News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by cm2187 on Sunday October 18, 2020 @07:52PM (#24822105)
The cost of owning this building isn't the cost of buying it, it is the cost of maintaining it. And you need pretty deep pockets for that. And it's not like you will be allowed to dig a swimming pool in the courtyard. It is highly protected by the French historical monuments authority which must vet every single change you are making. It's more of a liability than an asset.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by cletus on Sunday October 18, 2020 @09:53PM (#24822725)
You're right about the cost of maintaining these properties. This year I came across a funny British show called "Escape to the Chateau" [1]. The couple there paid <400K GBP for a 45 room chateau. At one point they're not sure if they need a new roof. If they do? That'd cost ~250K GBP.

But one interesting thing they mentioned was that in France, heritage of old buildings like these is opt-in. If you choose to opt-in the French government will pay you but you then need to abide by all sorts of standards.

This is in stark contrast with, say, English Heritage where they can decide at some point that your building is now listed, you get paid nothing and any alternations or renovations need to be approved (for maintaining the character).

If that's true about France, I prefer the sound of that system. There are literally thousands of castle/chateuas in France. Is it really justifiable to preserve all of them? Especially given that many are falling into disrepair and many of these buildings are already falling into disrepair through lack of demand for buyers.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escape_to_the_Chateau

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by CalRobert on Monday October 19, 2020 @05:51AM (#24824785)
English Heritage sounds a lot like heritage in Ireland, where a heritage officer can make your home worthless (or worth literally less than nothing!) on a whim.

Worked out handily for me, buying a 200+ year old cottage for less than the cost of the land, but I've been DIY'ing everything but the thatching.

Horrible, awful for the previous owners who saw at _least_ €100,000 knocked off the value of their house.

Edit: to give context, I bought it for far less than €100k, meaning the site lost most of its value.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by imdsm on Monday October 19, 2020 @05:26AM (#24824663)
IIRC, this couple made a massive success out of this though. A lot of persistent hard work, and they now rent it out for weddings and function as a hotel (or pre-covid they did anyway).
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by hardlianotion on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:28AM (#24824964)
The hard work included producing and selling a film of their experience, which might obscure the natural profitability of what they are attempting to do with the castle.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by m463 on Monday October 19, 2020 @08:23AM (#24825677)
sounds like what happened to the steve jobs home.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jackling_House

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by SilasX on Sunday October 18, 2020 @10:37PM (#24822900)
Interesting tidbit: in the Netflix show The Crown, there's an episode[0] where the queen's mother buys a castle in Scotland where the owner is happy to get rid of it because of all the pains of maintaining it.

Which is based on real-life event of the purchase of the Castle of Mey (1952):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_of_Mey

[0] s1e8 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Crown_(season_1)

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by HarryHirsch on Sunday October 18, 2020 @10:53PM (#24822956)
Wikipedia has an article on exploding houses in Britain: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destruction_of_country_houses_...

(There is also an article on exploding houses in Ireland, but for entirely different reasons): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destruction_of_Irish_country_h...

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by brendoelfrendo on Monday October 19, 2020 @09:30AM (#24826175)
This is a plot point in the Guy Ritchie movie "The Gentlemen," where Mickey's (Matthew McConaughey) marijuana growing operation is protected from discovery in part by renting land from broke nobles desperate to maintain their estates. I wonder, is this a common trope in England?
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by Schnitz on Sunday October 18, 2020 @08:06PM (#24822197)
A lot of the castles and palaces have been donated to "the public" that maintains them as tourist attractions or museums. Also Europe is not like the US, where you can just build in a lot of unincorporated areas, so building a new luxury home out of sight of the castle on your property is most likely impossible as well. I'm not 100% sure about this, but my guess is that the presence of the castle might even devalue the land in a lot of these cases, ie you would pay more for an equivalent amount of "empty" land.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by Cthulhu_ on Monday October 19, 2020 @08:19AM (#24825647)
There's an interesting case going on right now; while not a castle, an 'old' royal palace has been sold to a developer and they're considering turning it into an event center with a hotel and apartments nearby (https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=nl&tl=en&u=https%3...)
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by JimTheMan on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:16AM (#24823741)
I'd be running non stop murder mysteries if I owned a castle. But hey, that's just me.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by drewcoo on Sunday October 18, 2020 @08:58PM (#24822467)
Sure, if you see it as property and expect it to make you money somehow.

But like everything else in life, castle ownership is temporary. It's such a rare thing to own, preserve, and pass a castle along to the next humans that it could be seen as a great honor. History needs to be nurtured and shared or it dies.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by nickpp on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:41AM (#24824376)
Such an "honor" can only be afforded by the hyper-rich. The rest of us need to carefully plan our money and investments.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by imgabe on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:59AM (#24824492)
Yes it is truly an egregious injustice that thousand year old castles remain out of reach of the middle class. Something like 100% of castles are owned by the top 1% wealthiest people. Unconscionable.

