Also, I firmly believe that git is very simple if you use it right. I'd you are deep in the manual with exotic commands and flags it's most likely your own fault.
Edit: forgot to add that saying git is not complicated always gets heavily downvoted on HN. So goodbye digital karma...
I find that Git can usually do everything Mercurial can, but it does involve those "exotic commands and flags". For example, the equivalent to
hg id -i
is apparently git describe --abbrev=12 --dirty=+ --always
which is not exactly obvious, not even if you read the manual. Stack Overflow also suggests alternatives[1] using "git log", "git status" and "git rev-parse" which do similar but slightly different things and accept similar but slightly different options.What about listing all filenames from all commits – "hg manifest --all"? I'm sure it can be done, but I'm equally sure it involves exotic flags.
[1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/14333388/git-equivalent-...
If you just want the current commit ID in git it's just "git rev-parse HEAD". Which is still longer and uglier than "hg id -i", yeah, but it's a fairer comparison.
Git has (although it's gotten better!) functionality spread haphazardly across different commands, and many commands can perform several seemingly unrelated tasks depending on the flags. There are lots of command to give you the hash of current commit, all with different combinations of bonus features, and in this particular case we use describe (which really seems to be for finding tags reachable from particular commits) because it happens to support the right combination of features.
(Perhaps I should mention that I'm currently migrating to Git. Git is fine. Many things are better than in Mercurial, just not the UI.)
Like many things in the computer world one starts out feeling that something is overly complex and then slowly one realizes that one would have designed a system just like it is now, given the opportunity. Realizing this has made me stop judging new tech until I try it for some time. Also, when many people use something and I find it to be overly complex, I try to reserve judgement and spends some hours at least to really try something. Although this does require some problem to be solved (a concrete target), at least for me.
I am a very basic user of git, with one or two branches and straight merges.
Until I commit the wrong thing, or mess with the merge and end up with a set of files I did not create (.orig IIRC).
So git is simple but not simply forgiving (it may be forgiving, but you need to know more). https://ohshitgit.com/ helped me several times.
When you realise it's nothing more than commits and a bunch of special labels it starts to make sense.
EDIT: Meant to add that sites like ohshitgit might help in a crisis but you're only a few hours reading off working out WHY those things work.
Well, sometimes it does, sometimes it doesn't, e.g. on macos it doesn't.
> gitk, which should really be people's default go-to
That's a matter of preference. For instance, I've been recommending Magit to all new starters (quickly installing spacemacs as a shell for that) and it's been working out great so far.
I live in VSCode and the Git Graph [1] extension works nicely.
[1] https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=mhutchie...
I don't find gitk particularly useful, but it is right there.
> Git is truly the Dark Souls of version control systems
Yeah, but in a bad way. In my 10-years-experience with DVCS, Git requires orders of magnitude more attention than any other (D)VCS (except, maybe, monotone), offering nothing in return.
edit: closed parent
To be fair, From Software definitely plays into the "hardcore" image of Dark Souls with their marketing.
Do you think we'll ever get "Git: Prepare to Die Edition"?
Git is truly the Dark Souls of version control systems - that is, it's wonderful and masterfully crafted but it has attracted this misguided cult following which spreads misinformation about how intractable and hardcore it supposedly is. Dark Souls doesn't have forge sites deliberately (?) adding to the confusion (maybe all those youtubers...), though.