News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:David Graeber has died by mft_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:18PM (#24369011)
It wasn’t just related to criticism of Israel.

There were plenty of examples [0] of unpleasant statements coming from people on a Labour party platform or at their events, which were not dealt with sufficiently quickly or seriously by the Labour Party. They could’ve made this problem go away by just having a proper policy and dealing with these cases swiftly and appropriately. They didn’t.

[0] https://news.sky.com/story/12-shocking-claims-of-abuse-in-le...

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:37PM (#24369161)
Yes, and there is also now proof of sabotage by the right of the Labour party specifically in order to create the narrative you are repeating.

"The 860-page document claims that “an abnormal intensity of factional opposition to the party leader” had “inhibited the proper functioning of the Labour Party bureaucracy” and contributed to “a litany of mistakes” in dealing with antisemitism, which it admits was a serious problem in the party."

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/labour-leak-r...

Meanwhile, the Tory party gets a free pass on their rampant Antisemitism and stoking hatred of immigrants.

Re:David Graeber has died by frabbit on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:49PM (#24370184)
Don't forget the use of Facebook micro-targetted ads to attempt to trick Corbyn into believing that his own party machinery was putting out the message that it was supposed to be:

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/labour-hq-used-facebook-a...

The centrist and right-wing of the Labour party have a lot to answer for and have clearly displayed that they will stick at nothing to ensure that:

* There is no Green New Deal and the climate crisis is going to happen * Power remains in the hands of few incompetent fail sons and their sociopathic remoras.

Re:David Graeber has died by mft_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:02PM (#24369382)
Whether or not the draft dossier of uncertain providence is all legit, I agree it looks like Labour’s issues ran deep. However, I’d still argue there’s an issue around Corbyn’s leadership.

You’re the leader of Labour; your party is being criticised in very damaging ways and (for the sake of argument) it’s because your internal processes are being sabotaged. What do you do? Maybe... look into it? Fix it? Change the people responsible if that’s what it takes? At best, it was weak leadership. At worst, it was a reluctance to discipline political allies.

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:26PM (#24369594)
The Labour leaks prove that Labour did try to fix it - Corbyn should've booted all the neo-liberals out of his party via mandatory reselections. Unfortunately, he's too decent to play dirty - but that's what's needed right now.

I think it's pretty clear that Rachel Reeves, Ian Austin et al are not allies when they are funnelling money and faking ad spend, and leaking lies to the press specifically to stop labour from winning.

(I'm not referring to all claims of antisemitism here as lies by the way, but many of the stories that broke in the Guardian were later redacted as bunk)

Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:01PM (#24369827)
I hate this sort of defense-by-attack. Corbyn needed to defend Labor from anti-semitism by... eliminating neoliberals? How about by eliminating anti-semites?

It's like, what are the priorities here?

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:24PM (#24369979)
That’s a very cynical way to interpret what I said. I was responding to Corbyn being defined as weak and of the PR mess that was exasperated by saboteurs, not providing a solution to the real problem of antisemitism.

We’re not talking about a ranked value system here, we’re talking about an organisation that can do multiple things at the same time.

Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:04PM (#24370287)
No. The "real solution" is to oppose anti-semitism with all due expediency.

I don't care if it was exasperated by "saboteurs". If Corbyn can't adopt this basic moral position that all humans ought to adopt, I don't care to hear any excuses at all.

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:13PM (#24370360)
A straw man. It wasn’t exposed by saboteurs. It was exaggerated with false news stories to add to the legitimate and real concern and to keep the story in the news. The antisemitism is real. So is the outrage about how labour staffers conspired to destroy Labours electoral success. Your blindness to this obvious point is very revealing.

Edit: you seemed to have silently edited your comment to change your argument, so I’ll do the same:

> No. The "real solution" is to oppose anti-semitism with all due expediency.

And the labour leaks show that a faction of the party was purposefully undermining labours ability to do this against the wishes of the leadership. Do you accept this?

> I don't care if it was exasperated by "saboteurs". If Corbyn can't adopt this basic moral position that all humans ought to adopt, I don't care to hear any excuses at all.

That makes no sense: are you really arguing that Corbyn’s political enemies’ actions lead you to hate Corbyn’s moral position, even when it ostensibly matches your own?

