News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by adrianN on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:03AM (#25108600)
Imo all ads are ethically questionable. Their main objective is to make us want things we didn't want before. Unfulfilled desires make people unhappy; unnecessary consumerism uses up limited resources on a finite planet.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by smsm42 on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:05AM (#25109651)
Ads serve several functions:

1. Inform the consumer that certain offering exists. If someone invents a new superior type of coffee maker, they should let people know that there's now an option to make their coffee in a better way. There's nothing unethical in that. Of course, you can invent something like cigarettes, which people would be better without, but most inventions aren't like that.

2. Inform consumer that certain provider exists. I.e. if you have 20 coffee maker vendors, all alike, then when a customer goes to buy a coffee maker, they would tend to choose one they heard something good about, thus brand promotion and celebrity endorsements. This _might_ be somewhat unethical if inferior product is promoted with superior ones available, but usually there is enough offerings of similar quality that this is pretty neutral. Sometimes also something good comes out of it when companies sponsor worthy causes to get attention.

3. Associate the offering in consumer's mind with something positive and desirable. This one may be the ethically questionable one, as usually the association is completely bogus and is not based on any actual qualities of the offering but only on unsubstantiated claims of the advertiser that consuming the offering makes the customer "a kind of person" they want themselves to be. This is the kind that gives advertising the bad rep. But most online ads are actually not of this kind - it's just much harder to make such kinds of ads as a small banner.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by silveroriole on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:33AM (#25109816)
You don’t need product adverts for ‘ethical’ functions 1 and 2. Honest aggregators and reviewers which the buyer can seek out when they need something would fulfil that. I think that would also be much more convenient for the buyer (though obviously not for the seller, who wants to invent needs in people who otherwise wouldn’t think of buying anything).
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by jan_Inkepa on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:54AM (#25109955)
I’ve had some experiences getting hungry while visiting unfamiliar city centres pre-smartphone and wishing there was more public advertising of restaurants. That is to say, there’s definitely some minimal amount of advertising that I apparently want in my life.

If you don’t rely on advertising (speaking directly to possible customers) then you have to work with journalists other middle-men, whose tastes might not reflect those of your customers, or you have for a network to build, which might be too slow. Possible grateful future customers loose out here too.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Jochim on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:36PM (#25116690)
In what way do the aggregators/reviewers not solve that issue for you though?

If I see a place that has 100+ 5 stars on tripadvisor/yelp I'm much more likely to go than if I see an advertisement, because at that point I know a reasonable number of actual people have gone and liked the experience.

I typically dismiss any claims an advert makes as total bullshit because adverts are lying to you the majority of the time. In the case of a restaurant it might work if you're advertising that you're newly opened, but otherwise I'm wondering why people aren't being pulled in when they look on sites like tripadvisor/yelp.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by smsm42 on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:30PM (#25115932)
You don't "need" ads, as in there are other ways to do it, if there was some reason to never use ads. But there's no reason, so ads are used too, and are quite effective in that too. And it won't be convenient for a buyer that doesn't know certain offering exists. I.e. if I don't know such thing as wireless headphones existed, I couldn't effectively look it up and seek reviews for it - somebody should tell me first - dude, did you know you can get rid of those annoying wires and just buy wireless ones? Now, did I "need" them? Strictly speaking, no - I could very well have lived all my life with wired ones and be fine. But wireless are better for me, so why should I resent someone who tries to sell them to me? For me, it's a win-win.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Jochim on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:28PM (#25116610)
In response to 3. I'd argue it's a much bigger factor than we'd think. Instagram as a platform is now based almost entirely around influencers creating an idealised and unattainable representation of a lifestyle and then selling ad space for your product to be seen as part of that lifestyle.

