News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by m3kw9 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @11:07AM (#24960358)
Same as what happened to mp3s RIAA is the best marketer of pirate methods, and the dumbest
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by mekoka on Sunday November 01, 2020 @11:18AM (#24960432)
But youtube-dl is not a "pirate method", it's a neutral tool for downloading video contents. Presumably, you have the right to download those contents.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by xorcist on Sunday November 01, 2020 @02:51PM (#24961977)
Could we not call it "watch" instead? It's a neutral tool to watch youtube videos.

How exactly the video file gets downloaded into the viewing device is an implementation detail. Whether it's a MythTV plugin, that free Android app, Firefox, or this Python tool isn't important. If one of them is declared illegal in some jurisdiction, they all are.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by nkrisc on Sunday November 01, 2020 @05:29PM (#24963107)
It's important if a court cares, which would probably be the case. Watching a YouTube video on Firefox is unlikely to be construed as circumventing DRM while downloading the same video with youtube-dl conceivably could be construed as such.

Courts aren't always concerned with technical differences, more often intent.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by xorcist on Monday November 02, 2020 @11:58AM (#24970248)
No court has found any of the mentioned software to be illegal so far, anywhere.

They are all interchangeable. Should one implementation be found problematic, in theory it can be swapped with another.

It's not comparable to DRM, where a particular software can be licensed for a particular digital protection mechanism. In this case either they all are, or none are.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by nkrisc on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @11:38AM (#24981189)
You're still just focused on technical implementation and not the intent behind actions, which is also important and will likely be considered by the courts.

While there is no technical difference, there is quite a difference of intent between watching a streaming video and downloading it to circumvent copy-protection.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by hsbauauvhabzb on Sunday November 01, 2020 @03:43PM (#24962338)
There’s no technical differentiation between downloading and watching.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by lozf on Sunday November 01, 2020 @06:36PM (#24963512)
Apart from bandwidth being used quicker as the HLS/DASH segments are requested from the server at shorter intervals.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by hsbauauvhabzb on Sunday November 01, 2020 @11:56PM (#24964926)
Unsure if that can be configured or not, but if your video content distribution network can’t rate limit or handle bursts you probably have more pressing issues.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by lozf on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:20AM (#24966826)
Agreed, just mentioning a "technical difference" that could be used to determine if people are watching in real time vs downloading-with-a-tool-that-grabs-everything-as-fast-as-possible. Since this is Google, it's fair to assume they might be interested in anything that causes them to lose Ad revenue.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by majewsky on Sunday November 01, 2020 @06:02PM (#24963327)
youtube-dl is used for reasons other than just watching videos. For example, journalists use it to download videos from YouTube to edit them into their news stories. Data scientists are using it to download videos for automated analysis in quantities larger than any of the involved scientists could ever watch. Both are not "watching" in the narrow sense implied by the word, but not copyright violations either because they probably qualify as fair use.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by thaumasiotes on Sunday November 01, 2020 @06:59PM (#24963659)
The point is that youtube-dl does exactly the same thing as every other method of watching the video. You can't watch the video -- by any means -- without downloading it first. The uses you list may not be "watching" in a particular sense of the word, but they are "watching" in the same sense of the word that is relevant to using a web browser -- the only sense that would apply to YouTube.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by bitwize on Sunday November 01, 2020 @09:02PM (#24964262)
It doesn't matter. YouTube's Standard License authorizes certain videos to be viewed only by streaming through YouTube's web player or an authorized client. This is enforced by obfuscating code in the player. By circumventing that code, youtube-dl veers into "illegal piracy tool" territory.

Note that it wouldn't matter if youtube-dl contained no deobfuscating code at all, but merely downloaded and evaluated the JavaScript Google's web client uses to deobfuscate. The result is the same: youtube-dl circumvents copyright access controls and is therefore illegal.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 01, 2020 @05:38PM (#24963160)
That would make little sense because the tool itself doesn't have anything to do with watching videos. It only downloads them, or pieces of them, and does some format and metadata conversion. The name describes precisely what it does: it downloads data.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by Liskni_si on Sunday November 01, 2020 @07:19PM (#24963760)
That's not entirely true. youtube-dl, used as a library in a media player like mpv, is quite literally used for watching videos.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by josteink on Sunday November 01, 2020 @12:05PM (#24960815)
The new narrative is that obviously you’re not permitted expect in very rare circumstances, so any tool used to aid actual fair use gets slammed with DMCA take-downs.

I’m not saying it’s right, but that’s how they’ve been trying to frame the discussion for a long time now.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by feanaro on Sunday November 01, 2020 @12:20PM (#24960922)
Yes, and I'm very surprised at the number of people that are apparently falling for this narrative. It would've been unthinkable just a decade ago, it seems.

It's good to see others recognise it for what it is. It needs to be strongly pushed back.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by LordDragonfang on Sunday November 01, 2020 @03:38PM (#24962305)
That's because even a decade ago (well, a decade and a half, factoring in recent memory), the internet was a fundamentally different, much more open place. Now probably 90% of traffic exists in increasingly siloed walled gardens, which all take measures to ensure their content (and more importantly, you) stay there. (Hell, a good portion of that traffic isn't even from some general-purpose browser, it's from an app.) And circumventing that is pretty much the letter of the (poorly worded) law when it comes to the DMCA. It's not really the people that have changed, it's the internet that has.

(Sure, many parts of the internet are still open, but youtube isn't one of them.)