Yeesh.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by nickpp on Monday October 19, 2020 @08:53AM (#24825847)
Maybe it didn’t came out that way, but I just wanted to say that you need to be at a certain level of wealth to not seek profit from such an investment and to see it as an honor.

Sorry if I didn’t express myself clearer.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by Someone on Monday October 19, 2020 @07:13AM (#24825223)
The seller warns you for that. https://www.patrice-besse.co.uk/ads/castles-chateaux-histori...:

Our opinion

"He who lives without madness is not as wise as he thinks", one of François-de-la-Rochefoucauld’s maxims. His statue adorns the park. This maxim could become that of the future occupants.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by pcurve on Sunday October 18, 2020 @08:59PM (#24822469)
Yes, for something like this, you're looking at quarter million / year in bare minimum upkeep. I think half a million is more realistic, if not more.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by jgalt212 on Sunday October 18, 2020 @10:13PM (#24822808)
reminds of that old saw about the two happiest days in a boat owner's life: the day he buys the boat, and the day he sells it.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by bitbckt on Sunday October 18, 2020 @10:28PM (#24822863)
A boat is a funny shaped hole in the water where you pour all your money.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by rlt on Sunday October 18, 2020 @10:46PM (#24822928)
Break Out Another Thousand.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by hevelvarik on Sunday October 18, 2020 @10:04PM (#24822775)
Wow, why? That’s hard to fathom.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by onion2k on Monday October 19, 2020 @01:40AM (#24823595)
You'd need to have people like gardeners, maintenence staff, and cleaners just to stop nature taking over. To actually fix problems you need conservators and specialist builders. Plus you have to heat the place to prevent damp and mould.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by gabaix on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:17AM (#24823742)
My family inherited a large estate in the South of France and the roof alone was half a million. Now you don’t have to fix things right away, but it quickly becomes a hazard.

Castles are very much a leisure expenditure.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by jacquesm on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:30AM (#24823787)
And don't underestimate the cost of traditional materials either. Those usually have a high labor component baked into them.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by Chris2048 on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:27AM (#24824291)
When they where fixing the roof of Notre-dame, they had to source wood (oak) that was as old as the original. That kind of thing would really accelerate costs.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by dreen on Monday October 19, 2020 @05:23AM (#24824645)
As someone who owns a castle/manor house and desperately wanting to sell it... I agree completely. At least theres normally no property taxes on listed buildings, but just keeping it from falling apart is enough to eat a moderate income.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by fakedang on Monday October 19, 2020 @05:25AM (#24824654)
As someone dating someone whose family owns multiple, buy some art, maintain a garden of sorts, set it up as a museum, bam, revenue.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by dreen on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:07AM (#24824858)
Very easy to say, but would require multiple years worth of salary for me to open that, and the location is not suited to a museum. A wedding venue maybe, but still the investment required to start that is beyond what I can do. I also do not want to quit my software career in London to bank everything on a hospitality business in the middle of nowhere in Eastern Europe.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by fakedang on Monday October 19, 2020 @12:15PM (#24827763)
Oh, I thought you lived near the place. Then certainly not feasible.

Most of them section off part of the palace/castle for personal use while putting up the rest as a museum.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by whythre on Monday October 19, 2020 @11:02AM (#24826976)
Probably a good call- quitting your job go open an event venue in an Eastern European castle sounds like the beginning of a vampire novel.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by pm215 on Monday October 19, 2020 @05:56AM (#24824812)
Lots of these places do just that -- but unless you want your job to be "I run a tourist attraction/wedding venue as a small business", you might prefer to sell the place and let somebody else do it...
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by Someone on Monday October 19, 2020 @07:02AM (#24825145)
As many startups realize when the investor’s money runs out, getting revenue isn’t sufficient.

I guess making the revenue pay for the investments in art, maintenance of the building, security, etc. and buying you clothing and food is left as an exercise for the reader.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by fakedang on Monday October 19, 2020 @12:18PM (#24827803)
Art would be $10-30k. No need to go overboard. Get some exhibits about local culture or something like that. Screw that, get some cool shit made by some online blacksmiths or woodworkers. Put a bunch of placards about the history of the place. Security isn't a big deal if you don't have much of value.

