News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by kilroy123 on Friday September 11, 2020 @08:57AM (#24442257)
Most countries around the world do this by default.

For example, those big jugs of water that get delivered. In most places they are clean and reused. Where I'm living right now, in Turkey, those big bottles are made out of glass and it just gets replaced with a previously used glass jug.

Same with the beer, all the bottles are collected, cleaned, and reused.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by Ensorceled on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:09AM (#24442345)
Agreed. The “first world” really needs to get it’s act together on this.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by stx on Friday September 11, 2020 @10:30AM (#24443218)
The thing is we (the US) did do this at one point in time. When I was a kid you could buy a coke in a glass bottle and return it when done to be re-used by the manufacturer. For some reason we stopped. We should bring that back.

When I was in Mexico around the early 2000 they still did this. When you buy a drink you could return it for a few cents back from the vender.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by mattmanser on Friday September 11, 2020 @10:46AM (#24443379)
"We" didn't stop, it was cheaper for Coca-Cola to use plastic. Coca-Cola did it.

Stop blaming consumers for corporate choices to slightly increase profits.

Like in the UK, Tesco have just inexplicably switched from using cardboard egg containers to plastic ones. Is that my fault?

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by gambiting on Friday September 11, 2020 @10:50AM (#24443437)
The corporations only make those choices because they are allowed to(or rather, because they are not forced by the regulations to actually pay for the environmental cost of what they make). Yes, I recently noticed that with Tesco eggs, I have complained to them about it. And it's not our fault but we can definitely try to avoid these products as consumers. Telling companies why you avoid them is also a good thing to do.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by munificent on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:47PM (#24445321)
I hate this attitude that treats corporations as having zero responsibility beyond what they are legally mandated to do. Yes, it is an observable fact that corporatism and market economics incentivize corporations to behave that way. But it is an unjustified leap to turn that into a moral claim that it is ethically acceptable for that to be true.

People are incentivized to commit package theft in the US today. The odds of being caught and prosecuted are very slim, and the upside is you get free stuff. As an economic action, it is very market efficient: low barrier of entry, large number of "sellers", few cabals or controls over prices. There definitely isn't perfect information on products, but given that the cost is near-zero, that doesn't matter much. As a business, "package theft" is a great one to get into, and the market highly rewards you for doing so.

However, we correctly consider people who do so as despicable shitwads who rightfully earn our scorn and condemnation. We publicly shame them, and certainly don't want to hang out with them and count them as friends.

We should do the same with businesses that do morally harmful acts, regardless of whether the act is technically illegal or incentivized by market forces. It is certainly the business's fault when they do a shitty thing. They have fully agency in the choice of whether or not do so.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by dragonwriter on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:51PM (#24445364)
Corporations aren't natural persons and have no ethics. They are abstract creations of law and the only legitimate expectations of corporations as corporations are their responses to structural incentives including enforced legal obligations.

We can talk about the ethics of the actions of corporate decision-makers, but only while keeping in mind that structural incentives mean that decision-makers who sacrifice the narrow interests of corporate investors for ethical reasons beyond the constraints forcibly externally imposed on corporations are likely to, over time, be replaced by those who do not.

If you want corporations to act consistently with some view of ethics, you aren't going to do it sustainably by moral persuasion directed at decision-makers, but only by shifting the structural incentives.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by mattmanser on Friday September 11, 2020 @06:25PM (#24447973)
You're confusing their LEGAL status with their MORAL obligations.

Just because there's an easy way for a collective of people to absolve their moral responsibilities by getting a little certificate that says "We're a corporation" doesn't make it right. It's just a legal accident, a mummers farce, and you defending it is morally reprehensible too.

Worse still, it didn't used to be this way till some prat of an economist (probably American) starting saying so, and a bunch of people smelling easy money piled on. Companies used to care about their image, now their "care" about their shareholders (but actually their contractual bonuses and severance packages).

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by dragonwriter on Friday September 11, 2020 @06:35PM (#24448042)
> You're confusing their LEGAL status with their MORAL obligations.

No, I'm saying that considering corporations to be subjects of morality at all is pointless, and that one ought to consider what they want corporations to do to acheive moral ends, and then work to establish structures to at least incentivize that, if not actually constrain them to it.

