News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by jedberg on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @07:52PM (#24488053)
I mean this makes sense. She was watching a video on her phone while driving. It was her literal job to know that the car might make mistakes and correct for them, so she should have known that she still has to pay attention as though she were actually driving.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by brudgers on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:22PM (#24488266)
It makes sense because holding users personally responsible for the inadequacies of self-driving products externalizes all the risk for companies selling self-driving systems. The Uber system detected something in the road and proceeded because it did not recognize it. That's how it is designed. Otherwise the car would never go very far without stopping because the system does not recognize most things it detects.

To put it another way, the self-driving system did not alert the driver that it had detected something and did not know what it was. It wasn't an emergency, it was the car's normal operation.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by bastawhiz on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:23PM (#24488936)
The system was, by its very nature, not ready for production. That's why it had a safety driver in the first place. It's crazy to argue that the safety driver should have been alerted...the whole point they're there is to handle failures of the system, including ones where the system fails to detect an issue.

If my skydive instructor doesn't deploy the backup parachute because I, the student, didn't alert them that the primary chute failed to deploy, it's entirely their fault if we hit the ground at terminal velocity.

If a lifeguard is working at a public pool watching Netflix on their phone and a kid drowns, you can't argue that the kid should have splashed more.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by liability on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @02:19AM (#24490043)
Production? It wasn't even ready for testing on the unsuspecting public.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by bastawhiz on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @12:09PM (#24494007)
I don't disagree. But that's a separate issue. The safety driver provably did not even make a good faith attempt to perform their function. It's not possible to know whether they would have been able to avoid the tragedy that occurred, but it's a certainty that in any other universe where they were watching TV on their phone they would not have improved the outcome.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by Erlich_Bachman on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @03:06AM (#24490255)
Of course it was "inadequate system" if you consider it a full self-driving. It is inadequate in the simple fact that it was not complete. It was under development.

But how do you suppose we create FSD cars if we can't try them out before they are ready? There is just no other way to do it than vigilant drivers that watch what these cars do.

> To put it another way, the self-driving system did not alert the driver that it had detected something

Well of course not, who would expect that? If the car could positively identify the collision before it happened, it would have simply stopped, no need for a driver at all. The driver is there to prevent exactly this kinds of accidents, and this driver failed by getting our her phone and distracting herself with streaming videos instead of doing her one job. Plain and simple.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by formercoder on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:38PM (#24488373)
She wasn’t a “user”
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by derwiki on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @09:00PM (#24488503)
This was a training mission. Uber wasn't offering rides to passengers who weren't employees.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by skywhopper on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:13PM (#24488202)
As mentioned by others, I think it depends strongly on what the driver's training was. Between the overblown hype about the capabilities of self-driving cars, the state government's abdication of its regulation power, and the intentional disabling of existing safety devices on the vehicle (it's unclear if this change or the risks of the change were communicated to the driver), I would be honestly surprised if the driver believed it was actually that dangerous to allow her attention to drift.

It's one thing to charge negligent homicide with a typical car. But the near-fraudulent claims of self-driving car hucksters at the time had a lot of people believing these vehicles were already far more capable than they will be for decades to come. And it's inevitable that the Koolaid drinking in this particular program within Uber was at its strongest. So I doubt the safety drivers were adequately informed of the actual capabilities of the cars or the risks involved.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by tmsh on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @01:35AM (#24489852)
I agree. This is where torts get fun in first-year law school. If Uber's training wasn't perfectly clear about the importance of the job of monitoring outside the vehicle, then part of the liability shifts to them.

Consider two training courses:

* instructors who are gung-ho on automation being "nearly there" and encouraging people to relax in the car and let the software do its work!

* instructors who are constantly impressing upon students that they need to be vigilant.

One can see how one party is 90% liable. And the other is 10% liable, etc.

The interesting part of this case comes down to the training. In that if it was lacking, it then makes it very clear to future companies that their training needs to be more rigorous.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by Cd00d on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @12:00PM (#24493902)
Thank you for this comment and the insight. I have a follow up question: even after training, is there a liability burden to ensure the training is followed? I know no hiring process is perfect, so you're always going to end up with the occasional employee that disregards safety training. Knowing that, is there a burden on Uber to actively monitor the driver's attention and communicate to the driver when it is not sufficient? Even on an audit basis, but more ideally constant?
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by tmsh on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:56PM (#24498461)
Those are great questions. I think it comes down to negligence and whether the employer makes a good faith attempt training and monitoring throughout the process. Sometimes that's difficult in new fields and then it seems like the burden falls less on the employee (the company is taking on this risk, given the chance for new rewards).
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by cyrux004 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:23PM (#24488277)
Its literally in the name of the job title "Car safety driver"
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by xadhominemx on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:25AM (#24492461)
She was not brand new on the job, right? She knew how often intervention was required and chose to watch TV instead.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by darkerside on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:57PM (#24488485)
The fundamental attribution error suggests that the job she was asked to perform may not make any sense.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by cameldrv on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @09:21PM (#24488615)
The vehicle is designed to ultimately be a level 4 system. She effectively has the job of a test pilot of an experimental airplane. The job requires careful attention and is not easy.

