News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by rtkwe on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @09:31PM (#24574402)
More and more I think a good answer for this is something along the lines of "...a shared basic reality of facts." Especially lately in the US it seems like there's a schism in the basic understanding of what's happening with stuff like Coronavirus, effects of systematic racism past and present, climate change, etc.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by glial on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @09:38PM (#24574441)
Or at least, an agreement in the value of good faith discussion in pursuit of truth and mutual progress.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by AlexTWithBeard on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @09:55PM (#24574542)
Alas, claiming that your opponent discusses things in bad faith is often the simplest way to get the upper hand.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by watwut on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:50AM (#24576334)
There is however such thing as bad faith. Yes, the claim that opponent argues in bad faith itself can be don in bad faith.

But, when the discussion is actually in bad faith, you wont solve the issue by pretending to yourself that it was in good faith.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by adrianN on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:38AM (#24578488)
Discussing, especially online or in politics, is often not for convincing your conversation partner, but for convincing the silent readers. I feel like this objective is more easily reached if you always assume good faith arguments.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by watwut on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:28PM (#24580342)
I agree with first part but not with second. If you recognize bad faith argument and treat it as such, you can show why it is bad faith. If you don't recognize it that way, you will argue circles or leave implied lies unaddressed.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by rtkwe on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @10:42PM (#24574758)
It's easier to believe when from your understanding of the world the other side is blatantly lying and misrepresenting things. It forms a bit of a positive feedback loop where seeing bad intentions leads you to being less likely to give slack so you see more bad intentions.

From the left looking rightward at Fox News and many local stations (increasingly owned by and forced to run identical scripts from Sinclair Broadcasting) [0] at the response and the response to the response to coronavirus for example it's hard to ascribe that to just a different interpretation of facts.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QxtkvG1JnPk

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bobthechef on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @10:54PM (#24574802)
You do realize that the "other side" has the same EXACT perception of you, right?

It would be nice if people were a bit more skeptical of their preferred news outlets and opinion makers. What I see instead is the continuing existence of the same bubble that led to the shock and surprise at Trump's election. An absolute refusal or inability to consider other views, an inability to interpret events in historical context and with a healthy dose of common sense.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by rtkwe on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:52PM (#24575074)
No, of course, I never thought about the perception from the other side. Yes I know that, I believe the things I do though because I either think they're correct, they should be correct, or I hope they'll be right some day, I think I've considered and synthesized information from various sources not just one or a small few. I get that my whole world view is a conglomeration of what I was taught, when I grew up, what I've read etc. but if I didn't think I was at least partially right why would I believe it.

It's not even strictly about the news itself, the underlying philosophy that tilts the news and policy choices seems like it's missing or ignoring a piece of reality. [0] The further from my view the more alien the terrain seems and the less any of the logic makes sense because the priors are so different. Why do we keep swinging back and forth on banking regulations (or business regulation in general) when fundamentally the incentives haven't changed?

[0] Again I get that this is probably what a Conservative feels too but I don't know how to bridge the conceptual gap between the ideological poles here. I went into CS because I can reasonably understand what twiddling a given knob will do and I can control the scope of problems. I have no idea how to even start twiddling societal knobs.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by nickff on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:42AM (#24576289)
Jonathan Haidt's "The Righteous Mind" is a good start.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by throwaways885 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @08:52AM (#24578099)
> I get that my whole world view is a conglomeration of what I was taught, when I grew up, what I've read etc. but if I didn't think I was at least partially right why would I believe it.

Everyone believes this. It becomes dangerous when we start assuming these are the correct beliefs.

> I don't know how to bridge the conceptual gap between the ideological poles here.

Just talk to conservatives, in my experience they're willing to listen.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by NortySpock on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:21AM (#24578852)
And finding common ground is still easy: "It's bad/unfortunate when police kill people", "It would be good if we could feed and clothe the homeless", "It would be good if more people had access to healthcare" are statements that most people will agree with.

"What laws, mechanisms and tools do we use to achieve those goals?" and "How do we pay for it?" -- that's where you run into differing opinions.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by InitialLastName on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:21AM (#24578354)
Might I add that I've had and seen much more success talking to people outside of social media, where people of every political persuasion seem more concerned with performative outrage (makes sense, since that's what social media is designed to encourage).
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by throwaways885 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:37AM (#24578470)
oh, for sure! Humans just aren't designed to communicate in a one-to-millions paradigm, and it shows strongly in the political divide we all face.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by wolfram74 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @08:24AM (#24577889)
I don't doubt conservatives feel like liberals believe in nothing but power, and I'm sure the left has a few marks against it on that count. But I'd appreciate a few examples of them behaving in such a manner as knowingly lying about how deadly a disease is and then having large crowded in door events shortly afterwards[0]. It's easy to manufacture a narative that has the left drinking the blood of babies, but how much support is there for some large scale malicious thing?

https://www.npr.org/2020/09/09/911109247/trump-admitted-to-p...

[dead]
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by chownie on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:37AM (#24578473)
Why did you ellipse before the word "indoors"?

> The fact of the matter is, the right was more correct than the left when it comes to Covid; it's mostly a nothingburger unless you're over 70. Even the CDC says so at this point[0].

This is assuming that the only negative outcome of COVID is death, but that isn't the case.