All social media enables/encourages this to a certain degree and I think the personal touch and reach that individuals give to the products they promote is potentially far more subtle and harmful than the banner ads we typically think of as problematic.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by kennywinker on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:18AM (#25108676)
You're not wrong, but with tracking and targeting it is able to become exponentially more invasive. So now instead of advertising to broad classes of people, they can exploit specific weaknesses and specific moments of weakness. Technology takes advertising from the ethical scale of a petty crime, into the realm of war crimes.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by adrianN on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:37AM (#25108798)
Yes of course, the more effective the ad is the less I like it :)
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by a_imho on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:55AM (#25111610)
Agreed. Push/pull. If someone wants to learn about that new offering, go ahead and seek out. Otherwise it is literally spam. All without talking about the privacy/security of electronic ads.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by anopol on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:44AM (#25108832)
This take misunderstands how effective online advertising works. Effective advertising targets people who are likely to want the product or service already. The idea that ads can change people's minds to get them to buy something they don't want is so wrong. You would waste so much money trying to change peoples' minds. This isn't like Inception. In all my (and people I've read and worked with) experience, you have a chance at profitable ROI when you run ads targeting people likely to want what you're already selling, and just try to make them consider your product or service. You'd be guaranteeing negative ROI trying to change minds.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by adrianN on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:13AM (#25108995)
I disagree. Take the fashion industry for example. There is zero reason to replace clothing as quickly as we tend to. Almost all of the demand is produced by ads. Or take cars, very few people need cars of the size that they end up buying. But ads suggest that they might want to pull a trailer through rough terrain, or that bigger is more prestigious.

You might not be able to change an individual's choices by very much, but all these tiny nudges in aggregate push society more and more towards unsustainable levels of consumption, without improving happiness.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by amf12 on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:35AM (#25109832)
There is zero reason to replace clothing as quickly as we tend to. Almost all of the demand is produced by ads. Or take cars, very few people need cars of the size that they end up buying. But ads suggest that they might want to pull a trailer through rough terrain, or that bigger is more prestigious.

I think the problem here is not the ads but that people are gullible. If those people can afford to buy a car which can pull a trailer when they don't need to its not because of advertising, it's because consumption makes them happy.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Jochim on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:39PM (#25116720)
Aren't we waking up to the fact that consumption doesn't make people happy though? In fact advertising now actively seeks to make us feel unhappy in our current situation, promising whatever it is the advert is selling as the key to being able to achieve happiness. You might feel happy for a short while after buying that thing, but the problem is that there are always more adverts seeking to make you feel unfulfilled than things you can buy.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by smsm42 on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:13AM (#25109699)
> But ads suggest that they might want to pull a trailer through rough terrain,

Most cars I see around on the roads are family sedans and not trucks. Some are SUVs but those are not for hauling trailers - those are for hauling groceries and kids to the soccer games. So I don't think the trailer one works very well :)

And actually if you take about prestigious, two-person convertible looks much cooler than your standard family-size SUV/minivan. But people that buy the latter usually buy it not because they want to be cool, see above.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by mytailorisrich on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:47AM (#25109910)
> There is zero reason to replace clothing as quickly as we tend to.

That's irrelevant to the topic of ads.

Clothing is of cultural and societal importance for individuals in a group and we've become rich enough to afford to essentially buy items of clothing as we please.

This runs quite deep in human society. Look at every human groups on the planet even the most isolated and 'primitive'. People wear symbols and try to make themselves more attractive.

Clothing ads are just a 'symptom'. Our behaviour runs much deeper than that.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by joijoiwejrr on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:47AM (#25109915)
What if people already have enough pointless junk?

My problem is not that I want to see ads that are more "relevant", it's that I don't want to see ads. I don't care what you're selling. If my problem that you're trying to solve is really that important, I'd be actively searching for a solution, not waiting to be enlightened by a targeted advert.

Adtech evangelists seem to think that my biggest problem is a burning surplus of cash that I'm just desperate to get rid of. If only I could find more products to buy so I could be liberated from the pain of having money in the bank! Er, no thanks. I'll put my spare cash towards saving for a house and retirement and the occasional luxury; save your bullshit for the people who don't know how to install Adblock.

(The other way I use my spare cash on is to pay directly for content, because almost everything that's wrong with the Internet and modern media is the fault of the current ad-driven paradigm, and only future I want to live in is one where ads are dead.)

