News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:David Graeber has died by k1m on Thursday September 03, 2020 @02:27PM (#24367091)
As this is published in the Guardian, it's fair to point out that David Graeber was very much outspoken against the Guardian in the last couple of years and refused to write for them again.

> as for the Guardian, we will never forget that during the "Labour #antisemitism controversy", they beat even the Daily Mail to include the largest percentage of false statements, pretty much every one, mysteriously, an accidental error to Labour's disadvantage - https://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/1210322505229094912

> these venues only allow people like me on to legitimate themselves; i.e., the Guardian would systematically refuse to allow me to say anything about the Corbyn antisemitism charges, but simultaneously beg me to write about trivial matters like Black Friday. I finally was forced to face up to the reality: they wanted the name of prominent intellectual lefties associated with them so their systematic attacks on the political left would be taken more seriously. We were being used. - https://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/1256291019542401024

> oh I'm definitely not writing for the Guardian again - https://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/1214619782991040512

Re:David Graeber has died by samizdis on Thursday September 03, 2020 @02:53PM (#24367391)
You might want to read this. It is short and respectful:

https://pluralistic.net/2020/09/03/rip-david-graeber/#rip-da...

Re:David Graeber has died by tacheiordache on Thursday September 03, 2020 @09:21PM (#24370837)
In think the whole antisemitism saga is nothing but a pro palestine labor party policy which bothered some key people and hence the tarnishing campaign begun. Being critical of Israel is a nono, you will eventually be punished somehow, that state had long arms
Re:David Graeber has died by maerF0x0 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:25PM (#24369063)
> refused to write for them again.

Reminds me of Christopher Hedges and his experience on the CBC

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b4XlPxvi9F4

Re:David Graeber has died by dang on Thursday September 03, 2020 @02:37PM (#24367226)
And what a classic "journalistic" cheap shot they're taking at him with that photo (https://i.guim.co.uk/img/media/9e901f036a105724595e106ace3d6...). I was going to ask if anyone could suggest a better article, but the text itself is quite good. No doubt the photo was chosen by someone other than the author.

A pity to lose him. Graeber was unusually fresh, with a talent for provoking interesting discussion, whether one agreed or not. He also got into flamewars on Hacker News: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=davidgraeber.

Re:David Graeber has died by KineticLensman on Thursday September 03, 2020 @04:21PM (#24368436)
The photographer was [name redacted]. His portfolio [0] has several posed portraits of famous people that might be considered less than flattering but which were clearly posed with their agreement. [redacted] has produced work for news sources across the political spectrum including The Telegraph (diametrically opposite from the Guardian).

It's certainly possible that the author didn't choose it but it is possible that Graeber himself didn't object.

[Edit - totally agree about the sadness of his loss]

[0] [link redacted]

Re:David Graeber has died by dang on Sunday May 23, 2021 @12:50PM (#27256477)
I've redacted some personally identifying information from the comment above. It's clear that the comment wasn't malicious; it's just that these things can have unintended side effects (e.g. when they show up in search results) and we do our best to take care of people about such things.
Re:David Graeber has died by fkangaris on Friday September 04, 2020 @06:31AM (#24373661)
I am the photographer who shot his portrait. Sorry to hear he has passed. He was a lovely and friendly man as far as I recall from the few mins I had with him many years ago. He was very keen to pull some “quirky” expressions, his own choice. Other more “flattering” ones were also taken and provided to The Guardian. There’s no stitch-up intended here and it’s a shame that’s what’s being interpreted from his expression.
Re:David Graeber has died by KineticLensman on Friday September 04, 2020 @01:24PM (#24376954)
Great reply, thanks. I personally really liked this portrait and wanted to suggest to other commentators that it was intentionally quirky and not a stitch-up
Re:David Graeber has died by fkangaris on Friday September 04, 2020 @06:41AM (#24373724)
P.S. The majority of my portraits were shot for The Guardian and The Independent. The fact that I‘ve also shot a few assignments for The Telegraph and Wall Street Journal doesn’t indicate or imply a particular political affiliation. It’s probably best to not make assumptions that a photographer or even a writer holds the same views or political stance as the publication that commissioned them.
Re:David Graeber has died by FatalLogic on Thursday September 03, 2020 @03:58PM (#24368172)
I feel that you're rushing to judgement and assuming the worst.

The article sings his praises. The photograph isn't the best, but perhaps it was an attempt to illustrate his quirky and iconoclastic nature.

I fully agree with you that this is a sad loss. Much too soon.

Re:David Graeber has died by dang on Thursday September 03, 2020 @04:10PM (#24368313)
You may be right - I'm certainly making an interpretation there.

Edit: I realized something about my priors in this case. I've long had the sense that flattering vs. unflattering photo choices are a powerful way by which newspapers (or some faction of editors within them—I don't know how newspapers work) express a pre-existing agenda.

Re:David Graeber has died by k1m on Thursday September 03, 2020 @04:27PM (#24368502)
The photo choice struck me as a cheap shot too. But I don't know who's responsible for that at the Guardian. I assumed knowing his views on the Guardian they didn't try very hard when it came to the photo.
Re:David Graeber has died by phs318u on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:59PM (#24369356)
It’s worth remembering that The Guardian, like most large organisations, is comprised of individuals who may vary quite significantly from the position of the entity overall. This article may be a reflection of that.

DISCLAIMER: I’m a subscriber.