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by mckeed on Sunday November 01, 2020 @11:58AM (#24960765)
Does anyone technically have the right to download from youtube in this way? Even if so, it's clearly in the category of software predominantly used for piracy, all of which can also have legitimate uses.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 01, 2020 @12:10PM (#24960851)
Can you explain what makes you think that even makes sense? Most of the relevant YouTube videos are already available for free to the public, so there is no real incentive to download them from YouTube and upload them to The Pirate Bay. Downloading a copy for personal use would often fall under fair use. Uses with third party video players like mpv aren't even making a permanent copy. Many of the videos are in the public domain (e.g. from NASA) or are permissively licensed (e.g. many university course lecture videos or conference talks).

Who is even using this for some kind of meaningful copyright infringement?

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by roblabla on Sunday November 01, 2020 @02:05PM (#24961647)
> Downloading a copy for personal use would often fall under fair use.

Downloading a copy for personal use isn't even copyright infringement - for copyright infringement to happen, you'd have to then share that copy you made. For instance, you are allowed to do VHS copies of TV shows, and that was confirmed by Supreme Court[0].

This whole thing doesn't make sense to me either.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Corp._of_America_v._Unive....

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by sjy on Sunday November 01, 2020 @04:55PM (#24962868)
The Betamax case predates the DMCA, which created the “anti-circumvention” laws the RIAA is relying on here. It was also a 5:4 decision that depended on “a significant likelihood that substantial numbers of copyright holders who license their works for broadcast on free television would not object to having their broadcasts time-shifted,” and the copyright holders’ failure “to demonstrate that time-shifting would cause any likelihood of non-minimal harm to the potential market for, or the value of, their copyrighted works.” The opinion explicitly did not cover pay TV, and the court also noted that the cost of Betamax tapes made it difficult to build your own library of tapes for repeated viewing, in concluding that there was no likelihood of harm. I think it’s an interesting and open question whether the typical use of youtube-dl falls under fair use.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by stefan_ on Sunday November 01, 2020 @01:25PM (#24961369)
What a bizarre revisionist point of view. Radio players quite naturally learned to record to cassettes once the technology was available and no one ever came to raid player manufacturers, nor did anyone brand the kid sitting at home recording the radio some piracy overlord.

Stop repeating this RIAA nonsense.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by crtasm on Sunday November 01, 2020 @03:16PM (#24962128)
Unsure if this is sarcasm, if not it sounds like you missed https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Taping_Is_Killing_Music
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by crtasm on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:25PM (#24974193)
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by xorcist on Sunday November 01, 2020 @02:57PM (#24962022)
If you publish a youtube video publicly, there is an expectation that the public is allowed to view it.

Is the idea that the author didn't have the rights to publish the video in the first place, due to things like unlicensed background music?

Thus far, Youtube is under the safe harbor principle of the DMCA, and as long as they honor those takedown notices, the end user is not likely to be held accountable. The software they use is even less likely to be.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by adkadskhj on Sunday November 01, 2020 @11:12AM (#24960387)
Isn't marketing something illegal, also illegal? I wonder if some cheeky case could be made here, hah.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by wizzwizz4 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @12:51PM (#24961147)
There's nothing illegal about youtube-dl, so it can't.
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by adkadskhj on Sunday November 01, 2020 @01:27PM (#24961386)
Fair - what word should i have used in place of illegal to describe DMCA?

Youtube DL was taken down because it was DMCA'd, to which we all (mostly?) agree was an abuse of DMCA, but nevertheless the premise seems to be that it was effectively a form of piracy - no? Isn't Piracy (and supporting Piracy/etc) "illegal"? Or is there a better word to use here?

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by roblabla on Sunday November 01, 2020 @02:09PM (#24961675)
Getting DMCA'd doesn't mean anything more than somebody submitted a letter saying "I believe this content infringes my copyright, please take it down.". It does not establish guilt.

Just because the RIAA cries foul doesn't mean there is actually anything wrong here. Piracy is illegal, but youtube-dl is not a piracy tool, just like VHS recorders were not piracy tools. Making personal copies of videos is absolutely legal, and seems to be the prominent way to use youtube-dl (Why else would you use it? The content is already available for free on youtube itself!).

So what you should call youtube-dl is "Something the RIAA doesn't like", basically.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by adkadskhj on Monday November 02, 2020 @09:57AM (#24968743)
Right, but there is an implication that if it was piracy it is illegal, no? Lets not play coy.

My comment of illegal isn't a court of law, my intent was clearly discussing the idea that if the RIAA is accusing youtube-dl of piracy (effectively), and then they themselves increase popularity of youtube-dl, they would effectively be promoting piracy, aka something illegal.

Ya'll are getting hung up on the details. It was a joke.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by roblabla on Monday November 02, 2020 @07:03PM (#24974906)
Aaah, well, thanks for explaining, because the joke went totally woosh over my head :^).
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by adkadskhj on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @10:15AM (#24980345)
Well not a joke i guess, no punchline hah. But still - humor /cheeky comment about if it's considered piracy ("illegal"), and the RIAA end up promoting it, aren't they themselves promoting piracy. That's all :)
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by loeg on Sunday November 01, 2020 @02:27PM (#24961817)
The RIAA falsely claims youtube-dl is a tool for piracy. This is not reality. Accepting the RIAA's premise is problematic.

The right words here are not "piracy" or "illegal," but it is not clear what statement you are trying to make. I can't recommend any better words without additional context.

Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by sjy on Sunday November 01, 2020 @05:00PM (#24962907)
Maybe “arguably illegal”? The RIAA’s argument is that youtube-dl is a tool for circumventing copyright protection, which is related to the concept of piracy or copyright infringement, but prohibited by different laws. Marketing a circumvention tool can be illegal even if there are ways to use it that don’t infringe copyright. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-circumvention
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by joshuak on Sunday November 01, 2020 @02:15PM (#24961728)
I think the word you are looking for is "allegation."
Re:New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1 by bitwize on Sunday November 01, 2020 @09:07PM (#24964281)
It circumvents, therefore it's illegal. See 17 U.S.C section 1201(b).