News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by advisedwang on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:43PM (#24721647)
What is the actual advantage to consumers over an Uber? Novelty will wear off, and so to survive Waymo will actually need to be better in some way.

Can anyone in Phoenix answer if Waymo is cheaper?

Is Waymo hoping people will choose Waymo for safety?

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by klmadfejno on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:52PM (#24723826)
* You don't need to pay drivers

* You don't need an army of marketers/hr/legal/support staff for your drivers

* You don't need to dodge ambiguous contractor vs. employee laws

* You don't have any risk about individual drivers being bad actors or acting fraudulently

* You can predict, with great accuracy, how many cars will be available at any given time, whether or not they'll want to do another drive after (they will), and where they want to end up

* Your cars meet a minimum level of safety (if it works) that humans can't guarantee, especially in regards to distracted, tired, drunk, or whatever driving

Given how much effort is spent on attracting and retaining drivers, I'd say Waymo has many competitive advantages lined up. If it works.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by kevincox on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:06PM (#24724441)
There is also a direct benefit from riders who don't want to interact with a driver. Or want to have conversations that they would be uncomfortable subjecting a driver to.

I mean sure, there is a camera. But that is hugely different than a person (both positive and negative)

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by klmadfejno on Friday October 09, 2020 @04:49PM (#24734289)
I wonder if that'll play poorly in the business crowd. Talking in hushed tones is bad but passable when there's a human driver. It's terrible when it's a recording device.
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by kevincox on Friday October 09, 2020 @04:57PM (#24734357)
It's funny. For fun personal things I don't want to annoy the driver, but don't really care if what I say is recorded. For business you don't really care if the driver hears it, but don't want to get recorded.

I suspect that a well-defined retention and usage policy could satisfy most business. In fact they might prefer it to having a driver listening in.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by asdff on Friday October 09, 2020 @01:32AM (#24727145)
How long until these too are abused like shared scooters and bikes? You order one after a night out and the previous tenant discretely left their partially digested dinner all over the seat and floor. What then? In many ways, an uber driver is also a custodian.
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by klmadfejno on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:13AM (#24729551)
I'm sure there's potential for fraud but they're going to have the account info and billing info of people who rented the car time. If someone damages or dirties the car, they're going to be liable and probably kicked off the platform. All the car needs is a camera and a way for riders to complain about past transgressions that are leftover in the car and it'll probably sort itself out.

You could also pay people to manually remote into car cameras for a brief quality check after every ride. Wouldn't be that expensive. An interesting problem to solve though.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by ch33zer on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:59PM (#24721837)
It's possible that in the long term because Waymo doesn't need to pay drivers their overhead will be lower, which could mean lower prices for riders. Of course, Waymo cars have very expensive computers in them, and maintenance might be expensive, and the AI used to drive the cars is expensive, and they might need to have backup safety drivers (at least at first), so whether they're actually cheaper remains to be seen.
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by nwsm on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:19PM (#24722063)
Why does Waymo need to prove viability but Uber does not? Uber cannot lose $8B/yr forever.

The obvious advantage will be price, if Uber even still exists.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by adoxyz on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:55PM (#24721793)
I would assume cheaper and more reliable service.

With Uber/Lyft, you never know who you're going to get and what the experience will be like, and as someone that easily took 200-300 Uber rides per year pre-covid, I've seen some shit.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by jacquesm on Thursday October 08, 2020 @05:06PM (#24723957)
In the case of Uber/Lyft the driver has another function besides being the driver: they are on the hook for the capital invested in the vehicle or their ability to lease one. That's a lot of money per vehicle and utilization is the responsibility (and risk) of the driver.
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by jdminhbg on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:13PM (#24724497)
This is true, but note that for a self-driving vehicle, utilization is only bounded by demand and maintenance. An Uber driver can get tired or busy with other things, but a self-driving car can go 24 hours a day minus re-fueling/charging.
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by chris_st on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:10PM (#24721976)
For example, we were taking an Uber through a part of a nearby city I'd never been in before, and approaching a confusing bit of roundabout, the driver leaned over to me and asked me which way to go :-(
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by crazcarl on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:53PM (#24722422)
Just the other night my driver turned too wide and started going the wrong way down the divided street. He u-turned and fixed it without any issue thankfully, but then he blamed it on the construction workers "moving the road" - which they definitely didn't.
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by toast0 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:11PM (#24722650)
I mean, that's not great, but I would take that over my SuperShuttle experience. At least your driver wasn't falling asleep repeatedly, despite apparently regularly spaced prompts from the company app to confirm he was awake.
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by whimsicalism on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:52PM (#24721748)
I mean, if they can make this work well then you cut out the driver - which is very cost-saving.

It also lets you a. optimize exactly where cars are driving to maximize ride share revenue, b. have the cars ready to pick someone up 24/7.

