News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BitTorrent v2 by freedomben on Monday September 07, 2020 @04:24PM (#24402478)
Because customers lose their minds with that model, largely as a result of conditioning that "internet" is an unlimited resource (which of course it is when instantaneous demand <= supply, but during high traffic periods that isn't the case).

Personally I understand the economics around it, but still don't like the idea of paying per GB. I would end up skipping some Netflix and would get mad at kids for playing Netflix to an empty room (much like I currently get mad when they leave the lights on in an empty room). It's nice on a personal level to avoid that.

Re:BitTorrent v2 by bserge on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:06PM (#24402881)
I really don't like the idea of limited bandwidth or charging per gigabyte because I know ISPs will rip people off and still not upgrade their networks to handle more traffic.

But I think it would considerably change the Internet landscape. No more listening to the same exact song multiple times on Youtube or Spotify or whatever. No more downloading then deleting the same stuff over and over again. I think about it often, what a massive waste of bandwidth, I don't even know why. It's a lot of electricity used, I guess?

Even though I've got unlimited fiber, I'm looking for some sort of local "Internet cache" solution that would store everything so it would be re-downloaded from my home instead of across the ocean. Would be great for outages, too.

Re:BitTorrent v2 by Hamuko on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:10PM (#24402912)
>It's a lot of electricity used, I guess?

Is it though? How much electricity is used to serve a 1080p Netflix movie several times vs. playing the same movie from a local storage medium?

If you asked me, I'd rather burn Bitcoin mining rigs if I wanted to get rid of electricity waste.

Re:BitTorrent v2 by bserge on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:14PM (#24402955)
Yeah, I don't know. I just think about the bandwidth we all use sometimes and it seems extremely wasteful and it bothers me for some reason. I use around ~200-300 GB/month, which I thought was a lot until I saw how much other people use :D
Re:BitTorrent v2 by Hamuko on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:17PM (#24402986)
>I use around ~200-300 GB/month

Pretty sure I use more than that in a day.

Re:BitTorrent v2 by brokenmachine on Monday September 07, 2020 @08:45PM (#24404177)
That's a lot of linux isos to download per day.

Seriously, why would you use that much data per day for? Even getting full blu-rays you wouldn't be able to watch that many.

Re:BitTorrent v2 by carlhjerpe on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @06:43AM (#24407107)
A couple years ago I participated in a private tracker and wanted to get a good ratio, I uploaded constantly at about 95Mbps

95/8 = 11.875 (Mbit to MByte)

11.875 * 3600 = 42750 (MByte/s to MByte/h)

42750 / 1000 = 42.750 (MByte/g to GByte/h)

42.750 * 24 = 1026 (GByte/h to GByte/d)

1026 / 1000 = 1.026 (GByte/d to TByte/d)

In a two month period I uploaded about 50TB according to the tracker so my calculations seem about right.

It's easy to reach these numbers in a country where net neutrality is a thing.

Re:BitTorrent v2 by withinboredom on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @04:28PM (#24425562)
I was once working on some automation stuff once. I did, in fact, download 4tb worth of (the exact same) linux ISO in a day. From my house.

Luckily it was over fiber and through a corporate VPN and I barely noticed it. But I was shocked when I saw the usage on my router later that month.

Re:BitTorrent v2 by Hamuko on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @01:11AM (#24405379)
It's more up than down.
Re:BitTorrent v2 by brokenmachine on Thursday September 10, 2020 @02:19AM (#24429439)
Bless you, good sir.
Re:BitTorrent v2 by chii on Monday September 07, 2020 @11:30PM (#24404965)
> I'd rather burn Bitcoin mining rigs

that's because you benefit from it. You're not currently paying the cost of that 1080p stream - netflix (and the ISP/peering networks) are paying. Netflix recoups the cost from your subscription, and the ISP/peering arrangement is mostly cost neutral to them (save for a small amount i presume).

But it's still not "free".

Re:BitTorrent v2 by wmf on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:13PM (#24402941)
Wait until you hear how much CPU time and RAM is being wasted...
Re:BitTorrent v2 by bserge on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:15PM (#24402961)
It's actually the reverse that bothers me in that case! I have more RAM and CPU time than I can possibly use :D

Unless that's what you meant...

Re:BitTorrent v2 by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Monday September 07, 2020 @06:58PM (#24403646)
I think what they're getting is how bloated software has become. Some websites download several megabytes of data to display a kilobyte or less of actual content.
Re:BitTorrent v2 by ohyeshedid on Monday September 07, 2020 @07:25PM (#24403786)
> I have more RAM and CPU time than I can possibly use :D

Just open another tab; problem solved. :|

Re:BitTorrent v2 by Bnshsysjab on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:47PM (#24403216)
Yeah but your hardware requirements are driven by software bloat.
Re:BitTorrent v2 by rand49an on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:43AM (#24408231)
That would probably increase the amount of storage space people would end up buying which would greatly increase the electricity demands on the end user.

I would bet this is already the most efficient way of it working.