There would be a different blame calculus if this were a production level 2 system like autopilot. In that case, it's not a paid test pilot, it would be the paid purchaser of a certified aircraft.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by darkerside on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:12PM (#24489207)
And yet she was probably paid like the test pilot for a beta web application. A test pilot for experimental aircraft doesn't even bring their phone in the vehicle with them.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by cameldrv on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:25PM (#24497362)
Perhaps so, but there are a lot of jobs that have high responsibility but aren't very well paid. School bus driver, for example. If you're not willing to take the responsibility, don't take the job. I do think that Uber bears significant responsibility for their employee's actions as well though. They hired a convicted felon, and assuming this wasn't the first time she was watching movies on the job, didn't effectively monitor her, even though they had video cameras inside the car.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kyleee on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @02:15AM (#24490027)
I was wondering that too, was this person making $14 an hour or $140k a year? That factors in IMO, at least in some small way
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by johnnyfaehell on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:27AM (#24490974)
But even if she wasn't watching a video, as far as I remember, there was nothing that could have been done. It was an accident that would have happened if it was a manually operated car with an alert driver, no?
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by user5994461 on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:50AM (#24492695)
>>> It was an accident that would have happened if it was a manually operated car with an alert driver, no?

No, the last articles and discussions were quite clear that this accident wouldn't have happened with a real driver. The road conditions were good, the visibility was good. A driver would have seen the woman crossing the road well enough and slow down.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by jeroenhd on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @05:53AM (#24491103)
From the footage I've seen (both the footage Uber released, which portrayed the road as much darker than it actually was, and from videos of people driving around in the same area after it happened) I can only conclude that an attentive driver would've been able to prevent the crash.

However, I don't think it's reasonable at all to expect someone to remain attentive while looking at a self-driving car. This is the same problem train drivers face, which has been mitigated with all sorts of methods, least of which a dead-man switch. Some countries let their train drivers mention every signal they come across to themselves, with Japanese train drivers even pointing at signs to ensure they're paying attention.

This was a vehicle that had been modified to reduce certain safety features (because Uber couldn't get them to work properly) with someone at the wheel expected to be 100% focused on the road while giving them nothing to do at the same time. You can only go through so many hours of sitting in a card doing nothing before you go crazy.

From a revenge-seeking perspective it's easy to blame the one person who could've stopped the car for her obvious disregard for safety (streaming video on the job), and I suppose a criminal justice case might be in order. However, I think Uber should be mainly responsible for the loss of life because their flawed design not only made the car less secure but also completely disregarded the human psychology when they designed how their human safeguard driver should do their job. Even human-operated cars will beep and yell at you if you don't pay attention while you're driving in cruise control, if such safety features were omitted in the self-driving design then clearly the driver was set up to take the fall when something bad would happen.

I strongly believe Uber only put that woman in there because local law wouldn't let them test their car without a human at the wheel, not because they wanted to ensure their car didn't kill anyone.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by dllthomas on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @11:50AM (#24493808)
> Japanese train drivers even pointing at signs to ensure they're paying attention.

I think pointing out things in the environment is a great idea for safety drivers in this kind of setting. It helps keep them engaged, possibly helps the system notice when they're distracted, and possibly provides additional useful training data.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by DevoidSimo on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @06:47AM (#24491341)
From what I remember the person that was hit was fairly visible. The video uber released was very dark however, giving that impression.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:03AM (#24491760)
Accidents do happen, but the circumstances in this case are important; she was not paying attention to the road when it happened. If the victim came out of nowhere and she could not act, the case would pan out differently.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vaccinator on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @07:57PM (#24488087)
depends what she was told by the company I guess... and if he situation was avoidable at all
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:02PM (#24488124)
It doesn't matter what she was told. She was in charge of the vehicle. She was the licensed operator. The presence of a broken ML autosteer doesn't abdicate responsibility.