Re:David Graeber has died by echelon on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:54PM (#24369314)
This is why it's hard to be a human.

We jump to conclusions, but we're not always unwarranted. It'd be better to live in a world where we didn't have to suspect ulterior motives.

But alas, hill climbing in an adversarial landscape while continually being preempted and distracted seems to be our lot in life. It's no wonder we're a bit grumpy.

Re:David Graeber has died by FatalLogic on Friday September 04, 2020 @07:42AM (#24374051)
>I've long had the sense that flattering vs. unflattering photo choices are a powerful way by which newspapers (or some faction of editors within them—I don't know how newspapers work) express a pre-existing agenda.

Don't always ascribe to malice that which is adequately explained by incompetence (or time pressure on deadline). But deliberately choosing unflattering photos is certainly something that happens. It may often be the choice of an individual with an ax to grind, and no oversight, not an implicit policy of the organization

Re:David Graeber has died by BitwiseFool on Thursday September 03, 2020 @04:50PM (#24368744)
I think you're probably right. If the subject's photograph is unflattering the content of the article skews negative. For example, just look at any article where the person has their mouth open and is making the 'Ch' or the 'Ooo' sound - it's always negative.
Re:David Graeber has died by jacquesm on Friday September 04, 2020 @06:26AM (#24373627)
Those things are not accidents.
Re:David Graeber has died by werber on Thursday September 03, 2020 @09:18PM (#24370817)
I personally really like the photograph, it feels like it’s in the spirit of his work. Anarchism is a bit cheeky
Re:David Graeber has died by samizdis on Saturday September 05, 2020 @07:43AM (#24382888)
> I was going to ask if anyone could suggest a better article, ...

This is more tangential than it is better, but it is a nice read:

https://newrepublic.com/article/159227/david-graeber-changed...

Re:David Graeber has died by pmiller2 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @03:06PM (#24367547)
On the contrary, I thought that photo showed him with a quizzical, skeptical look, which is something I would bet he'd appreciate were he here to do so.

Any chance we can get a black bar for him? His ideas were so interesting that I think it would be appropriate, even though he wasn't involved in the history of computing per se.

Re:David Graeber has died by Tarsul on Thursday September 03, 2020 @04:00PM (#24368209)
I agree with your take on his look in that picture. Additionally, while his views of the Guardian have soured, it's more to the left than the quotes above might suggest. E.g. this opinion piece from today: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/sep/03/left-b...
Re:David Graeber has died by k1m on Thursday September 03, 2020 @04:38PM (#24368615)
I think Graeber's point is that occasionally publishing writers like this gives the Guardian a kind of fake left cred that then makes their attacks on the left (which can be relentless, as in the case of Corbyn) much more powerful.

Below his pinned tweet on the Guardian is this tweet from him, mentioning the writer of the opinion piece you link (Aditya Chakrabortty):

> this is the "cred" they built up by publishing people like me, .@OwenJones84, .@GeorgeMonbiot, .@chakrabortty - all of whom I very much respect. They used us so no one would believe they would simply lie to destroy any chance of a left gov't. But that's exactly what they did. - https://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/1210323190402162704

I actually respect David Graeber a whole lot more than the others he mentions here because he didn't let his access to the Guardian stop him from calling them out. Going as far as to say he wouldn't write for them again.

Re:David Graeber has died by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:16PM (#24368988)
So much this. The anti-Corbyn smearing was practically Soviet in its intensity, and directly contributed to the appalling political situation the UK finds itself in now. You expect it from the right, but when it's also coming from the supposed left - in sync with obvious social media astroturfing - it's impossible not to question what's really going on.

I know a number of people who will never trust the Guardian again. Unfortunately I know more who simply believed the lies.

I'm glad Graeber said all this because he confirmed what a lot of people suspected was the case.

So an especially sad loss, as well.

Re:David Graeber has died by Brakenshire on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:56PM (#24369783)
Corbyn actually got an easy ride in many ways, notably in the 2017 election where he inexplicably was able to stand as effectively the main Remain candidate without challenge, despite his record of Eurosceptism.

All of the accusations of antisemitism were dismissed by his supporters out of hand, but some were legitimate, likely not in any personal antisemitism but in a willingness to turn a blind eye to antisemitism in ideological allies.

David Graeber seems an impressive guy, but that doesn’t mean he’s right in everything.

Re:David Graeber has died by simoom22 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @09:55PM (#24371001)
I just watched a video where Graeber points out that Boris Johnson himself wrote a novel promoting anti-Semitic conspiracy theories, but not a single article was written about Tory anti-Semitism in prominent papers during the height of that controversy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6oOj7BzciA
Re:David Graeber has died by fao_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @11:05PM (#24371322)
Corbyn got invited to a Jewdas passover party - it's in literally no dispute that he was against anti-semitism. Labour's systematic problems were under investigation at the time and it was fair of him to not say anything until that investigation completed, however that itself was turned by the press into being viewed as an avoidant strategy, rather than an act of prudence. And as far as anti-semitism goes, the Tories have a much longer and much deeper history of islamaphobia. But at no point did it recieve the same 24/7 press attention, even though many of the incidents were happening concurrently. It was generally only ever mentioned as a sidenote to the Labour anti-semitism scandal. Hell, for a practical sample, just look at this article by the bbc[1], chosen at random (keywords: tory party islamaphobia general election), it is about Tory islamaphobia but the majority of the content present, per paragraph, is devoted to the anti-semitism accusations against Labour.