People come out of COVID with long term health complications such as lung scarring which may affect them for the rest of their lives. We don't have good data on the rates of injury in those who recover yet.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by scottlocklin on Thursday September 24, 2020 @01:56PM (#24581416)
Yeah, you know what; the flu has long term health complications as well. Ask me how I know this: I got the flu in 2014 and still have health complications from it -probably will until I eventually drop dead. It's a bummer, but that's life. I also don't demand we shut down civilization and destroy the economic lives and mental health of hundreds of millions to prevent spread of the flu, though it would have been nice if the plague doctor sitting next to me on the airliner didn't sneeze on my eyeball.

The "long term health complications" thing is, until someone comes up with an actual count rather than terror scare stories in trash news, mostly a figment of people's lurid imaginations. Just like the early reports of world-ending infection fatality rates.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by wolfram74 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:05AM (#24578699)
To be clear, are you arguing that malfeasance in the highest elected offices in the land is excusable because the oppositions protests aren't 100% peaceful?
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bleepblorp on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:23AM (#24576817)
Conservative perceptions of their opponents have very little basis in reality as most of what conservatives perceive regarding their opponents is projection intended to deflect from their own misbehavior.

Conservative messaging is driven almost exclusively by fabricated outrage for which there is no non-conservative equivalent; non-conservative messaging is driven by outrage over actual conservative behavior.

Non-conservative media spreads outrage at factual abuses of power by conservative elites (such as the dismantling democratic norms, or police brutality) while conservative media creates outrage by giving voice to fabricated controversies created over trivialities, such as over tan suits and arugula, or by amplifying non-genuine controversies manufactured by astroturf groups.

There's no more of an equivalency between conservative and non-conservative media any more than there's an equivalency between actual public health experts and the kind of people who think injecting bleach cures COVID-19. There is such a thing as objective reality and the history of the past forty years of conservative politics is a history of conservatives abandoning objective reality in favor of delusions they find comforting.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:34AM (#24578963)
At first I downvoted you.

Then I realized that this is a stupid way to have a discussion, so here's my reply instead.

I would love to see a specific example of "conservative fabricated outrage". Not because I haven't seen any in my life, but to align our understandings of the fabricated outage.

The most recent one is probably that with a new supreme court judge nomination. Here's what I managed to find out:

- according to [1] rejecting a supreme court nominee from the opposite party is a relatively rare, but not completely outstanding event. Last time (ignoring current senate) it happened when Reagan nominated Bork in 1987.

- in "good olde times" senate minority could use filibuster to block the unacceptable nominee. This option has been eliminated by Harry Reid in 2013. All McConnell did was to keep the status quo.

- current situation is in no way unique: over the history of USA 29 times supreme court judges were nominated in election year. In case of aligned senate 17 nominations out of 19 were confirmed. In case of a misaligned senate 2 out of 10 nominations were confirmed.

- in 2016 dems have brought up some very good arguments to why having just 8 judges is problematic and why the president should nominate a judge as soon as possible (even in election year). I personally think these arguments were exceptionally reasonable and they still hold in 2020: the president should indeed nominate a judge as soon as possible

Your turn?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nominations_to_the_Sup...

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bleepblorp on Thursday September 24, 2020 @01:52PM (#24581350)
The quip I threw out regarding 'tan suits and arugula' was not random; both were outrage incidents manufactured by conservative media in relation to President Obama.

Conservatives manufactured a moral panic over how Obama was unfit for office because he wore a tan suit in public and how he was out of touch with 'real Americans' because he ate arugula.

In contrast, most non-conservatives are disgusted at Trump because of his cruelty towards others, his failure to address COVID-19, the fact that violated democratic norms to put himself in office, and the fact that he is taking steps to rig the 2020 election in his favor.

The kind of scandals that conservatives created around Obama (such as tan suits and arugula) are not equivalent to the actual scandals that surround Trump.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bb611 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @01:51PM (#24581349)
I'll leave GP to answer the outrage comments, but I think the rest reasonably calls out for perspective.

Merrick Garland wasn't just not confirmed, his nomination was ignored for 9.5 months. As you point out, it's not uncommon for opposition party senates to turn down supreme court nominees, as is their due. It is, however, extremely rare for them not to hear those nominations at all, and Garland's nomination timeline stands out for its longevity.

Out of 163 nominations, only 11 have lapsed (from your wiki link, which lists an incorrect count in the summary). Reverse chronological order of the most recent 5:

- Garland (2016): 293 days. Opposition senate.

- John Marshall Harlan II (1954): 27 days in lapsed nomination + 49 days for confirmation. Ally senate, confirmed by opposition senate.

- Pierce Butler (1922): 14 days lapsed nomination + 16 days for confirmation. Ally senate.

- William Hornblower (1893): 45 days lapsed + 41 days to reject confirmation. Ally senate.

- Stanley Matthers (1881): 36 days lapsed + 59 days to confirm. Opposition senate, confirmed by split senate.

The point being that there is essentially no historical precedent for this behavior, to the point that we need to look 135 years in the past simply to find any example of an opposition senate delaying a candidate's nomination. Even then, Garland is the supreme court nominee with the most time under nomination in US congressional history by a factor of more than 2.

> over the history of USA 29 times supreme court judges were nominated in election year

This doesn't really do justice to the history here, 1/4 of those nominations happened in a single year due to conflict between President Tyler and the Whig party, and an overlapping 1/4 were withdrawals. The last ~170 years of supreme court nominees have been pretty uninteresting and undramatic.

- Garland (2016): lapsed. Ally senate.

