News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by sebastien_b on Saturday August 29, 2020 @06:53PM (#24319988)
Funny how most replies in that thread don’t actually address the initial question: why is there a policy of prohibiting disclosure of how the money the user pays gets distributed?

Most “answers” immediately diverge into monopoly discussions, or questions-as-answers of why 30% ‘seems so high’ (even though neither was initially brought up).

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by sebastien_b on Saturday August 29, 2020 @08:49PM (#24320467)
And besides this, most people seem content to compare it with the physical world with (IMO invalid) comparisons of malls, etc.

There's another thing: Apple already charges developers a fee every year. And they also sell ads on the App Store (which you basically have to buy otherwise you're a 'needle in a haystack'). AND they sell ads to your competitors, which use your (sometimes trademarked) keywords in their ads, which means you need to buy even more ads to counteract those.

Apple wins, and wins.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by modeless on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:26PM (#24320606)
And they make every developer buy a Mac because they prohibit running macOS in VMs and in general don't allow building iOS apps without the use of Mac hardware. That's probably a bigger expense than the app store fees for most, and artificially inflates macOS market share in the important developer market.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by gerash on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:43AM (#24321423)
This upfront payment from the developer might have the side effect of weeding out all but those who are heavily invested in their iOS app. Ensuring the apps there are not hobby or side projects and are maintained and supported by full-time devs.

That said, I wouldn't lock myself into that ecosystem with all those upfront costs and restrictive terms where Apple benefits much more from the devs than the other way round.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by nagyf on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:49PM (#24320982)
If you write an app that you can sell on the app store to 860 people for $5 you already got the money to buy a Macbook Pro 16”.

I don’t think the Macbook restriction is such a big problem. However, if you sell it to 1 million people and Apple takes the 30% cut, that’s a loss of $1.5M for you...

(Maybe I miss something, I never wrote iOS apps, I’m just doing the math)

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by mkl on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:07PM (#24321051)
You need to buy the Mac before writing the app. You might make enough to repay that investment, but it's out of pocket to start with. For many people that is a big problem.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by d3nj4l on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:17PM (#24321092)
This also makes it difficult to write FOSS apps for iOS, because the developer would have to front the cost of a macOS workstation + the $99 yearly fee with no expectation of a return at all.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by projektfu on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:38PM (#24321176)
Technically you can make it GNU compatible and charge for it with the source online. A user needs the build system but can modify your app and rerelease it at their convenience.

I prefer the F-Droid model myself.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by threeseed on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:43PM (#24321195)
This really is a ridiculous point to make.

You need a Mac because important components like the XCode Simulator require OSX libraries in order to function. It's no different to me needed a Windows machine in order to build Office plugins.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by mkl on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:37AM (#24321405)
If those software components were all that was needed, we could just run macOS in a VM, as we can easily do with Windows or Linux. Apple forbids that specifically to make all prospective Mac/iOS developers buy Mac hardware.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by modeless on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:53PM (#24321230)
I regularly cross compile for Windows from Linux, and I don't need to buy any hardware from Microsoft.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by efreak on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:59PM (#24321257)
Microsoft has little to do with the hardware you run their software on
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by hombre_fatal on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:26AM (#24321367)
> If you write an app that you can sell on the app store to 860 people for $5

fwiw, that's an incredibly hard feat that most people don't ever accomplish. Even "it's just 16 work-weeks at minimum wage" would have been a better demo.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by modeless on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:01AM (#24321267)
I would bet that the median developer in the developer program doesn't sell enough on the App Store to recoup the cost of a mid-range MacBook Pro every 3-5 years and an iPhone every other year and the developer program annual fee.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by threeseed on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:38PM (#24321178)
> And they make every developer buy a Mac

No. You just need to be able to run OSX.

For the last 6 months I've been running OSX on my X299/10980xe desktop using OpenCore. And it is far along enough now that you can run it on a range of PC equipment including AMD.

And Apple has said on a number of occasions that provided you don't sell these Hackintosh desktops they fully support you playing around with OSX this way.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by modeless on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:44PM (#24321197)
This is illegal and I am skeptical that Apple has officially endorsed breaking their EULA.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by threeseed on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:54PM (#24321235)
It's a breach of the EULA which is very different from being illegal.

And Craig Federighi has talked on quite a few occasions about supporting the hacking culture within OSX. Which is why Apple never went after Hackintosh like they could have e.g. by enforcing SIP.