Even at the end of the year, the Tory party had failed to address it in any meaningful sense[2]

In no way did he get an easy ride. Every single tabloid and media outlet was, on the whole, against him from the start. There was a London School of Economics study a number of years back, showing definively that press coverage of Corbyn was nowhere near balanced[3]. That's not even to take into account that during the election debate, the BBC edited out laughs, by the audience, directed at Johnson's comments[4]. The bbc committed a number of "editorial mistakes" that represented themselves as Tory bias.

[1]: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election-2019-50561043

[2]: https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/islamophobia-conservati...

[3]: https://www.lse.ac.uk/media-and-communications/research/rese...

[4]: https://www.theguardian.com/media/2019/nov/25/bbc-admits-mis...

Re:David Graeber has died by mercer on Friday September 04, 2020 @06:27AM (#24373634)
While I understand it's much to ask, I can recommend this episode of the Trashfuture podcast that goes into the anti-semitism kerfuffle: https://trashfuturepodcast.podbean.com/e/anger-ramadan-feat-...

or perhaps the article linked from the show notes: https://novaramedia.com/2020/04/14/i-feel-both-furious-and-v...

I'm nowhere near qualified to assess how accurate all of this is, but it all feels eerily similar to how the supposed American left, the Democrats, actively undermined Bernie Sanders in ways that IMO went too far. While I'm sure that's also up for debate, I at least followed the Bernie campaign closely.

Re:David Graeber has died by simoom22 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @09:58PM (#24371011)
What's inexplicable about it? They're called the Labour party, not the Remain party.
Re:David Graeber has died by jimnotgym on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:00PM (#24369819)
>I think Graeber's point is that occasionally publishing writers like this...

> this is the "cred" they built up by publishing people like me, .@OwenJones84, .@GeorgeMonbiot, .@chakrabortty -

I will challenge on the term 'occasional'.

George Monbiot writes a weekly column

Owen Jones writes a regular column

Aditya Chakrabortti writes a regular column and is their senior economics commentator.

This reduces your opening paragraph to, "By regularly publishing left wingers, by employing them on its staff, by publishing left wing material, the Guardian seeks to pass itself off as a left wing paper. " Well...yes.

I should also say that the idea that the Labour anti-semitism scandal was a plot to smear Corbyn, is not universally acknowledged even amongst left wingers.

Re:David Graeber has died by k1m on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:23PM (#24370449)
Perhaps "occasional" wasn't the right choice of word. They have regular columns, yes, but when the Guardian goes into attack mode against the left, these writers either don't appear or are drowned out by others in the paper.

I spent some time helping collect examples of the Guardian's output during its obsession with attacking Jeremy Corbyn. Try to find comparable coverage in support of Corbyn in the Guardian to offset these attack pieces published between 2015 and 2017: https://theguardian.fivefilters.org (note that Owen Jones, far from being a dissenting voice, joined in with the attacks here, later apologising).

David Graeber tweeted a link to this at the time - after all the Guardian's doomsayers were proven wrong. https://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/874853587880423426

After some time the Guardian intensified its attacks, this time focusing on spurious claims of antisemitism. They refused to run Graeber's piece defending Corbyn. Again, see if you can find comparable coverage defending Corbyn in the Guardian compared to ones trying to tar him with the antisemite brush: https://theguardian.fivefilters.org/antisemitism/

And that's of course not mentioning the study that found the Guardian to be one of the most innacurate in reporting claims of antisemitism (more so than even the Sun and the Daily Mail). That little fact is still the pinned tweet on Graeber's Twitter account, which must really annoy the Guardian when his name's trending on Twitter. https://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/1210322505229094912

Re:David Graeber has died by jimnotgym on Friday September 04, 2020 @02:13AM (#24372200)
I see the graph in the pinned tweet, but where is the study it is based on?

I doubt it annoys the Guardian at all. I think they are more than used to this kind of criticism.

Re:David Graeber has died by k1m on Friday September 04, 2020 @05:45AM (#24373389)
Here's the link to the study: https://www.mediareform.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/La...

Criticism they can ignore (as they often do) I'm sure doesn't bother them. But the widespread resentment toward the Guardian does bother them. It was apparent from their writers' responses when #BoycottTheGuardian was trending on Twitter for example, or more recently when they announced big job cuts and their writers pleas for support were mostly met with derision.

Re:David Graeber has died by jimnotgym on Friday September 04, 2020 @09:19AM (#24374665)
I think it is easy to feel things are more widespread than they are when guaged from social media.

Eg.I was very critical of Corbyn's stance on Brexit, and having a few followers I captured the attention of the Corbynite WhatsApp group run by Seamus Milne's team, and was heavily trolled...Rachel Swindon et al... and I block trolls, so fell out of the Corbynite bubble. The result of this is I have not seen widespread outrage against the Guardian at all. Perhaps widespread in revolutionary socialist circles is a more correct assertion.

Re:David Graeber has died by fault_lines on Friday September 04, 2020 @09:45AM (#24374849)
> I captured the attention of the Corbynite WhatsApp group run by Seamus Milne's team, and was heavily trolled...Rachel Swindon et al...

This is a conspiracy theory with no basis in fact.

Re:David Graeber has died by jimnotgym on Friday September 04, 2020 @02:29PM (#24377601)
Except for the direct quotes from her.

"“I do get advice from them,” she said. “But that’s the end of that.”