> Just because there's an easy way for a collective of people to absolve their moral responsibilities by getting a little certificate that says "We're a corporation" doesn't make it right.

I think you start from a false premise here; that it is of no value to analyze corporations as if they were moral actors does not in any way absolve any natural persons for the immorality of any actions they undertake in or around a corporate structure.

It just removes the ability to pass blame for immorality off on to an abstraction, and focuses it on the people responsible for the abstraction (which, for creatures of law, in addition to any others includes those responsible for the law, either as lawmakers or as electors thereof.)

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by mattmanser on Friday September 11, 2020 @06:44PM (#24448093)
Why is it pointless? Corporations are simply a collective of people, working together.

There was a story on here today about the dilemma a roman consul faced because the laws were contradictory. It was fine to murder for revenge, in fact Roman law didn't get involved in revenge or murders really, but patricide was viewed as an absolute wrong, a no-no. The woman had murder her Mum in revenge as the Mum had killed her grand-children to spite her Daughter. It was a real dilemma, revenge is fine, and it was a good reason for revenge, but parricide is an absolute wrong.

Does that sound normal?

Of course not TO US.

I think that in the future, today's corporate law will be viewed just as asinine and bizarre. Corporations poisoning people by flooding chemicals into rivers or releasing gasses or toxins, murdering people with product defects they decided not recall or destroying society's common goods, but all the people involved were let free rather than incarcerated for 20 years as accessories to murder? Thousands of people colluding to murder people with cigarettes when they knew how lethal they were? Fine. Because they were "employees" and the "person" doing it was a legal figment called a corporation?

A bunch of black people in America get incarcerated for simply being friends/near the murderer, but a bunch of white people who all spent years or even decades covering up systematic mass-murder get to walk away? Man, when you actually think about it it's mind-blowing. White collar crime is so easy to get away with.

It's a convenient fabrication that makes sense only when you're inside the system.

I'm a pragmatist, it's not going to change, it's the way it is, but otoh you simply can't see the wood for the trees. You think, somehow, it's right.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by dragonwriter on Friday September 11, 2020 @07:03PM (#24448246)
> Why is it pointless? Corporations are simply a collective of people, working together.

They really are not, and the entire corporate form is structured and governed by law differently than partnerships to make them not like that.

I mean, unless you count the chartering government, it's constituents, and all the investors as part of the group, as well as all the managers and other employees. But its completely useless to talk about the collectively morality of the aggregate of such a heterogenous group of individual actors with different knowledge and constraints with regard to the actions of the corporations. It makes sense to talk about, in any given value framework, the desirability of corporate action, and the morality of any of the individual actors.

> Corporations poisoning people by flooding chemicals into rivers or releasing gasses or toxins, murdering people with product defects they decided not recall or destroying society's common goods, but all the people involved were let free rather than incarcerated for 20 years as accessories to murder?

That's the consequence of viewing the corporation as an independent moral actor, since that allows viewing the corporation as the responsible party.

> I'm a pragmatist, it's not going to change

I'm a pragmatist, and recognize that it needs to change, and that change starts with not viewing corporations as moral agents, but as tools.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by munificent on Friday September 11, 2020 @07:14PM (#24448325)
> No, I'm saying that considering corporations to be subjects of morality at all is pointless

Is it pointless to consider political parties to be subjects of morality? Is it meaningless to say "The Nazi Party is bad."? If so, what is meaningfully different between a political party, a corporation, or any other kind of organized collective activity?

> It just removes the ability to pass blame for immorality off on to an abstraction, and focuses it on the people responsible for the abstraction (which, for creatures of law, in addition to any others includes those responsible for the law, either as lawmakers or as electors thereof.)

I think I get what you're saying. We should focus on the people, not the group, because the people can be punished. But I think that's an ineffective mindset.

The entire reason individuals organize into groups is because they can do more as a group than they could have accomplished as individuals.

If we don't allow our moral code to also operate at the group level, then it will always be at a disadvantage compared to the people whose organized behavior has moral outcomes with strong economies of scale.

We should treat individuals and groups as moral actors. We should be willing to say, "this corporation as an emergent behavior of its otherwise moral individuals did a bad thing, so should thus be dissolved."

