News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by cowmix on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:19PM (#24761343)
I was obsessed with the Amiga when it was announced in the mid-80s. I saved my paper route money (when that was a thing) and bought the Amiga 1000 as soon as it was available. I loved the computer and I am thankful for how it set me up for my expectations about what personal computing should be.

HOWEVER...

I'm perplexed how I keep seeing all these projects over the years to revive the platform. AmigaOS was good for its time but there's nothing it offers now that any modern OS doesn't do now. For how cutting edge it was, it was an unstable POS too.

GAH!

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by zmix on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @01:53AM (#24762672)
> but there's nothing it offers now that any modern OS doesn't do now

Did you ever go past your A1000? Did you use AmigaOS2.1 and up?

...like...scripting all your productivity applications with the same scripting language and have them interchange data, this way, orchestrating workflows I still dream about on other systems?

...like... mounting RAM: or SOUND: or HTTP: or IMAP: or FTP: or ARC(hives): or (raw) MEM(ory): ? All without any Virtual File System? Just real device level mounts?

    #> mount HTTP:
    #> COPY HTTP:hostname.tld/~user/index.html TO folder/
...like...having a hypertext standard, which can cross-reference all your includes, combine them with system documentation and have them appear on hover in your editor?

And so much more...

Yes, you can do all these things, the one way or other, on today's systems (except the mounting example,afaik). But with the Amiga these things were built-in. Which means, that, instead of system administration and time wasted on setup and tooling, you would just use the things and enjoy more productivity.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by pjc50 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:51AM (#24765086)
> All without any Virtual File System? Just real device level mounts?

Mounting "HTTP" counts as a virtual file system unless you have a real physical HTTP object plugged into your Amiga, surely?

> scripting all your productivity applications with the same scripting language and have them interchange data

Theoretically possible with both AppleScript and the much-hated VBA, but never quite as easy. Probably never will be as easy, as you can only have this kind of tight integration when there are no security boundaries between applications.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by ziotom78 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:32AM (#24764496)
Not the OP, but I understand the sentiment. Despite the many advantages of the platform, there are so many things that have evolved in the meantime:

- Compatibility with international character sets (UTF-8) for data exchange

- Support for modern peripherals like LCD monitors, printers, wi-fi cards, etc.

- Access to external filesystems (Ext4, NTFS, remote storage, etc.)

- Other

I have never used Amigas, so maybe these points are all addressable with a recent version of AmigaOS, but I understand the OP's concerns.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by zmix on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @04:55PM (#24781485)
> - Compatibility with international character sets (UTF-8) for data exchange > > - Support for modern peripherals like LCD monitors, printers, wi-fi cards, etc. > > - Access to external filesystems (Ext4, NTFS, remote storage, etc.)

This is all supported with the current version of the OS (AmigaOS 4), however, due to no market share, only select devices are supported (the situation is like Linux (was), but much more extreme: printers (non-postscript) and WiFi cards, especially).

It is other things, where the system did not age well: no memory protection and no multi user support.

However, I do not want to place the Amiga as a viable solution for today's use. I just wanted to address the comment, I replied to, which was a bit too 'absolute' in tone for my taste. I did not find the criticism to be justified. Currently there is a hardware scene, that builds FPGA systems, that are fully compatible and meant to be run as stand alone, or as add-in systems and which can cope with most modern tasks, albeit CPU and GPU power is a limit, of course.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by the_af on Monday October 12, 2020 @10:57PM (#24761805)
It's nostalgia aimed at people who had these computers as kids. I know it worked for me with their pretty cool TheC64.

Why not buy a real vintage home computer then? Well, in the case of the C64, vintage ones are unreliable, hard to get to work with modern screens and hard to get stuff in/out of them. You end up needing expensive extra hardware for all these things and for what? -- the retro remakes are pretty convenient out of the box, and give you the convenience of an emulator with the look & feel you remember from your childhood.

However, if you didn't own one of these as a kid, then you'll find them pointless.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by andi999 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @12:06AM (#24762176)
Also with the c64 you do not really want to go back to that keyboard, do you?
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by dylan604 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @01:19AM (#24762509)
I'd rather use it than the Apple Butterfly keyboard. I used to bang out BASIC on a C64 with the hunt&peck method. Sure, I was 10, but I know I beat on it harder than I do now with actual typing. That keyboard never had keycaps fall of it. I cannot say the same thing about this keyboard on my MacBook Pro 2017 model.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by Razengan on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @05:41AM (#24763862)
I’d rather stick with the Apple butterfly keyboard than many other keyboards, contemporary or historic. I’ve never had problems with it and I honestly prefer the short travel and snappiness.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by Razengan on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @12:55AM (#24773217)
Excuse me for having an incorrect opinion.

