News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by thaumasiotes on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @03:53PM (#24496878)
It bothers me that two arguments are commonly advanced for the idea that gerrymandering is a menace:

1. It lets politicians create districts that will vote for them no matter what.

2. It lets politicians waste opposition votes by putting them into districts that will, overall, just barely vote the other way.

The problem is that these two visions of "the problem" directly oppose each other. #1 says that the problem is districts that vote an 80/20 split. #2 says the problem is districts that vote a 51/49 split.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by roywiggins on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:06PM (#24497912)
You don't need to hypothesize. Look at Wisconsin. A bunch of fairly Republican districts and a few heavily Democratic districts means that it's quite easy to produce an overwhelming R majority in the State House. The fairly R districts are not sure wins, but they don't have to be.

> Republicans won 57 percent of the vote in contested races in 2016 and won 43 of 50 seats. In 2018, Republicans won the same percentage of the vote in contested races — but won 56 of 63 seats.

> That’s how gerrymandering works. Even the fact that so many more Democratic seats are uncontested is by design: By making certain districts heavily Democratic, many others can be more easily made slightly Republican.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2018/12/04/several-l...

This stuff works, it's easy to see the effects in heavily gerrymandered states.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by ars on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @07:09PM (#24499124)
> A bunch of fairly Republican districts and a few heavily Democratic districts

Something I just realized is that it will always be that way!

Democrats do better in cities (in general heavily democratic), while Republicans do better in rural areas (typicaly Republican, but not in a dense way like a city would be).

So if you divide districts naturally by geography they will always appear gerrymandered in Republicans favor.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by sudosysgen on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:33PM (#24500230)
That's why democracies generally divide districts by population. Geography is largely irrelevant. This was actually a deliberate choice in order to skew the electoral advantage into landed men.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by ars on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:55PM (#24500345)
> That's why democracies generally divide districts by population. Geography is largely irrelevant.

That's kind of my point: No it is not. Districts are meant to be contiguous geographical areas.

Even if you adjust the geographical size of each district to have similar population sizes (which was your point), my point still stands: Because of the geographical nature of districts, cities will always have a larger Democratic percentage, and it will always look like Republicans have gerrymandered things.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by sudosysgen on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @10:34PM (#24500566)
.... Which is why most democracies have multiple districts per city.

It won't look like Republicans gerrymandered it to their advantage, because they won't have the advantage.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by jasonwatkinspdx on Thursday September 17, 2020 @12:24AM (#24501174)
The rural vs urban partisan divide is not some exogenous thing. It's only existed in the last couple of political alignments in the US, basically since FDR. It's entirely possible things realign.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by edgyquant on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:01AM (#24501668)
The rural/urban divide has existed since the birth of the US. See Jeffersonian v Hamiltonian economies.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by hamolton on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:53AM (#24501883)
Yes, but the partisan divide based on political parties historically has been far more along the North/South divide than the rural/urban divide.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by bryanrasmussen on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:31AM (#24502360)
The rural/urban divide may have existed since the birth of the U.S but the division has not aligned with the same political parties all the time, which would be anyway impossible as some parties no longer exist.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by watwut on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:22AM (#24502014)
Have you seen those maps? They quite clearly are not geographic city vs rural. Nor geographic anything, they sometimes even ressemble abstract drawings of four legged animals.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by pessimizer on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:41PM (#24497602)
I think it's because you're off on #1. If you're going to create a district that will overwhelmingly vote for one party, you want it to vote for the other side. All votes over 51% are wasted. It's called "stacking." It's complemented by "cracking," where you break up a unit that would vote for the other side and add them to multiple districts where the other side will only get 40%.

