No, but that doesn't preclude us from stopping Uber and Lyft. We can have a different system where there are no medallions, the number of cars aren't artificially constrained, but the companies running them need to obey existing laws.
Well let's not act like "existing laws" are the most important factor. The laws were changed here, after all!
I'd like to see a system where drivers have a lot of control over when they work, and can be in both apps at once, but also have healthcare and the ability to access unemployment insurance. Even though as far as I'm aware it's not feasible under existing law.
Which laws? Do they exist now?
The only reason why the laws changed at all was because of Uber and Lyft.
Nobody would have changed the system if they didn't come in.
I really really hope that you fail. Thanks to Uber, my wife can enjoy safe and reliable transportation. But some whiteknighting woke people cannot tolerate that, I guess they hate women? Oh wait, my wife is an evil capitalist who's exploiting poor User drivers, right? How ironic
Why?
Also, if we're doing this, let's also artificially constrain something else, maybe the amount of meat produced, and auction the right to sell meat to few highest bidders? After all, meat production has a lot externalities like methane emissions, etc etc., so why not constrain it?
Then, we must prevent exploitation of poor underpaid workers in Bangladesh, so let's restrict clothes supply, to reduce harmful externalities. Two pairs of basic jeans and 3 shirts should be enough for everyone, right?
I agree with disrupting the medallion system but the cost of rides fell dramatically and by most accounts I can find if drivers actually did their taxes correctly, they would be making less than minimum wage[0]
[0]https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation-now/2018/03/02/ub...
Why keep driving if the wages are so low? Also, in the medallion days it wasn't uncommon for drivers to end up in the red after a bad day, when factoring the costs of renting the medallion in the first place.
I dunno, going through some forum threads on UberPeople shows exact opposite - drivers meticulously track their take, expenses, etc. - there is even a cottage industry of tools giving them all sorts of data analytics in exchange for the ride data.
Anecdotally, I’ve seen one driver keep a spreadsheet of various gasoline brands and his mpg (my destination was near Costco and I casually suggested he use it to refuel, and got an earful on how Costco was in his top 5, but not the best options to refuel).
There are still good reasons to drive below minimum wage.
I'm probably leaving money on the table with my retirement savings - perhaps there are lower cost funds or tax-loss harvesting I could be doing if I spent hours each week reading personal finance blogs. That doesn't mean I'm an idiot, and it's the same with drivers who don't necessarily calculate wear and depreciation for every last mile.
My favorite group are all the liberal tech writers, the majority of which fell under AB5 and are now freaking out too.
Unintended consequences are often far more damaging than just letting markets sort things out.
And who says making less than minimum wage is always a bad thing? A lot of people drive for these services as supplemental income. It’s NOT their primary income, yet all your arguments are coming solely from that perspective.
How presumptive of you.
You want to help these people out? Get rid of most occupational licensing.
[1] https://investor.uber.com/news-events/news/press-release-det...
Pre-Uber, either the driver rented the car to a middleman who rented the medallion from a rich owner, or said owner was selling and financing (most banks won't touch these medallions!) a medallion at a ridiculous interest rate to a driver that planned to use it as his retirement savings (an extremely volatile asset and not very liquid).
The more I spoke to cab drivers the more it seemed their industry was a pyramid schemed aimed at helping established rent-seeker take advantage of often poor new immigrants. Uber brought a breeze of fresh air: Someone could simply buy a car, calculate the depreciation and it's value on the market (since unlike medallions cars are relatively liquid assets!) do rideshare and calculate their profits or loss. They can get out of the game at anytime, and they know exactly how much they are going to get for the car they have should they sell it.
Also, the argument on Uber/Lyft drivers not being contractors since they can't set their own rates and decide which ride they take strikes me as weird since medallion drivers were contractors, had to charge the price set by the city and could only pick-up customers in the (arbitrary) zones covered by their medallions.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24225648