Butterfly bad. Gib upboat.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by boomlinde on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:34AM (#24764124)
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by krzyk on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @05:35AM (#24763829)
Why, it wasn't bad, at least I don't remember anything bad about it.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by andi999 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:17AM (#24764048)
When I used it, I didnt notice, but when I used it again years later (after having typed on pc keyboards), ... boy you really need to press the keys, almost hammer them, no more fluent typing. Give it a try (maybe your experience is differen)
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by protomyth on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:29AM (#24764938)
Yeah, bad was the Atari 400. The C64 was a dream compared to that. I was so jealous of the Sinclair owners that had ready third-party replacements available for their crap membrane keyboard. Typed a lot of code on that thing though.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by pizza234 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @05:43AM (#24763876)
The C64 keyboard used 2 cursor keys to implement the functionality of 4 (using shift). Programming with that was a PITA (at least for me).
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by krzyk on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:18AM (#24764852)
Ah, right, it was strange when I think of it now, but it didn't bother me then.

My programming was mostly rewriting code from magazines and I didn't have any IDE so arrows were out of the question either way (AFAIR).

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by the_af on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @01:26PM (#24767680)
I enjoyed the imposing physicality of the C64 keyboard, especially compared to today's flimsy laptop keyboard and cheap external keyboards (disclaimer: never used a good quality external keyboard, I'm sure they are awesome... but they lack the nostalgia factor).

Of course, it's mostly a nostalgia trip. Just like I fondly remember green phosphor CRTs.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by the_af on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @11:01AM (#24766216)
> Also with the c64 you do not really want to go back to that keyboard, do you?

I bought TheC64 because I wanted the keyboard. Why else use a C64 lookalike instead of an emulator on a regular computer?

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by andi999 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @11:18AM (#24766398)
So whats your typing speed on it?
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by the_af on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @11:24AM (#24766472)
Right now? I haven't used a C64 in more than three decades, so the answer is: very poor :)

Productivity isn't in my mind when thinking about retro/vintage computers, in any case.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by kristopolous on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:42PM (#24762046)
It's coveted by musicians and a number of other specialty applications.

Specialty groups are rather time agnostic. The Technics SL-1200 turntable for instance (look it up, you've seen it) hasn't changed much in 50 years and Technics brought it out of retirement because the demand for used ones was so high

So a 68020 is perfectly fine for these types of things. It's not a general purpose tool, it's a specific thing just like the Technics are for hobbyist and professional "turntablists" and not meant to substitute say Spotify

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by megablast on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @01:40AM (#24762607)
The Technics SL-1200 is used by DJs all over the world to entertain millions.

What is the amigs used for??

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by kristopolous on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @02:09AM (#24762742)
Techno and electro by artists which you may have not heard of but who have prestigious awards and Wikipedia pages. Along with the Prophet, Roland SH-101, TR-808 and TB-303, the Amiga is coveted vintage equipment. (For instance, this coldwave producer: https://www.discogs.com/artist/3805670-Equinoxious ... That's almost exclusively 35 year old equipment)

This album for instance, was produced on an Amiga and even has it in the album title https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=35Lv8J1VMog

Might not be your thing, sure, fine. That's not the point. There's a significant scene that uses amigas for this.

Vintage Commodores have a fanbase all on their own in the electronic music world and get featured prominently in some videos such as (1:50) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-UdW-lmHSNY

There's after market hardware, such as an Amiga 500 SCSI -> SD bridge because at one time old 50 pin SCSI drives were going for hundreds of dollars and people in this community started making modern retrofits so they didn't have to pay high prices for failing hardware.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by robin_reala on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @02:30AM (#24762850)
There was a great video on jungle production by Pete Cannon where he demonstrates his Amiga setup: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IDn7ZDcx9w0
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by kristopolous on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @02:38AM (#24762888)
Oh absolutely. Amen break slicing and sequencing on Amiga trackers was essentially THE junglist instrument.

Amen style has fallen out of fad but it's not dead by a longshot. (ex, 2018: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRkfrpgLpeQ and 2020: https://youtube.com/watch?v=D4y0X2zzzXM - compare to 1995: https://youtube.com/watch?v=GhopRCAFQ2k). I'd be shocked, literally shocked if these weren't done in a protracker-style piece of software.

It was also the hardcore tool of choice for classic rave (ex: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1PcHOHfwdOs) ... you can almost visualize the vertical scroll.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by EamonnMR on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:35AM (#24764981)
I assumed that rognvald used a tracker but his Rognmashine plugin seems to run only on Max for Live: http://rognvald.com/Rognmashine.html which suggests that Live is his Daw of choice (though I can't independently confirm that.)
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by mycall on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:19PM (#24771866)
Breakcore in particular.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by User23 on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:46PM (#24761474)
In Germany in the late 80s to early 90s the Amiga was the platform of choice for playing video games. It had great graphics and games were widely shared in the community. I wonder how much of the nostalgia is for the culture and experiences than the actual platform.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by snvzz on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:06PM (#24761861)
>(AmigaOS) For how cutting edge it was, it was an unstable POS too.

AmigaOS 1.0 release sure was. From 1.2 onward, it's trivial to get higher uptimes than windows 9x.