The "cracked" districts will vote for you no matter what, but certainly not at 80/20. You're looking for 51% + a safety factor of 10-20%.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by aaronblohowiak on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:11PM (#24497146)
They aren’t necessarily in opposition to each other, though. Imagine having three districts of 60/40 instead of two districts of 90/10 and one of 0/100. In this way, the party in charge has effectively erased the substantial portion of the population that would support the opposition!
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by thaumasiotes on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:37PM (#24497530)
What do you think the policy effects are in each case? In your second scenario, you have three politicians in two parties who are all basically unconstrained. In the first scenario, you have three politicians who all nominally belong to the same party, but their behavior is constrained much more sharply by the closeness of their districts.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by andrewem on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:35PM (#24497494)
The core problem is the ability to leverage approximately 50% of votes into winning far more than 50% of seats.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by rstuart4133 on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:07PM (#24499612)
I'd say the core problem goes deeper than that, and getting rid of gerrymandering only solves part of it.

Let's say you have parties representing 10%, 20%, 30% and 40% of the population respectively. Ideally, you'd like the politicians elected in the same proportions. In reality if the populations are dispersed evenly, then when you divide up the populations into seats and elect one representative from each seat you are going to end up with some mix of the 30% and 40% making up 100% of the parliament. If the distribution is perfectly even and you are using FPP then the entire parliament will all be from the 40% - which is more of a dictatorship by the 40% than a democracy.

Gerrymandering, and a "fairer" voting system like instant runoff might alter the break up of the 30% and 40%, but either way the 10% doesn't get a seat. To have any say at all they have to vote for one of the 30% or 40%. In other words you end up with a 2 party system, which is of course what we do have. Neither getting rid of gerrymandering nor using a better voting system actually solve the problem, if the problem is ensuring parliament reflects the voting population. Yet we see those two things proposed over and over again here on HN and elsewhere.

The solution is what the other posters in this sub-thread mention. Germany and NZ use it. To me, it looks to have worked very well for them. But getting there is hard as the incumbent 2 parties will combine to oppose it. The change always makes them lose seats to the minorities.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by dane-pgp on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @06:00PM (#24498504)
Which suggests that a simplistic "solution" to gerrymandering is that, after the total vote share of the best-performing party is calculated (call it V%), and their share of seats is also calculated (S%), the second-best-performing party should be able to propose a change in district winners that reduces the gap between V% and S%. (And so on for the other parties competing).

Of course that would be outrageously unfair, with politicians choosing which districts they win rather than voters choosing the politicians to represent them, and yet that is somehow an improvement over the current system of gerrymandering.

A slightly less extreme option would be for the districts that get flipped to be decided by where a given party came closest to winning (the "best near-winner" system used in Baden-Württemberg), but really the aim of this system is to remove all incentive to gerrymander in the first place, so this result flipping rule would never have to be applied.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by aaronblohowiak on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @06:57PM (#24499011)
This is how the German system works. Not unfair at all. You cast two votes: one for a person, one for a party. At the end of the day the party percentages have to roughly line up (with a minimum percent for any representative at all.) This system has some very nice balancing properties in that you can vote for the person you want to represent you in the present race as well as the party you most strongly identify with.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by dane-pgp on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @11:36PM (#24500932)
My understanding is that the German system is Mixed-Member Proportional Representation (MMP) [0] which usually involves having a list of top-up candidates who don't belong to any specific district. The Baden-Württemberg system is a clever way around this, although it does lead to some districts being represented by multiple representatives.

Having more representatives than districts seems like it would be an overly-ambitious cultural shift in the US, whereas my proposal keeps the familiar 1:1 correspondence, even if there is gerrymandering. It also doesn't change the ballot papers or counting process; and, if gerrymandering is successfully disincentivised, the process works exactly the same as under the existing system.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mixed-member_proportional_repr...