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by eindiran on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:19AM (#25109029)
> Effective advertising targets people who are likely to want the product or service already.

The whole point of advertising is getting conversions: convincing people who previously weren't going to buy your product that they should buy your product.

Some of the people that are converted just didn't know about your product, some had forgotten about it, some thought a competitors product was better, etc. So there is a sense in which the vast majority of people you convert aren't people who specifically "don't want" your product. And you're definitely right that this isn't Inception-tier infiltration of the mind. But at the same time, the conversions you are trying to get are the people who don't want your product yet, but just need a tiny push to want it.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by imtringued on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:29AM (#25109080)
I saw a pretty good low end CNC machine in an ad and there is a 0% chance I would have found out about it through any other means because the presence of the company is basically 0. I still didn't buy it.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by tsimionescu on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:33AM (#25109817)
There are well-known and documented PR campaigns designed exactly for the purpose of changing minds. Of course, this is big money, and the vast majority of individual ads are of the type you mention.

But it's quite likely that the majority, or at least plurality, of ad spending goes to the changing minds kind of campaign. This is especially visible in the massive popularity of lifestyle marketing campaigns, that seek to create a particular image making a product (or even type of product) more desirable. Think of the Coca Cola Christmas, "green" cars, hyper-technologized "smart" fridges/washing machines, fashion brands, Apple's success a few years ago in convincing people to change their phone each year etc.

You also shouldn't forget the disgusting world of children's advertising, where often the goal is to convince children to nag their parents or friends about an item - often by explicitly showing this type of behavior, which works wonders with small children especially.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by iamacyborg on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:15AM (#25109344)
> Effective advertising targets people who are likely to want the product or service already.

Yes and no.

The problem with digital advertising is that the only part that's easy to measure is what's happening at the bottom of the funnel. Which means that a disproportionate amount of effort and attention gets spent on those campaigns.

There's a whole layer of awareness advertising which, while it's not about influencing behaviour, is certainly about building consumer awareness of a brand or product to later build purchase intent.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by mytailorisrich on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:13AM (#25109329)
> Their main objective is to make us want things we didn't want before.

Is it the main objective, though?

IMHO the main objective is to make potential customers aware that you exist. It's very basic behaviour for someone who tries to sell something, like setting up your fruits cart on a busy road, in full view, and not in a deserted backstreet.

There is nothing intrinsically unethical about ads or targeted ads.

Targeted ads are not that different from telling a friend about something you saw or heard of because you know that they might be interested.

"Unethical" is one of those terms that is being exponentially thrown at anything some people don't like, which only hollows out its meaning.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Nursie on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:47AM (#25109534)
> Targeted ads are not that different from telling a friend about something you saw or heard of because you know that they might be interested.

Oh please.

Targeted ads are like following people around, tracking everything they do, then interrupting them as they go about their business to interject your commercial "message" about something you think you can sell them for a profit, regardless of genuine need.

They are absolutely nothing like interaction between friends.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by mytailorisrich on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:50AM (#25109548)
You describe one possible way to do targeted ads, and probably the worst way in order to support your point, but this does not represent targeted ads in general.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Nursie on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:58AM (#25109610)
It precisely describes targeted ads, using user data that's been generated by monitoring their activity to sell something you want to sell them.

Advertising is all, pretty much by definition, entirely unlike a friendly recommendation. It has a profit motive.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by jan_Inkepa on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:08AM (#25110065)
Many recommendations from friends also don’t have my best interests at heart.

Here are reasons friends recommend things in my experience:

  * They think I’ll like it (A++). 
  * They like it (When their default way of expressing enthusiasm for something is recommending it, one has to learn to not take it so literally.  Also, I’m not discounting the opportunity for shared bonding over something that at least one of us enjoys though.  Is this category of recommendation a symptom of having a weak theory of mind? I don’t know).
  * Loyalty (they’ll recommend products by friends/associates/compatriots, irrespective of quality).
  * Financial kickbacks/business connections.  (Still can be useful).
  * Pyramid schemes (almost no experience with this, thankfully. I guess the same as #4 but also creepier).
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Nursie on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:41AM (#25110230)
The pyramid thing is creepy, because it seeks to exploit friendship bonds. And usually only for the benefit of the company, the seller most often is being suckered into losing money as well.

