From the RIAA's point of view, it works to their benefit that a download link doesn't exist, and it may be something they like, but that doesn't mean that's why.
It could just as easily be that a download feature doesn't exist because YouTube wants you to keep returning to their site if you want to rewatch a video.
It would be one thing if some YouTube videos had a download button and others didn't. That would suggest that, on the ones where it's missing, it is missing for a reason, and that reason might be DRM. But as far as I know, YouTube doesn't have download for any videos.
Software doesn't always have all the features that end users might want, and the mere absence of a feature doesn't necessarily tell you why it's missing. Also, it's not some weird, suspicious thing to write software which fills in a feature gap in some other software. (Google encourages add-on software on other products, too. For example, Chrome extensions and Gmail add-ons.)
But, maybe there is some legal reason why this could make sense. Maybe some terms of service or licensing (for video uploaders or for regular end users) says not to download something, which would make it clear that the download feature is missing on purpose.
My understanding is that basically anything at all, if it is in any way "technical" and shows intent, will be accepted as a "technical protection measure" if you go by what has worked so far.
Much more absurd and blatantly bad faith arguments have been accepted, "conspicuously not supplying the feature" is a very strong case in the absurd world of the DMCA cases.
Outlawing the methods of committing a crime also (instead of just the crime) requires a balancing act between their legitimate and illegitimate uses, which seems precariously absent when talking about technically laughable “security measures” that can be circumvented by pressing F12.
Now all legal uses of everything behind that lock are illegal for circumvention reasons.
It's a way to apply the DMCA to literally anything digital. The quality of the software doesn't matter, because it isn't for security, just a legal hack.
The law is so vague on this point so as to include practically anything. Here is the text:
> a technological measure “effectively controls access to a work” if the measure, in the ordinary course of its operation, requires the application of information, or a process or a treatment, with the authority of the copyright owner, to gain access to the work.
an actual court in germany ruled that: https://openjur.de/u/2194436.html
sadly german only. lots of fud and hamburg is often pro copyright owner. not sure if that would hold at the highest instance.
Lets be clear though - the only reason copyrighted material is allowed on Youtube is because the owners then grant a license for the content in exchange for ad revenue. Offering a download link severly damages the "owners are paid for their content" part of the equation.
> # How YouTube Premium supports creators.
> Creators are the heart and soul of YouTube. To make sure they're compensated for their work, we share ad revenue with them when you watch ads on YouTube. If you're a YouTube Premium member, you won't see ads, so we share your monthly membership fee with creators. Best of all, the more videos you watch from your favorite creators, the more money they make.
So, to reply to the gp you technically aren’t just paying “evil” and “greedy” big corps, but your also helping all the YouTubers.
[1]: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/7060016?hl=en
Yes, they have some sort of DRM, albeit a very weak one.
What youtube-dl essentially does is reading the playlist and concatenating chunks together, there is no DRM circumvention here.
I would also argue that something that is ciphered and then deciphered is encrypted.
As I said it is as encrypted (no less, no more) as all other https traffic. Please note that normal https does no verification of the client, the client verifies the server not the other way around (client verification is of course possible but almost no public sites use it). So the encryption in this case verifies that the content comes from youtube or other sites that it supports but youtube itself does no attempt at verification of the client. This is in contrast to real DRM where the content is encrypted in such a way that it is hard to decode it without running the Content Decryption Module, which are proprietary plugins and that can check HDCP and similar ways to only allow playback on "trusted" devices.
In the USA legally it is because the vast majority of the judges that have ruled on these things think anything that isn't a browser is a hacking tool. Using wget is enough to get you thrown in federal prison for accessing public web resources.
Example?
https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/when-pro...
His JSTOR code (below) calls wget: https://osf.io/bnd2h
Edit: no, it’s a private land grant university. What kind of socialism is this, anyway? How is this structure even valid, if not for historical precedent?
Nothing against socialism or even my point, really. Just very odd to see how blatantly discriminatory and contradictory this seems to have a private university performing a necessary public service, with free land from the state. Not that the work isn’t well done, or anything. Just bears strict scrutiny.
I think weev may have used wget in his AT&T work where he discovered links or interactions between customer data and iOS in an AT&T subsite?
http://madisonian.net/2013/04/09/academics-go-to-jail-cfaa-e...
My analysis is at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24874277 and I'm broadly skeptical of the legal viability under US law.
The true purpose of the DCMA is to control the distributors via the use of tools like DRM.
The fact that you can view music on YouTube at all is something of an anomaly. The recording industry would love to dispense with YouTube entirely if they could.
> The clear purpose of this source code is to (i) circumvent the technological protection measures used by authorized streaming services such as YouTube, and (ii) reproduce and distribute music videos and sound recordings owned by our member companies without authorization for such use.
But the "circumventing" is still accessing a stream the user can view anyways, and the "reproduce and distribute" feels like a stretch -- there's no inherent distribution. This isn't anything like a pirating or a torrenting tool.
It feels more akin to when movie studios sued VCR manufacturers for being able to record TV back in 1984 -- and lost [1].
(Also, side note but I have never in my life seen a story upvoted so quickly on HN. 130 points in just 7 minutes so far.)
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Corp._of_America_v._Unive....