I do too, but your appeal to emotion is off-topic. This has nothing to do with the lawsuit. None of these companies want that, nor are they working toward that. Epic and Spotify are pushing their own walled gardens, they just want to do it with a bigger profit margin.
There is absolutely no problem with that because it cures the one and only walled garden problem. If they implement a subpar walled garden, it will be up to the users to exercise choice on using them, which they currently can't.
This is the core of the opponent processes of markets. It is irrelevant to demand ideological purity from opponents, what matters is the resulting dynamics their actions create, in this case creating a previously non-existing competition space on iOS app installs.
Epic games store is a very subpar walled garden. It's the only way to access several games that are either in exclusivity agreements with Epic or were purchased by Epic outright (RIP Rocket League). Spotify is (IMHO) a subpar walled garden. They recently purchased exclusivity for Joe Rogan, if you want to listen to him in the future you have to use Spotify. I don't see where in this process I get a choice of anything. These companies are not fighting for consumer choice, they just want to move more power over the consumer from one middle man (Apple) to another (themselves).
> They recently purchased exclusivity for Joe Rogan, if you want to listen to him in the future you have to use Spotify.
Joe Rogan's podcast is anti-science crap. That it moved to a walled garden, restricting access to it, I find that as being a gift to the world.
Namely, paying for exclusivity onto their store (or more accurately paying for the developer to not release onto Steam - the current incumbent). I'm not sure how you can argue that they are helping users exercise choice when this is behavior they already engage in.
Like f-droid , for iOS
Being able to choose to run whatever you want on your own device is a necessary first step to opening up app stores to competition.
They support the ideal because it's the only way to get what they want. It's a mistake to assume that since they are doing it for their own benefit that we all can't benefit as well.
I'm also backing these companies' argument and I don't want a walled garden. I want an open and competitive marketplace. I want to be able to distribute my software to everyone (like I used to be able to do).
> I want a world where we're free to install whatever we want on our devices or distribute our hard work to others without having to implement it 5 different ways.
That's lovely and all, but that has never existed? I don't understand how you would even accomplish this.
> I don't want to be taxed by entities worth trillions. Before they stood up the walls, I could reach all the people I wanted for free. Now they've turned us into poor serfs.
What does this even mean?! You could never reach "all the people" for free?
> he last bastion, the web, is even under attack...
Fair
> These rent-seeking companies took all of the goodwill and amazing technology we developed in the open
Who is "we"? Are we including the department of defense in "we"? Bell labs?
If you have a point, make your point. Tell me what specifically you take issue with in the original comment.
You can get unlocked android phones and install whatever you want. But the reality for our parents / grandparents etc is that the folks who want to have root on their device want to scam them, auto bill them with non-cancelable billing etc etc etc, market to them by tracking everything, turn all their data over to the govt.
We have basically one company who is trying to do a consumer / privacy first play. They went toe to toe with the DOJ to avoid unlocking the phone of a known shooter.
As more and more of our life lands on these devices, I think this is the smart play. Go use another phone if you don't like it.
Half of my audience is on your favorite device. I didn't have to pay for them before Apple sunk their claws in.
Even if there wasn't a tax, the lack of freedom is what really gets me. Apple built itself atop open source. They leveraged it to gain control over 40% of the CPUs used by consumers. Now we can't run code for these people.
I applaud their privacy stance. But freedom to run software is a separate issue.
If anyone wants to come up with a freedom to run software alternative that doesn’t result in me dealing with malware, I’m open to it.
Until then, I have to pay Apple, because I don’t have time to deal with the alternatives currently available.
Edit:
>Half of my audience is on your favorite device. I didn't have to pay for them before Apple sunk their claws in.
I might be part of that audience, but when I was purchasing tablets for my business, I chose Apple, because I didn’t want to deal with malware or google support. I knew I could rely on Apple to not have malware and to provide in person support in reasonable time. I’m also willing to pay 30% extra for a subscription via the App Store since I know it’s dead easy to cancel it.
I am aware of Apple’s injustices with their arbitrary rules and enforcement and how they are able to screw over developers. But I need to move on with life, and I need something that just works.
I don't mean secure as in the NSA can't break into it. I mean secure as in normal people can't mess it up clicking bullshit links in WhatsApp messages.
All I know is I needed a 100% guarantee the device won't be tampered with by random people for my business and that other than turning it off and on, there was no tech support needed. To me, this meant going with Apple.
Especially since nowadays your financial accounts and everything is secured via SMS 2FA.
As an example, HummingBad infected 85 million devices primarily via direct-download on malicious adult websites. (https://www.zdnet.com/article/this-android-malware-has-infec...)