I wouldn't really consider someone doing your last two things there to be doing something friendly, those are self-interested actions and I would treat them with suspicion.

The first three though, sure, those are friendly actions. Their utility is variable, but they aren't motivated by personal profit.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by mrow84 on Monday November 16, 2020 @11:53AM (#25113901)
No idea who flagged your next reply but I was going to say that I think the first sentence of it detracted from your otherwise good points in this thread.

I have vouched but I doubt it will have any effect, which I think is a shame because it think that, other than that single sentence, your conversation was constructive.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Nursie on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:54PM (#25115496)
Thanks. I wasn't trying to be inflammatory, but perhaps I need to moderate my language somewhat.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by mytailorisrich on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:08AM (#25109675)
It is obvious that targeted ads require knowledge (data) about the person. But it does not imply anything sinister despite what you're claiming it does in your comments, again you're picking a worst case. It's like claiming that cars are awful things by claiming that all cars are driven by drunks who end up killing people.

If I own an ecommerce marketplace I can look at a customer's previous purchases in order to gain some insights on what might interest them. There is absolutely nothing sinister, unethical, or just wrong about this. This is simply using knowledge about someone gained in a relationship in order to improve your service, again not too different from the knowledge you gain about your friends (or anyone you get to know since my use of the term 'friends' seems to bother you. This is not important to the point), which you use to improve, so to speak, your relationship with them.

Of course there is a profit motive, but this is a red herring. A good business profits by actually helping their customers, ie. by providing them with something of value to them.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by craftinator on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:56AM (#25108905)
This literally sums up my perspective on all modern advertising practices. The way we do advertising is manipulative and evil; the goal of advertising is no longer to alert people of potential solutions to their problems, it's to psychology manipulate them into buying something whether they want it or not.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by thdrdt on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:01AM (#25108938)
It has always been like this.

The Mad Man series are about an advertisement company in the fifties.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by legulere on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:08AM (#25109289)
It started around in the 1910s, 1920s when psychology was introduced to advertising:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_advertising

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by iamacyborg on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:16AM (#25109352)
Season 1 of Mad Men starts in 1960,not the 50's.
[dead]
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by _tulpa on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:14AM (#25108999)
Ignorant of the existence of some inane bullshit that they don’t actually need, because they haven’t been motivated to look for a solution to a real problem?

Sure! This is exactly where ignorance is bliss.

Modern marketing is just spreading dissatisfaction (sometimes borderline misery) with the false promise of relief through consumerism.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Camas on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:50AM (#25111566)
I'm guessing you have strong opinions on what makes something a Real Solution and not just Inane Bullshit I Don't Actually Need
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by _tulpa on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:00PM (#25114856)
No. You just missed the entire point...

I do have strong opinions about exploitation of other humans though, and probably stronger ones about modern mental gymnastics apparatus which lets people justify the whole thing.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Camas on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @02:01AM (#25120956)
When you move to calling it exploitation, and offer no other argument, do you think you're convincing me or yourself?

I think I understand you completely.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by emptyfile on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:01AM (#25109631)
I guess since I use addblock I already am ignorant.

Feels a lot better then seeing every website plastered with foot fungus cures and stuff I just bought the other day.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by legulere on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:10AM (#25109300)
Ads make people ignorant as they are not based on facts but making you believe insane things how products will change your life. Axe deodorant won’t make women crazy for you
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by fakedang on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:37AM (#25110206)
Just a tangential anecdote, but I once bought an Axe deodorant when I was staying in a boarding school in a really humid place. The smell actually made many of my female classmates cringe/move away when I sat in front of them. I had no idea about how they felt.

