News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by mytailorisrich on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:50AM (#25109548)
You describe one possible way to do targeted ads, and probably the worst way in order to support your point, but this does not represent targeted ads in general.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Nursie on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:58AM (#25109610)
It precisely describes targeted ads, using user data that's been generated by monitoring their activity to sell something you want to sell them.

Advertising is all, pretty much by definition, entirely unlike a friendly recommendation. It has a profit motive.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by jan_Inkepa on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:08AM (#25110065)
Many recommendations from friends also don’t have my best interests at heart.

Here are reasons friends recommend things in my experience:

  * They think I’ll like it (A++). 
  * They like it (When their default way of expressing enthusiasm for something is recommending it, one has to learn to not take it so literally.  Also, I’m not discounting the opportunity for shared bonding over something that at least one of us enjoys though.  Is this category of recommendation a symptom of having a weak theory of mind? I don’t know).
  * Loyalty (they’ll recommend products by friends/associates/compatriots, irrespective of quality).
  * Financial kickbacks/business connections.  (Still can be useful).
  * Pyramid schemes (almost no experience with this, thankfully. I guess the same as #4 but also creepier).
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Nursie on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:41AM (#25110230)
The pyramid thing is creepy, because it seeks to exploit friendship bonds. And usually only for the benefit of the company, the seller most often is being suckered into losing money as well.

I wouldn't really consider someone doing your last two things there to be doing something friendly, those are self-interested actions and I would treat them with suspicion.

The first three though, sure, those are friendly actions. Their utility is variable, but they aren't motivated by personal profit.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by mrow84 on Monday November 16, 2020 @11:53AM (#25113901)
No idea who flagged your next reply but I was going to say that I think the first sentence of it detracted from your otherwise good points in this thread.

I have vouched but I doubt it will have any effect, which I think is a shame because it think that, other than that single sentence, your conversation was constructive.

Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by Nursie on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:54PM (#25115496)
Thanks. I wasn't trying to be inflammatory, but perhaps I need to moderate my language somewhat.
Re:Only 17% of consumers believe personalized ads are ethica... by mytailorisrich on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:08AM (#25109675)
It is obvious that targeted ads require knowledge (data) about the person. But it does not imply anything sinister despite what you're claiming it does in your comments, again you're picking a worst case. It's like claiming that cars are awful things by claiming that all cars are driven by drunks who end up killing people.

If I own an ecommerce marketplace I can look at a customer's previous purchases in order to gain some insights on what might interest them. There is absolutely nothing sinister, unethical, or just wrong about this. This is simply using knowledge about someone gained in a relationship in order to improve your service, again not too different from the knowledge you gain about your friends (or anyone you get to know since my use of the term 'friends' seems to bother you. This is not important to the point), which you use to improve, so to speak, your relationship with them.

Of course there is a profit motive, but this is a red herring. A good business profits by actually helping their customers, ie. by providing them with something of value to them.