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by aaronblohowiak on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:21PM (#24507333)
yes, i dont believe i contradicted anything there, but you are right i didnt tell the whole story and thank you for spelling out some of the details. more representatives than districts would be a shift and i agree this may be a harder pill to swallow.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by willturman on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:15PM (#24497209)
These don't seem to contradict. It's entirely possible to carve up a rural area into sure-thing 60/40 districts, while carving up cities to be 55/45 while leaving a handful of 5/95 districts to the other party.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by tunesmith on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @06:09PM (#24498574)
Another way of looking at it: You have nine districts. Overall popular vote in the state is 55-44. Should the districts be awarded 5-4? Or should each have a 55-44 split?
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by kens on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:51PM (#24500317)
Gerrymandering can be much worse than that. The unpopular party could win 8 districts and leave one for the more popular party.

Math: Assume 900 people, so 495 voting for the popular party and 405 for the unpopular party. Put 100 popular voters in district 1. Split the remaining equally (395 popular, 405 unpopular). All districts except the first will be won 51%-49% by the unpopular party. (This is the "pack and crack" gerrymandering strategy, packing the party into some districts and cracking them across the other.)

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by dragonwriter on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:16PM (#24508743)
The thing about pack and crack is that if you try to do something most people think is fair (“preserving the integrity of communities of common interest”), you find that in areas with a urban core and suburban peripheries you end up naturally with pack-and-crack favoring Republicans because Democrats are often hyperconcetrated in the urban areas with Republicans holding a relatively narrow majority in the suburbs.

Of course, if you adopt something like STV in small (say ~5 seat) multimember districts, the opportunity for altering representation by how you draw district lines goes way down, and you still retain individual candidate accountability to the general electorate (unlike in party-list proportional schemes).

The problem isn't “how do you draw lines fairly in single-member, FPTP districts”. The problem is single-member, FPTP districts.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by tunesmith on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:23PM (#24511972)
We're talking about Federal districts here, not state. It'd take a constitutional amendment to alter the single-member, FPTP practice, wouldn't it? That's much, much, MUCH harder than passing a state law to change redistricting / gerrymandering practices.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by dragonwriter on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:33PM (#24512021)
> We're talking about Federal districts here, not state.

Yes.

> It'd take a constitutional amendment to alter the single-member, FPTP practice, wouldn't it.

Nope, the single-member district requirement is a federal statute that was adopted in response to states turning to, or at least considering, multimember at-large FPTP districts (majority-take-all) to prevent effectively enfranchising minorities (well, specifically blacks). Which was certainly a good motive, and single-member FPTP districts are better than that, but the same law could be retuned to prevent that but allow (or even require, in states large enough to support it) multimember districts with a candidate-centered proportional scheme like STV.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by tunesmith on Friday September 18, 2020 @05:42PM (#24522171)
Ah, thank you - I had been unable to find the details on that.

Suffice to say that it would take a federal statute to allow MMD outside of NM and Hawaii? That still seems like a heavier lift than passing state-level gerrymandering reform.

And they don't need to be set against themselves anyway - if MMD were allowed, state-level gerrymandering reform is still valuable, for those that stick with single districts.

Unless you're talking about a federal law to mandate MMD, which is even harder.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by tunesmith on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:08PM (#24508658)
I agree. I'm more just pointing out that it's non-obvious what "fair" even is.

Although I do like the standard that was suggested in the Wisconsin case, the one that Kennedy chickened out on before he retired. Sorry, I forget the details - something about minimizing wasted votes.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by p1necone on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:18AM (#24501441)
You're getting it slightly wrong/backwards. When gerrymandering you want to:

1. Create districts that will overwhelmingly vote for the other guy.

and

2. Create districts that will just barely vote for you.

Because it doesn't matter if you win a district by 1% or by 49% you can take a population that overall is 50/50, or even prefers the other guy and create a lot of districts that will vote for you by a small margin, and only a handful of districts that will vote for the other guy but by a really big margin.

There's actually an android puzzle game that does a great job of communicating how it works: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.studioBlim...

