I think Roma are the least interesting example of this.
In 2020 I had the pleasure of reading the Nobel Laureate Sigrid Undset's Magnum Opus _Kristin Lavransdatter_.
For those that don't know, _Kristin Lavransdatter_ is the Norwegian _Anna Karenina_ ... but longer. Recommended.
In the book, among other things, it describes that Norwegians in the fourteenth century thought that Finnish people were basically sub-humans. They were treated like animals and could be killed (!) without legal ramification.
Let that sink in for a bit ...
Blonde-haired, blue-eyed Handt Hanson considered Blonde-haired, blue-eyed Eli Halla to not even be a human being.
I think there may be some deep conclusions to make about the nature of division and difference in human societies. Could it be that there will never not be an out-group ?
From my perspective the United States is amazing because a lot of "white" people who stick together are actually from different parts of Europe who might not have always been fond of each other.
This is all conjecture but as a european I feel like I can easier spot where a european is from based on their appearance, while white americans don't see that in each other.
Similarly black americans are from wildly different parts of Africa who might have been at war during some time. But in the US they're all black americans.
I find this very fascinating, which shows how much more divided we are here and definitely prejudiced.
That's because you have seen italians speaking and acting italian, romanians speaking romanian etc. Americans see americans speaking american
Compare the advice a Chinese teacher in Shanghai gave my class when someone asked about telling whether someone was Japanese or Chinese: "It's easy. Japanese people wear much nicer clothes."
It's more than a bit. It's institutionalised and pervasive racism.
One big difference from the US is that Eastern-Europeans don't even acknowledge there is any racism against gypsies so it's not even part of the public discourse. Much like how fish don't realise they're surrounded by water, so do Eastern Europeans not acknowledge that they live in a racist society. The tensions flaring up in the US are partly caused by the fact that the opressed category is trying to get equal footing in society. If gypsies were to start talking about how they should be treated equally, you can bet there would be a backlash from a big part of society.
For comparison, look at how the US treated race relations 100 years ago. (To be clear, I'm not saying Eastern-European countries are backwards or more primitive just because they can be compared to the US in the past; it's just a helpful way to understand the context.)
Source: I'm originally from an Eastern European country and only realised the racism in Eastern Europe once I lived abroad for multiple years and drew parallels with the highly mediatised US racial tensions.
"We are not satisfied with the fact that one nation keeps the remnants of another from birth to death under police surveillance, we know that the vast majority of the oppressed nation is innocent and irresponsible for the actions of their anti-social minority, whose actions are justified by the current social order ... that mud would be slung on the rest of the nomadic nation and that it be made lawless in such a way that all human rights, which, even according to this constitution, belong to every human being, are taken away from this nation only because its members are dark-skinned. "
more details here: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=cs&tl=en&u=https:/...
I've been having exactly(!) the same "only after I lived abroad" experience.
'Race Relation' are a luxury of wealthier western countries. When you are struggling for food/heat/shelter yourself, it is hard to worry about other's problems.
I think it will take at least one more generation for things to slowly change.
In America, if people say "The things people say about Black people are a gross simplification HOWEVER", it's usually something really racist that's about to follow. Say, "Sure many Black people are fine, but if you find yourself surrounded by Black people in the Inner City, you are in danger." I mean, I dunno.
That said, people pay way too much attention to murder and violent crime in public discourse and in their private lives for the most part. Sure, Black people may murder at 5x the rate of non-Black people, but murder is really, really rare. What about we worry about, I dunno, diabetes? Education? Population growth? Climate change?
It really depends. I've been in that situation in open air markets, at fairs etc and no, definitely not in trouble. Walk into a ghetto? Maybe.
I thought gypsy was the exonym for the Roma(ni) people. Are there other "gypsy" peoples?
Part of the problem is that a nomadic lifestyle just doesn't gel with modern society so they don't integrate at all. For the same reason it's hard for these people to find work and a subset do often turn to crime.
Culturally they also have very conservative and often misogynistic views which acts as another barrier to integration.
In ways it is similar to the issues with Islamic migrants integrating into European society. It's too simplistic to just label it as racism and be done with it (not to say there isn't racism). There are real issues.
Yes I heard people use that label for all nomadic minorities. I wonder if it's improper use of the word.
As an American this always baffles me.
Hell if I know. I'm bulgarian, and you can imagine how this was portrayed to me, by parents, school, friends, etc. This article actually opened my eyes. Not that I didn't know how it looked, but how would it feel...
