News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by Someone1234 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:22PM (#24712298)
How does this seek to overcome the problem that killed Concorde: Civilian sonic booms over populations are illegal, and most places aircraft want to fly to/from are cities?

Concorde found a kinda niche between the East Coast of the US and European cities near the sea, but it really doesn't feel sustainable for an entire aircraft class to be limited to only that route (and wasn't for Concorde).

If it doesn't go supersonic then what is the USP?

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by gok on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:39PM (#24712456)
Primarily they are targeting transoceanic routes. Transoceanic demand has increased substantially in recent years. Transatlantic traffic has doubled since Concorde went out of service. Transpacific travel has grown even more, and Concorde was unable to compete there.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by lumost on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:59PM (#24712666)
Transpacific and trans-hemisphere super sonic flights would be an interesting. the demand to fly to Asia from North America is likely higher than currently observed due to lack of interest in 12-24 hour flights.

With careful planning the fastest I can get to Australia/New Zealand is ~18-24 hours flight time - on a 10 day vacation that's ~40% of my vacation time including recovery from an 18 hour flight. I'd be fine flying 6 hours to the west coast then hopping on a supersonic flight for a 2-3x premium ( still expensive, but worthwhile every few years ).

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by tim333 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:09AM (#24717013)
I wish they'd do bunk beds for the 18-24 hrs flights. Not super lux super expensive but utilitarian - I'd lie down on the floor if they'd let me. For me I think supersonic will be a bit expensive and polluting.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by mc32 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:03PM (#24712704)
Asia-North America. Would they do a polar trajectory? Or would they worry too much about the radiation?
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by stetrain on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:17PM (#24712845)
Existing flight routes between Asia and North America often fly over the arctic already:

https://www.flightradar24.com/blog/winter-winds-how-singapor...

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by bobthepanda on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @06:14PM (#24713412)
I don't think the planned Boom plane has the range to go trans-Pacific. Maybe with a stopover in Honolulu to refuel (which could still be substantially faster)
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by jessaustin on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @09:40PM (#24714786)
Anchorage seems a more likely stopover for most Pacific routes?
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by kortilla on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:50AM (#24716896)
Absolutely. To expand on this a bit, the great circle route between something like Hong Kong and Seattle is a leisurely flight up the Canadian coast, along Alaska, down it’s Archipelago, by Russia, Japan, and Korea. At no point do you come anywhere near Hawaii.

https://www.greatcirclemapper.net/en/great-circle-mapper.htm...

Anchorage is a very busy airport for cargo routes for this reason.

Traveling to Hawaii is a more dangerous than to something like Japan from mainland US due to the distance from land being much greater.

Never look at Mercator projections when thinking about flights, they will mislead greatly.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by bobthepanda on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:59PM (#24723207)
Fair enough.

Though honestly even 4500nm is not very far for transpacific; from ANC Hong Kong and Manila are barely within/outside range, Bangkok and Singapore are out of the question.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by BurningFrog on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:20PM (#24712876)
Not if it crosses a landmass, I guess.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by starik36 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @06:22PM (#24713496)
Why was Concorde unable to compete in the Pacific? Range?
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by vkou on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @06:41PM (#24713666)
Yes. Its maximum range was 4,500 miles. That won't even get you from Seattle to Tokyo (4,700 miles), let alone to anywhere else in Asia.

You can do two hops, by stopping in Anchorage, which will get you to Tokyo or Seoul on the second hop (Stopping in Hawaii won't get you the range to go to Seoul), but at that point a no-stop subsonic flight is faster, more comfortable, burns less jet fuel, and does not require you to make a landing within spitting distance of the Arctic circle.

This jet promises[1] to deliver a range of 4,500 nautical miles, which will barely get you from Seattle to crash-landing in the mountains east of Seoul (4530 nautical miles)

[1] It remains to be seen whether it will deliver on this promise.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by minitoar on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:35PM (#24715062)
How did you calculate that a subsonic flight with no stops is faster?
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by gok on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @09:07PM (#24714622)
Both because it did not have enough range and because it went out of production before airlines in Asia, Australia, or the Americas could buy it. Air France and British Airways can not legally fly routes like Seattle -> Tokyo or Sydney -> Seoul.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by cjrp on Thursday October 08, 2020 @08:25AM (#24718463)
> Air France and British Airways can not legally fly routes like Seattle -> Tokyo or Sydney -> Seoul.

