News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by sillysaurusx on Friday August 28, 2020 @08:24PM (#24312025)
Could you provide any info showing that Apple was definitely going to block all unreal engine powered iOS apps from the App Store? Ideally definitive evidence.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by madeofpalk on Friday August 28, 2020 @08:31PM (#24312089)
Apple was not going to explicitly block Unreal Engine from the App Store, but instead they were going to terminate a different Apple Developer Account that Epic uses for Unreal, hindering them from developing it on Apple platforms.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by sillysaurusx on Friday August 28, 2020 @08:40PM (#24312150)
Ah. Epic International. If apple has blocked that other account, would it have removed all Unreal Engine powered iOS apps from the App Store, just like all Epic games are now removed from the App Store?

I press this question because IMO that would be a serious tactical mistake on Apple’s part, and it’s surprising that Apple would make it (even incidentally). The judge’s injunction may have saved Apple from itself.

But I don’t know if it’s true that all UE iOS apps would be removed, if Apple terminated that other account. It seems like no one has given a concrete, conclusive answer.

It’s like blocking all apps that happen to use the leftpad library. It’s not those apps’ fault for what Epic is doing with Epic Store. It’s completely unrelated. And it would be worrisome if, by Apple’s decision, all businesses who built their futures on Unreal Engine were put out of business overnight.

Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by DRW_ on Friday August 28, 2020 @08:44PM (#24312176)
No. Even if Apple terminates the 'Epic International' account - nothing will happen to existing Unreal Engine games on the store by other developers.

The issue is that Epic will lose access to Apple developer tools and will struggle to maintain Unreal Engine going forward and as such that may hinder development of those games in the future.

There's no indication or reason to believe Apple would manually remove all UE based games (because it wouldn't be something they 'revoke' and all UE games stop working).

Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by cynix on Friday August 28, 2020 @09:28PM (#24312454)
Why would they struggle to maintain Unreal Engine? The developer tools/SDKs are free to download and you don’t need a developer account for that. All they will lose is access to pre-release tools such as betas or the Apple Silicon transition kit. It just means they might not have a release ready on launch day, but should be fine after that as the tools are made public.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by neurostimulant on Saturday August 29, 2020 @01:42AM (#24313902)
You can't even run a hello world app on iOS device without signing it with a developer account, and the restraining order that blocks apple from terminating epic international's developer account is just temporary. There is still chance that epic will lose developer account needed for developing unreal engine. You can run unsigned code on iOS simulator, but the simulator lacks many api and can't replace running on real devices (unlike Android emulator that can emulate almost everything a real device does).
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by rewq4321 on Saturday August 29, 2020 @04:27AM (#24314611)
> You can't even run a hello world app on iOS device without signing it with a developer account

What on Earth... Is this the same for Android? I come from the web, and this sounds like madness. You need to login to write code?

Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by floatboth on Saturday August 29, 2020 @05:19AM (#24314838)
No, on Android you can sideload anything. (Do you not use smartphones at all? How do you not know this?)

This hasn't been true for iOS either for the last N years, AFAIK you can sign apps for free to load on your devices, but the signatures are valid only for a week, so you have to reload the apps at least every week.

Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by neurostimulant on Saturday August 29, 2020 @05:34AM (#24314913)
> AFAIK you can sign apps for free to load on your devices, but the signatures are valid only for a week, so you have to reload the apps at least every week.

Guess where the key required for signing the binary comes from? That's right, it comes from your apple developer account, automatically downloaded and provisioned by xcode when you hit the build button. Without a developer account you won't have any valid key to sign the build, even for debug build. Afaik the only way to skip this is to jailbreak your device so it can run unsigned binary.

Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by dep_b on Saturday August 29, 2020 @10:39AM (#24316410)
To run on the simulator or build towards a simulator target you don't need anything.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by floatboth on Saturday August 29, 2020 @07:59AM (#24315485)
But this is with a free account you can register for anyone, with semi fake personal data even
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by mcdevilkiller on Saturday August 29, 2020 @05:17AM (#24314825)
It's not the login. They need to sign the binaries with that account, otherwise those won't run on an iOS device.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by javagram on Friday August 28, 2020 @09:40PM (#24312524)
The theory was that apple might revoke their ability to use the developer tools/SDKs (Broadly, this is what was stated in the letter saying their developer account would be revoked, even though you don’t need a paid developer account to download some of that stuff).