- Fortas (1968): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Thornberry (1968) withdrawn because the seat was no longer available, due to some musical chairs replacing Chief Justice Earl Warren. Ally Senate.

- Murphy (1940): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Cardozo (1932): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Clarke (1916): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Brandeis (1916): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Pitney (1912): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Shiras (1892): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Fuller (1888): confimed. Opposition senate.

- Woods (1880): confirmed. Opposition senate.

- Hunt (1872): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Chase (1864): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Bradford (1852): lapsed. Opposition senate.

- 7 various nominations (1844): none confirmed. Opposition senate.

- Crittenden (1828): postponed i.e. rejected. Opposition senate.

- Johnson (1804): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Ellsworth (1796): confirmed. Washington was president and rejected party politics, but the Federalists were friendly with him, so ally senate.

- Chase (1796): confirmed. Ally senate.

- Cushing (1796): confirmed. Ally senate.

I think there's plenty of evidence that Garland's nomination fight radically rocked the boat in US national politics, and we're likely to see similar boat rocking over the next few years as Democrats are pushed harder to abuse the limits of their power in order to improve their leverage on Republicans.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bleepblorp on Thursday September 24, 2020 @02:08PM (#24581571)
It's not accurate to imply that upcoming crises over USSC nominations will be the result of a Democratic power grab.

More intense fights over control of the USSC will happen because the differential population growth between the states and the rigid allocation of Senate seats means that the USSC is being filled without benefit of the democratic consent of a majority of the American population.

The fact that the USSC is being filled with judges who are hostile to the social values and economic interests of the majority compounds the problem.

Political strife over USSC nominations is not a partisan problem but rather a function of the fact that the US constitution, by design, allows the reactionary minority to dominate the majority. The constitution gives the reactionary 40% the legal right to rule the majority, but this does not mean the majority is under any obligation to meekly accept this.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday September 24, 2020 @02:24PM (#24581780)
(putting my hard hat on)

I am not sure the consent of majority or for the perceived benefit of majority is the right way to go.

What if the majority of the class votes that Jenny now must go to all school events wearing nothing but stockings and lingerie?

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bleepblorp on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:18PM (#24582435)
That's an arguable point; indeed it has been argued since at least Plato. No hard hat required as far as I'm concerned.

Excessive public representation can cause poor outcomes, (hard hat on) such as the governance problems in California caused by ballot initiatives. Letting the public write policy does not seem to lead to good outcomes in most circumstances.

However, representative democracy which combines the requirement that leaders secure consent of the governed with with normalized protections for individual rights seems to be the best system of governance humanity can come up with. Leaders, like employees, tend to do a better job if they can be fired for doing a bad job, and that is what the need for majority democratic consent provides. Protections for individual rights reduces the risk of individuals being harmed by mob rule, such as would be the case in the dress code problem in your post.

Indeed, most of the democratic world combines these principles to good effect. The US is an outlier among nominally democratic countries as it is governed without the consent of the majority.

Political systems that allow for governance without the consent of the majority allow rulers to act with impunity towards the majority and, as such have a very long history of abusing the majority. The kind of people who rise to the top of such systems tend not to be the kind of altruistic people who will govern in the interests of the public, and without any requirement for democratic consent they absolutely will not govern in the interests of the public. Indifference to majority needs, persecution, or even genocide, often follows.

Quite frankly, this is the situation the US has blundered into. Over the past few decades the US has gradually shifted from a polity where broad consent of the governed was essential into a situation where the constitutionally empowered minority (represented by the Republican party) has become increasingly abusive towards majority interests. Under Trump, the minority is now pursuing a platform specifically designed to antagonize--or even persecute--the majority. Fights over USSC nominations are just a part of this.

This isn't a good place for a country to be, especially as a large portion of the American ruling minority population is very pleased by the prospect of persecuting the majority.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by throwaways885 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @08:53AM (#24578118)
> There is such a thing as objective reality and the history of the past forty years of conservative politics is a history of conservatives abandoning objective reality in favor of delusions they find comforting.

Again, "the other side" has the exact same concerns about your tribe.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bleepblorp on Thursday September 24, 2020 @01:35PM (#24581165)
Again, just because conservatives (or anyone else) strongly believes something does not make it true.

Take the conservative position on climate change, for instance, which over the past forty years has degenerated from 'there's not enough of a consensus to act' through 'it's happening but it's not human caused' to 'the science is a Chinese conspiracy theory to destroy America.'

Also note the increasing fondness of senior Republican figures, from Trump downwards, for Q-anon and it's associated conspiracy theories. Notably, there's no Democratic Q-anon equivalent of any statute.

Finally, while in office, Trump has told upwards of 20,000 lies regarding objective facts[0]. There's no equivalent lie count for Obama, Biden, or any other prominent non-conservative in very large part because they, unlike prominent conservatives, accept that objective reality exists and see their duty as finding a way to cope with it.

[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/07/13/president...

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by jagged-chisel on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @09:44PM (#24574488)
How many times have I heard from folks claiming "conservatism" that they don't want progress, in any form-- individual, mutual, societal...
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by smegcicle on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:39PM (#24575014)
opposite extreme: "'progress'- whatever the cost"... for some reason referred to as 'woke'? (still need to work on understanding that angle)

"replacing what works with what sounds good" --T.Sowell

offtopic rant, but on the subject of politics; to me it seems underhanded to pursue experimental federal programs eg for healthcare- why not demonstrate it works in a few test states.. wouldn't california love to pass something like that? if only there were a way to pass the buck to the federal government for the homeless...

not that the 'red team' political machine hasn't been pulling on the middle as well, claiming to be 'good guys' while corrupting for their own aims; what grinds my gears is either side claiming any kind of moral highground without referencing empirical positive impact

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by flamble on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:06AM (#24575142)
There is nothing "underhanded" about it, and it's nowhere near being "experimental": almost every country in the developed world has universal healthcare and the overwhelming preponderance of evidence demonstrates its superiority in every criterion.