This is part of the general attitude that rights and freedoms don't matter if a machine violates them. When you walk out of a store post purchase and the security alarm goes off you have zero obligation to disclose what is now your property to the loss prevention experts. But somehow it's acceptable to assume you're a criminal because a machine said so.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by user5994461 on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @10:00AM (#24492764)
>>> When you walk out of a store post purchase and the security alarm goes off you have zero obligation to disclose what is now your property to the loss prevention experts.

protip: You probably want to let them figure out what is the thing beeping while you're still in the shop. It's not great to get home only to realize that they forgot to take off the anti theft device on some of your beers.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by mindslight on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @09:42PM (#24488744)
> This is part of the general attitude that rights and freedoms don't matter if a machine violates them. When you walk out of a store post purchase and the security alarm goes off you have zero obligation to disclose what is now your property to the loss prevention experts. But somehow it's acceptable to assume you're a criminal because a machine said so.

IMO this is much more applicable to Uber's share of the responsibility for this incident.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by brokenmachine on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:15AM (#24501728)
Can you explain this further? How does that example equate to uber's responsibility?
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by rhino369 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:26PM (#24488298)
Intent matters. The state has to provide criminal negligence, which in most states requires very risky behavior.

Driving while watching a video certainly qualifies normally, but purely hypothetically, if Uber had internally said it was totally safe to drive distracted, then maybe she has a defense.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:37PM (#24488369)
> Intent matters.

Only to a crime whose required mental state is intent, which rules out crimes of negligent or recklessness (or strict liability, for that matter.)

> The state has to provide criminal negligence, which in most states requires very risky behavior.

“A motorist can be convicted of negligent homicide for causing the death of another person while driving in a criminally negligent manner. A person acts with criminal negligence by unknowingly doing or failing to do something that creates a substantial and unjustifiable risk to others. The risk must be of such nature and degree that the failure to perceive it constitutes a gross deviation from the standard of care that a reasonable person would use in like circumstances.”

https://www.drivinglaws.org/resources/arizonas-vehicular-hom...

I don't think that that's a hard fit for the publicly-reported facts of this case.

> Driving while watching a video certainly qualifies normally, but purely hypothetically, if Uber had internally said it was totally safe to drive distracted, then maybe she has a defense.

No, if “Uber” said that there is an even greater case than there already is under simple respondeat superior for the actions of the driver alone as agent of the firm for Uber to be charged with negligent homicide, manslaughter, or even 2nd degree murder.

But I don't think any representation by Uber could reduce the standard of care owed by a safety driver to members of the public to something below “not watching a video on the phone while supervising the safety of the operation of a self-driving vehicle”.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by rhino369 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @09:25PM (#24488641)
I should have said "mens rea," but it's a legal term that roughly translates to intent.

>I don't think that that's a hard fit for the publicly-reported facts of this case.

Agreed, unless (again 100% hypothetically) Uber misled the driver about the capabilities. Even then it would still require that a reasonable person would believe a (hypothetical) incorrect statement about the car's capability.

>No, if “Uber” said that there is an even greater case than there already is under simple respondeat superior for the actions of the driver alone as agent of the firm for Uber to be charged with negligent homicide, manslaughter, or even 2nd degree murder.

Not sure respondeat superior applies to criminal law. In either case, I think operating a fleet while (again 1000% hypothetically) misleading the drivers would be itself the act of criminal negligence. So I don't think you'd even need to resort to master/agent liability.

>But I don't think any representation by Uber could reduce the standard of care owed by a safety driver to members of the public to something below “not watching a video on the phone while supervising the safety of the operation of a self-driving vehicle”.

Not my area of expertise and I haven't looked at any case law on this point, but I think a believable statements made by Uber would be considered as the circumstances wrt "standard of care that a reasonable person would use in like circumstances."

If a reasonable person would believe it was safe to watch the video while driving, it wouldn't qualify as criminal negligence.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:56PM (#24488479)
The only reason why motor vehicles require licensed operation is because of their extraordinary capacity to kill people. That is why it is regarded as a privilege and not a right.

The reason why Uber had a human monitor, one required to have a valid motor vehicle license, is because of the potential lethal outcomes. You learn all of this when preparing to test for a license. It doesn't stop being one's responsibility to be a vigilant driver because it's convenient to do something else. Even considering the general stupidity levels of American drivers, ignorance of the law is no excuse.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:04AM (#24491775)
> if Uber had internally said it was totally safe to drive distracted, then maybe she has a defense.