You can setup a proxy service to cache internet requests too, but they're getting less useful due to greater use of HTTPS.

Re:BitTorrent v2 by tyfon on Monday September 07, 2020 @04:38PM (#24402623)
That kind of depends on the price pr gb.

To use the power analogy, when I was young the price of power was relatively high but in recent times it has now dropped to 0.6 NOK / kWh so even charging the car from 10-80% (~61 kWh) cost 40 NOK or $4. I do not get mad at the kids leaving the light on like my mother did to me.

I (or rather my job) currently pays about 1000 NOK/ month for unlimited 500 MBit synchronous fiber internet. I transfer maybe 500 GB/month so for it to be cheaper for me it would be under 2 NOK/GB or $.2 which sounds really high but that is what I currently pay with my usage.

Re:BitTorrent v2 by wolco on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:10PM (#24402915)
You pay for peace of mind that little Johnny doesn't download some crazy amount by accident. Now you don't have to monitor family usage so that makes things easier as well.
Re:BitTorrent v2 by em-bee on Monday September 07, 2020 @09:42PM (#24404485)
i had per gb pricing in new zealand. the key feature to address your issue was that i could set an upper limit, so, say start throttling the connection once i reach $50. that's the same that other ISPs would do anyways once i reached a certain amount of usage, but with this ISP i decided the limit and i could change it at any time.

the price was competitive too. other ISPs charged $70 per month, and had a limit of 50gb (that was 15 years ago) my ISP charged $20 as base fee and $1 per gb of usage. if i used less than 50gb, i saved money, if i used more then i could...

Re:BitTorrent v2 by efreak on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:03PM (#24422425)
It's unfortunate that cellular providers don't offer this. I get around it by setting my data connection to prefer 3g. It helps with a 500mb limit (data is expensive on cheap plans), but it'd be nice to be able to throttle apps individually (no, I do not want video ads to be downloaded, but internet connectivity is required for the app to work online. A HN client with webview, for example)
Re:BitTorrent v2 by em-bee on Thursday September 10, 2020 @01:37AM (#24429203)
years ago i came across per gb pricing but the cost was insane. it was essentially: prepay your usage or we charge you 10 times as much as the prepay would have cost you.
Re:BitTorrent v2 by em-bee on Thursday September 10, 2020 @08:22PM (#24438002)
i mean i came across gb pricing for mobile
Re:BitTorrent v2 by Dahoon on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:09PM (#24402901)
I thought internet in Norway was cheaper than in Denmark. Interesting. For comparison I pay 449 DKR/month for 1000/1000 unlimited fiber with a guaranteed bandwidth of minimum 950 (they are upgrading the network atm. hence not a guarantee on the full 1000 yet as some customers equipment is too old).

Is it a normal connection or a business connection perhaps?

Re:BitTorrent v2 by iso947 on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:47PM (#24403219)
Bandwidth to where? Do they really have 1gbit per customer peering with say level3? And with cogent, and telia? And a full non blocking internal network? And enough packet buffers to ensure that microbursts don’t saturate any link?
Re:BitTorrent v2 by ShroudedNight on Monday September 07, 2020 @09:11PM (#24404319)
Depending on the SLA, or lack thereof, they could have enough peering for a sustained +(x = 3?)σ demand spike without having a full dedicated peering for each customer, and still reasonably guarantee throughput availability.
Re:BitTorrent v2 by iso947 on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @05:08AM (#24406583)
Even ignoring peering, I’m still trying to picture the non blocking network. An Arista 7368X4 isn’t cheap, but will cope with 12,000 customers with appropriate switches downstream (128x100G ports with each port breaking out to 96 customers. Not sure how you’d scale beyond that without blocking.

Your peering will only scale to your (combined) interface speed regardless of your SLA. Our 2x 40G peer with level 3 serve far more than 40 1G devices (I personally have 600 in one building alone, and that sets aside the rest of the users), but it’s rare it’s more than 30% utilised.

Clearly that’s not going to be a domestic isp architecture, so a reasonable question is what does uncontended actually mean.

I very much doubt an isp with 10,000 customers has 10TB of peering physically available. Linx public peering is less than half that for the entire UK, and while private peering will likely increase that, the suggest is it’s welll under tenfold, so the 50 million plus internet users in the UK only use at peak times 1M each, and that ignores all the non-domestic use.

Even a 100:1 contention ratio seems enough at a core level, so any isp spending money on improving on 10:1 ratios seems that they are just burning cash.

Clearly as you go the the edge contention ratio needs to drop - but 40G, or maybe even 20G uplink for 48x1G users would be reasonable to me.

Re:BitTorrent v2 by tyfon on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @06:26AM (#24407004)
It's a normal connection (Altibox). I'm allowed to runs services and whatnot on it though I mostly use it for data analytics and downloading large datasets.
Re:BitTorrent v2 by fomine3 on Monday September 07, 2020 @09:51PM (#24404542)
> guaranteed bandwidth of minimum 950

Wow really interesting to see such high (assume Mbps) bandwidth guarantee for consumer service. Is the guarantee really work?