News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by bigtones on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:41PM (#24151257)
The real reason Epic Games did this... Money - they were forced to hand over more than $500 Million dollars to Apple and Google in the past 12 months alone. That's $1.3 Million dollars per day.

Epic gave Apple over $360 Million dollars in the last twelve months just to list the game in it's app store, and over $150 Million to Google to do the same. By any measure, having to hand over half a billion dollars is just an insane cut of revenue to have to give two companies that had absolutely nothing to do with conceiving, designing or developing such a successful game.

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/13/technology/apple-fortnite...

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by Ductapemaster on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:14PM (#24151600)
"...absolutely nothing to do with conceiving, designing or developing such a successful game."

But it has everything to do with distributing the game. Also it has a lot to do with outsourcing the maintenance of the mobile platforms — designing hardware, OS releases, etc. Epic did not design their own hardware, their own silicon, build entire global supply chains, design UX, etc. Apple and Google did. Do they not deserve a cut?

I'm not here arguing the percentage of the revenue, just that that some percentage is clearly warranted here. Their relationship with Apple and Google is clearly a partnership, meaning it has to benefit both sides. Same way it works with consoles.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by _qulr on Thursday August 13, 2020 @09:56PM (#24152311)
Apple's expensive hardware pays for itself, and for the operating system. That's the way it's always been, since 1976. Third party software helps sell Apple's hardware, so in that sense it's always been mutually beneficial, while each side remained independent financially. The App Store in 2008 was an unfortunate change in this relationship, making it too one-sided.

Google didn't even invent Android, they purchased it. (Of course Apple purchased NeXTSTEP too.) And Google is not even the biggest Android hardware manufacturer.

The bizarre thing is that most apps on both iOS and Android are free, so they pay very little for the so-called "maintenance", even if these apps are hugely popular. This is very different from a game console, where every game earns money directly. Fortnite is hugely popular, but for some reason struggling little indie paid apps are forced to subsidize the platform for immensely popular free apps?

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by _qulr on Thursday August 13, 2020 @09:59PM (#24152332)
Apple actually bragged in their response to Spotify that 84% of the apps on the App Store were free.

Imagine a game console where 84% of the games were free. We can't compare these platforms to consoles.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by mrguyorama on Friday August 14, 2020 @11:58AM (#24159604)
Ah yes, I'd love a game console where half the library was free fart apps that try to steal my data or show me ads.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by ggggtez on Thursday August 13, 2020 @10:35PM (#24152576)
Ahem... PC.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by _qulr on Thursday August 13, 2020 @11:00PM (#24152754)
I don't understand this reply.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by chrisjc on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:43PM (#24160881)
Perhaps they mean you can pirate pretty easily on PC?
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by justanotheranon on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:21AM (#24153336)
why has it become normalized to accept iPhones and Android as locked down computers where we are all rental peasants whove sworn fealty to our Feif Lords?

the computing culture from the PC era (1990's-2006) has been utterly destroyed. a computer used to be a thing you owned and which you therefore controlled like any physical property. install any software you want. you own it, so you dont have to keep plugging quarters into it like an arcade game. but not the phone. even though a cheap phone is a supercomputer compared to a high end gaming PC from 20 years ago.

everything Richard Stallman predicted 40 years ago about the worst case scenario outcome of propietary software has come true. the computing revolution was originally about empowering the user. information wants to be FREE. slowly we lost that, and now everything is about how much money can our corporate overlords squeeze out of us.

I FIGHT FOR THE USER

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by Ductapemaster on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:35AM (#24153466)
I respect your adherence to your beliefs and that you are ready to stand up for your side. However, I think the thing that you’ve missed here is that not all users are the same.

Many many other highly technical folks on this website agree with your points and would side with you if it came down to it. However, that group of people (and surely the other groups who feel the same way) only represent a microcosm of the total user base for a device like a smartphone.

Millions and millions of people didn’t buy their phone because they wanted a handheld general purpose computer to tinker with and install any software on. They purchased their devices simply for the utility, the access to content, and user experience they provide.

The systems and businesses that create each of those sides are very different, and misaligned in terms of the freedom you wish to have. Apple has chosen to fight for what they view is an optimal user experience for their target market.

I pose a question: can the two expressions of technology not exist together? Not on the same device, but in the same world as separate entities?

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by wvenable on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:27PM (#24151706)
> But it has everything to do with distributing the game.

Because they're the only option. I mean there's no reason why Epic couldn't host the app on their server that people could download. It's not without precedent. But it's just not allowed for mobile.

> designing hardware, OS releases, etc. Epic did not design their own hardware, their own silicon, build entire global supply chains, design UX, etc. Apple and Google did. Do they not deserve a cut?