We know with certainty that the gypsies came from India, though we don't know the details.
Many of the replies to your comment are from Europeans defending their prejudice likewise as "oh but you don't understand, in Europe it's different because you may be surrounded by a gang of people that are clearly gypsy and they rob you, so it's easy to see why!".
But that's the exact same thing with X race in Y country. Such as blacks in America. It's a broad brush stroke based on an experience or group of experiences that eventually paints the whole race that way.
You can find these things in basically every country, sadly.
https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0494831/
Documentary above also really nicely shows the microculture of these people
Ofcourse I don't know how big this group was, relative to all Roma people in the US. This was some reality marriage show, I think on TLC or something. (yes, my then-girlfriend watched this :) ).
Once Eastern Europeans of other ethnicities are no longer willing to do migrant work, Western farms and slaughterhouses shall run out of options and employ Roma migrant workers. This is already happening.
https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/can-europe-make-it/eyes-wid...
In Denmark they're committing a mass crime against humanity in a cultural cleansing against their Muslim minority, a vicious fascist action, and nobody cares to stop it.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/01/world/europe/denmark-immi... (https://archive.is/Um7tE)
https://www.vox.com/world/2018/7/3/17525960/denmark-children...
https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2020/01/15/denmarks-ghett...
As rule of thumb the bigger the distance from the Blue Banana the less enlightenment you encounter. Especially in the eastern and southern direction.
It's only as an adult that I realized this was probably a racial or cultural slur.
Europeans spent centuries coming up with creative ways to kill each other in the name of god, country or race, and was able to move on to better things only after having been on the precipice of annihilation.
The American condition shouldn’t be whitewashed and is a story that is still evolving. But people are people, and the stories of America or Europe or some subdivision are more about people than country.
Brexit was one big middle finger to the Polish diaspora.
On the larger point, it's possible xenophobia is "natural", but I think it pays to be very cautious about what is "natural" or not among humans, what even that means. So so much is our social context. We can look at what social contexts (re)produce xenophobia and which don't without even having to decide what is "natural" though.
Most comments in this thread, even the ones with a negative tinge, show some evidence of earnestly wrestling with the topic. Your post does not. Please don't post like this here.
I will continue to do what I do. I recommend that you ban me though.
Most people here do not have that experience. In their ignorance they think, that it is a case of racism. It is not. It is not tolerating asocial behavior.
Romas, who integrate into the society are accepted by the majority. Unfortunately, that requires for the individuals to break ties with their community, because their community encourages their members to behave asocially. It is really hard problem, you cannot even start with pupils in school, as they routinely skip it, because... see previous sentence.
Untold millions of euro were spent to solve this problem. It was wasted money.
In fact, here in the south, they are completely indistinguishable--we have the exact same skin colour, facial features, etc. You can only tell romas apart when they choose to. In other words, this is not a case similar to blacks in America.
As you said it is probably an unsolvable problem. Better in ghettos than causing trouble. If any roma wants to leave the ghetto and live a normal life, nobody would bat an eye--in fact, nobody would even notice.
Being surprised and even afraid of someone that looks very different from what you are used to is natural in a 3 years old.
Or in an aboriginal that has never seen a person from the other side of the world before.
Fostering hate is a completely different thing.
Especially if someone has the opportunity to learn what racism it, and yet choses to be racist.
[citation needed]
Whoever you think you're arguing against in your reply to my post, it's not me.
Let me make my position clear.
Racism is not a white invention.
I never said it, I don't believe it.
What I said is "Not everybody's racist".
That doesn't mean there aren't racists in all societies or cultures. Maybe there are maybe there aren't. That's tangential to my point. But it's clear that there are many racists in many societies.
But, again, that doesn't mean that "everybody's racist". They're just not.
Neither does my point imply that "racism is a white invention or has anything to do with being white". You picked that out of thin air, not out of anything I said, because I never so much as implied it.
I always respond by pointing out that the citizens of almost every country are naturally xenophobic and/or racist, just not necessarily against people of African descent. In the case of Europe, I usually point to the Roma as an area where Europeans tend to be a bit racist. I had no idea there were huge Roma ghettos in Bulgaria, but I knew of some Roma communities when I lived in Rome, Italy. And without fail, countless Italians warned me to steer clear of the Roma because "they are all liars and thieves"...