Something I just realized is that it will always be that way!
Democrats do better in cities (in general heavily democratic), while Republicans do better in rural areas (typicaly Republican, but not in a dense way like a city would be).
So if you divide districts naturally by geography they will always appear gerrymandered in Republicans favor.
That's kind of my point: No it is not. Districts are meant to be contiguous geographical areas.
Even if you adjust the geographical size of each district to have similar population sizes (which was your point), my point still stands: Because of the geographical nature of districts, cities will always have a larger Democratic percentage, and it will always look like Republicans have gerrymandered things.
It won't look like Republicans gerrymandered it to their advantage, because they won't have the advantage.
> Republicans won 57 percent of the vote in contested races in 2016 and won 43 of 50 seats. In 2018, Republicans won the same percentage of the vote in contested races — but won 56 of 63 seats.
> That’s how gerrymandering works. Even the fact that so many more Democratic seats are uncontested is by design: By making certain districts heavily Democratic, many others can be more easily made slightly Republican.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2018/12/04/several-l...
This stuff works, it's easy to see the effects in heavily gerrymandered states.