News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by WJW on Friday October 02, 2020 @12:43PM (#24664422)
A very Stephen Wolfram article. As usual, if you assume all his unproven priors (ie, reality is actually a hypergraph with well defined update rules, the hypergraph has premade nonlocal 'long threads' in it) and go along with his redefinition of the speed of light as the speed of causality then the article makes perfect sense.

Where the trouble starts is that there seems to be no evidence whatsoever to support the axioms, and also no way to actually measure the predicted effects. It is not so different from saying "There might be a godlike being out there that can just teleport us anywhere we want, but we have no way of contacting it or even of being sure it exists". A cool theory, but until any proofs or falsifications come along it is indistinguishable from science fiction.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by krick on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:09PM (#24664710)
> redefinition of the speed of light as the speed of causality

Since when this is redefinition? As far as I understand, this was always the definition. In fact, calling it the speed of light was always a bit misleading, since, first off, actual speed of light depends on environment, and second, there is nothing really special about light. It's just under ideal circumstances it can propagate with the maximum possible speed, i.e. the speed of causality. Light isn't fundamental for the laws of physics, causality is.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by cthalupa on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:51PM (#24665107)
You’re correct. The speed of light is not actually about light.

https://youtu.be/msVuCEs8Ydo has a great explanation from the always excellent PBS Space Time, for the curious.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by uoaei on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:07PM (#24664688)
This comment displays yet again the conflation between "exploratory model" and "explanatory model".

This model does not purport (in its current iteration) to explain material reality. It purports to generate a theory of physics without going so far as to claim that that theory coincides with the dynamics of our universe specifically.

It is taking the idea of "physical model" and abstracting it to see how flexible of a theoretical substrate can be used to demonstrate certain behaviors within the defined set of axioms which we would expect out of any model of physics, i.e., causality, limits of information propagation rates, etc.

In short: it is not a theory of the physics, but just a physics.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by WJW on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:24PM (#24664850)
Are you sure? Because https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2020/04/finally-we-may-h... definitely implies that he believes his "hypergraph with update rules" model is how the universe actually works and what remains is to find the particular structure and update rules that describe our own universe.

Don't get me wrong, I think it's a very interesting model that is quite flexible and could be used for a great many things. But if we're moving the goalposts from "can we go faster than the speed of light in our own universe" to "can we go faster than the speed of light in a universe I constructed from arbitrary rules" then the result becomes much less interesting.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by BobbyJo on Friday October 02, 2020 @03:03PM (#24665927)
It'd be weird if the guy forwarding a theory didn't believe in it. An I think there is room in between believing a framework can explain things and believing it is.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by outworlder on Friday October 02, 2020 @04:32PM (#24666741)
> definitely implies that he believes his "hypergraph with update rules" model is how the universe actually works and what remains is to find the particular structure and update rules that describe our own universe.

This goes back to his obsession with cellular automata. There's an outstanding amount of references to "I" in your link. Great works of science usually reference the works of others...

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by uoaei on Friday October 02, 2020 @06:42PM (#24667788)
It makes sense that the first steps toward developing a sufficiently robust theory is making sure your model can recreate the various phenomena that you are interested in modelling, no?

The goal is to get to a theory that reflects the behavior of the universe, and figuring out how to emulate the various idiosyncracies inherent in how the universe evolves over time (finite speed of information propagation, etc.). Finding testable aspects of the model is only possible after actually applying the theory, seeing where it falls short, and identifying ways to validate ambiguous conclusions.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by throwaway_pdp09 on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:21PM (#24664826)
> but just a physics

Without modelling the real world, and in describing it's own rules, I think you might better describe it as a branch of mathematics, and not a physics, no?

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by l33tman on Friday October 02, 2020 @05:38PM (#24667276)
Superstring theory is considered a branch of physics but it's in a similar position (not saying there's anything of value in the wolfram article, just saying sometimes purely theoretical frameworks can be called physics even though they have not reached a predictive or even postdictive state yet)
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by prionassembly on Friday October 02, 2020 @12:52PM (#24664518)
I think he's content with this reputation; also independently wealthy and not taking public funds or seats in academia.

I say the future generations will be better off for Wolfram having gone down his rabbit holes.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by mnemonicsloth on Friday October 02, 2020 @04:54PM (#24666923)
Right. Except for all the times he's claimed credit for others' work.

And his wikipedia page has been thoroughly whitewashed, which suggests he is not content with the reputation he deserves.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by pa7x1 on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:14PM (#24664745)
Haven't read the article yet, so I don't judge the merits of his proposal, but unproven priors is exactly how science is built. A scientific hypothesis is taken without proof, then you derive its consequences and try to falsify them.

