If you just want the current commit ID in git it's just "git rev-parse HEAD". Which is still longer and uglier than "hg id -i", yeah, but it's a fairer comparison.
Git has (although it's gotten better!) functionality spread haphazardly across different commands, and many commands can perform several seemingly unrelated tasks depending on the flags. There are lots of command to give you the hash of current commit, all with different combinations of bonus features, and in this particular case we use describe (which really seems to be for finding tags reachable from particular commits) because it happens to support the right combination of features.
(Perhaps I should mention that I'm currently migrating to Git. Git is fine. Many things are better than in Mercurial, just not the UI.)
I find that Git can usually do everything Mercurial can, but it does involve those "exotic commands and flags". For example, the equivalent to
is apparently which is not exactly obvious, not even if you read the manual. Stack Overflow also suggests alternatives[1] using "git log", "git status" and "git rev-parse" which do similar but slightly different things and accept similar but slightly different options.What about listing all filenames from all commits – "hg manifest --all"? I'm sure it can be done, but I'm equally sure it involves exotic flags.
[1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/14333388/git-equivalent-...