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by dragonwriter on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:05PM (#24448961)
> Is it pointless to consider political parties to be subjects of morality?

Yes, though perhaps somewhat less so (I'll address the “perhaps somewhat less so” part later.) What I said further down a sibling thread about corporations applies exactly to political parties as well: “It makes sense to talk about, in any given value framework, the desirability of corporate action, and the morality of any of the individual actors.”

> Is it meaningless to say "The Nazi Party is bad."?

No, if by “is bad” you mean “tends to produce bad outcomes”. In the general sense this is distinct from though correlated with the morality of the persons comprising the party.

> The entire reason individuals organize into groups is because they can do more as a group than they could have accomplished as individuals.

Yes, groups are tools of individuals, not moral actors. It is no more sensible to talk about their morality than it is to talk about the morality of other tools. You can talk about the morality of the people who are using the tool. In some types of groups, many actions of the group are a fairly direct reflection of a moral consensus of the members, and in the case of those actions of those groups one can refer to the morality of the group as a useful shorthand for the morality of the shared position of the membership that is behind the action. This is true of political parties generally in a simplified, idealized view, and frequently enough in a realistic view that it's not always completely pointless to talk about the morality of political parties.

It's almost never true of the complex set of stakeholders with different structural roles that are behind business corporations, especially large and/or broadly held corporations. For any given action of a particular corporation, there might be some group of it's constituents whose morality it fairly directly reflects, but even for actions for which this is the case it won't necessarily be the same group (or even a similarly situated group) from action to action.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by Ntrails on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:39AM (#24443940)
We are responsible for our parliamentary representatives, and thereby our laws. It is absolutely our fault, as a society, as consumers.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by res0nat0r on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:56AM (#24444129)
Good doc here on how the plastic industry pushed for "recycling" laws so they could look like the good guys, but much of the stuff you see the recycling logo on can't in fact be recycled.

https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/plastic-wars/

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by bostik on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:39PM (#24445247)
> Like in the UK, Tesco have just inexplicably switched from using cardboard egg containers to plastic ones. Is that my fault?

If you keep buying them, yes. Tesco's beancounters (who are legion) are certainly going to keep track of the overall cost and revenue structure. Assuming the plastic containers cost less and are sold in equal amounts, they will push forward to roll out plastic over cardboard where they can.

If they want price signals, give them price signals. Vote with your wallet.

We buy our eggs from a nearby farm. Tray of 30 is good for a week, and sometimes two. Better quality than what Tesco or Sainsbury's offers, too.

EDIT: we also return our cardboard trays to the farm shop when we buy a new batch. Reuse >> recycle.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by mattmanser on Friday September 11, 2020 @06:22PM (#24447961)
Slightly OT: I may be a bit unfair picking on Tesco as it turns out the pulp used to make egg cartons has run out because of the demand for eggs from the covid home-baking upswing, they do plan to switch back.

But only because the last time they pulled this stunt back in 2011 or so claiming it was eco-friendly to use "recyclable" plastic it blew up in their face (most of which isn't recycled) .

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by bostik on Saturday September 12, 2020 @02:24AM (#24450291)
Fair enough. Now that you mention it, I remember how during the height of the lockdown cardboard pretty much ran out. People bought more stuff online (lots of cardboard in packaging), while there was no waste paper collection to fill the demand from the supply side.

There still isn't enough waste paper collection happening, really. The communal large containers are emptied at most once a week - and they have capacity for less than two days. People have a lot more cardboard packaging to get rid of, but with collection points hitting their capacity in 1/3 of the pre-covid time, there's a constant backlog to get through.

> last time they pulled this stunt back in 2011 or so

Wasn't aware of this historical detail. Thanks.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by matthewheath on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:03PM (#24444195)
> Tesco have just inexplicably switched from using cardboard egg containers to plastic ones.

They've only switched because they've run out of the pulp used to make the cardboard egg containers. It's a temporary switch, although not ideal.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by makomk on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:29PM (#24445132)
I'm sure the disruption to UK recycling collections due to Covid can't have helped much with that.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by petre on Friday September 11, 2020 @02:44PM (#24446013)
A plastic tax would solve this. Make plastic containers at least as expensive as cardboard or aluminium cans through added taxes.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by jasonwatkinspdx on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:50AM (#24444066)
A bunch of states have bottle deposit laws. Stuff goes to recycling rather than direct reuse, but still, the concept is to use the deposit as an incentive to reduce litter and increase recycling rates.