What Wolfram has to do is to replicate known physics at a minimum and ideally derive new testable predictions that we can attempt to falsify.

If he does that his unproven priors will become the new "taken for granted" priors.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by WJW on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:27PM (#24664867)
That would be nice and he mentions that he can already replicate a few of the observed effects from relativity. But my point was exactly that he has (so far) not generated any testable predictions. I'd love it if he did.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by BadThink6655321 on Friday October 02, 2020 @02:42PM (#24665676)
What do we do with a theory that conforms to every measurement ever made, but whose predictions aren’t testable? After all, we’re already there. We’ll never measure the interior of a black hole, for example. I think our theory selection criteria needs work.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by outworlder on Friday October 02, 2020 @04:42PM (#24666812)
> We’ll never measure the interior of a black hole, for example

Don't say 'never'. You can say we are pretty confident that the interior of black holes can't be measured now or in the future, given our current understanding. But science is not made of absolutes.

> What do we do with a theory that conforms to every measurement ever made, but whose predictions aren’t testable

Then it's kinda worthless, at last for physics. If two explanations agree with all observations (so far) that means they are completely interchangeable. You might as well use Occam's Razor and pick the simplest one. Until such time we find experimental differences, then we can compare again.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by marcus_holmes on Saturday October 03, 2020 @06:39PM (#24675198)
well, the next step in the mathematics -> physics chain is either Chemistry or Engineering.

If your theory allows an engineer to build a warp drive, your theory is sound.

If not, not.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by rbanffy on Friday October 02, 2020 @03:52PM (#24666425)
> but whose predictions aren’t testable?

Until we can test it, we should avoid calling it a theory.

In the meantime develop it until we can test it. We continue observing until we find something that isn't quite right.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by jlokier on Friday October 02, 2020 @02:26PM (#24665490)
All fundamental theoretical physics starts by building a model idea and exploring what the possible consequences are in a mathematical way.

The goal is to model the real world, but it's far too difficult to go straight from a fundamental model up to the world observations to find out if the model works.

Doing that "work out the consequences" work can take decades, and a lot of people.

So models are built, explored, their consequences worked out, and if they match something interesting in other more well-established theories, then the models are looked at with more interest and developed further. If not, the models are tweaked or thrown away.

You could call it a branch of mathematics, but in a sense all theoretical physics starts out that way, so we just call it theoretical physics when the goal is to model observed reality while providing a useful underlying model.

Browse the papers on arXiv.org or any theoretical physics journal and there's a lot of exploratory model-building like this. It's very common.

Graph-space models are also not unique to Stephen Wolfram. Several physicists (paid ones) are exploring these models as an approach to reconciling relativity and quantum physics. In a sense, this is what deriving from observation looks like: We've observed relativity and quantum, and we still haven't figured out how to understand the logical consequences of both together, so exploring theoretical underlying models like this is necessary to understand current observations.

The article's theory is not "philosophical" or "metaphysical" theory where nothing can be tested in principle. He explicitly talks about measurable effects differing from other models, albeit with many difficulties and potential intractibility due to computational limits.

But the point is there are, in principle, observable differences, making it more than just a metaphysical model, and if it's intractable to access them we can't figure that out without studying the model further. Even if we can't, there not being able to may have consequences as well (like the way the Heisenberg uncertainty principle turns out to have logical consequences, not just preventing measurements).

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by criddell on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:18PM (#24664784)
> if you assume all his unproven priors (ie, reality is actually a hypergraph [...]

What's the mainstream theory for what reality actually is?

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by bladedtoys on Friday October 02, 2020 @03:16PM (#24666059)
If I can take a shot at this, there are broadly two: the quantum mechanic explanation and the relativity explanation. But we seem to only be talking about relativity.

Relativity explains a couple of counter intuitive things that we actually see:

1. Apparently there is no particular velocity that can be called absolutely stopped or special in any way: every velocity is just as valid as every other.

2. Observers moving at different velocities disagree on 3D distances and time intervals between events.

3. But they all agree on the spacetime distance between events. Which is to say, there is a simple formula that resembles a distance formula in 4D where one of the dimensions is time.[0] We know that using this formula, all observers at all velocities get the same result.

gravity is not being discussed but relativity addresses it as well.

So relativity explains actual (but counter intuitive) observations. If we had the simpler Newtonian universe then we could fly around at unlimited relative speeds and time would flow unambiguously at constant rate and be completely unconnected to distance/space. But by direct observation, we see we don't live in such a universe.

If causality could percolate at unlimited speeds then we would not observe any these things and the formulas for relativity would not work but the formulas of Newton would. For one, there would be infinite frames of reference for which you arrive before you depart and these frames of reference could use faster than light travel reverse casualty.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spacetime#Spacetime_interval

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by criddell on Friday October 02, 2020 @03:52PM (#24666422)
I know of one other non-mainstream explanation from Max Tegmark: the mathematical universe hypothesis says reality is actually mathematics.