I consider 2.0+ (~1991) pretty modern. I haven't seen a crash in a very long time, and I always have some Amiga running.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by LocalH on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:13AM (#24764034)
The only real problem with the AmigaOS architecture is the lack of memory protection.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by _b8r0 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:29AM (#24764937)
It's only really a problem if your software isn't designed for it. Most of the problems people had with DOS memory protection issues were due to the lack of standardization around memory management. Similarly so with Windows 3.x, running DOS programs from Windows on top of DOS was never going to work well. Even Windows95 had its problems.

On the Amiga it didn't have this problem. There was AmigaOS and that was it. The base hardware was for the most part tightly coupled to the OS and the architecture was designed to provide standardised mechanisms for accessing hardware that were fairly stable. The Amiga had different stability issues of course, but my A4000 manages fine without memory protection despite having a full MMU on-board.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by LocalH on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:05AM (#24775586)
I mostly meant in terms of security in the modern age. Few people in their right mind (in the realm of computing enthusiasts) would use AmigaOS as their only daily driver because of it. There’s a reason all modern OS architectures have memory protection as a core feature. In 2020 you really don’t want any process on your system to be able to access, let alone clobber any other process space.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by boomlinde on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:32AM (#24764122)
> I'm perplexed how I keep seeing all these projects over the years to revive the platform AmigaOS was good for its time but there's nothing it offers now that any modern OS doesn't do now.

Maybe you are perplexed because you misunderstand the intent of the project, and judge it on a basis that is unrelated to its intent. Considering the various other "mini" computers and consoles, including Retro Games' previous such project, THEC64, the idea here probably isn't to revive the platform as a competitor to a modern OS, or even what AmigaOS offers at all, but to create a toy for retro computer/retro gaming enthusiasts.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by Scramblejams on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:46PM (#24761471)
there's nothing it offers now that any modern OS doesn't do now

This is why of any old OS I’d like to see revived, it’s BeOS[0]. To this day I’ve never used a desktop OS so fluid, so responsive and stutter-free.

[0] Yup, there’s Haiku. I guess I just want that to be successful!

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by User23 on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:47PM (#24761482)
The BeOS demos at MacWorld Boston in 1997 were incredible. I've also never since seen a multitasking operating system with that level of user interface responsiveness. It really was wonderful engineering.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by hvs on Monday October 12, 2020 @09:37PM (#24761435)
Lots of have these what-if computers/operating systems of the past (Xenix, OS/2, AmigaOS, etc.). It's mostly just harmless nostalgia.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by flohofwoe on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:33AM (#24764971)
The way that later AmigaOS versions integrated UI and command line workflows through OS APIs and design-guidelines is still mostly unmatched today IMHO, from today's point of view this is like a dead end in the tree of operating system evolution. Linux, Windows and MacOS all were behind in different aspects (and of course ahead in some others) but then developed into entirely different directions. I would like to have seen the ideas of AmigaOS ca. '92 developed further (instead of just merely keeping it alive and adding a new UI skin from time to time). Instead the command line and UI drifted further apart in all surviving operating systems.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by kjs3 on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:36PM (#24762016)
Because it could be fun? Or is that not HN worthy?
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by swiley on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:33AM (#24764499)
Toy OSes are fun, that's why there's haiku and the open source windows xp.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by adamredwoods on Monday October 12, 2020 @10:25PM (#24761645)
I did corn detasseling to save up for my Amiga 500. My first C program was on an Amiga. Good for nostalgia, not for modern times.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by icedchai on Monday October 12, 2020 @11:27PM (#24761974)
My first C program was also in the Amiga! I taught myself C from those “Abacus” books when I was about 14. I was using Lattice C. Fun times.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by aphrax on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @05:11AM (#24763686)
Dice C for me, the author (Matt Dillon) is the guy who created Dragonfly BSD..
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by AndrewStephens on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:33AM (#24765392)
I also used Dice C, starting with the free version that I got from one of the Fish Disks. I didn't have dialup access to anywhere but a local computer retailer used to charge NZ$5 for Fish disks, which were my main source of software in small-town NZ.

For a school project (fractals!) I needed floating point support, which the free version of Dice C didn't have. I wrote a letter to Matt Dillion and he very kindly sent me the 3 disks of the full Dice C by return post (about 4 weeks). I still remember what a pain it was to arrange an international money order to actually pay him.

That must have been 1991. My program very slowly drew a 320x256 Mandelbrot set in 32 colors - as I recall it took about 90 seconds on a A500.

By coincidence I was mucking around with Cuda the other day and wrote a short un-optimized program to draw a 2048x2048 Mandelbrot in 256 colors - over 80 times more data - in about 2 seconds. This 2 year old laptop is about 3680 times as fast as my old A500.

Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by dgregd on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @05:51AM (#24763918)
Lattice C occupied two 3.5 disks so when I was compiling a program I had to switch the disks many times. Then I bought a second external disk drive and it was 10x improvement. As far I remember an executable was very slow for some reason. AMOS was much better for graphics and audio.
Re:Commodore Amiga could get a mini/classic version next year by Phil-bitplex on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:55AM (#24765554)
There one thing it did, and OS/2 did that I really really really miss.

Having different sized icons.

I miss my giant Battletech icon :(