News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by kenjackson on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @01:58PM (#2463482)
Here's the LG Prada:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:LG_prada_phone_private_pic...

http://mobile.engadget.com/2006/12/15/the-lg-ke850-touchable...

Announced Dec 2006. I'm not saying Samsung copied this phone, but if I was LG, I'd start to wonder.

BTW, best article on the issue to date.

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by halo on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @06:33PM (#2464503)
To be fair, the iPhone looks uncannily like the LG Prada. LG accused Apple of copying their design when they announced the iPhone.

The Samsung Galaxy S bears more than a passing resemblence to the LG Chocolate KG800 (http://www.muamat.com/adpics/4b98d2cc2ac18ee7579fe7516.jpg) from 2006.

Edit: Samsung announced the F700 in Febrary 2007, which is very similar to the Galaxy S in design (http://www.mobilephoneonly.co.uk/phonereviews/upload/samsung...).

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by warfangle on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @04:14PM (#2464035)
Definitely interesting, as the iPhone was first unveiled in Jan '07.
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by kedi_xed on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @07:33PM (#2464663)
Brilliant.
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by ddlatham on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @02:08PM (#2463537)
You’re probably familiar with patents, copyrights, and trademarks, the three main types of intellectual property. Trade dress is the wonky red-headed step-cousin of the family that fills the gaps between the three; you might think of it as a trademark on design elements that trigger consumer recognition. (That’s a vastly simplified explanation, but it’s good enough for our purposes.) Trademarks and trade dress are all about protecting consumers from being deceived in the marketplace — the idea is to clearly indicate the source of a product or service.

It's very interesting that in trademark and trade dress the issue is whether a product confuses consumers, rather than whether ideas were copied. Does this mean, with respect to these claims, that it's fine to copy product ideas and designs, so long as the product is clearly from a different source and consumers would not confuse it with the original source?

(For patents and copyright claims, it's more clear that it's about the duplication rather than the confusion it may cause.)

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by roc on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:04PM (#2463785)
Only utility patents protect ideas. No other intellectual property does. It's unfortunate that there aren't stronger penalties for rights-holders who make claims wildly beyond the scope of the licenses they're granted. They cause a lot of confusion and unnecessary animosity toward what are very pro-consumer concepts [1].

[1] Conceptually and originally at least.

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by ChuckMcM on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @01:59PM (#2463489)
I really enjoyed the discussion about "Trade Dress" as protected IP, that was something I had vague notions about and now have less vague notions about (the story about how the Coke bottle shape is protected was new to me)

I also find it somewhat amusing to compare the 'Apple in the dead pool' under Scully vs the current Apple. Few companies have made such epic reversals in their fortunes.

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by patrickaljord on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:01PM (#2463770)
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by cube13 on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:09PM (#2463809)
The image is wrong. According to a post in the reddit thread, as well as Samsung's own website, Samsung unveiled that phone in February 2007, one month after Apple showed the iPhone.

Looking at Samsung's photos, I do not see how it's possible for anyone to say that Apple was copying them. Samsung probably can make a case on the home screen format(4 icons, bottom row, etc.), but the overall design is quite different. The F700 has a physical keyboard.

http://www.samsung.com/us/news/newsRead.do?news_seq=3516

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by eli on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:57PM (#2463966)
The LG Prada is perhaps a better comparison? http://www.gsmarena.com/lg_ke850_prada-3d-spin-1828.php

Looks very similar from the outside, and was definitely demoed before the iPhone.

In fact, from a 2007 report:

> One analyst asked the executives whether they plan to sue Apple as some reports have suggested over design similarities with the iPhone: LG executive Chang Ma replied: "Should we? (laughs) Obviously, we are introducing this touch screen first [since the Prada phone will be available in Europe next month]... we are much more faster realizing and launching products in the market [than Apple]. But LG is targeting a different customer than Apple."

http://www.fiercewireless.com/story/lg-prada-shine-windows-m...

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by brudgers on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @02:52PM (#2463733)
">In 2000 the company sued both eMachines and a company called Future Power"

Neither was $172 billion company with a history of manufacturing handheld touchscreen devices dating back to 1989 and a huge portfolio of touch screen devices since then. [see image of early Gridpad here: http://ashishtiwari.posterous.com/guifx-touchscreens-that-ch... ]

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by kedi_xed on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @07:31PM (#2464656)
How does this compare to another field, say cars? I recently been car shopping for the first time, and the similarities between sedan models is amazing. Due to the nature of a car, and a sedan at that, it seems that all models have to follow a similar design for them to be functional and acceptable.

If a trade dress results in the monopoly of an industry, I assume then that the it would have to be avoided, or everyone pays Apple a small fee for use of the shape.

The issue as well is that many phones are all the same shape - rectangular, and many had rounded corners before Apple. Nokia have been using a XxX grid of icons for years before Apple. So essentially Apple is trying to trademark all of these elements put together as a trade dress issue.

But then Apple did take the time to invest and research the iPhone so they should take some of the benefits, but why sue so late?

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by chalst on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:36AM (#2465530)
There are two tests a trade dress lawsuit has to meet: first, the features have to be distinctive of the product in the eye of the consumer; second, the features must not be functional. This second requirement should mean that trade dress cannot be used to establish a monopoly.