> In 2018, hostile downloaders made up 22.0% of all sideloaded PHAs, making this the third most prevalent category, as in 2017. While this category accounted for 0.39% of all sideloaded apps in 2017, it is down to 0.20% in 2018, a sharp decline. Last year, Trojans were particularly targeting devices in India, Indonesia, Russia, Brazil, and Mexico.
> The prevalence of hostile downloaders is due to a combination of legitimate third-party stores with poor security setups that distribute PHAs, fake stores that are built specifically for spreading PHAs, pre-installed apps that slipped through the security scans of OEMs, and plain apps that pretend to (or actually do) offer user-wanted features while downloading PHAs in the background.
And again, how does this affect iOS system level privacy settings and protections? App permissions and warnings don't change.
A big part of the reason why I bought an iPhone is the App Store. That’s because the App Store imposes rules on software developers, such as Facebook, which have consistently proven that they don’t particularly care about privacy, security or other user-centric concerns. If I felt like I could trust these developers, maybe I wouldn’t be on an iPhone. But they haven’t earned my trust.
It isn't, because it's tied to security.
I don't understand why a company, like Apple, shouldn't be allowed to create locked-down devices.
This practice isn't new either. Locked down game consoles have existed since the dawn of computing. What makes this situation special? Don't like it, then don't buy it.
Speaking of the situation at hand, Epic did in fact distribute Fortnite outside of Google Play. Until they eventually caved, because distribution via Google Play is more lucrative.
This isn't about your freedom, they couldn't care less. This is about them making Apple succumb to their demands, while still using the App Store as a distribution channel.
And yes, it matters what "champions" are fighting for your "freedoms". When the likes of Epic are your champion, maybe you're on the wrong side of it.
I buy some of my devices from apple because I like the hardware. The walled garden is annoying and has nothing to do with resale value. The resale value is high because of continuing updates and nice hardware - you'd factory reset everything you buy second hand anyway.
We, as consumers, should demand better behavior from trillion dollar corporations before they run our lives completely.
While techies lived in their utopia, the rest of us without the ability to compile from source were tricked into downloading spyware, profiled, and scammed from dubious "developers". These problems were known, but nothing was done about them in the name of "developer freedom".
A company comes along and offers the vast majority of people a safe computing environment at a premium. Surprise, surprise most people choose that and instead of having to trust N-developers to not do everything in their power to get a quick buck, I only have to trust 1, Apple, to do the filtering.
The problem that I'm starting to see is most people here, being developers, naturally side themselves against Apple. The alternate perspective I have is that most developers are actually user hostile and Apple is the only one that has repeatedly shown to value my dollars over abusing my data or privacy. So, no, I'm not "rooting" for Epic after the games industry and repeatedly shown they will abuse children with gambling mechanics. Why should fight for Match Group's rights at the detriment to my own?
The App Store has become a virtual Truman Show. As long as you don't look beyond its simulated reality, it's a happy place.
Developers have the perspective and ability to look behind the curtains. And what they find there is a truly miserable reality of unfair practices, deceptions, and even censorship.
The philosophical answer to the question above has long been given. In the end, a miserable reality is always preferable to a happy delusion. And it's only a matter of time until "ordinary" users will discover that harsh truth themselves.
Being a bit more unprotected is a small price in exchange to not losing your freedom.
Your miserable reality is one where:
* Nation-states have full access to location data to many Americans
* Ad companies abusing user data to push questionable products
* Moneyed interests spreading disinformation through hypertargetting.
This isn't hyperbole. Snowden already showed the length the USG was willing to go (1). Facebook is currently under fire for (2) and (3).
So yes, I'd gladly trade away my freedom in my pocket toy to ensure I retain my freedoms in my everyday life. If it's unfair that Epic has to charge a 30% markup on "v-bucks" so be it. The Developer complaints, deceptions and censorship have been so laughably elementary compared to the level abuse that Apple's wall garden prevents. It, again, shows the level blindness that utopians who can build from source have ignored.
If I cared about device freedom, there are plenty of phones on the market that provide that. However I have explicitly bought into Apple's platform in order to prevent developers from doing whatever they wish on my device.
I hope for you that we utopians won't have to rescue you one day with our ability to build from source. If enough of your kind would exist, we might all be working for the FANGS and nobody will be there for you anymore.
We all have different opinions, so we're never going to get everything in this world to adhere to the same ideals. If you don't like Apple's approach as a consumer, use Android. Some of us like that Apple locks things down very tightly and want it to remain. It's not a perfect solution, but neither is Google's approach, so it's nice that there are two very different options.
> or distribute our hard work to others without having to implement it 5 different ways.
Even if Apple allows sideloading, this problem will still exist.