After that spray was over (a few months later), I decided to switch to Playboy (which was cheaper at the time), mostly because I liked its smell. It had the added bonus of being tolerable too. A few days later, my teacher bought the same Axe deo that I had, and that's when I realized that that deo would literally mix with sweat to give off this wafting smell, as though you were a raving alcoholic. The smell was unbearable to say the least, and would literally make me choke. Thankfully someone had the nuts to convey that to the teacher and he switched deos.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Camas on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:37AM (#25111433)
If you believe most people are idiots you can justify pretty much anything
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by legulere on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:41PM (#25116064)
So you believe that your mind can withstand an entire industry that is specialized in manipulating you? They use these techniques because they work. And some part of it you cannot escape from even if you actively try.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Camas on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @01:51AM (#25120908)
You're assuming because adverts work it must be due to manipulation, and nothing else.

And yes, to link back to your initial comment, I think most people know that an Axe advert isn't real.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by strombofulous on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:17AM (#25109021)
Can you explain why you think this makes people ignorant?
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Camas on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:16AM (#25111235)
See every other reply to my comment
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by renewiltord on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:37AM (#25108789)
Honestly, I'm just disappointed it's legal to tell people about a new purchase. For the same reason, it should really be illegal. Keeping up with the Joneses should be punishable by death.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by ineedasername on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:16AM (#25109009)
I also think the government should murder you for wanting the nice things that other people have.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by renewiltord on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:14AM (#25109332)
HAHA! Truly absurd indeed. But anyway, the point was that ads are just speech.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by imtringued on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:26AM (#25109069)
>Their main objective is to make us want things we didn't want before.

The main objective of ads is to connect buyers and sellers via brand recognition. That's why companies spend so much money on advertising.

The problems with digital ads is that they are deceptive, clickbait, annoying, resource hogs, ugly and a source of malware.

For some reason my preferred news site has these shitty low quality clickbait ads that make you lose a lot of brain cells each time you see them.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by TeMPOraL on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:15AM (#25109345)
> The main objective of ads is to connect buyers and sellers via brand recognition. That's why companies spend so much money on advertising.

That's a "motte and bailey" defense of advertising, though. If the stated main objective of connecting (existing) buyers and sellers were true, almost all ads would be restricted to opt-in forms like trade shows and catalogs (be it paper or digital). After all, it makes sense to let a buyer self-identify before spending money and effort on informing them about your wares.

The actual primary objective of most advertising, as demonstrated in the real world[0], is to create new buyers, and recapture those you buy from your competition.

> The problems with digital ads is that they are deceptive, clickbait, annoying, (...) ugly (...).

That's started way before digital. Check out pictures of some old newspapers or billboards from a century ago - that was "clickbait" 100 years ago too. It does read strange (all that presumptuous and grandiose language), but it's only because we've became culturally immune to that kind of wording. More recently, I'd argue TV ads were and are the worst - the current form was refined into pure and unadulterated brainwashing. On-line at least mostly spares us that.

--

[0] - "The purpose of a system is what it does". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_purpose_of_a_system_is_wha...

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by legulere on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:04AM (#25109264)
All ads are deceptive since the introduction of psychology in ads.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by harry8 on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:13AM (#25108648)
Ads providing information about proper precautions for covid and any new temporary regulations that should be adhered to have probably saved lives.

"All ..." frequently leads to obvious counter-examples and exceptions.

When you invent the new thing that completely solves the problem, how will you let people know that your thing is available and works just great?

Well the answer to that for designer labels is to hire film stars to appear in expensive tv ads so you can buy stink that costs cents to make for hundreds of dollars which obviously makes the world a better, kinder more equitable place for Chanel. /s

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by adrianN on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:40AM (#25108810)
I wouldn't call things providing information about Covid precautions "ads", because they don't advertise goods or services. I'd refer to them as public information campaigns.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by harry8 on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:44AM (#25109898)
That's a distiniction without a difference. Ads you like are now public information campaigns, ads you don't aren't.

"The government is about to pass a bill to lock up your reproductive organs. Join the campaing to free the genetalia!" Public information or ad? Context depedent, sure, and also dependent on your views on whether the bill is actually teriffic, terrible or anywhere between the extremes.

Still an ad to make the public aware of the information.