There are hundreds of Github projects and websites right now detailing how to setup a Hackintosh Mac and not once has anyone ever received a cease and desist.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by modeless on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:59PM (#24321258)
It's breach of contract and copyright infringement among other things, so it is illegal. Not taking every opportunity to enforce the EULA is not the same thing as condoning breaking it. If Apple actually wanted to support hackintoshes they could change the EULA, but they never will.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by threeseed on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:11AM (#24321511)
If the VP of Engineering publicly states it's okay I will take his word for it. And it's definitely not clear depending on your country whether an EULA is enforceable or not.

And the reason it's not permitted in the EULA is because it would allow commercial competitors to build Hackintosh Macs which nearly destroyed the company during the Power Computing era.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by modeless on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:36AM (#24321592)
It is never a good idea under any circumstances to believe someone when they tell you it's ok to violate the terms of a contract they are requiring you to sign.

They could modify the EULA without enabling commercial sale of hackintoshes. They just won't. It's actually better for them when you are in breach of contract, because then they can use selective enforcement to create any unwritten rule they like.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by skewart on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:31PM (#24320628)
Don’t forget their initiative to capture an even bigger percentage of app advertising spend. Nerfing the IDFA is designed to make advertising anywhere other than the App Store less effective. Apple is betting that this change will force developers to shift more advertising dollars to Apple, and away from places like Facebook.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by spideymans on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:40PM (#24320662)
> And besides this, most people seem content to compare it with the physical world with (IMO invalid) comparisons of malls, etc.

Are there any major digital stores that disclose the costs of doing business (royalties, fees, etc...) to the customer as purchase? For example, the PlayStation/Xbox Online Store or Amazon Music

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by cnst on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:22PM (#24320849)
I recall in the UK in 2006, in retail supermarkets, it's been disclosed that the tag price is a cash-only price. That if you pay by a credit card, then the price is 2 or 3% less, but there's an extra 2% or 3% fee for credit card processing.

In the US, sales tax is almost never included in the price tag, so, when you checkout, you get the sales tax itemised separately, including when different jurisdictions charge separate taxes (e.g., county + city sales tax). Hotels in states with a gross-receipts tax often pass this tax back to the consumer as well.

In Eventbrite and many other similar apps, including for donations, the processing fees are nearly always shown separately from the cash price itself; I believe some platforms let the seller decide how it's shown (e.g., "who pays it").

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by sgc on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:35PM (#24320909)
Tax break downs are also posted at the pump when buying gas in the US, because they are so high. Which is kind of the point in the case of the app store as well. They would have more sympathy from me if they charged a more reasonable fee.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by warmfuzzykitten on Sunday August 30, 2020 @08:17PM (#24327238)
In the US, credit card companies don't allow sellers to disclose credit card fees or charge separately for them. You do sometimes see a discount for cash, which is probably due to lax contract enforcement, and, of course, many sellers only accept the subset of credit cards with the lowest fees.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by cnst on Sunday August 30, 2020 @09:18PM (#24327575)
Are you sure the sellers aren't allowed to disclose the fees? I believe the sellers aren't allowed to charge more on CC than the cash price. Note that the example above may be a little convoluted if you aren't too observant a reader, but the whole idea is that the total price that the user pays is still the same regardless of the method of payment, it's just that the money are allocated differently, with the user being informed of the allocation.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by sebastien_b on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:42PM (#24320668)
Dunno, probably not. But "everybody else does it too" isn't a good excuse to prohibit it.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by lacker on Saturday August 29, 2020 @07:38PM (#24320184)
It seems pretty obvious to me. Apple wants a user experience that makes the user happy with Apple products, not one where the app is complaining to the user about Apple policies. Apple is happy to prohibit zillions of random different things; they perceive the openness or fairness of their platform as much less important than user experience.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by CharlesW on Saturday August 29, 2020 @07:52PM (#24320234)
> It seems pretty obvious to me.

Me too. Absolutely no retailer, digital or physical, would allow anything like this.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by hetman on Saturday August 29, 2020 @07:51PM (#24320230)
But how does prohibiting disclosure of money distribution facilitate this?
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by jachee on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:00PM (#24320505)
It's keeping the users who have chosen Apple's products from being weaponized-via-guilt-trip against them.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by dane-pgp on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:14PM (#24320559)
So, the same reason that China doesn't have a free press, then?
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by jachee on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:29PM (#24326907)
Not a lot of people immigrating to China willingly for that analogy to hold up.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by dane-pgp on Sunday August 30, 2020 @07:46PM (#24327009)
Then perhaps a better example would be the UAE:

https://www.news.com.au/travel/destinations/middle-east/duba...

