Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard
by sudosysgen on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:33PM
(#24500230)
That's why democracies generally divide districts by population. Geography is largely irrelevant. This was actually a deliberate choice in order to skew the electoral advantage into landed men.
> That's why democracies generally divide districts by population. Geography is largely irrelevant.
That's kind of my point: No it is not. Districts are meant to be contiguous geographical areas.
Even if you adjust the geographical size of each district to have similar population sizes (which was your point), my point still stands: Because of the geographical nature of districts, cities will always have a larger Democratic percentage, and it will always look like Republicans have gerrymandered things.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard
by sudosysgen on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @10:34PM
(#24500566)
.... Which is why most democracies have multiple districts per city.
It won't look like Republicans gerrymandered it to their advantage, because they won't have the advantage.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard
by jasonwatkinspdx on Thursday September 17, 2020 @12:24AM
(#24501174)
The rural vs urban partisan divide is not some exogenous thing. It's only existed in the last couple of political alignments in the US, basically since FDR. It's entirely possible things realign.
The rural/urban divide has existed since the birth of the US. See Jeffersonian v Hamiltonian economies.
Yes, but the partisan divide based on political parties historically has been far more along the North/South divide than the rural/urban divide.
Re:When Math Gets Impossibly Hard
by bryanrasmussen on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:31AM
(#24502360)
The rural/urban divide may have existed since the birth of the U.S but the division has not aligned with the same political parties all the time, which would be anyway impossible as some parties no longer exist.
Something I just realized is that it will always be that way!
Democrats do better in cities (in general heavily democratic), while Republicans do better in rural areas (typicaly Republican, but not in a dense way like a city would be).
So if you divide districts naturally by geography they will always appear gerrymandered in Republicans favor.