News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by timcederman on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:00PM (#24508589)
Hi Ted - can you speak to Namecheap's stance on bulk spam domain registrations and the fact that Namecheap does nothing to stop it?

There has been (at least in the Bay Area) a large increase in text spam. They all have a very similar format, e.g. pretending you missed a delivery, and try to get you to click on a link, usually a .info domain.

They are all hosted on Alibaba Cloud, but they are registered in bulk via Namecheap. Your legal and abuse team says they have no obligation to prevent such registrations, but to instead take it up with the FTC or the hosting, both of which do nothing either.

Here's a recent article about the problem with bulk registrations and spam: https://www.spamhaus.org/news/article/795/weaponizing-domain...

edit: I highly recommend reading the article for more context on why bulk domain registration is problematic. Note the DOJ filed a temporary restraining order again Namecheap, and the office of the NY AG also contacted them due to their role in spam and scams.

To address some of the questions and comments below:

> A registrar is simple: request a domain, they check you match the requirement for said domain rules, take your money and register the domain for you. Very simple, very stupid, very non-opiniated.

Where do you draw the line on this? How do you feel about registering hate speech in a domain name, or someone else's trademark? Clearly there needs to be some level of regulation.

> do they have any obligation to investigate the purouse people want to use the domains for

Do domain hosts have any obligation to investigate what people are hosting? Does Google have an obligation to remove results from search? There are clearly multiple parties to hosting content on the web, and it's a shared responsibility to keep folks doing the right thing

> Are you asking Namecheap to take unilateral action against domain registrations with no due process?

No - what makes you think that's what I was asking?

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by nolok on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:02PM (#24509275)
You really, really don't want registrars to enter that game.

A registrar is simple: request a domain, they check you match the requirement for said domain rules, take your money and register the domain for you. Very simple, very stupid, very non-opiniated.

If registrars start deciding who is worthy of domains, what arbitrary set of rules they want you to follow on top of the real ones, what set of laws they act as judge for ... Things would go wrong insanely quickly.

If the price of that is that they let abusers through too then fine, they're not the justice department either way and if they apply the judicial decision once those abusers are caught, that's all we should ask from them.

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by shiftpgdn on Friday September 18, 2020 @01:30AM (#24513305)
Registrars already deal with abuse complaints (and have done so since the 90s.) GoDaddy, eNom and other large registrars are happy to suspend domains with proof of network abuse.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by ted0 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:47PM (#24509104)
Thanks for the question. I can assure you that our legal and abuse team do their very best to address bad actors. In fact, they are one of the hardest working teams in the company. We put a lot of time and due diligence into each case and do not takedown domains without sufficient evidence. We believe that taking domains down without proper cause can be a slippery slope.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by vorpalhex on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:52PM (#24509160)
I reported a spam domain to namecheap, including a police case file, full emails, and basically everything except a bank statement after my elderly parent was taken for a (several thousand dollar) scam.

Namecheap never resolved it or even responded back beyond the precanned message.

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by geocrasher on Thursday September 17, 2020 @05:20PM (#24510102)
Legal requests should go through Legal channels. You can have all the evidence you want, but do you really want the justice system involved to be administered by a registrar? No. You don't. You want it to go through the actual Justice system.

If you should be upset with anyone, it's your local police who didn't escalate the case further.

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by tommoor on Friday September 18, 2020 @12:26AM (#24513000)
I had exactly the same experience recently with Namecheap too, I guess this is why the scammers use them.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by MertsA on Friday September 18, 2020 @07:42PM (#24522966)
As a counterpoint to that a few weeks ago I reported a Bitcoin giveaway scam site to Namecheap and it was NXDOMAIN later that day.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by lopmotr on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:25PM (#24509549)
Isn't it the police's job to be seizing property from criminals to prevent crime? Not individual victims. If the police won't demand Namecheap remove it, then sorry? They don't have to. It's not like Namecheap committed the fraud any more than a carmaker robbed a bank because the robber drove away in their car.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by vorpalhex on Friday September 18, 2020 @11:15AM (#24517819)
Your local police department doesn't have any authority over namecheap. In scams, we do open a case file with them so that they can monitor problems, to create a verified paperwork trail and if issues such as stolen identity arise.

Namecheap does have a duty when they are informed with reasonable evidence to not be an accessory to a crime. Prior to being informed, Namecheap is in the clear. Once they're given clear evidence (and in my case it was blatantly obvious because it was a crappy scam) then they do have a duty to act.

