The real safety hazard is anything that makes it harder to evacuate the plane, such as bulky clothing or eye-wear that make it harder to see in the dark or through smoke.
I particularly like the "He's doing it anyway" comment.
I imagine there are situations where they can't descend though.
On the other hand, even at 3000-4000 feet per minute, it can take a while to get from 35,000 to 10,000 ft.
If you really want nightmares about flying in that region, I recommend looking at the approach to Paro airport. 7.5k elevation, surrounded by 18k peaks, horrifying turbulences.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SbLHah4XUwk (Paro landing)
If you did try to fly an airliner down at a 45 degree angle, you would either have to do it with a falling-leaf stall after slowing to about 150kts (I doubt this is possible in an airliner?) or you would quickly break the speed of sound and the aircraft would disintegrate as the wings and stabilizers were ripped off. A max rate descent feels steep, but it's not that steep lol.
Some transport aircraft like the C-17 can deploy thrust reverses in flight to achieve those attitudes. I'm told the people riding in back don't enjoy it though.
Emergency descent maneuvers in the C-172 and I believe many other small aircraft actually involve a 45 degree roll angle, and whatever pitch angle achieves a desired speed (e.g. 120 kias in the C-172). This produces a tight downward spiral, the spiral helps because it moves lift off the vertical axis which lets you descend more quickly at a fixed speed - otherwise you'll speed up until the wings fall off. I suspect the 45 degrees above may have come from confusion over which axis it was around. I'm not sure what the exact justification is for the choice of 45 degrees but 60 degrees roll angle is usually considered sort of the upper limit (beyond that is technically aerobatics) so 45 is pretty commonly considered the "steep" extreme.
It looks like the procedure is different for the big boys. A quick google shows that the emergency descent procedure for the 747 is thrust closed, speedbrakes at flight position, gear down, make 320 kias. Pitch angle that produces would depend on weight but it's not going to be 45. No spiraling involved, but then 747 seems to (unsurprisingly) have a lower max bank angle (really max load factor) than smaller planes.
The point is you wouldn't even really pay attention to the pitch attitude, you'd pay attention to airspeed. The answer to "what should the pitch be" is pretty much always "whatever results in the airspeed you want."
And of course the landing itself (for airliners at least, that is) will be with the main gear first and only then does the nose wheel come down as well.
Once you've internalised that, you can't help but notice that one style of pictograms typically used to designate the "Arrivals" section of an airport (e.g. https://www.alamy.com/airport-signs-departure-and-arrivals-a...) alarmingly looks rather like a crash landing than a regular landing :-)
I should at least provide a little source material though: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lUUU-C-7o98 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gdn0465zE4o
Is that correct? People can obviously hold their breath for longer than that. Is it something like panic causing you not to hold your breath?
In a decompression event, the air is sucked out of your lungs. The air that remains has a low O2 partial pressure, and so oxygen can leak from your bloodstream into your lungs. As such the body's normal mechanisms for storing oxygen simply don't work.
Now, you have larger pressure differentials when scuba diving - every 10m of depth is an atmosphere of pressure - but the half atmosphere that you get from 10k vs 40k feet is probably still enough to cause some serious issues. (10k feet is ~0.69 atm, while 40k is ~0.19)
Male, 32 years, healthy, medium sporty.
Correction, sir. That's "blown out."
There is a thing where you deliberately hold your breath, which starts with taking a big lungful of air, which presumably is at normal pressure and contains 21-ish percent oxygen.
Even untrained individuals can hold their breath for a while like this.
There's another thing, which is what happens if the air you're trying to breathe either is at lower pressure, or has lower oxygen proportions. Either way, each breath has fewer oxygen molecules.
If you haven't prepared for this and try to continue breathing, you can quickly become short of breath, and then cognitive abilities become impaired, hampering your attempts to rectify the situation.
I wonder if the problem is that if cabin partially depressurizes by the time the masks drop, you may no longer be able to take a deep breath and hold it while taking your time putting on a mask.
I acknowledge that I do not have training in dealing with cabin depressurization. As luck would have it, my sister has worked for Air Canada for more than 30 years, I will ask her about it.
---
I see some other comments about the oxygen actually coming out of your blood into your lungs at low pressure, and the air coming out of your lungs because the cabin is lower pressure than your lungs.
Those make sense, and had I trained for summiting 8,000m peaks instead of tech diving, I would have known that!
Suppose you're 2000 feet down, breathing hydrox or hydreliox. It's mostly hydrogen, maybe some helium, and less than 1% oxygen. You suddenly ascend to the surface. Instead of changing gas mixture, you try to hold the gas in your lungs and maintain the pressure.
You won't hold it in. As the pressure drops in your lungs, the dissolved gases in your blood will escape into your lungs. That drops the oxygen content in your blood.