I'm not sure your explanation is an alternative explanation of what reality is. You've laid out some characteristics and consequences, but haven't described what's at the bottom of it.

I've heard that matter is a consequence of quantum field excitations, but what is a field? From the little bit I've read it sounds like mathematics again.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by aeternum on Friday October 02, 2020 @04:33PM (#24666742)
The concept of a field can be described using mathematics but does that really mean mathematics is actually what the universe is made of?

Suppose for example we found that protons, neutrons, and electrons really were fundamental. Their behavior can be described with mathematics but wouldn't we say it's still the elementary particles that our compose our universe?

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by criddell on Friday October 02, 2020 @05:25PM (#24667185)
Tegmark's theory says exactly that - the particles are ultimately mathematics. Not that they can be modeled with mathematical methods, but that they are actually constructed from mathematical structures.

It's definitely not a mainstream theory.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by goatlover on Friday October 02, 2020 @06:04PM (#24667486)
What does the mean, though? Mathematics as we understand it is an abstraction. If the universe is fundamentally abstract, what breathes fire into the models? Consciousness?
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by wcoenen on Saturday October 03, 2020 @04:54AM (#24670609)
Modal realism. A mathematical structure is "real" to its conscious inhabitants (if any), and merely an abstraction from the perspective of those who are not, i.e. the inhabitants of other mathematical structures.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by piannucci on Friday October 02, 2020 @03:07PM (#24665973)
The mainstream theory is that whatever reality is, its consequences on measurable length-scales are as-yet indistinguishable from an almost-everywhere-continuous medium. (I.e. away from black hole singularities.). Until we have the ability to measure not just deviations of reality from theory, but deviations from what any continuum theory might predict, the question of whether hypergraphs have the correct asymptotic continuum behavior is largely moot. Wolfram has been pushing an atomistic program of cellular automata as models of physical systems for many years. They are beautiful, but so far they are only useful insofar as they approximate continuum mechanics-- which is to say, they are of limited application.

The thing about continuous media is that they involve dynamics on all length scales: .1 meters, .1 nanometers, 1e-10 nm, etc. Because of wave-particle duality, length scales and energy scales run inversely: a low energy experiment just does not exhibit any measurable dependence on extremely short-range behavior of the universe. Only high-energy experiments have a wavelength short enough to be sensitive to this unknown sector. Low energy physics is “well understood” in the sense that any experiment with a modest number of component particles can be totally predicted from theory, to the limits of experimental accuracy. Granted that many real-world problems involve stupendous numbers of particles, and exhibit challenging-to-explain emergent behavior: but this is not evidence of unexplained fundamental phenomena, just of the limits of our mathematical insight into finding good abstractions for many-body problems, and evidence of the limits of our computational power to try and work around the lack of good abstractions.

It is known that the most generous interpretation of current theories is that they are self-consistent to arbitrary high energies (renormalizable is the term). That does not mean they are consistent with actual reality, just with themselves.

So... hypergraphs are a big lift, an unneeded multiplication of entities. Until an experiment reveals non-continuum behavior of space-time, what we have here is a solution to a non-issue.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by dblack12705 on Friday October 02, 2020 @11:09PM (#24669177)
I just wanted to say that this is a really fantastic explanation of the current state of the art, particularly the way you state the high-level motivation for ultra high energy colliders. Of course, without a few orders of magnitude gain in acceleration gradient, the necessary collider size is impractically large, so these sorts of questions may not be investigated for a while.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by criddell on Saturday October 03, 2020 @09:53AM (#24672110)
But it doesn't answer the question for what is the mainstream theory for what reality is. I'm starting to think that maybe there isn't one.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by czbond on Friday October 02, 2020 @12:54PM (#24664531)
But is still worth noting. Science tends to be pretty rigid, and often dismissive of outlandish theories because participants in the field are too close to 'socially accepted facts'. Which as we know from human existence - humans have small minds due to social conformity.....
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by mellosouls on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:17PM (#24664778)
It's not worth noting - because we also know that almost all theories of this ilk tend to be dismissed because they break the laws of physics.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by jlokier on Friday October 02, 2020 @02:41PM (#24665658)
> almost all theories of this ilk tend to be dismissed because they break the laws of physics.

Actually no.

Theories of this ilk which demonstrate their consistency with laws of physics to the level of observations already made and significantly beyond, tend to end up studied more, by more people.

Especially ones that take an unusual angle, and end up deriving existing laws of physics almost as a surprising side effect. It suggests a useful insight.