As long as there's no law where if a company refuses to cancel a "recurring billing" with the same number of clicks that was done to create a recurring billing a customer can immediately collect N times the amount of subscription value from the company the likes of Epic, Match and Spotify can go and eff themselves. Customers like app store payments because the alternatives demonstrated to be swindling scum.
It sounds like you’re an App developer so perhaps it would be more honest to just explicitly state that you want to make more money rather than claim youre on the verge of tears?
It looks like they command between 33% and 46% of sales in the US per quarter. [1]
That's a lot of people. Many of them use their iPhone as their only computer.
> It sounds like you’re an App developer so perhaps it would be more honest to just explicitly state that you want to make more money
I want freedom back.
I have projects that make zero money that I want to run. I also don't want to have to have an Apple SDK license or write it in their chosen technology or be required to follow their stringent UI guidelines because my audience is niche and doesn't care about that. My time on this earth is too limited to jump through more hoops.
I also don't want to have my app deleted because I'm protesting them.
Dealing with Apple is like living under an authoritarian regime. We don't have any choice but to deal with them because of the power they wield.
[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/620805/smartphone-sales-...
I’m not sure I’m following. You are being forced to develop for Apple devices against your will?
It sounds like you’re an App developer so perhaps it would be more honest to just explicitly state that you want to make more money rather than claim your on the verge of tears?
In favor of supporting a cartel who will essentially have the same power? I don't think the OP was defending Apple, just that the antagonist is likely just as awful.
> Before they stood up the walls, I could reach all the people I wanted for free.
What are you referring to? Blogging, social networks, forums, etc.?
Now you can't distribute binaries without oversight and taxation.
Also, web browsers on mobile are much less capable than on desktop.
> Now you can't distribute binaries without oversight and taxation.
do you mean selling software?
On a slightly different note, I'm curious about how much of the change in your experience of the internet comes down to a change in its user base. I'm not sure when this happened, but I think the vast majority of internet users now consists of people who don't care about these issues at all, for better or for worse.
At that I don’t trust companies with credit cards and subscriptions - I trust apple. I get an email for every renewal, but every charge, and cancelling is easy. Other stores and companies do not do that because letting you know means less money for then.
It has been unsafe, but Android was designed with this in mind and is continually improving its security model. For instance, Android 11 added a regular check-in for permissions you have granted to apps and tightened a bunch of other loose ends like background location access.
(In general, barring unpatched security vulnerabilities, it's about as unsafe as blindly clicking things in your web browser, or believing the weird robot that calls you every day really should know your bank account number. You can try to help this using technology, but it is not a technology problem).
Apple does the same kind of work all the time, tightening sandboxes and patching vulnerabilities, but they always have the crutch of app reviews to fall back on. But it is completely wrong to believe that crutch is the thing between iOS as a reliable platform and iOS as a malware-ridden hellscape. That's what Apple wants you to think, but their developers are not actually that stupid.
For evidence on how you can build a solid, reasonably secure platform without this kind of crutch, you might consider Linux on servers, desktop MacOS, modern desktop Linux (particularly stuff like Fedora Silverblue), even modern Windows. This is not a solved problem by any means, but it's solved enough that giving up, closing the gate and throwing away the key is completely counter-productive.
Among smartphones, Android™ devices are the most commonly targeted by malware. In mobile networks, Android devices were responsible for 47.15% of the observed malware infections, Windows©/ PCs for 35.82%, IoT for 16.17% and iPhones© for less than 1%.
Nokia Threat Intelligence Report (https://onestore.nokia.com/asset/205835)
And by free I mean the amount of people who currently use for example WhatsApp, which allows us to freely communicate with others. Even my mother is using it! Ten years ago she hadn’t touched any kind of tech.
What is wrong with us?
Our computers and technology have been locked down by anti-competitive juggernauts. Our legislators have written laws that cede more of our liberties and privacy. This modern internet sucks so much and I want to go back to when it was free.
I want a world where we're free to install whatever we want on our devices or distribute our hard work to others without having to implement it 5 different ways.
I don't want to be taxed by entities worth trillions. Before they stood up the walls, I could reach all the people I wanted for free. Now they've turned us into poor serfs.
The last bastion, the web, is even under attack by the forces of embrace, extend, extinguish. Mozilla is dying, meanwhile Google is removing support for adblock, removing the URL, promoting web bundles with baked in DRM, ads, and tracking.
These rent-seeking companies took all of the goodwill and amazing technology we developed in the open and they corrupted it. They saw the amazing capabilities we built, and realized exactly how they could adopt it, take control of it, and steer the public into their arms instead.
2020 doesn't suck. Everything since 2010 sucks. And it's getting worse.