Wouldn't those be covered under the fifth freedom[1], assuming the flight originated in the airline's home country. E.g. BA flying London -> Seattle -> Tokyo.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedoms_of_the_air#Fifth_free...

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by gok on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:53PM (#24721776)
Well Concorde couldn't make it to Seattle from London, so it would have had to do like London -> New York -> (subsonically) Seattle -> Tokyo which would have been a pretty hard sell I think. Plus the Seattle -> Tokyo route in particular would have required a next generation plane.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by rkangel on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:10AM (#24717677)
> Air France and British Airways can not legally fly routes like Seattle -> Tokyo or Sydney -> Seoul

Can you explain more about this? I assumed those routes were just ones that were only of interest to the more local carriers.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by gok on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:01PM (#24721862)
The laws around this are very complicated but generally airlines are not allowed to operate flights that operate between two non-home countries unless it's part of a larger route that originates in home country. This would be called a 7th freedom flight, and outside of the EU almost no countries have a deal like this.

(See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedoms_of_the_air )

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by new_realist on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @09:03PM (#24714598)
The airline industry is dying because air travel is dead. I don’t see it coming back anytime soon, especially for such a carbon-polluting aircraft.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by godelski on Thursday October 08, 2020 @12:00AM (#24715624)
For what it is worth, Boom is claiming that their jets will be carbon neutral.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by kenneth on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:30AM (#24717123)
The jet cannot be carbon neutral. The operations of the jet can be if the operators choose to offset the carbon. Boom is not an airline, so it can't say whether or not the jets will be carbon neutral.

It could contractually require buyers to offset carbon emissions but that's a dubious idea.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by azernik on Thursday October 08, 2020 @05:50AM (#24717525)
Carbon offsets aren't the only way to do carbon neutrality; Boom is ensuring compatibility with synthesized fuel (they specifically mention Prometheus Fuels). This is where hydrocarbons are basically used a an energy storage medium for renewably-generated energy, extracting the CO2 from the atmosphere for fuel production and emitting it back into atmosphere when the fuel is burned.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by aero-glide on Thursday October 08, 2020 @12:53AM (#24715963)
Any more details on this? Will they use captured co2 to make the fuel?
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by godelski on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:48AM (#24716238)
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by tobinfricke on Thursday October 08, 2020 @12:52AM (#24715956)
We could just as well choose to burn biodiesel in today's jet aircraft.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by bnegreve on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:15AM (#24716078)
Actually, I find worrying that you can build a plane that creates trust from breaking long carbon chains into CO2 and, at the same time, publicly announce that it will be "carbon neutral" some day.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by godelski on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:53AM (#24716270)
It is doubtful that we'll find fuels that are carbon negative anytime soon. So hey, neutral is better than positive.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by bnegreve on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:58AM (#24716600)
Neutral would be good, but I doubt that they are serious about this.

Otherwise, they wouldn't build their plane around gas turbines, which create trust from burning carbon compounds.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by bnegreve on Thursday October 08, 2020 @07:12AM (#24717991)
For downvoters: it's a fine project, but I don't think they can fly planes at higher speed, lower cost, and lower carbon emissions, without a major technology shift. It is hardly controversial.

Most likely: they do care, but it is not their main priority.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by jabl on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:29AM (#24716439)
Not good enough. About 2/3 of aviation climate forcing is from non-CO2 effects: https://www.carbonbrief.org/guest-post-calculating-the-true-...
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by GoOnThenDoTell on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:43PM (#24715117)
The moment there is a vaccine everyone will fly
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by billclerico on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:31PM (#24712380)
I think it is more likely that the economics killed Concord ($20k per seat), not the route, and it appears that Boom thinks like they can deliver a luxury, supersonic experience at a far cheaper, business class price.

