Re:The Cement of Society Is...
by blhack on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:05PM
(#24574854)
You're in a car. The speedometer reads 50mph. How fast are you going?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Too fast for the city, too slow for the highway. 50mph is a compromise that nobody wants
You're in a rocket-ship, the speedometer reads 0.5c (half-lightspeed); How fast are you going?
If you understand you'll ask "from what frame of reference?"
Re:The Cement of Society Is...
by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:27AM
(#24575240)
I wonder... If there were such a speedometer what would it use as a reference in real life? Earth? Sun? Sag A?
Most useful in space depends a lot on what you're doing at the time. Docking with small separation? Velocity relative to target. Orbiting something? speed relative to that body. Traveling between stars? Tougher but most likely relative velocity towards your target since your path is going to be relatively linear?
Re:The Cement of Society Is...
by icedistilled on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:34AM
(#24575279)
But you can easily answer "I'm going 0.5c from the frame of reference the speedometer uses"
But the point is you need to understand what speed is.
"It doesn't matter, as long as enough other people agree that 50mph means the same thing."
50, plus or minus a bit depending on environmental conditions, tire wear, and speedometer calibration, relative to the surface you're driving on.
Not really if the car is running on a treadmill installed by a foreign government.
I covered that. "The surface you're driving on" in this case would be the belt of the treadmill.
Ok you’re right. But you haven’t covered the case when the speedometer is lying :)
"Lying" or miscalibrated? Because I did mention calibration. My speedometer is the mechanical sort, because I drive an old beater. It's incapable of complex deception. If I was paranoid, I could easily verify that the cable is connected to the gearbox appropriately, and trace it up to my instrument panel in about 20 minutes.