News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vaccinator on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @07:57PM (#24488087)
depends what she was told by the company I guess... and if he situation was avoidable at all
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:02PM (#24488124)
It doesn't matter what she was told. She was in charge of the vehicle. She was the licensed operator. The presence of a broken ML autosteer doesn't abdicate responsibility.

This is part of the general attitude that rights and freedoms don't matter if a machine violates them. When you walk out of a store post purchase and the security alarm goes off you have zero obligation to disclose what is now your property to the loss prevention experts. But somehow it's acceptable to assume you're a criminal because a machine said so.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by user5994461 on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @10:00AM (#24492764)
>>> When you walk out of a store post purchase and the security alarm goes off you have zero obligation to disclose what is now your property to the loss prevention experts.

protip: You probably want to let them figure out what is the thing beeping while you're still in the shop. It's not great to get home only to realize that they forgot to take off the anti theft device on some of your beers.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by mindslight on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @09:42PM (#24488744)
> This is part of the general attitude that rights and freedoms don't matter if a machine violates them. When you walk out of a store post purchase and the security alarm goes off you have zero obligation to disclose what is now your property to the loss prevention experts. But somehow it's acceptable to assume you're a criminal because a machine said so.

IMO this is much more applicable to Uber's share of the responsibility for this incident.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by brokenmachine on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:15AM (#24501728)
Can you explain this further? How does that example equate to uber's responsibility?
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by rhino369 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:26PM (#24488298)
Intent matters. The state has to provide criminal negligence, which in most states requires very risky behavior.

Driving while watching a video certainly qualifies normally, but purely hypothetically, if Uber had internally said it was totally safe to drive distracted, then maybe she has a defense.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:37PM (#24488369)
> Intent matters.

Only to a crime whose required mental state is intent, which rules out crimes of negligent or recklessness (or strict liability, for that matter.)

> The state has to provide criminal negligence, which in most states requires very risky behavior.

“A motorist can be convicted of negligent homicide for causing the death of another person while driving in a criminally negligent manner. A person acts with criminal negligence by unknowingly doing or failing to do something that creates a substantial and unjustifiable risk to others. The risk must be of such nature and degree that the failure to perceive it constitutes a gross deviation from the standard of care that a reasonable person would use in like circumstances.”

https://www.drivinglaws.org/resources/arizonas-vehicular-hom...

I don't think that that's a hard fit for the publicly-reported facts of this case.

> Driving while watching a video certainly qualifies normally, but purely hypothetically, if Uber had internally said it was totally safe to drive distracted, then maybe she has a defense.

No, if “Uber” said that there is an even greater case than there already is under simple respondeat superior for the actions of the driver alone as agent of the firm for Uber to be charged with negligent homicide, manslaughter, or even 2nd degree murder.

But I don't think any representation by Uber could reduce the standard of care owed by a safety driver to members of the public to something below “not watching a video on the phone while supervising the safety of the operation of a self-driving vehicle”.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by rhino369 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @09:25PM (#24488641)
I should have said "mens rea," but it's a legal term that roughly translates to intent.

>I don't think that that's a hard fit for the publicly-reported facts of this case.

Agreed, unless (again 100% hypothetically) Uber misled the driver about the capabilities. Even then it would still require that a reasonable person would believe a (hypothetical) incorrect statement about the car's capability.

>No, if “Uber” said that there is an even greater case than there already is under simple respondeat superior for the actions of the driver alone as agent of the firm for Uber to be charged with negligent homicide, manslaughter, or even 2nd degree murder.

Not sure respondeat superior applies to criminal law. In either case, I think operating a fleet while (again 1000% hypothetically) misleading the drivers would be itself the act of criminal negligence. So I don't think you'd even need to resort to master/agent liability.

>But I don't think any representation by Uber could reduce the standard of care owed by a safety driver to members of the public to something below “not watching a video on the phone while supervising the safety of the operation of a self-driving vehicle”.

Not my area of expertise and I haven't looked at any case law on this point, but I think a believable statements made by Uber would be considered as the circumstances wrt "standard of care that a reasonable person would use in like circumstances."

If a reasonable person would believe it was safe to watch the video while driving, it wouldn't qualify as criminal negligence.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:56PM (#24488479)
The only reason why motor vehicles require licensed operation is because of their extraordinary capacity to kill people. That is why it is regarded as a privilege and not a right.

The reason why Uber had a human monitor, one required to have a valid motor vehicle license, is because of the potential lethal outcomes. You learn all of this when preparing to test for a license. It doesn't stop being one's responsibility to be a vigilant driver because it's convenient to do something else. Even considering the general stupidity levels of American drivers, ignorance of the law is no excuse.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:04AM (#24491775)
> if Uber had internally said it was totally safe to drive distracted, then maybe she has a defense.

What Uber (hypothetically might have) said is completely irrelevant; she was the driver, she is responsible.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by nafey on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:00AM (#24491742)
"licensed operator" [citation needed]

I dont even know what license beyond a driving license exists for this job. Clearly not every driving license holder is fit to hold this position.

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:37AM (#24492571)
Everybody with a drivers license is supposedly qualified to operate a motor vehicle. That usually entails not killing random people.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by baddox on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:00PM (#24488107)
That is, presumably, something that the grand jury considered.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vaccinator on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:14PM (#24488210)
maybe she had an attorney chosen by Uber?
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kortilla on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:16PM (#24488225)
She can choose her own attorney.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vaccinator on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:20PM (#24488258)
but did she...maybe Uber said.. here, take this free attorney
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kayfox on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:34PM (#24488342)
Its unethical for a lawyer to do things not in their client's best interests, and even if Uber is paying for the lawyer, their client is who they are representing.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by bigiain on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:57PM (#24488486)
And _surely_ Uber would never do or encourage anything unethical.

Oh, right...

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kayfox on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:58PM (#24488493)
Ethics violations are a big deal for attorneys, if a complaint is sustained against them with the bar association, they can loose their ability to practice law.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by mindslight on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @09:46PM (#24488764)
In theory, yes. In practice an attorney has to be intelligent enough to recognize the conflict of interest, and many of them aren't.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vmception on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:07PM (#24488158)
mmm yeah with their expert witness that can make up stuff on the spot

lets just acknowledge inefficiencies in the system

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by baddox on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:44PM (#24488411)
I acknowledge inefficiencies in the system but I also suspect that grand juries usually consider the most basic relevant facts of the case.
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vmception on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:32PM (#24488988)
Grand juries consider the local laws as worded and the instructions they are given by the state which can be plain wrong, it is inherently imbalanced and is a common area of review when looking at miscarriages of justice.

Also trending on HN today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24488350

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by kortilla on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:15PM (#24488221)
So you’re positing that the expert witness committed perjury and that Uber secretly told the driver that it was okay for her not to pay attention to what the car was doing?
Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by vmception on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:34PM (#24488997)
Miscarriage of justice possible, perjury not necessarily.

I don't even know if an expert witness was there, thats how grand juries work.

And that a corporation didn't tell a full truth and threw an "maybe employee" under the bus? Not really that much to "posit".

Ironically also trending on HN at time of writing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24488350

Re:Uber backup driver indicted in 2018 self-driving crash th... by brokenmachine on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:32AM (#24501788)
I thought it was very interesting that the police chief came out immediately blaming the pedestrian and saying the crash was unavoidable.

When I saw the dashcam footage, I just thought to myself, I probably would have avoided that, had I been driving.

I've watched my own dashcam footage before and people on the periphery come out less visible than in reality because the headlights blow out the video - the camera has less dynamic range than our eyes.