And if transoceanic supersonic travel becomes popular, pressure will mount to define overland supersonic corridors, or manufacturers will invest to reduce the noise, or both.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by bobthepanda on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @06:16PM (#24713438)
In its later years I believe BA and Air France found that perceived costs of a Concorde ticket were actually more expensive than what they were charging, so they increased prices to match perceptions and then Concorde was fairly profitable.

By the time Concorde was actually retired, 9/11 dented air travel demand in general and the thing was a flying dinosaur with not a big enough market to justify an upgraded version of the plane.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by nickik on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:03AM (#24716624)
It was only ever close to profit because it didn't have to finance its own development.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by kenneth on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:33AM (#24717141)
It's not necessary to account for R&D costs if the R&D has other benefits (e.g. putting Airbus on the map as an alternative manufacturer to Boeing, giving Europe technology with military implications independent of its reliance on the USA, etc.)
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by bobthepanda on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:08AM (#24717004)
The context is pretty clearly talking about operating profit, not the profitability of the program as a whole.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by trhway on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:46PM (#24715144)
>pressure will mount to define overland supersonic corridors

yes, that definitely need to happen. I wonder whether the sonic boom public scare is just based on the fact that the majority of the public has never experienced it. I grew up on a Navy base in USSR, and we regularly had fighters booming at the altitudes much lower than the altitude normal for the commercial supersonic travel. It was just fun for us children. May be you'd not want the boom echoing/bouncing through the Manhattan concrete mazes, yet at 20km altitude over rural areas there should be no issues.

Also there are large swaths of less populated lands in other countries who may be open to having such corridors over these areas. And back in Concorde times, there weren't such a big rich markets like China who has different approach to clearing of permitting/regulation issues for example when it comes to public transportation infrastructure.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by galaxyLogic on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:13AM (#24716380)
But why not fly subsonic over the land and supersonic over the ocean?
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by trhway on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:52AM (#24716560)
first it makes the flight longer while not decreasing the cost of the flight thus damaging the economics of such an operation.

second - those are very different modes. We don't know how to design a plane flying efficiently (and thus achieving a good range, and the range is already an issue for supersonics) in both modes, subsonic and supersonic (well, we do have B-1 and Tu-160 though that is well beyond commercial reach and i'd say those planes more like illustrate the issue than showcase the solution). Concorde for example was using afterburner to get to supersonic mode as quickly as possible, and while afterburner is very inefficient, such approach was overall still most efficient for Concorde because the plane was designed for the supersonic mode.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by Theodores on Thursday October 08, 2020 @05:18AM (#24717361)
Just to clarify, Concorde used afterburners for take-off and to get to supersonic speeds. When at speed it was able to supercruise without the afterburners.

What this meant in reality was that anyone in South West London (near to Heathrow but not necessarily just west of Heathrow) had this part of the day when the noise was terrible. You could be outside, sat down enjoying beers and all conversation would have to stop until this thing went overhead. Ear splitting was the word and there was no doubt the plane was Concorde.

Further down the road in the West Country the Concorde (there was only one!) would be able to be heard but it would not be announcing its presence and demanding that you stop everything that you were doing to look at it. At this stage it was high altitude but not on the supersonic super-cruise.

Then, over the Bristol Channel, Concorde would hit the afterburners good and proper to get up to full speed. People in Devon, Cornwall, South Wales and the south of Ireland would hear the boom albeit not at full intensity. It was still a 'boom' though.

If you look at the map and the size of the Bristol Channel then you can get an idea as to how big of an overland corridor you would need. It is huge, even for somewhere like Tibet.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by galaxyLogic on Thursday October 08, 2020 @08:06PM (#24725343)
I see. But so was there any technical necessity for Concorde go supersonic already over the land, rather than say 50 miles off the cost?

Or was that only an economic necessity?