If you think that the debate over healthcare has anything to do with the substantive merits of one system over another, you're viewing it through the wrong lens. It is purely a power struggle between a class of potentates who have become obscenely wealthy from selling insurance, and the vast majority of the public in whose interest universal healthcare is.

Medicare for All being a success in one state would change little by just adding more evidence to the existing mountain because, again, it is not a struggle between differing points of view, but between monied interests and the masses. The colossal propaganda apparatus wielded by corporate interests would continue to wage relentless war against any expansion of such programs.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bleepblorp on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:36AM (#24576890)
I'd say the real divide over American healthcare funding reform is not between the industry and everyone else but rather between those Americans who believe government should work to improve the lives of the people and the 40% of Americans who see the role of government as preserving existing social hierarchy.

The healthcare industry does pour a lot of bribe money into preventing reform; see e.g. killing anti surprise billing legislation. However, the bulk of research into why the US doesn't have universal healthcare access points the blame at the blocking minority of Americans who'd prefer not have healthcare for themselves if the alternative is people lower on the social hierarchy (read: non-whites) having healthcare.

This is likely a far harder problem to fix than the already nearly insurmountable problem of excessive corporate influence over government policy.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by zentiggr on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:06AM (#24579289)
I'll agree with the other comment - "bulk of research ... points the blame" - if there is any credible information that does show this, I'm very curious.

My cynical short take is that the insurance/medical industry, sitting on a cash cow, will do anything to keep it being taken away. That seems to be a lot of the motivation for some people to support policies that only benefit corporations / status quo.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by cik2e on Thursday September 24, 2020 @07:25AM (#24577503)
> However, the bulk of research into why the US doesn't have universal healthcare access points the blame at the blocking minority of Americans who'd prefer not have healthcare for themselves if the alternative is people lower on the social hierarchy (read: non-whites) having healthcare.

Citation needed. This is quite an inflammatory statement to throw out there without a backing source.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:04AM (#24579269)
Public healthcare for the whole country would be great.

In absence of that, I would prefer to have public healthcare in one state, than not to have it at all.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by smegcicle on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:36AM (#24575290)
>Medicare for All being a success in one state would change little

at least it would prove to work here- it's not like the US is in the exact same position as the EU

eg, I'm not sure how they're connected, but it's obvious that the majority of medical research is being done over here, and I never see that mentioned in the comparisons between our systems and overseas; if the overpayment we're doing over here is necessary waste for that goal, that should to be made explicit! health insurance is probably taking more than their honest share of the pie, but complaints that our health care is 'too expensive' never seem to take into account that our (expensive) health care is the best in the world

am I wrong?

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by flamble on Thursday September 24, 2020 @02:06AM (#24575746)
> at least it would prove to work here- it's not like the US is in the exact same position as the EU

The EU and Japan, South Korea, Hong Kong, Bahrain, Brunei, Australia, and New Zealand. It works all over the world. Research on the US system accords with the overwhelming evidence from all around: it would work.

> eg, I'm not sure how they're connected ... medical research

Let's clarify. The repugnant gouging in the cost of hospital care, doctor's visits etc redounds mostly to the profit of private insurance who provide no social value in return. The exorbitant cost of medicine does indeed flow to pharmaceutical companies, but the particulars of how they would be affected depend on the details of how universal health care was implemented.

> complaints that our health care is 'too expensive' never seem to take into account that our (expensive) health care is the best in the world

I have no idea where you got that notion; the US is generally not ranked in the top 20.

https://www.who.int/healthinfo/paper30.pdf

https://healthcarechannel.co/how-australian-healthcare-ranks...

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by luckylion on Thursday September 24, 2020 @07:30AM (#24577523)
> The EU and Japan, South Korea, Hong Kong, Bahrain, Brunei, Australia, and New Zealand. It works all over the world.

Not necessarily at the same price though. The US healthcare system is crazy expensive because US salaries for high-skill individuals are crazy high (because tuition is crazy high?....). To fund an expansion might be more expensive.

I'm sure it's possible, but if you need more funding, you need more taxes. I'm not at all sure Americans would be okay with that. Remember that you have very low taxes compared to Europe or Japan.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bildung on Thursday September 24, 2020 @08:13AM (#24577815)
Not qualified to have an opinion on that, though of course that doesn't prevent me from a back-of-the-envelope calculation:

* A third of US healthcare cost is assumed to be administrative overhead just caused by the current system. "Cutting U.S. administrative costs to the $550 per capita (in 2017 U.S. dollars) level in Canada could save more than $600 billion, the researchers say." [0]

* Median wage level for healthcare workers (everyone directly care-related, i.e. including nurses, technicians and MDs) is $68k, about 5.5M people alltogether. [1]

* With the efficency gain of $600B one could double the headcount of medical practitioners and still be better off as a society.

[0] = https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-costs-administrati...

