#25111439)
Never got into aoe2 but used to play a good bit of aoe3 (and have started again since the DE released). I used to hang around people who played ot semi competitively though I was never on that level.

I understood the game for the most part, but my execution was never good enough. Too much semi precise timings required and I could never get my APM high enough.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by baxtr on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:53AM (#25110301)
Ahh. So many nights lost (spent) :) AoE was sooo much fun. Dunno. Feels like nothing similar out there nowadays?
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by noahtallen on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:59AM (#25110341)
AoE2 is alive and well with the recently-released definitive edition! I’m also excited for AoE4, which will be set in the same time period, but otherwise different.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by nurettin on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:09AM (#25109678)
There is not even a modicum of similarity other than both of them being called games.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by icegreentea2 on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:13AM (#25111817)
I think the similarity being raised isn't really in the game or mechanics of the game, but the mechanics of being top tier. Aside from some very surface level similarities, you're right that RTS and Chess have pretty low overlap. But I think that the grind required to be top-tier in both is similar. They require you to play A LOT, and to do one of the hardest things a human can do, which is to try to be as objective as possible while analyzing when and why you lost.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:50AM (#25112299)
Exactly.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by Pelic4n on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:55AM (#25109965)
There is a staggering amount of similarity between the two, especially at the competitive level where chess moves needs to be played very fast.

The biggest differences I see is that AoE2 is not a perfect information game, and that it needs micromanagement.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by arcticfox on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:43AM (#25110242)
You might enjoy the games of Federico Perez Ponsa, chess Grandmaster. He plays Age of Empires II at a 2k+ level and is known as Fedex.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by aerovistae on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:51AM (#25112312)
I was just watching Fedex play last night in a game on twitch! I never knew this.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by nurettin on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:03AM (#25110351)
Thanks, that is interesting. I used to be 2000+ rated for AOE1 on zone.com and 1400+ chess on Yahoo! games back in late 90s, and to me it is a point of contention that I often bring up because chess is not motivated by capital greed whereas microsoft and their game studios are. And the dissimilarity between two games is pretty obvious to anyone who plays above 700 ranks.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by Guthur on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:15AM (#25110410)
Sorry, what?

What does MS market position have to do with the design of the game, it's not like it has any sort of monetization within the game mechanics at all.

You are conflating so much BS that it shows a profound lack of understand of both game mechanics and dare i say market economics.

It appears that you've rapped yourself up in some anti market bubble of cognitive disonance and can not longer think straight, I'm sorry for your pain.

Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by kimjongtrill on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:17AM (#25111242)
What does this even mean?
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by nurettin on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:46AM (#25111519)
I'd gladly clarify my position if you specify which part doesn't make sense.
Re:On Learning Chess as an Adult – From 650 to 1750 in Two Y... by C19is20 on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:38AM (#25109858)
Once I explained the similarities, my kids got into chess.