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by trhway on Thursday October 08, 2020 @09:55PM (#24725946)
My understanding it is economics, range and time. Technically Concorde of course could fly subsonic. It is just that fuel efficiency was lower due to supersonic design of wings and engines. Its engines were designed with Mach 2 ram effect in mind - that ram pressure on top of mechanical compression resulted in high compression ratio and thus provided high efficiency - and without that additional ram pressure (which is much much lower at subsonic speeds) the pure mechanical compression ratio of its engines was pretty low and thus low efficiency. It naturally didn't have that switch from mechanical compression to pure ram like SR-71 :) The Concorde supersonic wings have low lift-to-drag ratio at low speeds which naturally means high thrust - high fuel consumption and resulting high noise - to keep it in the air at those low speeds.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by bob33212 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @07:47AM (#24718191)
Supersonic planes have to be thin to be efficient. That makes it hard to give someone a large seat with a large screen and also provide them with large range of food/drink and flight attendants. I would think the math works best at a higher price 60k/flight.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by jagger27 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:29PM (#24712360)
Their FAQ section^0 says this:

> Overture flights will focus on 500+ primarily transoceanic routes that benefit from supersonic speeds—such as New York to London or San Francisco to Tokyo. Overture won't generate a sonic boom over land cruising at subsonic speeds. Its passengers won't even notice breaking through the "sound barrier," which will be inaudible and uneventful.

So I guess they haven't really solved physics. edit: in an economic way.

[0]: https://boomsupersonic.com/contact#faq-section

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by Robotbeat on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:49PM (#24712555)
NASA has solved physics, though:

https://www.nasa.gov/X59

The Low-boom Flight Demonstration mission has two goals: 1) design and build a piloted, large-scale supersonic X-plane with technology that reduces the loudness of a sonic boom to that of a gentle thump; and 2) fly the X-plane over select U.S. communities to gather data on human responses to the low-boom flights and deliver that data set to U.S. and international regulators.

Using this data, new sound-based rules regarding supersonic flight over land can be written and adopted, which would open the doors to new commercial cargo and passenger markets to provide faster-than-sound air travel.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:45PM (#24714146)
> NASA has solved physics, though:

"NASA has a project to test whether the physics can be adequately finessed" would be more accurate description of what is on that page than "NASA has solved the physics".

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by uranium on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:39PM (#24714107)
NASA has a goal to solve physics; we'll see how they do.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by JacobDotVI on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:31PM (#24712382)
there is also ongoing research into making the boom less audible & turbulent over land, which would enable cross-country flights:

>Graves explains that SonicBAT is an unusual test in that it uses a typical military aircraft with its loud sonic boom to help engineers better understand the sounds from future quiet supersonic aircraft

>"We're hoping we can eventually lower sonic booms to a low rumble," he said. "The goal is to eventually accommodate jets that can fly from New York to Los Angeles in two hours."

https://www.nasa.gov/feature/new-supersonic-technology-desig...

I'd hope that Boom is also working on such an approach

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by lumost on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:03PM (#24712703)
WRT to the US. I'd be curious if anyone has done a route analysis on trans-continental flights to minimize overheard booms. Once you're 200 miles from the coasts there is a lot of open space to fly through.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by qppo on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:51PM (#24713178)
I think you'd be hard pressed to find a path where the boom cone's carpet doesn't pass over a moderately populated area and can be navigated by the aircraft at supersonic speeds. The US is not sparse east of the Missippi, which is more like 750 miles from the coast.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:52PM (#24714184)
> Once you're 200 miles from the coasts there is a lot of open space to fly through.

That's really only true west of about a North-South line through the eastern edge of the Texas panhandle. From there east, there's still some open space (not a lot once you hit the Mississippi River), but you'd have to dodge around to make path not going over population concentrations.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by ed25519FUUU on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @08:30PM (#24714421)
I think that’s why they specifically call out O’hare to London, and SF to Tokyo, routes that take them over the ocean.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by nopzor on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @06:54PM (#24713766)
that's an interestingly worded statement.

in concorde, the passengers didn't even notice breaking through the sound barrier either.

regarding sonic booms over land, their plan iirc is to reduce the noise level to the point where they can lobby to change legislation.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by rich_sasha on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:36PM (#24712433)
There were a lot of potential buyers for Concorde in other parts of the world. They backed out when the operating costs came out, and the range was found to be lower than expected (though BA managed to increase it through operational improvements).

