Hawaii's mortality rate is nearly 1/3 the rate of Canada (which has done a solid job by comparison to the US) and 1/6 the rate of Sweden. Finland, which has one of the elite outcomes in the West, is how far you have to go to find a better outcome (Finland's mortality rate is only 2/3 that of Hawaii).
It may be harder than NZ, but closing borders should be much easier for Sweden than Germany, Turkey, or Thailand. They all fared better than Sweden.
I'm not sure there's actually much of a difference in ability to "close the border" between a island country like NZ and one with land borders like the US. The US probably has equal control over arrivals by air, and most land traffic comes via controlled border crossings.
The main difference is basically the greater amount of illegal immigration and other kinds of smuggling. I don't know what the ratio of legal international travel vs. illegal immigration is, but I'd strongly suspect there's orders of magnitude more of the former than the later (at least during normal times). IIRC, the rates of illegal immigration have also dropped significantly during the pandemic.
Based on NZ's past actions I would bet they come out of total lockdown sometime in mid 2022 or about 2 years from now. If the people of NZ are fine living this way for the next 2 years while their economy and lively hoods crumble then that is their business.
No way in hell I would let that silently happen to me.
Doesn't sound like "total lockdown" is what's happening there right now.
Yes, it sucks for the travel sector and it sucks for people who need to travel internationally (my family are in Ireland so it directly affects me).
But it sucks everywhere for everyone, and in both economic and health outcomes, we are way ahead of the curve.
Most of New Zealand is at "Alert Level 1" which means there aren't any restrictions or mandates, but since COVID-19 exists you're asked to please consider wearing masks on public transport, and try to keep your distance when possible.
For now (likely until next Wednesday) the city of Auckland is at "Alert Level 2" with a prohibition on large gatherings (more than 100 people in one place together) and a requirement to wear masks etc. as a result of an outbreak that happened there in August.
I live in Nova Scotia, Canada. We've bubbled with three surrounding provinces (~2.5 million people) and are in basically the same boat as NZ. We've had < 10 known cases since June IIRC, often with < 5. We're currently at two known cases.
We are NOT an island nation but have taken one hard line measure that has been effective: a 14 day quarantine when you come here from anywhere outside the four-province bubble
We also have a largely compliant population when it comes to social distancing and masking in public indoor places.
We also have the benefit of being a discretionary trip for most people who visit - there isn't a ton of travel in and out of the main cities compared with e.g. Toronto or Vancouver.
But life is pretty much back to normal. Restaurants + bars buzzing (at 50% capacity), retail open, no lockdown, etc.
I'd argue that it would work in any nation with an educated population where the leadership is listening to health experts and not undermining the containment effort or lying about the danger.
[0] https://www.who.int/news-room/articles-detail/updated-who-re...
[1] https://www.statnews.com/2020/01/31/as-far-right-calls-for-c...
They were able to eliminate covid in states of equivalent size as NZ, in effect achieving something just as impressive. But because the country is bigger, all it takes is a cluster in a single state to then propagate to others.
Australia is a pretty small country. In a country as big as the US it would be virtually impossible to eliminate without extreme levels of control over the population.
One of the giveaways was in their briefings at the time. New Zealand was interested in every new case, because you don't get to elimination with some sort of high level statistical approach, you get there one case at a time. Australia was happy to cheer success if it had fewer cases this week than last week - but fewer isn't elimination.
New Zealand left Level 2 only after weeks with zero new cases. Because they understood that "it's just one case" plus "infectious disease" multiplied by time = unlimited cases. Meanwhile Australians decided they were done, after all it's only a few cases, what's the harm? Well this is the harm.
As for your edit according to which this is only possible in large countries if they are totalitarian, the tactics China used are exactly the same that NZ has used, and are fully consititutional in the United States. Basically, telling people not to leave their homes for two weeks, using the Army to deliver food and supplies, and stopping travel between cities. These tactics have been implemented historically in the US in other epidemics and pandemics, so unless your claim is that the US is authoritarian, I don't follow.
Here in Canada I'm not allowed for the next 28 days to socialize with anyone outside of work. This is more restrictive than what was imposed on most cities in China.
You can also legally take them into a complex and prevent them from leaving until they test negative, as has already been done for other infactions in the US.
The executive branch in the US also has the authority to rapidly execute such measures, and has done so historically.
If New York was isolated totally and completely self governed, you have a hope of achieving what NZ achieves.
Even a country as small as Australia is evidence of this thesis. They can get it under control in one state but a cluster pops up in another and it becomes a never ending game of whack a mole. If Australia was only Sydney, covid would be a distant memory. If Australia, population of 25 million, can't eliminate it, then trying to do so in a democracy with 300 million is a pipe dream.
This includes outside gathering.
The end result is that I am not allowed to engage in any in person social activity for the next 28 days, at all. The only context in which I will be able to see people outside of my dwelling will be going to work (sadly/luckily I work remote), and getting groceries.
So basically, I'm banned from socializing for the next 28 days at minimum, and so are most people in Québec.
That said: having it controlled now doesn't mean that it will stay controlled forever. As we're seeing right now in Spain, France and the US plains states, even very low steady state infection rates can still flare up. Then you spend a week watching people die, locking down, and watch rates go back down slowly. And then... realistically it probably happens a third time. Or a fourth.