At the end of the day, if we want companies to do more sustainable things than using single use packages that cost nearly nothing to dump in a landfill (or litter), then we need to start charging them enough to incentive sustainable behavior. And sadly few politicians want to be the person that raises prices on bottles of milk or racks of beer.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by Steltek on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:15PM (#24444329)
Personal anecdote time, I guess. My state has a bottle deposit law. I don't return anything but it still goes into recycling. We buy very few individually packaged things, I honestly can't be bothered to collect large bulky containers and bring it back to a redemption center for a lousy $5 or less.

Generally speaking, our recycling outweighs our trash and (commercial) compost put together. Mostly the bottle deposit doesn't change my recycling or purchasing behavior and it only annoys me that I'm "throwing money away". I think the biggest reason to keep it is because it's a perverted form of social welfare for homeless trash pickers who have a different tradeoff of time for money than myself.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by bobthepanda on Friday September 11, 2020 @06:03PM (#24447821)
Part of the problem is that nickel deposits were introduced in the '70s but have not been adjusted for inflation. The inflation-adjusted value of a nickel in the '70s is closer to a quarter, and if the deposit on the bottle was a quarter people would certainly feel more strongly about collecting said deposit back.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by rhacker on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:12PM (#24444295)
There's at least one company in the west (US) that still does this. Have you tried Strauss farms milk? The creamtop is absolutely delicious. There's a $2 bottle deposit which encourages the bottles to be returned. Only problem is you can only get this milk at higher end grocery stores or fancy co-ops.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by jasonwatkinspdx on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:35PM (#24444503)
Yeah, Strauss is great. Sadly it's getting harder to find their cream. Everyone seems to carry the ice cream tho.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by beenBoutIT on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:59PM (#24445464)
Strauss is great but they need to use amber glass bottles to protect their delicious milk from light.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by refurb on Friday September 11, 2020 @02:53PM (#24446097)
Moving to plastic significantly reduced the cost of transportation and the resulting CO2 emissions (but increased CO2 through production of plastic - net?).

Better to haul a trailer full of coke that 98% product and 2% plastic than one that’s 90% product and 10% glass.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by Scoundreller on Friday September 11, 2020 @03:33PM (#24446474)
You can fit more plastic-packaged product too. Still waiting for them to sell it in cubes though.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by brianwawok on Friday September 11, 2020 @10:43AM (#24443356)
The reason is money. Labor is a lot higher in the US over Mexico. Cheaper to trash and remake vs reuse. You would need a stick or carrot in the economic cost to shift behavior. Corporations are smart, they will choose the cheaper path.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by mythrwy on Friday September 11, 2020 @04:28PM (#24447000)
I was in Guatemala in the early 90's on a bus and it stopped near a stand with people selling soda.

The procedure was open the soda bottle, pour the soda into a plastic bag, put a straw in the bag and tie it. The vendor kept the bottle (presumably you could keep the bottle yourself if you paid the deposit with your soda). I kept waiting to see a bag leak or some other disaster but it seemed to mostly work. You couldn't put your soda down though. Maybe it was a scheme to encourage rapid consumption or accidental loss and sell more sodas, not sure.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by ad_hominem on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:14AM (#24443689)
Maybe the reason is because of stronger food safety laws and tort law.

If some guy used his bottle as a hammer for several months before turning it in for recycling, then someone cuts their hand on a jagged edge or drinks a glass sliver, that's a multi-million dollar lawsuit. Unlikely maybe but at Coca-Cola scale I imagine things like that will happen eventually.

These companies would have to have sophisticated QA processes, or melt down and re-cast the bottles to ensure the food safety of their supply chain against millions of chaos monkeys.

Edit: Here I just did a Google search for the butthurt downvoters that proves there is extra QA that needs to be done. From an Oregon glass bottling reuse program:[1]

> Among other attributes, the machinery features an electronic sensor that uses X-ray equipment to image each bottle, detecting flaws in the glass, as well as mold and other contaminants, Bailey said. That step will reject any bottles that are chipped or contaminated.