Whether supersonic travel is still relevant is another question, but there buyers then, maybe there would be now too.

https://www.heritageconcorde.com/concorde-b

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by griffinkelly on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:40PM (#24712465)
Concorde had a bunch of publicly tours around Asia. There are a few that could make sense-- HK to Tokyo? Tokyo to Singapore?

The fuel requirements from the US to Asia are pretty intense, so I'm interested to see how they solve that issue.

Sonic booms haven't always been illegal in the US (1973?). My dad grew up near O'hare, and he said you'd occasionally hear them when it was still a military base. Its just annoying, but for people who live near airports, jet noise is already annoying? I think as long as jets just boom over specific areas, it would minimize the public nuisance.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by ajmurmann on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:14PM (#24713936)
> I think as long as jets just boom over specific areas, it would minimize the public nuisance.

That's not how it works. The boom is continuous along the flight pass

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by tshaddox on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:48PM (#24712543)
We heard sonic booms routinely growing up in the 1990s in small-town Missouri, presumably from nearby air force bases. It was little more than a curiosity, and never enough to rattle windows or really affect anyone much beyond perhaps a brief startling.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by ajmurmann on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:12PM (#24713919)
I grew up not far from an Air Force base on Germany. We got sonic booms multiple times a day. It was super shitty. We never had windows break, but as a young child I started to cry every time it happened. My grandfather woke up from his naps from them quite regularly which sucked especially when he was dying of cancer.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by spaetzleesser on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @09:33PM (#24714754)
I doubt they went supersonic over Germany. They probably went just very low which can be extremely terrifying and loud.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by zaarn on Thursday October 08, 2020 @02:20AM (#24716402)
I live in germany and can confirm that Jets go supersonic there. Live near both a US and german air force base and both sometimes go supersonic, more often it's the german air force to go after an unresponsive plane, probably about once every few months or so.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by spaetzleesser on Thursday October 08, 2020 @09:51AM (#24719082)
In an emergency yes but not several times a day as the OP described.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by zaarn on Thursday October 08, 2020 @10:42AM (#24719490)
Could happen that there were several per day.

Especially from US airforce bases in germany you can't expect much, they pretty much ignore air safety regulations entirely and do what they want (there have been multiple almost collisions over my city reported to air safety, several accidents where people got injured or died due to american personel acting reckless).

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by ajmurmann on Thursday October 08, 2020 @12:23PM (#24720635)
This was in the late 80s and early 90s in a part of Rhineland-Palatinate that is still designated as a practice area for fighter jets. The low flying jets are still a common nuisance, but as far as I know going super sonic sad been banned since.

I tried to google verification of this but only find more current information.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by tshaddox on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:14PM (#24713939)
I wonder what the difference is. Airplane size/speed/altitude?
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by ajmurmann on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:47PM (#24714155)
Most likely altitude. I recall that they used to practice flying at low altitude.

Much more interesting than our anecdata is probably the Oklahoma City Sonic Boom study: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oklahoma_City_sonic_boom_tests

> the NORC reported that 73% of subjects in the study said that they could live indefinitely with eight sonic booms per day, while 25% said that they couldn't. About 3% of the population telephoned, sued, or wrote protest letters, but Oklahoma City surgeons and hospitals filed no complaints.

However, with the city population at 500,000, that 3% figure represented 15,000 upset individuals. There were 9,594 complaints of damage to buildings, 4,629 formal damage claims, and 229 claims for a total of $12,845.32, mostly for broken glass and cracked plaster.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by spaetzleesser on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @09:31PM (#24714746)
They still go supersonic in the Mojave desert. You can hear them from time to time.

To make a supersonic passenger plane meaningful you can’t just go supersonic in a few areas but you have to go at that speed as much as possible.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by Swizec on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:50PM (#24713161)
Concorde’s other problem was newfangled airport security. Why spend 5x on tickets for a 3h flight if you spend 2h at airports anyway? The day is wasted to travel regardless.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by chrisseaton on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @08:14PM (#24714327)
> The day is wasted to travel regardless.