Maybe you should have another think before you reply

Re:David Graeber has died by cynicalkane on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:17PM (#24370387)
The "straw-man" concerns one of the most hateful, vapid and odious ideas that humanity that ever devised. Corbyn failed to confront it.

Conspiracy theories, whataboutism, insults -- these are less than nothing, yet the spineless Corbyn and his supporters dare claim leadership over better people, and fabricate whiny paranoid stories of their persecution. Given that there are liberals and leftists who are not comfortable with pointless evil, everything else is insignificant.

Re:David Graeber has died by s0l1dsnak3123 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @08:29PM (#24370490)
Meanwhile, the Tory party (The party which is in power) gets a free pass: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_the_UK_Conse...

Corbynite Labour is the party you vote for to fight fascism and antisemitism. But instead media parrots like yourself prefer to ignore any nuance because - I suspect - it suits your conservative political ideology.

It’s destructive thought patterns like the ones you are displaying which have allowed Boris Johnson into power. I think you’ll find that if Jewish people in the UK (and I sincerely And truly hope this never, ever happens - to Jews, or any other vulnerable group) is ever treated like they have been in the past, it won’t be from people like Corbyn, it’ll be by people like Patel.

But, you know, you do you.

Re:David Graeber has died by jessaustin on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:36PM (#24369154)
Oh good, another English dossier. Those are entertaining! One notes that at that link there are no specific accusations against Corbyn. It's all "Corbyn-supporting groups" and "concerns about Corbyn's leadership". Seems a bit thin!

We would have seen this fiction in USA too, if voters would have just forgotten that Bernie is actually Jewish.

Re:David Graeber has died by mft_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:47PM (#24369247)
No one said Corbyn himself was anti-Semitic - just that there was anti-Semitism within the Labour Party, and it wasn’t dealt with sufficiently during his tenure as leader.

It’s not unreasonable to hold a leader somewhat responsible - it’s not like Trump isn’t criticised (rightly) for things done by other people on his watch.

Re:David Graeber has died by jessaustin on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:56PM (#24369334)
ITT, one reads "...anti-semitism in the UK Labour Party... culminated with the recent leader Corbyn..." There aren't too many ways to interpret that.

It is interesting to imagine holding the national leader of a political party responsible for her or his own actions, let alone the antics of other party members. Whatever UK has done to make this possible, we should do. Only, I suspect it will turn into yet another double standard.

Re:David Graeber has died by mft_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:07PM (#24369427)
I interpret to chronologically: that the rise of Corbyn to leadership of Labour revitalised some segments of supporters, some of whom had anti-Semitic views. I don’t for a second think that he personally was anti-Semitic, but some of his supporters and political allies probably are, and his prominence led to their greater prominence also.
Re:David Graeber has died by pydry on Thursday September 03, 2020 @07:19PM (#24369939)
There was a mountain of accusations of anti-semitism that boiled down to "she said something anti-zionist which we think implies she is anti-semitic if you look at it in the right light".

Meanwhile, over in actual Israel they're busy setting up an apartheid state and enacting race based policies.

It's simply not possible to be consistently anti racist without being accused of anti-semitism. Rebecca Long Bailey getting fired is simply the latest illustration of that.

Re:David Graeber has died by mrow84 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @05:58PM (#24369352)
> No one said Corbyn himself was anti-Semitic

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/2019/12/05/jeremy-corbyn...

Re:David Graeber has died by mft_ on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:03PM (#24369397)
Sure; I meant in this discussion on HN. Sorry for not being clear.
Re:David Graeber has died by mrow84 on Thursday September 03, 2020 @06:13PM (#24369484)
> It’s not unreasonable to hold a leader somewhat responsible - it’s not like Trump isn’t criticised (rightly) for things done by other people on his watch.

Clearly you could decide that you will hold a leader to be (somewhat) responsible simply by virtue of them being the leader, as a matter of principle. However, it seems quite possible to at least _imagine_ situations where a leader is "fatally" undermined by people within their own organisation. Given that, it is worth considering whether that may have been the situation for Corbyn, and if so where culpability lies.

To complete your point, I would contend that this isn't the key issue with Trump - it isn't obvious to me that generalising over these situations is really that useful.