I’d be inclined to give them a pass if they were looking at the road and just inattentive (because that’s expected, like you say), but I find it hard to sympathize with someone watching a show on their phone, explicitly ignoring their one job.
Obviously the system should improve to make errors less likely, but that doesn't absolve anyone of guilt in my view.
in this case, the backup driver should shoulder some blame, but not the majority of it, and commensurately, should not face any of the harsh penalties associated with manslaughter.
the wet bags behind the autopilot get bored, distracted, complacent, ill or reckless due a moltitude of factors some of which outside their control
it is well known at this point the human modes of failure, and that there was basically no mitigation is a reasonability of the system designer
A better system would have spotted this person was watching their phone not the road, but it would still have held them accountable and (at minimum) fired them!
That doesn't mean that an employee being clearly negligent doesn't also need to be held accountable.
Them being held accountable is one part of a good system.
Also, many people work at really boring jobs. If serious errors happens while you watch netflix, you'll get fired, for sure.
But again, sometimes listening to music is permissable.
I don't think it's realistic to expect people to function well under those conditions.
And I think it's wrong. If my car is on cruise control, that doesn't mean I can stop worrying about my speed. You can't always just blame the company because it's the bigger entity.
Which is all to say that "the system made me do it" really doesn't fly as an excuse for felonious behavior.
for instance, in the 737 max crashes, the pilots made errors, but the principal blame lies with boeing and their egregious systemic design flaws.
That said, I don’t think this gets Uber off the hook. If I were on a jury, I’d likely say Uber was guilty of manslaughter (barring a real look at the evidence).
There is exceptional negligence on their part. The fact that vehicle was just blithely travelling the posted speed limit, even at night, even though the speed violated it's assured clear ahead ability, is a damning point. The vehicle will operate unsafely in it's default configuration.
How much slower was the car supposed to go for it's sensors and was it all the guys responsibility even if he knew Uber apparently disabled the auto-braking due to issues and didn't pause roadtests?
Yeah, and how was the driver even supposed to know how fast the car should have been driving? I know how fast I should driving because I know how far I can see, but the car had LIDAR / Radar / night vision / etc. If the speed limit is 45MPH and the car is going 45MPH, what reason did the driver have to think that the car couldn't see? Either the driver can rely on the car to "see" or they can't.
If you did and someone drowned in the mean while, there would be no debate about who was liable.
I'd probably be looking at the road all the time, but just freeze at that moment where I'd need to take over.
Probably more like "absent mindedly" pull out a phone.
This person was being paid to pay attention, which is hard enough to get right. What happens when the person owns the car, and is just commuting? And there are millions of them, not just one person?
Mayhem, if it’s a variant on this system instead of something much more sophisticated.
How about starting by simply removing their phone? Isn't that easy? The driver was looking at her phone at the time when she was supposed to be looking at the road. This is a simple violation. The phone should have been banned and the driver fired after a first violation.
I am pretty sure that while what you say might be hard to do for some people, there are individuals out there for whom sitting and looking at the road for hours would not be such a big problem. If she couldn't handle the job, she shouldn't have worked there.
Those people are known as drivers and they’re doing more than just looking at the road. The driving/feedback from the controls is keeping them engaged.
Or "sacrificial part" -- designed to break first to protect the rest of the system. The NTSB report (https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/...) is an interesting read, by the way.
"Here's your self-driving car with a 20 page EULA/ToS. Oh, but if it's in self-driving mode and something goes wrong it's not our fault, you must respond (within seconds) and fix it yourself."
Would you blame an airplane's autopilot if it crashes? We still have two pilots even though 99% of the time the thing is on autopilot.
She's a test driver, she did not pay attention, and she killed someone. At best, her employer should help and compensate her, given how it was a workplace, on-the-clock accident.
For train conductors with a similar challenge, a solution has been invented requiring them to pass various visual attention challenges that detect if they aren’t alert. Such systems weren’t present here. The system wasn’t designed to work - it was designed to protect Uber by shifting the blame for failure.