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by morei on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:16PM (#24497227)
No, they complement each other. What do you do with the 'excess' vote after creating a 51/49 district? You combine the excess from N 51/49 districts into a single district that is 20/80. That way you have N districts that fairly reliably vote for you, and a single districts that extremely reliably votes against you.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by thaumasiotes on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:34PM (#24497492)
They oppose each other. You're doing a better job the more of the vote you have in a district of type 1, and you're doing a better job the less of the vote you have in a district of type 2. Contradictions don't get any more direct than that. To the extent that a politician is benefiting himself in style #1, he's hurting himself in style #2, and vice versa.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by pessimizer on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:44PM (#24497638)
The people you're replying to aren't realizing your mistake, and you're not reading their replies. You're doing a worse job the more of your vote you have in a district of Type 1. You're creating districts of Type 1 for the other side. Every vote over 51% is a wasted vote, and there's never a reason you would shove all of your voters into one district if you were in control of districting.

> To the extent that a politician is benefiting himself in style #1

There's no possible benefit to a politician in winning a district 80/20 rather than 60/40.

edit: If 6 people want to vote for me, and 6 want to vote for you, I want to put 3 of your voters in one district, and have three more identical districts each with 2 of my voters and 1 of yours. The first district is what you're referring to as Type 1, and the other three are what you're referring to as Type 2. If you can find a more ideal districting arrangement for my party, I'd like to hear it.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by thaumasiotes on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:47PM (#24497670)
> The people you're replying to aren't realizing your mistake, and you're not reading their replies.

No, you're just not bothering to read my comment. I'll repeat it.

There are two (2) arguments commonly advanced toward the idea that gerrymandering is bad. In summary, they are:

1. Creating safe seats;

2. Nullifying opposition votes.

More of one means less of the other.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by roywiggins on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:13PM (#24498008)
Old-fashioned gerrymandering sometimes worked that way. You'd have incumbents- in both parties- try and use the gerrymander to keep their individual seats, for personal political reasons. Party bosses made sure that their own seats were uncontestable, because they had power over the process. Sometimes this would cross party lines (you, party A boss, give me a safe seat, I'll vote to give you a safe seat, we'll both be happy).

The way it works now is that you create a perfectly safe seat for the other party in exchange for many more fairly comfortable seats for your own party. The maps are not drawn up to make individual incumbents happy, but to maximize party power.

The fairly comfortable seats may still be "safe" in normal elections- they're not 100% a sure thing, but they're not particularly competitive and elections can be reliably fought and won cycle after cycle. You can't just not campaign, but the other side has one hand tied behind their backs, so as long as you have a competent campaign and no sex scandals, you're fine. Whether that's the sort of "safe seat" people are talking about I couldn't say.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by arcticfox on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:12PM (#24497993)
Can you give examples of informed people arguing that (1) is a problem? 99% of the criticism that I have seen, and what I feel, is that the issue is only (2).

The handful of ultra-secure opposition seats created by (1) are more like an unfortunate byproduct of the truly foul (2).

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by sbierwagen on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:39PM (#24498301)
Does anyone actually complain about #1? In practice, congress members in very safe districts then get primaried from the left: Ocasio-Cortez knocked out Joe Crowley in NY-14, and Pelosi is currently fighting a primary election. The people disadvantaged in a democratic district in a gerrymandered republican state are... republican voters in that district. But they own the state, so what?
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by function_seven on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:36PM (#24498262)
Well in that case, #1 is a misinformed argument. #2 is the reason districts are gerrymandered.

The party in charge of drawing the lines will—as a side effect–create some safe seats for the minority party. And in doing so, will retain control of the legislative body, by having a larger number of districts they can win.

Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard by einpoklum on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:36PM (#24498254)
They don't necessarily contradict - one could create a couple of 80/20 districts for the political boss of the region and 51/49 (or 60/40 to be safer) for the rest of the region.

Also, I've mostly heard the second argument made, not the first. A large party's leadership should probably lean in that direction anyway, not caring as much about the individual official.