It's the difference between Ford selling a car which happens to be used in a bank robbery, and Ford knowingly selling a fleet of armored vans after being told that their client is a known bank robber.

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by Aeolun on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:35PM (#24512035)
If Tesla is aware that a certain car is stolen, and they have the ability to remotely disable it, should they?

And if they’re aware that the car will be imminently used for a terrorist attack, does that change the equation?

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by yjftsjthsd-h on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:56PM (#24512505)
And if we trusted Tesla to make that determination, that would be an interesting question. But counterpoint: Do you want Tesla to remotely kill your car because someone decided to tell them that it was stolen? I can think of some "fun" ways for that to blow up...
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by manquer on Friday September 18, 2020 @02:50AM (#24513688)
Tesla can do that at government instruction. They have no business doing that if private individual asks for it even if it is world ending nuclear threat terrorist attack.

Same for namecheap. They cannot be the judge of what is spam and not. they should not be asked to gatekeep for the justice system

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by dogecoinbase on Friday September 18, 2020 @02:29AM (#24513562)
Contrariwise, should they be permitted that ability, when what it will actually be used for is someone to disable their abused partner's car?
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by gowld on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:59PM (#24509881)
Usually if someone is using your property for crime, you have an obligation to stop it.

Don't know if it applies in this particular case though. Clearly the government didn't think so.

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by geocrasher on Thursday September 17, 2020 @05:21PM (#24510111)
This is the very reason that Safe Harbor laws are in place for these industries.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by vorpalhex on Friday September 18, 2020 @11:16AM (#24517839)
Safe harbor laws only apply when you reasonably don't know or couldn't know about the illegal behavior. Once you become aware of it then safe harbor no longer applies.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by timdev2 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:17PM (#24510662)
> How do you feel about registering hate speech in a domain name, or someone else's trademark?

In the US, all kinds of speech is "awful but lawful", including hate speech. I don't think registrars should be policing legal speech.

If there's trademark infringement going on, there are legal processes to which the injured parties can avail themselves.

If there's more serious criminality afoot, law enforcement should generally lead.

I don't like the idea of unpopular but legal speech being scrubbed from the public internet because people object loudly to it. I think domain registrars (and other infrastructure vendors) are qualitatively different than social media properties, etc, in this regard.

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by timcederman on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:22PM (#24511163)
It's not a legal requirement for them (AFAIK) to make decisions on allowing someone to register a domain or not. They're a private business, so my argument is it's (probably) in their best interest to not upset their customers and partners. There are plenty of examples of limits on almost all registrars, and I was curious why they have such a hands-off stance on bulk registrations very clearly being used for illegal activities. Ted's answer gives me partial insight, but my takeaway is not enough damage, legal risk, or people complaining to say no to the money.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by thefounder on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:30PM (#24508907)
Yeah, let's make the domain registries another walled garden! Then start whining when they suspend your supid game or whatever they don't like about your website/business(i.e an abusive DMCA report)
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by PhilosAccnting on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:06PM (#24509312)
The trouble with free speech is that it hurts people who get hit by it (e.g., scams, defamation/slander/libel, intrusive advertising).

The trouble with regulating speech is that the regulators have become a type of autocratic judge presiding over the decision.

The only cure to allow regulation AND autocracy would require some level of distribution of power. We've seen councils of industry leaders before, and this may be a good chance for an enterprising NPOer (NPOneur? NPOinator?).

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by proto-n on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:11PM (#24508691)
Well, do they have any obligation to investigate the purouse people want to use the domains for?
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by Simulacra on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:17PM (#24508754)
I’m interested to hear a response to this too instead of a sales pitch.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by MiroF on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:35PM (#24508971)
I'm somewhat surprised AlibabaCloud wouldn't act on it. The others, not so much - nor do I think namecheap has an obligation to do so.
Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by toomuchtodo on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:08PM (#24508661)
Are you asking Namecheap to take unilateral action against domain registrations with no due process? As a Namecheap customer, I do not support such behavior, nor is it their mandate as a registrar.

If the problem is with mobile provider spam filtering and where the sites are hosted, that is where the abuse issue should be dealt with, with continued complaints to regulatory bodies (ie, the FTC and the FCC).

Re:Tell HN: Never search for domains on Godaddy.com by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:28PM (#24508881)
I'm getting a lot of text spam from what look like hacked cell phones. Someone in the phone industry should get off their bottoms and do something about customers sending out unusual volumes of SMS.