Xcode, the SDKs, etc. are licensed, not open source, and probably contain clauses allowing apple to terminate the license.

Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by Hamuko on Saturday August 29, 2020 @01:34AM (#24313869)
Beta versions of iOS and macOS are largely behind a developer paywall as well.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by jonny_eh on Friday August 28, 2020 @09:49PM (#24312579)
They wouldn't be able to publish OSX binaries.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by madeofpalk on Friday August 28, 2020 @08:45PM (#24312181)
No, all Unreal Engine apps wouldnt have been removed. But it would be harder for Epic to develop the engine, and other developers would be less inclined to use the engine knowing development would be impeded.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by neurostimulant on Friday August 28, 2020 @08:29PM (#24312069)
Well, how could Epic continue developing unreal engine for iOS without a developer account?
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by m4rtink on Friday August 28, 2020 @08:53PM (#24312224)
>Well, how could Epic continue developing unreal engine for iOS without a developer account? I thinl this nicely sumariges whats wrong - why the hell should one need an account somewhere to develop software for an OS!

Thats a totally arbitrary limitation and as nicely illustrated by Apple - very very dangerous.

Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by JiNCMG on Saturday August 29, 2020 @02:24AM (#24314081)
You need an account to develop for Xbox, Sony and Switch.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by m4rtink on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:52PM (#24338090)
Sure and while that's still bad IMHO, for general purpose devices this should simply not be required ever.

I can develop and distribute software for my tablet (Android), Notebook (Linux/Fedora), gaming PC (Windows), smartphone (Sailfish OS) or e-reader (Kobo) without the need to open an account with a third party and be at their mercy.

Sure, in some cases a repo system account can make things easier, but I can just as well put the source and binaries on a website and any users wanting to use that will not be needlessly hindered by stupid OS maintainer policies.

Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by DangitBobby on Saturday August 29, 2020 @03:28PM (#24318779)
The issue is not necessarily that you need an account, it's that punitive action is being taken against this other related account as a form of coercion/arbitrary punitive action. Imagine if your Gmail account was deleted because you made a nasty comment on YouTube. It would be a clear abuse of administrative power.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by m4rtink on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:47PM (#24338077)
IIRC the Gmail & Youtube example is actually true - they are all a single Google account and if it gets blocked due to one service, you loose everything.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by lights0123 on Friday August 28, 2020 @08:43PM (#24312169)
> Apple originally wanted to terminate the developer accounts of both Epic Games and Epic International, a separate account linked to Epic's Unreal Engine used by third-party app developers, but a judge issued a temporary restraining order preventing Apple from doing so.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by neurostimulant on Saturday August 29, 2020 @01:35AM (#24313873)
But this it just a temporary restraining order, right? Not final yet? Epic's future on apple ecosystem is not clear yet.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by floatboth on Saturday August 29, 2020 @05:20AM (#24314848)
Why would they need their own account to just develop the engine? They could use any employee's personal account, or a third party partner company's account, anything
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by neurostimulant on Saturday August 29, 2020 @05:47AM (#24314960)
Apple is know to cracking down abuse of developer accounts, so they could ended up playing cat and mouse game with apple. Also, the dev tools are probably licensed in a way that you can't use it legally after getting kicked out of apple dev program. Maybe epic can get around this by divesting unreal engine into a separate company. I think it's already done that (unreal is under epic international), but as apple was considering taking down epic international's account too, maybe that too is not enough.
Re:Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account by floatboth on Saturday August 29, 2020 @08:02AM (#24315504)
You can use Xcode and the SDKs without even having an account! A free account is required to sign code temporarily to run on test devices. Apple shouldn't even get to know what is being signed.

Apple might be cracking down on people who sign apps for others as a service, publish signed stuff online, etc. but they literally have no way of preventing development of anything.