[1] = https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes290000.htm

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by luckylion on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:08AM (#24578233)
I'm sure there are large cost savings possible, Canada seems to spend about half as much on administration (17% vs 34%) [1]. While not quite four times as much, that'd still be significant, though whether it's guaranteed to have the same effect in the US is uncertain. Canada and the US may be neighbors, but they're quite different in culture.

[1] https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M19-2818

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by throwaways885 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @08:57AM (#24578144)
> Not necessarily at the same price though. The US healthcare system is crazy expensive because US salaries for high-skill individuals are crazy high (because tuition is crazy high?....). To fund an expansion might be more expensive.

Cut new grad salaries in return for halfing their student loan, otherwise the outrageous cost of education is being subsidised by the sick and elderly.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by nickff on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:45AM (#24576305)
But pharmaceutical companies and health insurance companies are not outrageously profitable compared to chemical manufacturers and other insurers (respectively). The biggest cost center in the health industry is human resources, and nobody seems willing to tackle that (by reducing remuneration to doctors and nurses).
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bildung on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:44AM (#24576938)
Health insurance definitely is outrageously profitable compared to other insurance sectors: https://www.statista.com/statistics/948687/health-insurance-...
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by lotsofpulp on Thursday September 24, 2020 @08:53AM (#24578124)
It’s paywalled, but based on the blurb it’s an irrelevant comparison of absolute dollars of profit from a health insurance company versus a non health insurance company selling health insurance. One would expect a grocery store to have more absolute dollars of profit from selling groceries than a gas station would.

The profit margins of a health insurance company are ~5% per the SEC filings of the largest insurance companies, which is not a large profit margin.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bildung on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:42AM (#24576919)
As a proxy of the effectiveness of the current US health care system, please have a look at the achieved life expentancy in the US vs. the other G7 countries:

https://data.oecd.org/healthstat/life-expectancy-at-birth.ht...

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by vixen99 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @07:41AM (#24577593)
Yes, the US is an outlier. One example: "In the most extreme case, we see that Americans spend more than 5-times what Chileans spend, yet the population of Chile actually lives longer than Americans".
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by jacobush on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:30AM (#24576851)
Your "peak healthcare", available to your landed gentry, is the best in the world, no doubt.

One could stop all research for decades, and the US as a whole would still be better off if what was available now was distributed evenly.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by rtkwe on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:02AM (#24575122)
> why not demonstrate it works in a few test states

It's tough to do some things at the state level because there's less money at the state level vs the federal level. It's a lot easier for a business to move from a state to avoid taxes meant to pay for healthcare by rerouting fund from the private market to the public market than it is to leave the US entirely.

The federal government gets it's taxes first from income taxes then payroll taxes, I checked a couple states and most are income then sales/use tax which is a big difference. Not being able to reroute money from employer based systems into the single payer system is a huge hole in any state level attempt at single payer. Also just having more people means a federal level system will have more bargaining power than even the largest states.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by rtkwe on Thursday September 24, 2020 @01:00AM (#24575391)
As for the etymology of woke I'm no linguist but it seems to flow pretty clearly from the idea of being awake to a problem. The particular slang is just from AAVE, not sure it's possible to trace where the different conjugation started from.

> "I been sleeping all my life. And now that Mr. Garvey done woke me up, I'm gon' stay woke. And I'm gon help him wake up other black folk."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woke

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:07AM (#24579297)
> there's less money at the state level vs the federal level

So if anything, it means to me that we need to work on increasing roles of individual states and decreasing federal powers.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by rtkwe on Friday September 25, 2020 @10:46AM (#24590333)
That's more of a question of where you come down on the idea of federalism. Personally I think way more stuff makes sense to have created and funded uniformly across the country than fragmented. The biggest budget sinks at the federal level of military and entitlement programs like social security make sense to be there. The military for obvious reasons makes more sense to have funded from there and then social security et al as well because people often move from where they were working to where they retire so trying to fund that at the state level get's a bit dicey for moving the money to where the old people actually are.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by arrosenberg on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:02AM (#24575124)
> offtopic rant, but on the subject of politics; to me it seems underhanded to pursue experimental federal programs eg for healthcare- why not demonstrate it works in a few test states.. wouldn't california love to pass something like that? if only there were a way to pass the buck to the federal government for the homeless...

Some states have scoped this out, and Vermont passed a law to pursue it. The problem has to do with financing (individual states can't print money) and the freerider problem, which isn't about the homeless, so much as more...libertarian states paying all of their diabetics to move to California to get treated.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by rtkwe on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:51AM (#24575355)
It's a bit extreme sounding but cities do this with homeless people today, some places will give out one way bus tickets to move homeless people to another city. [0]

Even without a Machiavellian "muahaha we'll ship all our sick people to X" good cheap healthcare will attract sick people to a state. It was a problem with the ACA where if enough healthy people weren't paying in [1] insurance companies could go belly up from having to cover sicker people they could previously refuse. That's why there was an individual mandate and a backstop for companies that lost too much money on plans.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/...

[1] In the case of a single state doing a single payer system it's older or simply sicker people who may make less money because of chronic debilitating illness.

[dead]
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by rtkwe on Thursday September 24, 2020 @01:54AM (#24575678)
Maybe for the sake of argument the D politicians are cynically doing it purely for the sake of holding power so we don't even have to ask what the end goal is. Then why do voters want it? There are plenty of democratic voters like me who aren't direct beneficiaries of public assistance. Why do I and others like me support expanding social safety nets?