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by jachee on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @10:40PM (#24360361)
That's people getting scammed into migrant labor. Hardly a choice they'd make if they knew the facts.

I don't see a parallel to someone buying a premium device, at a premium price, expecting—and getting—a premium experience. Apple respects the trust their customers have afforded them, and rightfully keeps potentially-hostile third parties from detracting from that experience.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by m00x on Saturday August 29, 2020 @09:33PM (#24320636)
What if all apps did this? Isn't it just transparency?
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by jachee on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @10:43PM (#24360372)
Sure, it would be transparency.

Why don't they just break down how every percent is allocated?

How much is food? How much is electricity? How much is grey-market nootropics?

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by kstrauser on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:24PM (#24320857)
An analogy I heard:

What would Target do if their canned beans vendor started putting labels on the cans like "we sold this item for $0.23. Anything else is profit that your store is charging you."? Those cans would never see the shelves.

If, in effect, Apple buys a product from its vendor for $3.50 and then resells it for $5.00, keeping the difference as profit, I can understand their statement that the wholesale price is irrelevant and shouldn't be shown.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by tyoverby on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:44PM (#24320955)
> What would Target do if their canned beans vendor started putting labels on the cans like "we sold this item for $0.23. Anything else is profit that your store is charging you."? Those cans would never see the shelves.

Arizona Iced Tea does this and they're very successful.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by hoistbypetard on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:27PM (#24321130)
Arizona Iced Tea puts the suggested retail price on their cans. They do not disclose what price they charge to the retailer on the cans.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by smabie on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:13AM (#24321303)
Yeah but the implication is you should never pay more than 99 cents or whatever. Coke did the same thing, running advertisements about 5 cent Coke even though they couldn't control the actual price of a bottle of Coke. Worked really well apparently.

Also, I've never paid above 99 cents for Arizona. So it seems that worked as well.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by hoistbypetard on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:54PM (#24324536)
Books have printed the recommended price on the cover for decades. So have many snack foods.

It's very different than disclosing your revenue split on the packaging. Apple lets you set the price on your app store page. And no one will have to pay more. They would object if you mentioned your revenue split there.

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by TheJoeMan on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:51AM (#24321635)
Well every product I buy has a website address on the packaging, and often I can go there and buy it direct from manufacturer but I don’t see Publix banning beans anytime soon.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by sebastien_b on Sunday August 30, 2020 @03:30PM (#24325247)
>An analogy I heard:

>What would Target do if...

Again with the real-world mall/stores comparisons!

Does the beans vendor need to buy a machine from Target to manufacture the cans? Do they need to also pay a separate yearly fee to Target?

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by jasonhansel on Saturday August 29, 2020 @11:07PM (#24321050)
> “We know that these freedoms require protection,” [Tim] Cook said of First Amendment rights. “Not just the forms of speech that entertain us, but the ones that challenge us. The ones that unnerve and even displease us. They’re the ones that need protection the most.”

Source: https://9to5mac.com/2017/04/18/tim-cook-free-expression-awar...

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by nemothekid on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:03AM (#24321272)
>why is there a policy of prohibiting disclosure of how the money the user pays gets distributed

The same reason Visa doesn't let you let disclose to your customers that using your credit imposes a 3% fee to the merchant. People would use alternatives if they knew

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by mdoms on Sunday August 30, 2020 @01:04AM (#24321491)
Visa and Mastercard fees are absolutely disclosed to customers, as a matter of course. In fact Australia implemented a law a couple of years ago that retailers who pass the processing fee to customers must only charge the actual fee itself and not an arbitrary "CC fee" (some retailers had been charging ridiculous fees like $5 or 15% previously). So by law these fees must be available to the public.

https://www.accc.gov.au/media-release/excessive-payment-surc...

Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by smabie on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:07AM (#24321282)
They would? Why? I don't care what my merchant is paying in fees. I care about what I'm paying in fees.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by ThatPlayer on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:14AM (#24321309)
Yeah I don't know what he's talking about. A lot of places I've been to will give cash discounts. Or have minimum credit card orders
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by m463 on Sunday August 30, 2020 @12:56PM (#24324061)
I think there are all kinds of weird clauses added by apple, #1 being you can't disparage apple.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by sebastien_b on Sunday August 30, 2020 @03:25PM (#24325215)
Then those kinds of rules should apply both ways: Apple's can't disparage others either.
Re:Apple doesn't let you disclose their 30% IAP fee to your ... by epanchin on Sunday August 30, 2020 @03:40AM (#24321971)
Including your “answer”.