Everyone needs to be taking this seriously. NZ isn't immune to the next outbreak, nor Sweden. But no: in areas with known-low and steady infection rates, a full lockdown isn't necessarily required.
Still: stay outside, stay masked, stay apart. Break those rules as little as possible.
That or they are so hardcore crazy "My freedoms above all else" that they would rather 250k die than they be asked to stay in for a few weeks
For us. It's been over for them for a while.
Clearly any announcements that suggest an outlier positive performance in this situation will be taken with a pinch of salt, regardless of whether they are true or not.
Also, this isn't outlier-positive performance, it is the expectation given the measures that were taken. I don't see how the virus could spread with the strict measures that were imposed.
There's over a billion people in China, with an extensive diaspora that keeps in touch with family back home. The world is connected, and we aren't living in 1929 anymore (Where your entire extended family could have starved to death, and you wouldn't hear about it for a decade.)
What exactly do you think is happening there? They've lifted the lockdowns - and if the virus were still circulating through the community, it should have infected tens of millions of people by now. Do you think that millions of people are getting sick and dying, and their overseas relatives, who are frequently in touch with them, don't know about it?
They've tried to suppress COVID information, when only thousands of people were infected in January, and... Everybody still knew about it.
Do you think they are somehow orders of magnitude more successful at doing so in September, while secretly having millions and tens of millions of cases?
Or is the more plausible explanation that they probably don't have millions and tens of millions of cases?
Or, alternatively, do you think that they only have tens and hundreds of thousands of cases (Few enough to suppress information on), and somehow, despite the lockdowns being lifted, they aren't ballooning into millions?
People thinks the CCP is some omnipotent organization and can suppress any and all information. If that's the case, then how do we even know about the Uyghur detention camps?
So there are no more containment measures in China, not even masks are needed. However, the cases haven't spiked in the 2-3 months since the lockdowns had ended.
If China was covering up the disease and still had thousands of cases, then by now there would be millions of cases. However there aren't, I have friends and China and they don't know anyone who caught the virus in the last months. There haven't been secret lockdowns either because they would be easily noticeable.
As a consequence, we can come to the conclusion that the virus has essentially been eradicated in China, and while I don't know anyone in Vietnam I'd imagine it's the same.
Could you tell us how you feel about your fellow countrymen and women who work in travel and who's lives have been completely upended (sometimes permanently) by the affects of the lockdowns?
There's no good answer here, only a least bad alternative.
If that doesn't happen within a reasonable timeframe, then we definitely have to reassess our strategy.
But in the meantime, yes, COVID is effectively "over" within the country.
I mean, sure it's nice to be able to shut down borders for a year and a half, but you must see how this is not a realistic option for most other countries, including Sweden, so it's not really a valid comparison in the first place.
It is also a question of how much economic cost a country is willing to incur. Trucks can swap trailers/tractors at borders so drivers never cross border. International Tourism can be completely shutdown. Borders of some countries could be closed by the army, incurring personal costs to anyone that normally would cross the border regularly.
Tourism in New Zealand contributed 6% of the country's GDP and supported 8% of New Zealand's workforce. Most of that was international so has dropped radically, and there are other economic costs to NZ on top of that. There are also the personal costs of families that are split between countries and people that can’t get to important life events like weddings or funerals etc.
NZ has decided that the economic costs are worth the gains of avoiding 2500 early deaths (expected 10yr decrease in lifetime for each) and x0000 long-term health problems. I don’t know if the gains are worth the costs, but I am pleased we have given ourselves time and avoided making a rash decision to incur those costs.
Verifiable untrue.
https://theconversation.com/new-zealand-hits-zero-active-cor...
NZ eliminated Covid in the country. There were no active cases at one point.
The fact that another case came into the country does not change that fact.
New Zealand Reports No New COVID Cases as Country Nears Elimination for Second Time
https://www.newsweek.com/new-zealand-reports-no-new-covid-ca...
And a third is coming. And a fourth. And a fifth.
At what point will you admit that it won't be eliminated?
If your house has rats and you call an exterminator, you don't say you still have rats because other houses do and they might show up again.
Mine is longer term.
> I fail to see your point
I know you do. I know you would.
My point is that you have not eliminated it. If it keeps coming back it's not eliminated is it?
Yes it is eliminated. If it's not eliminated, it can't come back.
If someone removes all the rats from the house, so that there aren't any, we say they have eliminated the rats.
If, later, someone brings a rat to the house, we say they have brought rats back to the house and now we need to eliminate them again.
Elimination is an action, the action of removal, and eliminated means the removal is now done. It means the thing is gone. It can still come back later.
We locked down early and hard, and there was a definite hit to the economy (although not as bad as some had feared).
We eliminated Covid in the country. There was a tiny second wave which forced our largest city back into lockdown, but that has been lifted.
Aside from international travel, Covid now has basically zero impact on my day to day life. Because there is effectly 0 chance of communitry transmission at the moment, life has essentially returned to normal. Bars, restaurants, etc are open and buzzing.
All this and our case numbers are lower than almost any other countries death numbers.
There is no way I would rather live in Sweden.