It's going to be a much more efficient use of car capital than hiring a person to drive it.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:54PM (#24721782)
But it's a very different business model to ride share, which is based on externalising the costs of the car to the drivers.
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by whimsicalism on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:17PM (#24722036)
I agree that it is a very different model, but it's a bit much to say that externalizing car repair costs is what the business model of Uber/Lyft is "based on"
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by disgruntledphd2 on Friday October 09, 2020 @05:22AM (#24728178)
Dunno if you'll see this, but when I made my comment, this link was much of my source: https://ftalphaville.ft.com/2019/04/29/1556557142000/Scoop--...
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by whimsicalism on Friday October 09, 2020 @01:07PM (#24732005)
Even that paper demonstrates that if you weaken their assumptions about taxi-car occupancy being exactly the same as Uber/Lyft and don't assume that you will have a remote monitor per every 10 cars (unsure why they would include this assumption, even the current Waymo setup doesn't have this), self-driving actually does come out as priced less.

They also don't source their cost for CDV, which is substantially lower than any other number I can find cited in paper. Further, the current regulatory framework includes huge wealth transfers/incentives for car ownership, so it's not a fair comparison. For instance, the $130/yr cost of a parking permit in SF is a huge wealth transfer to car owners as that is substantially below what the market-price would be for that permit.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by vernon99 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @05:28PM (#24724121)
These costs are still included in your ride cost though
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by evanlivingston on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:40PM (#24722299)
Is it though? will autonomous vehicles ever get to point where there is even close to less than one engineer for each vehicle? Engineering salaries are substantially larger than driver's salaries. Also, there is the cost of years and years of extremely expensive research that needs to be offset, cloud infrastructure costs, hardware costs + costs of retooling factories for integrating the large numbers of sensors + compute. I can't imagine (without doing any actual math) that there's a cost savings within 200 years
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by drivebycomment on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:12PM (#24722662)
It's a good question.

https://investor.uber.com/news-events/news/press-release-det... shows Uber generated $65B gross booking in 2019, and we know substantial fraction of that goes to the driver.

https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/networth/article/For-a-... says driver takes about ~60% of the booking.

So this is a question of whether the capital cost / the engineering cost / operating cost for autonomous vehicle is higher than $65B * 0.6 = $39B per year for the same number of rides.

The engineering cost will be amortized over long enough time that it's likely not a significant factor in the long run. So, the limiting factor will be the capital cost (for vehicles and its support infra) and the operating cost. As you say, at this point we don't know for sure - one thing we know is that the capital cost and the operating cost likely will see significant reduction thanks to the economy of scale.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by leetcrew on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:13PM (#24722668)
> will autonomous vehicles ever get to point where there is even close to less than one engineer for each vehicle?

if FSD actually ends up working on most roads, I don't see why not. there's no inherent reason why engineer headcount would scale linearly with the number of cars.

as for the cost savings, they don't necessarily have to beat uber's pricing today. they could alternatively try to drive uber's costs up by lobbying hard to get drivers classified as employees and catch some PR points at the same time.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by xtracto on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:51PM (#24723815)
I hate interacting with that random person, it is awkward and unnecessary. Also, hopefully this will decrease the cost. This, in addition to the lower maintenance needed for electric cars might make my dream com true of not having to own a car and travel only by driverless-Uber (i.e. it might become available and affordable at last!).

My take is that this will become widely available in the next 5 years. The future is bright!

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by RivieraKid on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:45PM (#24723764)
If you can take a ride with or without a random person travelling with you, what would you choose? Some people will prefer the latter, because of introversion, social anxiety, etc.

In the long-term, the obvious benefit is the price. In the next 5 to 10 years I don't expect it to be cheaper than Uber, even if their cost is half of Uber's.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by ilaksh on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:59PM (#24721844)
For the moment one advantage is you can't catch anything from a driver since there isn't one.

Long term it should be possible for the service to be cheaper than manned since they don't have to pay a driver.

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:37PM (#24722947)
But you can catch something from the previous rider, and there isn't any driver to sanitize things for you.
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by sergeykish on Friday October 09, 2020 @04:32AM (#24727961)
Entire driver space can be scrapped.

Cars with different seat configuration — I would love to sit with my family, friends, not on separate rows.

Smaller cars for one-two passengers, brand it Eco friendly, I would certainly select Firefly over usual car.

https://www.google.com/search?q=driverless+car+interior&tbm=...

Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by jeffbee on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:03PM (#24723252)
Let's see: you won't get raped by the driver, a professionally-maintained vehicle is likely to be more safe than a Prius with 500k miles and no windshield wipers, you won't be cyberstalked by "God View" gawkers at Uber HQ, ...
Re:Waymo is opening its driverless service to more people in... by executive on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:21PM (#24724556)
But will you be able to run over rioters when they attack your vehicle?