She eventually explained that there are several private Twitter DM groups where discussion goes on “all day”, with new pro-Corbyn lines posted alongside anti-Tory memes — which are often taken and repurposed from Facebook groups.

Asked whether Labour officials were in the groups speaking to the pro-Corbyn accounts, she said “Maybe”, smiling."

https://www.buzzfeed.com/markdistefano/heres-the-woman-behin...

It was tangential to my point, but Corbynite trolls were just as nasty and just as organized as the right wingers. Everyone not for Corbyn was neoliberal scum, or a 'yellow Tory'. In the end this only serves to shut down real debate and polarise each bubble.

Re:David Graeber has died by fault_lines on Friday September 04, 2020 @03:21PM (#24378049)
Your implication was that Seamus Milne, or his team, command a sort of "troll army" through WhatsApp. This is substantially different to disseminating talking points to friendly media faces (which is something all parties do, and is normal in political campaigning).

When you got trolled, it wasn't because of a secret WhatsApp group conspiring against you. It was because you said something that a large number of left wing people disagreed with, and Twitter worked the way it usually works and encouraged an organic pile-on. I can assure you that the UK left-wing network on Twitter has no need to get marching orders from a mythical WhatsApp group. If somebody says something that the left disagrees with, pile-ons will happen naturally.

Ironically, by dismissing people who disagree with you as commanded by Seumas Milne, you are shutting down debate yourself.

Re:David Graeber has died by jimnotgym on Friday September 04, 2020 @05:03PM (#24378865)
Disseminating talking points to friendly faces...

Nice euphemism.

Re:David Graeber has died by frabbit on Thursday September 03, 2020 @09:06PM (#24370754)
Paul Mason also was busy trying to climb over Corbyn's corpse.

He's another of the Look-We-Publish-Left-Wing-Opinion go-tos for the Guardian centrists.

Re:David Graeber has died by pydry on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:21PM (#24369547)
>Additionally, while his views of the Guardian have soured, it's more to the left than the quotes above might suggest.

It's one thing to wax lyrical about a utopian left wing ideal. It's quite another to then be a willing attack dog for an establishment that is hell bent on killing any hope of something like it flourishing:

"The Corbyn era certainly has been buried. It was never going to survive its complacency over Boris Johnson, its failure to treat allegations of antisemitism with any urgency, or its years spent umm-ing and ahh-ing over Brexit."

One of those examples was part of a baseless smear campaign (partly on behalf of a foreign state) that the Guardian helped spread, quite deliberately.

It's quite audacious for a newspaper to attack a public figure with a baseless smear campaign and then try to attack them on the basis that they didn't appropriately deal with the smear campaign they helped run.

Re:David Graeber has died by ChrisMarshallNY on Thursday September 03, 2020 @09:11PM (#24370784)
I liked the famous photo of Einstein, sticking out his tongue.
Re:David Graeber has died by FpUser on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:04PM (#24369840)
I suspect he would be heavily downvoted should he be posting in HN (anonymously of course). All in all sad to see him go.
Re:David Graeber has died by eli_gottlieb on Thursday September 03, 2020 @09:14PM (#24370801)
It looks like he was a poster here, but alas, he never commented himself on the Graeber vs Thiel debate or "Flying Cars and the Declining Rate of Profit", his most HN-relevant pieces of work.
Re:David Graeber has died by RandoHolmes on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:27PM (#24369079)
I don't see anything wrong with the photo.
Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @04:59PM (#24368827)
"He also got into flamewars on Hacker News"

It's disappointing to see 'flamewar' contexualizxed after 'provoking interesting discussion'. Reading through Graeber's long, contradictory, insult-filled, self-important rants, I'm not sure what would motivate this contextualization.

Normally, I might assume good faith, but Graeber's polemical behavior characterizes both a significant part of his work and a significant part of his participation on his site. The contextualization of this kind of unhinged and hateful behavior as some sort of intellectualism is something I find especially repulsive and pernicious.

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:34PM (#24369141)
Can you provide examples please? I've followed Graeber for years, and this sounds nothing like the person I came to know.
Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:51PM (#24369284)
You can refer to dang's link to Graeber's flamewar with Brad DeLong on here. It begins and ends with insults sandwiching a suspiciously uncharitable characterization of the subject.

This suspicion is founded: many of Graeber's claims are also false; in particular, Delong provided a litany of elementary falsehoods in Debt, in which Graeber's inaccurate claim about Apple is merely of especial characteristic inaccuracy--but that's beyond the scope of this post. Zooming back out, if one leads and ends with hateful insults which they cannot justify, that ought to be viewed with deep suspicion. No, DeLong is not a "con-man" who "suckers" people because he wants to call out a book which he feels, and can earnestly argue, is deeply wrong.

Near the end of this long, screenfilling rant, Graeber claims he has been trying to "ignore" DeLong. I didn't know such fits of apoplexy were how you ignored someone.

Re:David Graeber has died by amznthrowaway5 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:18PM (#24369532)
Can you go into more detail? Because Graeber's post seems quite convincing, and DeLong fails to coherently reply to the accusations.

Graeber went into detail about why DeLong was impossible to ignore, including DeLong apparently creating a twitter bot to attack Graeber (!!).

Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:24PM (#24369577)
I mean, Graeber is right in that he was being trolled. But Graeber lies when he says he tried to ignore DeLong and Graeber lies when he characterizes DeLong as obsessively harping on one inaccuracy.