[1]: https://resource-recycling.com/recycling/2018/03/13/oregon-e...

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by kevin_b_er on Friday September 11, 2020 @02:25PM (#24445767)
Why should laws to protect people be deleted and laws added to protect corporations?

You base laws that protect the well being of the citizenry into a tort reform call. Protecting corporations that abuse the public does not improve the lives of the public. It just improves the profit margin.

The basis of "tort reform" is a panic assessment that lawsuits run wild and the only solution is to indemnify the rich and powerful. This lets them abuse the public even more.

Your link implies this is for liability, but it could just as easily be a filtering step so that the bottles provided are up to a certain quality standard to be readily reused.

The root problem is the bottles are cheaper to make out of disposable material. The cost burden is shifted to The People over a longer term. This is the tragedy of the commons.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by blacksmith_tb on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:44AM (#24443983)
That's quite a hypothetical - if there were a rash of lawsuits the lead up to Coke being sold in 2 liter plastic bottles, that would be indicative, but I am not aware of anything like that - and you'd expect there'd be no glass bottles of anything (beer, mustard, maple syrup) if that was the case.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by ad_hominem on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:06PM (#24444227)
> you'd expect there'd be no glass bottles of anything (beer, mustard, maple syrup) if that was the case

That's completely different - you're confusing recycling with reuse. The bottles you're referring to are made anew from glass that has been smashed into cullet and re-cast into new glass.

What the commenters above are advocating are thicker glass bottles that are washed and reused as-is, i.e. reuse.

Different QA concerns when you're manufacturing fresh glass versus collecting it from randos

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by layoutIfNeeded on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:41PM (#24444558)
Bullshit. The Club Mate I'm drinking right now came in a reused glass bottle. Some of these bottles have more wear on the outside, some of them look pristine.
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by Theodores on Friday September 11, 2020 @02:15PM (#24445658)
I know a lot of people are conditioned to not drink tap water, however, we need a world where tap water is not only clean enough to drink but also seen as the definitive clean water that you would want to drink.

I live in the UK and never buy water. All mine comes through the tap. There is no lorry delivering water for me although the water supply does have lots of big pumps and processes that mean it isn't arriving in my house by gravity alone and it does have a carbon footprint.

If you are living 50 miles out in the desert then you are going to need a lorry to fill up a big tank rather than bring lots of little glass or plastic bottles. Otherwise, tap water rules and needs to be kept clean. Drinking bought bottled water should be discouraged.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by csunbird on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:11AM (#24442362)
Exactly, we take the “reuse” and repurpose parts of three R’s very seriously in Turkey. Our flower pots are usually used empty cheese containers and all the plastic bottles are reused for containment of homemade stuff, tomato paste/olives etc...

We do not recycle although.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by conradfr on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:16AM (#24442417)
Which is not necessarily safe depending on the type of plastic (not sure how it goes in Turkey though).
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by mschuster91 on Friday September 11, 2020 @09:45AM (#24442717)
... and depending on the type of food. IIRC acidic foods should not be mixed with some plastics (and also not with aluminium foil).
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by amatecha on Friday September 11, 2020 @10:34AM (#24443264)
Huh I'd be interested to know more about the aluminum foil, since at a place I regularly get takeout from they wrap some of the items in aluminum foil (to keep it warm)...
Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by scrooched_moose on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:00AM (#24443553)
It's well established that some trace amount of aluminum leaches into your food when using foil, and it's more pronounced with acidic foods.

As far as I'm aware there's no evidence of any health effects of this (still trace) amount. The main hypothesis is aluminum may somehow be linked to Alzheimer's, and dietary aluminum may be the source of that.

The Alzheimer's Association rather definitively says there is no known link and most current evidence doesn't support this: https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/about-dementia/risk-factors-an...

Every other health effect I've seen hypothesized seems even more fringe.

Re:Pringles tube tries to wake from 'recycling nightmare' by mschuster91 on Friday September 11, 2020 @10:46AM (#24443383)
For short times it's not that problematic IMO, but for long term storage? Rather avoid it: https://www.rd.com/article/cooking-with-aluminum-foil/

Additionally, salty foods seem to be problematic too: https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/22133/why-did-...