Personally it's for me it's that I think the economy is pretty brutal and random and to make the best economic choice means treating your whole life as fungible in the service of not winding up on the streets. You're supposed to just pick up and move uprooting the whole family if your local region goes into downturn probably leaving wealth behind if you did buy a house or find time to learn a new trade while also working to not starve. Personally I'm in a fairly secure position as a knowledge worker but even those jobs are subject to the whims of the larger economy. I'd like there to be an alternative to that for myself so I want to extend that grace to people who've had a worse time of it than me.

At the core it's a lot of believing that whole you can steer yourself we live in a big economy that only cares about people as much as we force it to. I think people deserve better than to just be cogs in a machine that funnels money towards people that already have it.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by OCASM on Thursday September 24, 2020 @04:08PM (#24583008)
Because people who support these measures are all about the intentions and never care about the results. 60 years of welfare and things are worse off now than before.

We know the solution to poverty, here and everywhere else in the world, is to teach, help and allow people to generate wealth. Instead, programs like welfare only make people completely dependent (for generations) on stealing money from others to the benefit of politicians.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by screye on Thursday September 24, 2020 @08:43AM (#24578046)
"good faith assumption"

That would be my guess too

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by AlexTWithBeard on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @09:54PM (#24574538)
I don't want to sound like a nitpicker, but "basic understanding" and "facts" are two very different things: facts are facts. Their understanding has more to do with the interpretation.

And if we all agree on interpretation of the facts, then cementing the society becomes too easy of a task.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by blhack on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:05PM (#24574854)
You're in a car. The speedometer reads 50mph. How fast are you going?
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by oxygenjoe on Thursday September 24, 2020 @07:34AM (#24577549)
Too fast for the city, too slow for the highway. 50mph is a compromise that nobody wants
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by Chris2048 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:20PM (#24574921)
You're in a rocket-ship, the speedometer reads 0.5c (half-lightspeed); How fast are you going?

If you understand you'll ask "from what frame of reference?"

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:27AM (#24575240)
I wonder... If there were such a speedometer what would it use as a reference in real life? Earth? Sun? Sag A?
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by rtkwe on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:35AM (#24575284)
Most useful in space depends a lot on what you're doing at the time. Docking with small separation? Velocity relative to target. Orbiting something? speed relative to that body. Traveling between stars? Tougher but most likely relative velocity towards your target since your path is going to be relatively linear?
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by icedistilled on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:34AM (#24575279)
But you can easily answer "I'm going 0.5c from the frame of reference the speedometer uses"
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by Chris2048 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @06:47AM (#24577255)
But the point is you need to understand what speed is.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by Lammy on Thursday September 24, 2020 @04:47AM (#24576631)
"It doesn't matter, as long as enough other people agree that 50mph means the same thing."
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by klyrs on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:21PM (#24574925)
50, plus or minus a bit depending on environmental conditions, tire wear, and speedometer calibration, relative to the surface you're driving on.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by nlitened on Thursday September 24, 2020 @04:24AM (#24576523)
Not really if the car is running on a treadmill installed by a foreign government.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by klyrs on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:13PM (#24580132)
I covered that. "The surface you're driving on" in this case would be the belt of the treadmill.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by nlitened on Thursday September 24, 2020 @02:14PM (#24581653)
Ok you’re right. But you haven’t covered the case when the speedometer is lying :)
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by klyrs on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:13PM (#24582394)
"Lying" or miscalibrated? Because I did mention calibration. My speedometer is the mechanical sort, because I drive an old beater. It's incapable of complex deception. If I was paranoid, I could easily verify that the cable is connected to the gearbox appropriately, and trace it up to my instrument panel in about 20 minutes.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by tasogare on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:03PM (#24574838)
It’s especially egregious in this case with 1/3 of examples being extremely politically oriented (the so-called systemic racism). One of the big issue is when people start thinking their fantasies are reality and will distort every fact to fit in, instead of critically think that they may, in fact, be wrong.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by rtkwe on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:29AM (#24575262)
This is a fine example of what I mean. To me, from the left, there's very little room to question the existence of systematic racism. [0]

From my perspective it flows pretty cleanly from several pretty solid facts. Black people were literally property for several hundred years. Once that ended there were explicitly racist laws and actions to keep black people out of any kind of economic or political power. [1] Maybe most importantly redlining kept black people out of home loans during one of the greatest periods of wealth growth in the US during the postwar boom. Combine this with the fact that poor neighborhoods are more polluted, [2] have worse schools, poor parents have less time to devote to tutoring their kids, etc and we get a self reinforcing system.

This system shits on all poor people but history has put a thumb on the scale of who wound up starting where. Given a much longer time span this may sort itself out naturally but with the way wealth compounds in capitalism there are also countervailing forces.

[0] The definition gets muddied a lot so I'll define myself here. Systematic racism is the concept that the interlocking /system/ of the government and economy have a racially biased outcome, ie it's racist, hence systematic racism. Importantly it's not that this system is necessarily currently intentional, though personally for me, not addressing the problem does feel like you get some blame for it's continued existence.

[1] Jim Crow laws, the Tulsa Race Massacre, the Wilmington insurrection of 1898 (look this one up in particular), the list is long and quite consistent.

[2] Which studies show has deleterious effects on educational performance. Pulling one random study out: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6140474/

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:58AM (#24575385)
I think noone in their sane mind will deny that racism does exist. This is a fact and there are scientific ways to check it.