Graeber's fit of apoplexy wasn't just in that one HN comment. His "ignoring" DeLong was an uninterrupted train of obsessive, one-sided, and often bizarrely misdirected anger and insult. The only "ignoring" was that Graeber, in all his raging against DeLong's trollbot, did not bother do any raging in the form of citing facts or other defense. As DeLong puts it:

> Graeber, of course, makes no attempt to defend his claims in his chapter 12. He doesn't because he can't. Chapter 12 is in fact riddled with errors.... It really appears to be just too easy for people like David Graeber to imagine that they are in a two-month extended conversation where there is a human mind on the other side, when actually they are just the bird pecking itself in the window glass[1].

That incident was a piece in a longer flamewar in which Graeber, essentially, behaves in the obsessive and intellectually bankrupt manner he accused DeLong of behaving.

[1]https://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2013/04/david-graeber-april-f...

Re:David Graeber has died by notahacker on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:16PM (#24369915)
To be fair to the late Graeber, DeLong was intentionally provoking him from the start. To be fair to DeLong, he was doing it because Graeber had dramatically overreacted to relatively mild critical takes on his work on the Crooked Timber economics blog whose contributors thought his book intellectually stimulating enough to hold a multi-author 'seminar' on it - accusing them of being part of a 'strategy of delegitimization'. Which just goes to show that academic debate can easily head in the same direction as arguments on the rest of the internet.

As for the actual Debt: The First 5000 Years book, it's engaging, thought-provoking, less opinionated than I was expecting and right about a lot of big things. But his critics aren't wrong that it's also wrong about a lot more small details than the founding of Apple Computer (one I'm surprised none of the academic economists scrutinising his book picked up on: he describes Treatise on Money as Keynes 'most famous work' which is akin to calling Wings Paul McCartney's most famous band. That's particularly surprising in the middle of a passage about Keynes' work which is actually well-informed). Still think it's worth reading for people vaguely interested in the subject matter though.

Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:40PM (#24370571)
I feel like there's some form of Gell-Mann amnesia here. Why say a book is right about a lot of big things when it is frequently wrong about those things which can be verified?
Re:David Graeber has died by notahacker on Friday September 04, 2020 @05:42AM (#24373372)
Because I've read other, less entertaining writing on the history of money which concurs with Graeber's central argument that money is much best understood as debt accounting (and some pretty terrible writing about the magical powers of certain metals) and the sloppiness in illustrative anecdotes (or impractical utopian proposals of regular debt jubilees) doesn't really affect that central thesis. I wouldn't necessarily rely on Graeber's colourful anecdotes about historical civilisations or obscure tribes being accurate and uncontroversial without checking what other anthropologists think, but those are 'small picture' things.
Re:David Graeber has died by earthboundkid on Thursday September 03, 2020 @11:03PM (#24371316)
Because I didn’t read Debt to learn about Apple, and that’s not what I took away from it.
Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Friday September 04, 2020 @02:06AM (#24372160)
That's deeply disingenuous. It's not like this guy was telling the truth everywhere else. The lies were numerous.

That's what Gell-Mann amnesia is, really: we believe what we want to believe, and forget the quality of the source.

Re:David Graeber has died by gord288 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:09PM (#24369450)
Well no, here's what Graeber actually said at the end of his comment (emphasis added):

> I've honestly tried to just ignore the guy, hoping he'll eventually go away, but since he won't, I guess I have to explain what's really going on.

Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:14PM (#24369497)
That reads like a post-hoc justification to me. Most people practice ignoring people by, well, ignoring them. If they don't, they will explain what's "really going on" by just explaining it, not with prolonged fits of unwarranted and uncharitable apoplexy.

As I described elsewhere, Graeber is also lying when he said he made any serious attempt to ignore DeLong at all.

Re:David Graeber has died by Talanes on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:36PM (#24370540)
It's well presented, but can you explain how your argument is fundamentally different from a child shouting "liar?"
Re:David Graeber has died by ChickeNES on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:25PM (#24369582)
I felt much the same way having never heard of Graeber before but being familiar with DeLong. I'm seeing the same from Graeber supporters in the comments shouting down Noah Smith's review of Debt instead of addressing his arguments.
[dead]
Re:David Graeber has died by kunai on Thursday September 03, 2020 @04:33PM (#24368564)
Why? It's pretty evident at this point that the whole Labour anti-Semitism thing was a cheap way to generate clicks and tank Corbyn-led Labour. Criticism of Israel's genuinely awful human rights record is not anti-Semitic.
Re:David Graeber has died by mft_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:18PM (#24369011)
It wasn’t just related to criticism of Israel.

There were plenty of examples [0] of unpleasant statements coming from people on a Labour party platform or at their events, which were not dealt with sufficiently quickly or seriously by the Labour Party. They could’ve made this problem go away by just having a proper policy and dealing with these cases swiftly and appropriately. They didn’t.

[0] https://news.sky.com/story/12-shocking-claims-of-abuse-in-le...

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:37PM (#24369161)
Yes, and there is also now proof of sabotage by the right of the Labour party specifically in order to create the narrative you are repeating.

"The 860-page document claims that “an abnormal intensity of factional opposition to the party leader” had “inhibited the proper functioning of the Labour Party bureaucracy” and contributed to “a litany of mistakes” in dealing with antisemitism, which it admits was a serious problem in the party."

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/labour-leak-r...