Even better if they take an unusual angle, predict some differences from assumed existing laws but only in unusual circumstances nobody has tried to observe so far, and are consistent with those laws in areas already observed.

Or ones which explain existing laws better than current explanations. Notably the inconsistencies between general relativity and quantum mechanics mean that anything which can explain both at the same time and give correct answers to both is quite interesting.

The ones that get dismissed quickly are those which aren't consistent with laws of physics that are already assumed, especially at the level of existing observations.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by mellosouls on Friday October 02, 2020 @05:16PM (#24667102)
No, that only happens if there is a convincing argument that covers more ground than existing theories with testable predictions.

What new predictions (ie. not covered by existing theories) does this theory propose that are testable?

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by czbond on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:55PM (#24665149)
Mind expanding ideas are - because they help the mind to make connections in the future in which they involved. The field of science contains numerous personality types, some of which are creative, some of which are analytical. It is often worth the analytical (who must see data) to entertain those with creativity or intuition to make the jump - since often data does not lead to leap insights.

Incremental science happens because of data; leap science happens because of creativity and intuition to explore the areas data hasn't 'gapped to'. And it is the difference when 'the data does not yet lead there, so we can't think there' that I refer to for social conformity.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by mellosouls on Friday October 02, 2020 @05:09PM (#24667049)
Non conformity is used as an excuse by cranks to justify their lack of academic groundwork and resulting acceptance.

Once in a blue moon one of these outsiders turns up something genuinely impressive.

There is no reason whatsoever to assume that is the case here.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by throwaway_pdp09 on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:19PM (#24664795)
I'd like to know if you can give some evidence in the past (say) 20 years that science has discarded or delayed acceptance of a good theory because of 'social conformity'.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by BadThink6655321 on Friday October 02, 2020 @02:25PM (#24665487)
See the <a href=“ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_drop_experiment”>Millika... Oil Drop Experiment</a>, particularly the section “ Millikan's experiment as an example of psychological effects in scientific methodology”
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by saagarjha on Friday October 02, 2020 @03:03PM (#24665925)
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by BadThink6655321 on Friday October 02, 2020 @05:52PM (#24667387)
Thanks!
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by throwaway_pdp09 on Friday October 02, 2020 @02:46PM (#24665728)
Interesting, I'll have a careful read of that but I must point out it was from 90 years ago, a bit outside my stated margin!
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by TheOtherHobbes on Friday October 02, 2020 @02:49PM (#24665755)
Older: Wegener's theory of Continental Drift was dismissed for around four decades before it was reinvented by someone else and accepted by geologists.

Recently: transgenerational epigenetics was considered a violation of the Central Dogma of biology, but since then evidence has piled up and it's now considered a legitimate area of research.

The jury is out in high energy physics where SUSY and string theory elbowed some (possibly) more interesting competitors out of the way. It's too early to tell how that will work out - but it is clear that some approaches get a lot more funding and attention than others, and this seems to be for political rather than objectively scientific reasons.

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by czbond on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:53PM (#24665125)
I'm talking at the individual level - humans are socially pressured to conform to their field of study current beliefs (in any field). It takes long periods of time for ideas that go against the grain to bubble up to become 'mass conscious' within a field. Especially in areas requiring higher mathematics where practitioners can feel inferior.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by throwaway_pdp09 on Friday October 02, 2020 @02:43PM (#24665693)
Which I'm saying I don't believe. Show me recent examples where it happened, I asked.

> Especially in areas requiring higher mathematics

I just don't recognise this at all. Why do you say this? The journals are full of new discoveries, my experience with mathematicians is they're a very open and accommodating bunch (ok, it's not my field, but still)

Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by rstupek on Friday October 02, 2020 @02:28PM (#24665509)
I'm not sure if it meets your 20 year criteria, but science believed that peptic ulcers were the result of over production of stomach acid when one researcher proved that a bacteria was the cause of the majority of them. He had to buck general scientific consensus
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by throwaway_pdp09 on Friday October 02, 2020 @02:41PM (#24665663)
My understanding was that he provided the strong evidence (by experimenting on himself), and things changed. If he'd provided the evidence then been told to take a running jump by everyone else, I'd say you have a point.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by inimino on Friday October 02, 2020 @08:58PM (#24668577)
If you would think for a moment about the time scale over which these things develop ("one funeral at a time") you'd recognize how absurd a question this is.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by edem on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:26PM (#24664861)
Wait a second. We already know (since Einstein) that the speed of light is in fact the speed of causality.
Re:Faster Than Light in Our Model of Physics: Some Prelimina... by JPLeRouzic on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:20PM (#24664801)
Perhaps Stephen Wolfram's theory is comparable to Maxwell's theory and we need a modern Oliver Heaviside to make it more palatable. (I am a layman)