Re:Apple sues Samsung: a complete lawsuit analysis
by roc on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:04PM
(#2463785)
Only utility patents protect ideas. No other intellectual property does. It's unfortunate that there aren't stronger penalties for rights-holders who make claims wildly beyond the scope of the licenses they're granted. They cause a lot of confusion and unnecessary animosity toward what are very pro-consumer concepts [1].
[1] Conceptually and originally at least.
It's very interesting that in trademark and trade dress the issue is whether a product confuses consumers, rather than whether ideas were copied. Does this mean, with respect to these claims, that it's fine to copy product ideas and designs, so long as the product is clearly from a different source and consumers would not confuse it with the original source?
(For patents and copyright claims, it's more clear that it's about the duplication rather than the confusion it may cause.)