What Uber (hypothetically might have) said is completely irrelevant; she was the driver, she is responsible.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by nafey on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:00AM (#24491742)
"licensed operator" [citation needed]

I dont even know what license beyond a driving license exists for this job. Clearly not every driving license holder is fit to hold this position.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:37AM (#24492571)
Everybody with a drivers license is supposedly qualified to operate a motor vehicle. That usually entails not killing random people.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by baddox on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:00PM (#24488107)
That is, presumably, something that the grand jury considered.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vaccinator on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:14PM (#24488210)
maybe she had an attorney chosen by Uber?
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kortilla on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:16PM (#24488225)
She can choose her own attorney.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vaccinator on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:20PM (#24488258)
but did she...maybe Uber said.. here, take this free attorney
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kayfox on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:34PM (#24488342)
Its unethical for a lawyer to do things not in their client's best interests, and even if Uber is paying for the lawyer, their client is who they are representing.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by bigiain on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:57PM (#24488486)
And _surely_ Uber would never do or encourage anything unethical.

Oh, right...

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kayfox on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:58PM (#24488493)
Ethics violations are a big deal for attorneys, if a complaint is sustained against them with the bar association, they can loose their ability to practice law.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by mindslight on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @09:46PM (#24488764)
In theory, yes. In practice an attorney has to be intelligent enough to recognize the conflict of interest, and many of them aren't.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vmception on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:07PM (#24488158)
mmm yeah with their expert witness that can make up stuff on the spot

lets just acknowledge inefficiencies in the system

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by baddox on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:44PM (#24488411)
I acknowledge inefficiencies in the system but I also suspect that grand juries usually consider the most basic relevant facts of the case.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vmception on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:32PM (#24488988)
Grand juries consider the local laws as worded and the instructions they are given by the state which can be plain wrong, it is inherently imbalanced and is a common area of review when looking at miscarriages of justice.

Also trending on HN today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24488350

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kortilla on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:15PM (#24488221)
So you’re positing that the expert witness committed perjury and that Uber secretly told the driver that it was okay for her not to pay attention to what the car was doing?
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vmception on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:34PM (#24488997)
Miscarriage of justice possible, perjury not necessarily.

I don't even know if an expert witness was there, thats how grand juries work.

And that a corporation didn't tell a full truth and threw an "maybe employee" under the bus? Not really that much to "posit".

Ironically also trending on HN at time of writing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24488350

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by brokenmachine on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:32AM (#24501788)
I thought it was very interesting that the police chief came out immediately blaming the pedestrian and saying the crash was unavoidable.

When I saw the dashcam footage, I just thought to myself, I probably would have avoided that, had I been driving.

I've watched my own dashcam footage before and people on the periphery come out less visible than in reality because the headlights blow out the video - the camera has less dynamic range than our eyes.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by jeffbee on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:13PM (#24488206)
How many Americans have been killed by distracted drivers, though? How many of those were indicted for homicide? Usually what happens when you run over someone, no matter what the circumstances, is the cops exonerate you on live television, with a statement about how "no criminality is suspected" which is suuuuuuuper weird because there's no other kind of killing you can do and get that treatment.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by pb7 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:19PM (#24488249)
How many have videos of both the victim being clearly hit and the driver being severely negligent leading up to and including the accident? How many are pedestrians that subsequently die?
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by jeffbee on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:26PM (#24488292)
Well, 20 pedestrians die on American roads every day. It's incredibly common. The cops usually don't even bother looking for evidence. This idiot live-streamed himself killing a pedestrian in San Francisco, after months of filling up his Instagram with motorized jackassery, and the cops only charged him with manslaughter, not negligent homicide.

https://hoodline.com/2020/08/driver-who-killed-pedestrian-at...

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by pb7 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:39PM (#24488382)
I did a cursory search and it seems that involuntary manslaughter and negligent homicide are the same thing in some jurisdictions but in others (most?), manslaughter ranks lesser in severity than negligent homicide. One reason I can think of that they would charge one and not the other is that it’s easier to convict due to not having to prove criminal intent, especially when the possible punishment is similar.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by renewiltord on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @01:55AM (#24489946)
Drivers getting away with killing pedestrians and cyclists is like the most common thing in the world.

As for "how many have videos": when Amelie Le Moullac was killed by a truck, the police didn't even check videos. There had to be a grassroots effort to go get the video.

You're kidding me.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by gkop on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:18PM (#24488242)
To any curious readers like me: the charge is negligent homicide (the indictment itself is linked at bottom of article)
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by jedberg on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:19PM (#24488250)
Most of the time there isn't a video of both the driver and the incident with detailed telemetry data. Also, commercial drivers are held to a higher standard.