More importantly, make sure this is a passive business of sorts. Works well if you live in or near the same place.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by m3kw9 on Sunday October 18, 2020 @10:47PM (#24822935)
What happens when someone forfeits it? Who’s gonna pick up the maintenance bill?
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by aeden on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:06AM (#24823930)
Often the local governments (whether that's the town, the department, the region, or all of the above), along with some funds from the nation. This is usually thanks to one or more residents of the town who get together to try to save the structure by getting public funds allocated for it.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by julienchastang on Sunday October 18, 2020 @08:24PM (#24822298)
Moreover, are you not exposing yourself to French tax liabilities on your income and assets if you own property in France?
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by cm2187 on Sunday October 18, 2020 @08:33PM (#24822342)
Not a tax lawyer but I believe only on the income and assets in France. So I assume you would be paying the French wealth tax on the value of the castle.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by p_l on Sunday October 18, 2020 @09:13PM (#24822544)
Most of the world considers only income and assets that happen to be inside the country to be taxed by that country, yes.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by julienchastang on Sunday October 18, 2020 @10:03PM (#24822769)
Except for the US which will tax its citizens anywhere no matter where they derive their income and assets. It is a leading reason why a number of Americans renounce their US citizenship.

[1]https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/more-americans-are-renounci...

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by cromka on Sunday October 18, 2020 @11:03PM (#24822979)
Citizens, but not the property owners, which is what is being discussed here.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by angry_octet on Sunday October 18, 2020 @10:55PM (#24822963)
The difference with America is they tax you if you're a citizen, regardless of whether you are abiding (tax resident) there.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by angry_octet on Sunday October 18, 2020 @10:54PM (#24822958)
No, not so! A number of countries consider worldwide income. Generally it must have been taxed somewhere, and in a place with a tax treaty with your primary residence, or it will get taxed as foreign income.

It gets even more complicated with capital gains or losses, and different rules for how losses can be moved between financial years.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by angry_octet on Monday October 19, 2020 @12:33PM (#24827972)
The best thing about HN is being downvoted to greyed out when factually correct. "You're opinions offend me Sir, your facts run counter to my views on what the facts should be, and I desire you to depart."
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by nopzor on Monday October 19, 2020 @01:15AM (#24823500)
a number of countries? really? the usa is the only g7 country to do so. we (the usa) is in good company with countries like libya and north korea...
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by ampersandy on Monday October 19, 2020 @01:50AM (#24823641)
No, there's an important distinction here. Many countries tax world-wide income, but USA is one of the few that taxes your non-US income even if you are not considered a resident for tax purposes. For example, if you are a Canadian expat and notify the CRA, you do not have to file a tax return at all unless you earn income from Canada. However, if you are a US expat, you still must file US taxes each year (and pay the difference between my local taxes vs. what you would have owed in the US).
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by angry_octet on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:15AM (#24823978)
Exactly. If you live in a high tax / high social benefit country it isn't so bad, but if you live in a no tax (but high income, high cost) country like the UAE it would be painful. The Foreign Earned Income Exclusion is like $100k but that isn't so much in some countries. Luckily US income taxes are quite (scandalously) low.

(And if you live in the UAE that US passport will be really valuable if you need to avoid having you hand chopped off for pissing off the wrong people.)

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by compsciphd on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:55AM (#24824158)
US Income taxes are low?

take someone who makes a million+ dollars in california. Their marginal rate is 50% (37% federal + 13% CA, and with the note that the SALT limits due to Trump, dont really get them 37% back on the state tax anymore).

compare this to most european countries where your income tax rate at the top is 50% or less.

now, they have other taxes they pay (social and the like) outside of income taxes, but so does the US. FICA and ss fees also "taxes" in a way.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by vidarh on Monday October 19, 2020 @05:30AM (#24824687)
The marginal rate is really not particularly relevant unless you earn far more than that, which most people don't. What matters is the effective rate, and even California, which is one of the highest taxed states in the US, and so misleading if you want to talk about the overall US tax burden, is lower than a lot of Europe.

I agree with you they're not particularly low, though, especially when factoring in what you get or don't get. E.g. add health insurance into the picture and starts to look very different.

The US is pretty middle of the road in terms of tax.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by daxfohl on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @12:36PM (#24839421)
"No representation without taxation"? Our forefathers would be proud.
Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by guerby on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:52AM (#24823875)
For 3.3 millions EUR you would pay about 15kEUR/year as "Impôt sur la Fortune Immobilière" on the value of the asset:

https://www.impots.gouv.fr/portail/particulier/calcul-de-lif...

Minus 30% if the asset is your regular home.

There are other taxes of course, this is only the "wealth" one.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by laurent92 on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:22AM (#24824011)
IFI, yes, 15k€

+ Taxe d’habitation (city tax), 10-20k€ if it is proportional (depends on sqm and salary, and decreasing with children).

+ Taxe foncière (land tax), same amount as previous.

But French people earn about twice as less due to taxes, so you don’t have much competition from French buyers ;) I’m not a lawyer, just a big house owner. Who got rich abroad obviously.

Re:House Hunting in France: A Once-in-a-Millennium Castle fo... by guerby on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:06AM (#24824854)
Note: taxe d'habitation is being phased out in the coming years, it's already 0 for about 80% of taxpayers this year.