Meanwhile, the Tory party gets a free pass on their rampant Antisemitism and stoking hatred of immigrants.

Re:David Graeber has died by frabbit on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:49PM (#24370184)
Don't forget the use of Facebook micro-targetted ads to attempt to trick Corbyn into believing that his own party machinery was putting out the message that it was supposed to be:

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/labour-hq-used-facebook-a...

The centrist and right-wing of the Labour party have a lot to answer for and have clearly displayed that they will stick at nothing to ensure that:

* There is no Green New Deal and the climate crisis is going to happen * Power remains in the hands of few incompetent fail sons and their sociopathic remoras.

Re:David Graeber has died by mft_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:02PM (#24369382)
Whether or not the draft dossier of uncertain providence is all legit, I agree it looks like Labour’s issues ran deep. However, I’d still argue there’s an issue around Corbyn’s leadership.

You’re the leader of Labour; your party is being criticised in very damaging ways and (for the sake of argument) it’s because your internal processes are being sabotaged. What do you do? Maybe... look into it? Fix it? Change the people responsible if that’s what it takes? At best, it was weak leadership. At worst, it was a reluctance to discipline political allies.

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:26PM (#24369594)
The Labour leaks prove that Labour did try to fix it - Corbyn should've booted all the neo-liberals out of his party via mandatory reselections. Unfortunately, he's too decent to play dirty - but that's what's needed right now.

I think it's pretty clear that Rachel Reeves, Ian Austin et al are not allies when they are funnelling money and faking ad spend, and leaking lies to the press specifically to stop labour from winning.

(I'm not referring to all claims of antisemitism here as lies by the way, but many of the stories that broke in the Guardian were later redacted as bunk)

Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:01PM (#24369827)
I hate this sort of defense-by-attack. Corbyn needed to defend Labor from anti-semitism by... eliminating neoliberals? How about by eliminating anti-semites?

It's like, what are the priorities here?

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:24PM (#24369979)
That’s a very cynical way to interpret what I said. I was responding to Corbyn being defined as weak and of the PR mess that was exasperated by saboteurs, not providing a solution to the real problem of antisemitism.

We’re not talking about a ranked value system here, we’re talking about an organisation that can do multiple things at the same time.

Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:04PM (#24370287)
No. The "real solution" is to oppose anti-semitism with all due expediency.

I don't care if it was exasperated by "saboteurs". If Corbyn can't adopt this basic moral position that all humans ought to adopt, I don't care to hear any excuses at all.

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:13PM (#24370360)
A straw man. It wasn’t exposed by saboteurs. It was exaggerated with false news stories to add to the legitimate and real concern and to keep the story in the news. The antisemitism is real. So is the outrage about how labour staffers conspired to destroy Labours electoral success. Your blindness to this obvious point is very revealing.

Edit: you seemed to have silently edited your comment to change your argument, so I’ll do the same:

> No. The "real solution" is to oppose anti-semitism with all due expediency.

And the labour leaks show that a faction of the party was purposefully undermining labours ability to do this against the wishes of the leadership. Do you accept this?

> I don't care if it was exasperated by "saboteurs". If Corbyn can't adopt this basic moral position that all humans ought to adopt, I don't care to hear any excuses at all.

That makes no sense: are you really arguing that Corbyn’s political enemies’ actions lead you to hate Corbyn’s moral position, even when it ostensibly matches your own?

Maybe you should have another think before you reply

Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:17PM (#24370387)
The "straw-man" concerns one of the most hateful, vapid and odious ideas that humanity that ever devised. Corbyn failed to confront it.

Conspiracy theories, whataboutism, insults -- these are less than nothing, yet the spineless Corbyn and his supporters dare claim leadership over better people, and fabricate whiny paranoid stories of their persecution. Given that there are liberals and leftists who are not comfortable with pointless evil, everything else is insignificant.

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:29PM (#24370490)
Meanwhile, the Tory party (The party which is in power) gets a free pass: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_the_UK_Conse...

Corbynite Labour is the party you vote for to fight fascism and antisemitism. But instead media parrots like yourself prefer to ignore any nuance because - I suspect - it suits your conservative political ideology.

It’s destructive thought patterns like the ones you are displaying which have allowed Boris Johnson into power. I think you’ll find that if Jewish people in the UK (and I sincerely And truly hope this never, ever happens - to Jews, or any other vulnerable group) is ever treated like they have been in the past, it won’t be from people like Corbyn, it’ll be by people like Patel.

But, you know, you do you.

Re:David Graeber has died by jessaustin on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:36PM (#24369154)
Oh good, another English dossier. Those are entertaining! One notes that at that link there are no specific accusations against Corbyn. It's all "Corbyn-supporting groups" and "concerns about Corbyn's leadership". Seems a bit thin!

We would have seen this fiction in USA too, if voters would have just forgotten that Bernie is actually Jewish.

Re:David Graeber has died by mft_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:47PM (#24369247)
No one said Corbyn himself was anti-Semitic - just that there was anti-Semitism within the Labour Party, and it wasn’t dealt with sufficiently during his tenure as leader.

It’s not unreasonable to hold a leader somewhat responsible - it’s not like Trump isn’t criticised (rightly) for things done by other people on his watch.

Re:David Graeber has died by jessaustin on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:56PM (#24369334)
ITT, one reads "...anti-semitism in the UK Labour Party... culminated with the recent leader Corbyn..." There aren't too many ways to interpret that.