The questions are: how much does racism contributes to poverty among black people? Is it the only reason? Is it the main reason? Are there any other reasons? If these reasons are unpleasant (pick your favorite here) will we still be able to freely discuss them?

If racism is not the reason (let's imagine for a moment), how do we find it out?

If racism is the reason, then which policies are effective in fighting it and which are not? Why white-to-black unemployment ratio in conservative Alabama is the same as in progressive New Jersey? Why both New York and Texas do better?

Why? Why? Why?

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by vixen99 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @07:47AM (#24577646)
Other reasons? http://www.tsowell.com/Discrimination2.html '...challenges the very foundation of assumptions on which the prevailing “social justice” vision is based. The first two chapters of Discrimination and Disparities present a new framework of analysis, and back it up with empirical evidence from around the world, before proceeding to demonstrate why and how so much of the "social justice" vision is a house of cards.'
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by luckylion on Thursday September 24, 2020 @07:41AM (#24577595)
An issue I see with that line of thinking is that Turks in Germany are also a lot poorer than native Germans, get lower education and rely on welfare a lot more, commit more crimes etc. Yet they immigrated barely 60 years ago and were immigrating as workers, not refugees.

Turks have never been enslaved (quite the contrary, they've been slave-owners for much of their history), there were no racist laws against Turks, yet they still ended up in a very similar place.

That suggests that there might be different reasons why groups are less successful, and might suggest that it's not racism. That the results in different African American groups are very different also makes the simple narrative of "it's because of racism" hard to follow, I think.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by InitialLastName on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:19AM (#24578335)
Is it possible that different parts of the world, with different ethnic and migratory histories, might have different dynamics that lead groups to wind up in impoverished situations? Once groups of people are in poverty, yes, I would expect the issues you mention: lower educational outcomes, increased welfare reliance, and increased crime rates.

In the US, the combined demographic trend of Black, urban, and "in poverty" can be traced in substantial part to specific racist policies in the New Deal and post-WWII eras. There's more detail available, but:

a) a substantial amount of government subsidy and policy in those periods was designed to encourage people (especially young families started post-war) to move out of cities, buy land, and raise families there (through low interest rates, development subsidies, etc). This allowed the people who benefited from those policies to start building generational wealth, and essentially created the single-family self-owned non-commercially-functional lot as the fundamental unit of the suburbs.

b) The benefits of many of those policies were both openly and subtly denied to black people, all over the country. Many of the New Deal and post-WWII policies explicitly excluded black people from benefiting. Additionally, redlining (where banks had explicit policies that denied mortgages to black people) and deed covenants (where developers and communities explicitly disallowed sales to black families). This prevented those families from benefiting from the wealth injection I mentioned earlier, occurred all over the country, and was only banned in 1968.

c) After that, poverty is a pretty easy steady state to maintain for specific groups. You just need long-term, focused policing strategies, constant downward pressure on educational and municipal funding, and policies that encourage urban real estate consolidation (and thus rentership).

Where is the argument that this isn't an example of systematic racism denying black people many of the benefits available to the rest of modern American society?

The argument isn't that this was applied to all African American people, the argument is that it was applied to enough to create a correlated gap.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by luckylion on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:56AM (#24579872)
It's totally possible that it has vastly different reasons, but I find the jump to and insistence on "this is it, this must be it, and it's just different elsewhere" to be a bit hastened. It doesn't explain the strong variety in outcome and doesn't seem to apply to other regions. American Exceptionalism is well and good, but it does sound a bit wanted rather than found.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by notahacker on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:12AM (#24578278)
I don't think many Germans would argue that Turkish immigrants and their descendants have not been subject to significant degrees of racism and discrimination. It's particularly hard to claim with a straight face that the cultural similarities between between Turkish Germans and African Americans are much more obvious...
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by luckylion on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:47AM (#24579765)
> I don't think many Germans would argue that Turkish immigrants and their descendants have not been subject to significant degrees of racism and discrimination.

I'd like to see that argument, if you put it next to racism in the US. Racism towards Turks in Germany might be a slur on the school yard (which, I can assure you, was much more commonly used by Turkish kids), not slavery, Jim Crow and segregation.

> It's particularly hard to claim with a straight face that the cultural similarities between between Turkish Germans and African Americans are much more obvious...

That's not what I wrote. If racism isn't the great explanation, other explanations need to be looked at. You chose to neglect the fact that African Americans are not at all similar in the outcomes, even though they're all experiencing racism in the US, and were, by and large, always treated as a singular group.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by notahacker on Thursday September 24, 2020 @04:31PM (#24583254)
> I'd like to see that argument, if you put it next to racism in the US. Racism towards Turks in Germany might be a slur on the school yard (which, I can assure you, was much more commonly used by Turkish kids), not slavery, Jim Crow and segregation.

Sure, I haven't pretended the two countries had exactly the same social and political environments. The respective outcomes for the different minorities aren't exactly the same either.

I'm not even sure what your argument is now: you appeared to be questioning the existence of systematic racism in the US, and yet are now insisting it was extremely bad. If your claim is instead that systematic racism was extremely bad but actually had no discernible effect, that's pretty extraordinary.

Though perhaps not as extraordinary as you choosing to support that with the claim that ---checks notes--- mid twentieth century Germany is a good counter example of a society where migrants didn't encounter any adult racists. Surely you're just trolling for Godwin's Law there.