The actual application of the functionality requirement is hazy. See http://www.akingump.com/docs/publication/549.pdf

It's unclear to me that Apple's claims to trade dress pass the functionality requirement.

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by rodh257 on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @05:40PM (#2464344)
Sounds like Samsung are going to have a tough job defending this. I imported a Galaxy S to Australia before they were release here and I had many people asking me if it was an iPhone, or just assuming I had an iPhone when they saw it. That's changed a bit now as they have been heavily marketed by all the phone carriers so more people know what they are.

Of course, if you inspect it closer, you'll notice the device is thinner, and the screen is larger and has more vibrant colours (particularly compared to the 3gs that it looks like), but on a quick glance you'd think it could be an iPhone.

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by orionlogic on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @01:00PM (#2467397)
One can stretch this issue as far as it can. http://cl.ly/1M2s1H1r3o2f2K1b2037

However i should correct the date till 350 B.C.

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by nl on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @10:01PM (#2464968)
As an otherwise very happy Samsung Galaxy S user, personally I wish it looked a lot less like an iPhone.
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by metageek on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:06PM (#2463792)
I love this bit: "It sounds simple, but, well, that’s only because we’re simplifying it.".
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by hesdeadjim on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @02:40PM (#2463686)
This has to make things a little awkward considering Samsung has been fabbing Apple's mobile chips.
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by protomyth on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @02:49PM (#2463719)
I get the feeling that the division doing the fabbing doesn't really care about the phone division beyond how many chips they are ordering.
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by r00fus on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:24PM (#2463859)
It's only confusing if you think this lawsuit is meant to be won on merits and not to primarily annoy a competitor into not competing.

It's placing pressure on Samsung to "toe the line" and "deliver our components, not your own products".

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by jamesaguilar on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @01:58AM (#2465435)
Seems quite likely from this guy's analysis that it could be won on merits. By making the lawsuit, Apple is also making a statement that it believes the case has merit. And winning the case on the merits (or settling it because a victory for Apple would be likely) would profit Apple significantly.

On the other hand, there is no chance that Samsung will shut down its phone division, whether or not Apple wins the lawsuit.

So I cannot understand how you got the impression that Apple is making this lawsuit in order to annoy Samsung into not competing. That is a much less likely explanation for the suit.

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by r00fus on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @04:03AM (#2465737)
> On the other hand, there is no chance that Samsung will shut down its phone division, whether or not Apple wins the lawsuit.

Samsung may not shut down their phone operation but this suit could make them re-evaluate the cost-benefit of Android phones... others have mentioned that this is a proxy lawsuit against Google, I'd agree.

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by warfangle on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @04:16PM (#2464042)
Makes me wonder how many patents of Samsung's that Apple is infringing upon?
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by kenjackson on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @04:25PM (#2464070)
I don't know, but when you see lawsuits like this it becomes clear why companies patent everything they can. It would suck to be in a position where Apple could come after you and you have no response. You have to have a patent portfolio to fight people attacking you.
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by kenjackson on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:19PM (#2463842)
And displays and Flash. I recall at one point Samsung made 40% of the world's Flash memory.
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by goatforce5 on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:48PM (#2463943)
I'd have to assume that Apple was really comfortable with the terms of their component supply contracts with Samsung, and that Samsung can't find a way to get out of them at this point.
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by cooldeal on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @04:34PM (#2464103)
Why would Samsung want to get out of the contracts when they're making billions off them?
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by kenjackson on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @05:38PM (#2464337)
Because it could cost them even more. Apple is problematic for Samsung for two reasons: (1) This lawsuit and (2) Apple selling product that Samsung makes much higher margins on than displays and fabbing.

Samsung ends up being in a MUCH better place if Apple becomes a niche player and Android and/or Windows Phone become the dominant platforms.

If Samsung was able to get out of all contracts to Apple it could probably stall Apple's growth a bit. Not an enormous hit, but enough to help Android get some tablet strength and WP7 to get Mango out the door.

Given that Samsung is the premiere vendor of non-Apple phones and tablets, and given this market is much more lucrative than components, they may be willing to give up 4% of revenue in a powerplay.

With that said they probably have contracts through 2011. Although if they were late on delivering the product, they could probably deal with the penalties, since they're probably small in comparison.

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by iamdave on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @08:51PM (#2464818)
Samsung IS Apple in South Korea, and for what it's worth, an event like this is not by an stretch of the imagination going to hurt them. Especially when you consider Samsung has a lot more going for it than home appliances and electronics in the United States.

That tower in Dubai? Guess who built it.

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by rsynnott on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @05:14PM (#2464251)
Samsung doesn't make the iPhone or iPad display; LG does. There may at this point be others; certainly, people have noticed minor performance differences in some newer iPhone 4 displays.
Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by kenjackson on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @05:18PM (#2464266)
http://www.slashgear.com/samsung-clinch-240m-ipad-display-co...

I don't know the details of if the deal broke last minute, but that's what I'd read.

UPDATE: More here -- http://www.slashgear.com/lg-and-samsung-ipad-screen-shipment...

Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis by gonzo on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @09:31PM (#2464891)
Micron and Intel are large suppliers,too.