This doesn't add up. At the moment when I fly from the UK to New York I leave my house at 6 AM and could be in the city by just after lunch. With supersonic, including airport and transfer times, I could literally get up at my normal time in the UK and arrive to get a full working day in New York. None of the day is wasted.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by Swizec on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @08:34PM (#24714445)
You’re right it works in one direction. Now add to that 5x pricing. Worth it?

In the other direction it’s harder. Too short to sleep on the plane, too long to get a full day.

If you want to be in London at 9am, you’re leaving NYC at 2am-ish for a supersonic flight. (1h transit to airport, 2h at airport, 3h flight, 1h transit to London)

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by chrisseaton on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @08:50PM (#24714545)
> If you want to be in London at 9am, you’re leaving NYC at 2am-ish for a supersonic flight. (1h transit to airport, 2h at airport, 3h flight, 1h transit to London)

I'm not sure what you mean - that gets you into London at 2pm not 9am (2am + 1 + 2 + 3 = 9am New York = 2pm London.)

To get into London at 9am you'd need to leave New York City at 10pm (9am - 1 - 3 - 2 = 3am London = 10pm New York. Which seems fine you're doing it overnight no days lost? You'd not get tons of sleep that night but you're not wasting a day either way. Could leave at 8pm and get two hours's sleep in the arrivals lounge!

And leaving at 10pm instead of 5pm as you have to now makes all the difference because it now isn't interfering with your day at all! That was the goal wasn't it? Makes it worth it?

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by Swizec on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @09:29PM (#24714736)
You're right I mathed wrong. The problem is that on 3 hours of sleep now that I'm over 30, the next day is lost.

As for worth it, prob depends on who you are and why you're flying and how much more than a normal ticket it ends up costing. For me paying 5x the price isn't worth it under any circumstances.

And I'm pretty productive on airplanes (esp now with good wifi) so 3h vs. 6h flight isn't a big deal.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by acomjean on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:04PM (#24713844)
They literally named the company “boom” so they must have thought about it.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by moralestapia on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:35PM (#24713007)
>[...] the problem that killed Concorde: Civilian sonic booms over populations are illegal

Did this killed the Concorde? I don't know the story well, but I always though it was because it was never a profitable venture but it was kept because it was good PR. Then the accident happened and it was just not worth it anymore ...

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by bobthepanda on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @06:18PM (#24713459)
Concorde was profitable. It initially wasn't, but then BA and Air France found out that customers thought Concorde was more expensive than it actually was. Once they increased prices to customer expectation the Concorde was fairly profitable. https://theadaptivemarketer.com/2012/01/14/a-pricing-lesson-....

The major issue with Concorde by the time of its retirement was that it was very old and outdated, among other things needing a 3-person crew. The market for new Concordes was not large enough for a next-egeneration update to be profitable. And 9/11 had dented air travel demand.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by moralestapia on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @06:47PM (#24713706)
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by fotbr on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:30PM (#24712364)
The theory is that they can reduce the supersonic shockwave to the point where supersonic flight over populated areas can be legalized again.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by Voloskaya on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:34PM (#24712410)
> How does this seek to overcome the problem that killed Concorde

This did not single handedly killed the Concorde, there are plenty of routes with substantial flying time over unpopulated areas. Presumably if the cost of maintenance and the fuel consumption were lower it could still be flying.

So assuming Boom fixes those 2 points, then not being able to go supersonic over land just lowers efficiency but does not mean it's not viable.

Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by failuser on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:26PM (#24712330)
We might be at the point when it can be legal again, just make sure you don’t fly supersonic above mansions of people with actual power.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by jankassens on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:30PM (#24712365)
Without any deeper knowledge, there might also be a good amount of business travel between Australia/East Asia and the US West coast?
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:43PM (#24712499)
It's for Emirati playboys to continue their game of oneupsmanship while they still have money to burn.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by seany on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:28PM (#24712939)
Lobby to make them legal again? The restriction is stupid to start with.
Re:XB-1 Supersonic Rollout by sumedh on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:06PM (#24713864)
Why do you think its stupid?