It is interesting to imagine holding the national leader of a political party responsible for her or his own actions, let alone the antics of other party members. Whatever UK has done to make this possible, we should do. Only, I suspect it will turn into yet another double standard.

Re:David Graeber has died by mft_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:07PM (#24369427)
I interpret to chronologically: that the rise of Corbyn to leadership of Labour revitalised some segments of supporters, some of whom had anti-Semitic views. I don’t for a second think that he personally was anti-Semitic, but some of his supporters and political allies probably are, and his prominence led to their greater prominence also.
Re:David Graeber has died by pydry on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:19PM (#24369939)
There was a mountain of accusations of anti-semitism that boiled down to "she said something anti-zionist which we think implies she is anti-semitic if you look at it in the right light".

Meanwhile, over in actual Israel they're busy setting up an apartheid state and enacting race based policies.

It's simply not possible to be consistently anti racist without being accused of anti-semitism. Rebecca Long Bailey getting fired is simply the latest illustration of that.

Re:David Graeber has died by mrow84 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:58PM (#24369352)
> No one said Corbyn himself was anti-Semitic

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/2019/12/05/jeremy-corbyn...

Re:David Graeber has died by mft_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:03PM (#24369397)
Sure; I meant in this discussion on HN. Sorry for not being clear.
Re:David Graeber has died by mrow84 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:13PM (#24369484)
> It’s not unreasonable to hold a leader somewhat responsible - it’s not like Trump isn’t criticised (rightly) for things done by other people on his watch.

Clearly you could decide that you will hold a leader to be (somewhat) responsible simply by virtue of them being the leader, as a matter of principle. However, it seems quite possible to at least _imagine_ situations where a leader is "fatally" undermined by people within their own organisation. Given that, it is worth considering whether that may have been the situation for Corbyn, and if so where culpability lies.

To complete your point, I would contend that this isn't the key issue with Trump - it isn't obvious to me that generalising over these situations is really that useful.

Re:David Graeber has died by steffandroid on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:14PM (#24368970)
Please read this piece that Graeber wrote in defence of Corbyn: https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/opendemocracyuk/first-time-...
Re:David Graeber has died by samizdis on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:48PM (#24369260)
Exactly that. I second your recommendation that it should be read.
Re:David Graeber has died by gghhzzgghhzz on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:05PM (#24369414)
Re:David Graeber has died by ChickeNES on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:17PM (#24369520)
Same old argument I've read from others, it's not going to change my mind about Corbyn or Labour, sorry. And before I get accused of being a right-winger, I'm no fan of Boris, Trump, the Tories, UKIP, or the GOP either
Re:David Graeber has died by JansjoFromIkea on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:47PM (#24370636)
There's milder right-wing stances than Trump, y'know? Clegg-era LDs were definitely centre-right and I haven't seen a lot since to suggest they've changed radically, beyond shifting from a 100% useful (and unfortunately sabotaged) focus on voting-reform to pie in the sky dreams of undoing Brexit.

The UK is several decades into successive governments with centre-right leanings to some level or another. New Labour were mayyyyybe centre-left, but Blair had to drag them as far right as he could to get anointed by the media.

I'd be interested to hear how your mind was made up though. The UK benefits from having some pretty strong social systems built into its core but the media seems to be practically one-note in a way I haven't experienced in the other countries I've lived (all European/North American) and the sheer fixation on finding ways to push negative write-ups on him was exhausting. You're getting the same counterarguments because it was pretty much the same things coming up again and again.

Brown, Miliband, Kinnock and the voting reform referendum all got similar carpet bombing treatment; albeit to nowhere near the same levels of venom (although the attacks on Brown and his eye were pretty cruel iirc).

Re:David Graeber has died by areoform on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:58PM (#24369795)
Please reconsider your broader position on changing your mind. This reflexive inflexibility is perhaps the central reason why our civilization is in disarray.
Re:David Graeber has died by kmlx on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:17PM (#24368996)
like any other person, he had his misgivings.

yes, it's a bad look, but one of his few (another one was the infantile Occupy movement).

but, to be factual, anti-semitism in the UK Labour Party has been a thing since the 20th century, and culminated with the recent leader Corbyn:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_the_UK_Labour_...

Re:David Graeber has died by pydry on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:41PM (#24369685)
>but, to be factual, anti-semitism in the UK Labour Party has been a thing since the 20th century

Anti semitism is a thing in society at large. It's bigger than it is in society in the Conservative Party. It's smaller than it is in society at large in the Labour party, but not entirely non-existent.

The reason it became such an "issue" with Corbyn was about Israel attempting to shield itself from Corbyn's criticism (e.g. land expansion, abuse of palestinians, highly racist policies) and because others found it useful to jump on Israel's bandwagon. It's not because it was common. It wasn't.

Tom Watson (deputy leader, never a corbyn fan) was one of those people.

He even went as far as visiting Isaac Herzog in Israel with a contingent of MPs (all of whom loathed Corbyn) to "apologize" for the "anti semitism problem" in the Labour party: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/nov/15/tom-watson-...

Isaac Herzog, then leader of the Israeli Labour party, is famous for declaring that "race mixing is a tragedy" and refusing to apologize for it. This is who the concerned "anti racists" allied themselves with - an Israeli obsessed with racial purity: https://www.middleeasteye.net/opinion/isaac-herzogs-remarks-...