> If racism isn't the great explanation, other explanations need to be looked at. You chose to neglect the fact that African Americans are not at all similar in the outcomes, even though they're all experiencing racism in the US, and were, by and large, always treated as a singular group.

I'm not sure the fact some African Americans do better than others in any way detracts from the argument that systematic racism is a thing which negatively affects the group. Not all outcomes of shootings are the same; this is not evidence bullets cause no harm. We can look at as many complementary explanations for ethnic minority underperformance as you like, and it's not going to remotely undermine the OP's claim that racism has an effect.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by kgwxd on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:17AM (#24578818)
That would be a great answer if only there weren't a shit ton a people refusing to accept reality and recognize actual facts.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by Lammy on Thursday September 24, 2020 @06:22AM (#24577128)
I could not disagree more! I've seen this demand for One Shared Reality Of Facts from all sorts of groups who will never be able to agree on one. I've watched our attempts set many well-intentioned humans at many other well-intentioned (and otherwise) humans' (and otherwise's) throats, yelling at each other because THEY'RE WRONG when they describe personally experiencing a reality that sounds at times completely alien to mine. It seems to be a path toward fragmentation and alienation and not a path toward unity.

I do not wish to speak for anyone else here, of course, but the concepts of "true" and "false" don't really map on to my physical human dimension of reality very well at all, if I think about it! Observing something as "true" is just observing it. Maybe other peoples' thought patterns run differently? Serious question here for you all, my wonderful fellow HN readers: I don't really walk around in what I perceive as reality thinking "that's false, and that, and that over there too". Exactly the opposite! Everything I observe is true, because I observe it. I don't even think about perceiving reality at all. Everything that Is, just Is. This isn't meant to be coy or cutely condescending — I've legitimately just never thought about thinking very much before now.

My concept of the "necessary-shared-binding-force-between-things", if you will, has thus moved away from constantly bikeshedding "truth" and toward the simple observation that all things that Exist exist and all things that Don't don't, such that when another human describes experiencing our physical dimension of reality in a way different than my own, the fact that they experienced it is what's true, not the thing they're talking about when they describe the experience, since I might still completely disagree with that.

Most people have usually also gone one leap beyond "experiences" just within their own mind or some smaller slice of community before it's possible for me to hear from them, so what they will actually share are their proposed solutions to the problems they experience in reality. These suggestions are at times very distasteful to my particular (not-Truth) set of values, if you know what I mean, but still must be ignored and/or forgiven if I want to hope we live together here on Earth. I don't see any other possible alternative if I fail to scream loudly enough at all 9 billion of us until finally we all agree (with all of my suggestions, of course) and can stop arguing, all at once, forever. No solutions aside from the, uh — you know, distasteful ones.

It's been very personally meaningful to me to be able to find something I can consider "true" in common and makes it a lot easier for myself to communicate with other humans who might hold views I find abhorrent, especially when those are toward groups including myself. My views toward our physical-reality-at-large didn't change at all either — I'm the same typical Bay Area lib-left as ever. I'm not suggesting important and difficult subjects should stop being discussed, be discussed less-intensely or less-frequently, or be discussed among a smaller set of participants. I just feel that discussing them will be a hell of a lot easier once every attempt to do so doesn't begin with an existential punch-in-the-face basically telling the other person that they must be lying about the way they perceive reality.

Thinking about it a little more: isn't it kinda extremely fucking amazing that any "truth" or "falsehood" we short-lived humans throw back and forth at one another was, at some point possibly thousands or even tens of thousands of years ago, toggled from a state of non-existence into a state of Existence by a single human mind? Forgive me for torturing the metaphor a bit too hard, but that's one form of true equality I can believe in: that every human mind has the godlike ability to Create new informational "lifeforms" out of complete nothingness. These days AIs have that ability and are our equals too!

It's pretty cool to think about how the moment any new informational lifeform is shared by its creator with any any other mind (human, artificial, or otherwise) it becomes forever outside of its creator's control. You can't really kill them, but the various humans (and otherwise)[0] comprising my country's Federal government has sent many well-intention humans to die fighting wars that try to. You might be able to slow or even stop the spread, but all it takes is for one other person to find one copy of one old book, and boom, it's back[1]!! This made the Dawkins definition of "meme" make immediate and intuitive sense.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eKl6WjfDqYA

[1] You just lost The Game.

Re:The Cement of Society Is... by bobthechef on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:00PM (#24574826)
Basic understanding? How about an extremely high and unwarranted confidence in one's own understanding of what constitutes a fact. I see no signs of having ever even considered whether the categories underlying one's thought are even valid. All I see is the mindless repetition of slogans and a superficiality of understanding. Concepts are merely accepted because the comedian or talking head or my environment want me to accept them. In other words, little interest in the truth and little common sense in interpreting events and claims.
Re:The Cement of Society Is... by sleepysysadmin on Thursday September 24, 2020 @08:43AM (#24578048)
I think you're right, but I think you might not understand why. All 3 of your examples are part of a new religion that's forming right now. You may not blaspheme against these issues.

Take your systemic racism: What is white supremacy? https://www.showingupforracialjustice.org/white-supremacy-cu...

Out of curiosity, do you agree with that webpage that to be an individual or perfectionist is to be a white supremacist?

On the issue of climate change, I challenge you to be devils advocate. Go to another thread or even another site and pretend to be against climate change. You might expect that you will be told where you are wrong or have a discussion. That won't happen. You will be told how you're a trump lover who needs to die.