For covid info, advertising slots are still bought. They are filled with content tha has been paid to be created to fit the format and effectively convey the message, including on an emotional level. The covid information ads still decorate media being consumed for reasons other than seeing the associated ads.

"All $whatever..." rarely works out.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by adrianN on Monday November 16, 2020 @08:20AM (#25111276)
No, the distinction is about as clear as distinctions go that you make in a HN comment as opposed to a scholarly article on sociology. If someone tries to influence you to make a profit for themselves (e.g. by getting you to spend money on their products) then it's an ad. If your government tries to tell you how to protect yourself or others from a threat then that's not an ad.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by harry8 on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:00PM (#25113996)
And what then about the opposition's paid information disbursement when the government policy is wanting? An ad or not? Then of course if, according to your definition there are no ads there is no place for the mandadated government paid slots which aren't ads to run. If you're a non-profit, like say a church, selling any of the things churches sell, then that's an ad for that stuff that's not an ad so that's then ok. If the profit you make is by being elected and then being a crook, then that's not an ad. If you're just doing brand awareness and recognition and promoting the fact that your company does charitable good works that's also not an ad. In fact the majority of ads I've seen don't have an explicit "you should buy this" line in them at all. The construction is obvious and basically nobody misses it but it's not actually explicitly there. Certainly Chanel's stink ads, which are the epitome of everything I hate, don't.

The grey areas here overlap so badly and based on opinion alone that it really is a distinction without a difference. Any rule you set up I'll show you as many exceptions that show it's futile until boredom takes over.

You slice it any way you like. Do they take money for services? Ok so UNICEF information is ads but political advertisements are not. The Coca-Cola company endorses being nice to puppies and supporting your local shelter.

There can't be a clear distinction. There can't be sensible policy that fairly discriminates between good and bad paid 30 second television slots or between good and bad magazine spreads, between good and bad PR influenced news articles or anything of that nature.

The Covid information adverts that probably saved lives. They could easily have had the opposite information content and cost lives. Without verifying it, i'd be sure that somewhere in the world they were and activists were advocating a better response with paid ads which were funded by industry groups.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by kennywinker on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:22AM (#25108695)
The issue is that there is no difference between smell-water and "new thing that solves problems", under capitalism. If an advertisement can tell you about a real problem, and make you buy (or quarantine) then that's good, but an ad can just as easily create a problem, and there is no way to differentiate between those. So while ads may have done occasional good, or made someone's life a little better by offering a solution to a problem they had, it's also filled the ocean with plastic.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by ineedasername on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:11AM (#25108985)
"problems" have quite a wide spectrum. For some people, they perceive their problem to be that they don't smell the way they want to smell, or the way they think other people want them to smell. An ad that says "this smell water smells the way you want to smell" will help solve their problem.

In this sense, to "solve" advertising, you can't just avoid advertising things that don't solve problems, you need to address the underlying causes for the perception of countless problems that may or may not actually be relevant/rational etc.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by TeMPOraL on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:47AM (#25109170)
> For some people, they perceive their problem to be that they don't smell the way they want to smell, or the way they think other people want them to smell.

This is one of the prime examples of problems that are explicitly created by advertising itself. What these example people perceive as a problem and the way they see it are product of generations of advertising.

> you need to address the underlying causes for the perception of countless problems that may or may not actually be relevant/rational etc.

There is nothing to address here. The market is an optimization system. As long as there exist a single exploitable loophole in the human psyche - and there always will be something[0] - advertising industry will evolve to find and exploit it. Lying to people, or making them feel bad and offering a product to relieve the emotional pain? All par for the course, tried and true methods.

Advertising - and marketing in general - needs to be reined in, because it's a cancer on modern society.

--

[0] - Even if we were emotion-free robots with perfect reasoning capabilities, there's only so much time an individual has to acquire and process information about any given thing. This limit, and prioritization in general, is exploitable too.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by ineedasername on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:09AM (#25111770)
My point was rather that people always want things. Take away ads and that doesn't change: Long before ads people fought each other so one group could get the things the other group has.