The hypocrisy and pearl clutching on this issue was absolutely staggering - especially by the guardian. The fact that something like this can be used to take down an honest politician in this way gives us a terrifying glimpse into the future.

Re:David Graeber has died by kmlx on Friday September 04, 2020 @04:32AM (#24372962)
what i do not understand is why, when there are so many issues in the UK would any party focus on what happens in some far away land. was the UK labour party trying to attract the vote of palestinians?

this was an entirely avoidable mess. but Mr Corbyn and his team were so bad at politics that they managed to not only make this non-issue (to the UK voters) an important one, but also be defined by it.

i honestly could not believe such bad politics would ever survive. and of course it didn't. Corbyn is now again a backbencher and his group has been replaced.

Re:David Graeber has died by pydry on Friday September 04, 2020 @07:55AM (#24374112)
You can have one of two types of politician:

* A politician that will speak out against all injustices.

* A politician that will speak out against injustice only when it is politically expedient.

The reason people liked Corbyn was because he was the former. Why do they want the former? Well, because any day you might be the one thrown under a bus because it is politically expedient to do so. In a world where every politician is apparently a lying snake, he was somebody you could trust to be true to his word and true to his principles.

It's not like he spent all of his time on Palestinian issues and none on anything else. This isn't about how he allocated his time at all. The reason this blew up is because Israel decided to engage in the nuclear propaganda option because he had already spoken out against injustice in Palestine and wasn't going to apologize for it. Consequently, they threw everything they had at him and as it turns out they had a multitude of weapons they could deploy.

Note that if he had just shut up about Palestinian issues after becoming leader they would not have left him alone. They had a destroy at all costs mentality. As did many others who were similarly evil with powerful weapons at their disposal (Lord Rothermere, etc.).

This is probably the primary reason we can't have honest, principled politicians (what you described as "bad"). The system will filter them out - usually before they even get to that level and as we can see it will attempt to destroy them if they do.

To have avoided this scenario he would have had to grovel and apologize profusely for speaking out against Palestinian rights in the past. That's the only way this would have gone away. US politicians will do this kind of thing to appease powerful lobbies (e.g. NRA) and as we all know they are a lovely bunch of highly principled human beings who are loved by their people.

The US is actually a good example of what happens over the long term when people instinctively just try to pick the lesser evil and all integrity eventually gets washed out of politics by powerful, entrenched, wealthy groups. It's a long, dark, winding road to some kind of populist fascist leader - an incompetent one if you're lucky, a competent one if you are not.

Re:David Graeber has died by DonaldFisk on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:52PM (#24370676)
Are you aware that David Graeber was Jewish? Here he is, defending Jeremy Corbyn and pointing out that the threat to Jews comes not from Labour, but from the far right: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZ8MeRagpmc

Here's Jeremy Corbyn condemning two antisemitic attacks:

https://twitter.com/jeremycorbyn/status/1022172377269133312

https://twitter.com/jeremycorbyn/status/1100553357075382276

Sad to read of David Graeber's death. I attended two of his talks in support of Universal Basic Income.

Re:David Graeber has died by kmlx on Friday September 04, 2020 @04:24AM (#24372903)
yes, very much so.

this is why i've written this naivety was one of Mr Graeber's flaws.

as for Mr Corbyn, he was an honest but very weak leader. exemplified by his failure in containing this issue. an issue which to be completely honest is actually a non-issue for the UK considering it's many, more pressing and more important problems.

Re:David Graeber has died by claudeganon on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:49PM (#24369263)
From your own link:

> In April 2020, an 860-page report into the handling of antisemitism by the party concluded that there was "no evidence" that antisemitism complaints were treated any differently than other forms of complaint, or of current or former staff being "motivated by antisemitic intent.”

So how exactly did it “culminate” with Corbyn?

Re:David Graeber has died by notahacker on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:34PM (#24370068)
Because that 860 page report was written by his team to exonerate themselves and their allies and blame their rivals and whistleblowers because the party were being investigated by the Equality and Human Rights Commission, an independent investigation still in progress

Irrespective of the merits of the claims made in the report - itself the subject of further independent investigation and lawsuits filed by people criticised in it - it's not something which would have been written if things were going well.

Re:David Graeber has died by Talanes on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:20PM (#24370413)
All of the things that you claim are evidence of a problem are only evidence of a public perception of a problem. In a world where they are guilty, and a world where they are innocent and it's all a smear campaign, the investigating bodies respond the same.
Re:David Graeber has died by kmlx on Friday September 04, 2020 @04:19AM (#24372878)
but this is politics, where perception is reality.
Re:David Graeber has died by kmlx on Friday September 04, 2020 @04:18AM (#24372869)
the report written by the very same team accused of antisemitism?
Re:David Graeber has died by tome on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:29PM (#24369096)
Here is a (1984, hah!) book on the topic that I found interesting

https://libcom.org/files/thats_funny.pdf

Re:David Graeber has died by eli_gottlieb on Thursday September 03, 2020 @09:11PM (#24370785)
>> as for the Guardian, we will never forget that during the "Labour #antisemitism controversy", they beat even the Daily Mail to include the largest percentage of false statements, pretty much every one, mysteriously, an accidental error to Labour's disadvantage - https://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/1210322505229094912

Can't say I really agree with Graeber about this at all, one Jewish leftist to another. Told him so over Twitter at one point. Think someone blocked me after this conversation, but it wasn't David.

Gonna miss him.