But you only have a few dozen seconds before you become an idiot incapable of helping yourself. You can survive and be conscious for minutes in this state, but its "game over", you're not going to be helping yourself put on the oxygen mask once the critical period is up.
Given the tradeoffs of the situation (ie: your neighbor will be fine for minutes, although helpless), it makes far more sense to ensure the oxygen safety of yourself before helping other people.
No it isn't.
> you can survive and be conscious for minutes in this state
No you can't.
You are not going to remain conscious for more than a few seconds at 35000 or 40000 feet. You could potentially be between 15000 to 20000 feet but there's a reason oxygen supplementation is required above 10k feet in unpressurized cabins.
> It is the period of time from the interruption of the oxygen supply or exposure to an oxygen-poor environment to the time when useful function is lost, and the individual is no longer capable of taking proper corrective and protective action.
> It is not the time to total unconsciousness
35,000 feet is 30-seconds to 1-minute of total useful consciousness, half that for rapid decompression situations.
I stand by my estimate for "Dozens of seconds before you're an idiot". Most people will remain conscious after this time is up: they just will have become such idiots that its unlikely they will ever be able to fix their Hypoxia condition. (Slurred speech, unable to dexterously control your limbs, etc. etc. You're conscious, but no longer capable of putting on a mask even if it is dangling in front of you)
Wikipedia takes the table from an FAA document: https://www.faa.gov/pilots/training/airman_education/media/A...
There's pretty much no reason to measure "time to unconsciousness", because you're incapable of helping yourself long before you're unconscious.
At 40,000 feet, time of useful consciousness is 15-20 seconds.
See https://expertaviator.com/2012/04/19/oxygen-requirements-tim...
Basically the partial pressure of oxygen is low enough at altitude that the oxygen is driven out of your blood instead of in.
There are some breathing techniques that can offset that somewhat, but only if you are prepared and trained, which is unlikely in a sudden decompression event.
If I remember correctly, commercial aircraft are pressurized at about 8,000 ft. 25,000 ft is 5.45 psi, resulting in about 5.5 psi overpressure if you are depressurized. You might have a hard time, and you can injure your lungs doing that.
The time until you pass out will depend on your oxygenation situation before the loss of pressure, general health and fitness, activity level (panicking would be a bad idea), and a bunch of other things.
Depressurization means oxygen is quickly escaping, but that doesn't mean that people will rationally take a giant breath of air and hold it. I imagine most people continue breathing normally, or more rapidly due to increased stress. Not realizing that they are sucking in less and less oxygen, and begin to lose consciousness.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_of_useful_consciousness
Most commercial flights are operating in the 30,000-39,000 range.
FlightSafety International's training materials indicate that TUC could be cut in half if the decompression is explosive.
But, for sake of argument, it assumes a few things:
1) That your lungs are healthy enough to hold your breath for >= 1 minute (not all are)
2) You actually have the opportunity to breath in a lungful of oxygen-rich air (depending on the situation/timing, this might not be the case)
3) You have your wits about you while a very stressful situation unfolds around you (let's argue that you, personally, are cool and collected under pressure - this; however, is not universally true for all other passengers)
So not only are you unable to get more oxygen, your lungs are actively sucking the remaining oxygen out of your blood.
Edit: as was pointed out in this comment a level up on this thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24495970
With a sudden event, you’d have about 15 seconds because there’s a lot to panic about.
Edit: just tried. 25s panic started, 30s my chest was trying to inhale, 36s I had to let myself breathe. This was at my desk while calm and in control.
On a plane I’d probably panic sooner and might be able to go a full minute before actually passing out.
Edit 2: I did use to freedive as a kid and am in very good shape (45 resting heart rate) so maybe that helps
On the subject at hand, the best freediver in the planet would still have zero chance in a low pressure environment.
Also, at 1ATM you have 14.7 lb/square inch in your lungs, at 30,000 feet that drops to 4.3 psi making trying to hold your breath dangerous on it’s own.
It is a huge gamble that you would or could hold your breath at the opportune moment.
With a lack of oxygen in the air, you will quickly and painlessly blackout and then die.
https://expertaviator.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/TimeOfU...
If the cabin depressurises, a little oxygen mask pops down from the top. You have a few seconds to put this on your face before you're unconscious¹, and a few minutes after that for somebody else to put it on your face before you're dead. Try doing that while inside a tent.
(I'm don't know whether this conclusion is statistically valid, considering how few non-Boeing's have been depressurising v.s. the proportion of the population with COVID-19, but it feels intuitively right, and that's how these decisions have been made lately.)
¹: read "not usefully conscious"; you might still be awake, but your brain won't be doing much thinking or hand-moving.