I'm not advocating for anything positive about ads, but when I say we need to address underlying causes, it's that thousands of years old behavioral pattern I mean. Destroy all ads, it will still be here.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by TeMPOraL on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:25AM (#25111964)
That's true. And I don't think we can really eliminate the underlying behavioral pattern entirely. But we can limit its consequences and channel it in productive ways. Advertising was never properly constrained, and it's grown far beyond its usefulness for society; I think cutting it down to manageable size would already be a huge win - after all, we ultimately care about negative consequences of advertising, not about the concept existing in the abstract.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by ineedasername on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:07AM (#25112523)
I think we fundamentally agree, but I am also thinking about the greater system in which advertising exists. Ads drive consumerism, and we have an economy that is driven by consumerism. Technological advancement, economic stability and growth, it is paid for by the creation of economic value driven by consumerism. Societies with unstable economic systems do not stay stable themselves for very long unless the economic issues are addressed.

So we cannot remove or drastically reduce advertising without it causing far-reaching second-order consequences that in turn have their own consequences. Less ads, people buy less stuff. Places that make stuff make less of it, or go out of business, and not as many people are needed to make that stuff. Businesses that supported those businesses suffer the same problem. Countries whose economies rely on us buying their stuff or having our stuff made in those countries suffer major economic losses.

Lets take the consumer electronics industry. Lets say we just got rid of advertising for things to the point where everyone was willing to keep their stuff twice as long and buy less stuff they don't really need. That industry is about $1 Trillion/year. Let's say the second-order economic effects from support industries that depend on that are another $500 Billion. Still doesn't seem like a lot in the scheme of things, a little under 1% of the world GDP. But it's also not evenly distributed. Some countries are hit much harder. The economies of South Korea & China are hit particularly hard. And a part of China's stability is driven economic growth that supports propaganda promising increased quality of life. War may not break out, but small cracks start to appear. Do that same for the automobile industry, and that's about another $2.5 trillion out of the economy.

So we cannot remove from this system a part we don't like and still have that system function the same way. I guess we can go into it eyes-open and say "it's worth the consequences" and go ahead with it. Or, and this is my preference, we can try to understand the system well enough to figure out how we can change the parts we don't like smoothly enough to avoid the worse of those consequences.

None of this means we shouldn't complain about ads, and want them to go away. But if we're being practical about it, we don't just need a way to get rid of ads, we also need a way to patch that hole in the system.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by hvdfhbj on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:28AM (#25109402)
You seem to be suggesting that humans only prefer certain smells (eg a nice perfume) to others (dirt and sweat) because advertising has created this desire. I don't believe this is true.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by TeMPOraL on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:50AM (#25109553)
No, I'm suggesting that the problem of dirt and sweat smells is solvable with basic cosmetics, and doesn't require such ridiculously huge fragrance sector. What's propping it up is advertising - both directly, and by maintaining fragrance as social signalling mechanism.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by harry8 on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:55AM (#25109960)
>The issue is that there is no difference between smell-water and "new thing that solves problems", under capitalism.

Yeah, but not just capitalism. Anywhere you don't have unelected legislators imposing censorship on what they feel is good and wholesome and what isn't. Competing candidate's platform advertisements in the run-up to a union election in that union's newsletter isn't displaying a lot of capitalism and it's as true there as mop advertisements between talk-show segments on late night tv. (One or more of the candidates might be, gasp, wilfully and knowingly telling, omg, lies!)

When the ads are creating a problem that is actually difficult to solve they're revealing a problem that is not the ads themselves. It's a crisis in education and the general public's ability (or the pereception of it) to do a decent job critical thinking and bs detecting.

Making cruel fun of ridiculous fear-mongering accross society ought to be the answer to organised lying. When it isn't, getting Zuck & Jack to censor it is kind of a worrying development. Tough to get that back in the bottle even if it's initially done in support of causes you kinda like, coz you know that condition of it only being "for good", (where /you/ define good) will not last. Guaranteed. Never does.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by craftinator on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:58AM (#25108920)
I'm sorry sir, but your argument is shit. It's a false rationalizing, and it should be put down, along with all modern advertising practices.