Seriously? You think Epic should have to pay for the hardware that we consumers buy for thousands of dollars? Apple has some of the highest hardware margins in the world. They don't need software developers to pay for the hardware that we've already paid too much for. These aren't consoles sold for a loss.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by interpol_p on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:38PM (#24151803)
> Because they're the only option. I mean there's no reason why Epic couldn't host the app on their server that people could download. It's not without precedent. But it's just not allowed for mobile.

Didn't they move to the Google Play Store (from their own download manager) specifically because sideloading was too hard and scary for customers that it was having an impact on Fortnite installs?

Having the option wouldn't be enough for Epic even if it were available on iOS, because it wasn't enough for them on Android

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by scarface74 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @09:33PM (#24152162)
Especially when the very thing that Google warns about actually happened...with Fortnite.

https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-fo...

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by wvenable on Thursday August 13, 2020 @09:44PM (#24152242)
Well Google specifically doesn't make it easy or safe to install apps from other sources. But there's no reason why it couldn't be just as simple and safe as getting it from the app store.

The problems mentioned below are really only possible because Google kind of leaves everyone to the wolves when it comes to sideloading.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by interpol_p on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:14AM (#24153869)
Epic's quote at the time was the following:

> Google puts software downloadable outside of Google Play at a disadvantage, through technical and business measures such as scary, repetitive security pop-ups for downloaded and updated software, restrictive manufacturer and carrier agreements and dealings, Google public relations characterizing third party software sources as malware, and new efforts such as Google Play Protect to outright block software obtained outside the Google Play store.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by threeseed on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:31PM (#24151754)
> You think Epic should have to pay for the hardware that we consumers buy for thousands of dollars? Apple has some of the highest hardware margins in the world

Sure. If they want to complain about the cost of using someone else's hardware.

Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft etc do it.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by Panini_Jones on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:27PM (#24151708)
> Epic did not design their own hardware, their own silicon, build entire global supply chains, design UX, etc. Apple and Google did. Do they not deserve a cut?

Where did the $1k I spent on my phone go?

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by Ductapemaster on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:22AM (#24153343)
Fair point. From the way I see it, Apple is not a traditional hardware company, persay. It’s not like buying a PC from Dell. Dell sells hardware, and just that.

The difference is Apple sells a user experience. Sure, you have to purcahase a physical thing to access that experience, but that is the nature of what you have purchased when you buy an iPhone.

I think this boils down to a mismatched set of perspectives on the business Apple has created. Apple breaks the typical “buy hardware from X, install software from Y” flow and instead turned their iPhones into a portal into their own user experience universe. They did this because it provides a fundamentally unique experience when compared to other platforms. It’s a differentiating factor for them. Again, I would argue that Apple doesn’t want to be a hardware company. They want to be an experience company. In order to do that, they have to develop and sell cutting-edge hardware to you and me.

Don’t get me wrong, not trying to say this is good or bad — just observing a sublety that I think gets missed when passionately arguing about hardware ownership and the rights that come with it.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by yazaddaruvala on Thursday August 13, 2020 @09:53PM (#24152301)
$1k is what I'm willing to pay for that hardware knowing it is "locked down". I prefer the convenience of the "walled garden".

If you or any customer feels like the hardware's capabilities (i.e. no side-loading) was miss-advertised, I would highly urge them to return the hardware to Apple, sell it, or at the least not re-buy an iPhone next time.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by Panini_Jones on Thursday August 13, 2020 @10:24PM (#24152496)
I'm responding to the argument that the service fees pay for the hardware. No, my $1k paid for the hardware.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by zepto on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:12AM (#24153857)
The service fees pay for the service, but part of that is in the OS which you received with the hardware, but which continues to be updated.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by harry8 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:22PM (#24151673)
A unit fee for each distribuion of a couple of cents is warranted here and NO MORE than that. And it should be a flat fee for each unit be it 1 unit of a billion unit. Possibly with volume discounts if there were any variation in that pricing.

Apple and Google are claiming the right to tax the success of others as though they were nation states and had been granted that right by popular mandate.

A percentage? Of revenue? From companies that refuse to pay a percentage of profit in acutal tax to governments who actually do have that mandate to impose the tax.

Evil is what evil does. Call it out.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by threeseed on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:30PM (#24151735)
This vitriol is pretty hilarious. Do you actually understand how business works ?

If you sell a product through ANY distribution channel whether it be online, brick/mortar store, influencers etc you need to pay a fee. It's been this way for centuries.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by dahfizz on Thursday August 13, 2020 @09:45PM (#24152252)
> If you sell a product through ANY distribution channel ... you need to pay a fee.

This is literally what OP is arguing for...

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by cma on Thursday August 13, 2020 @10:30PM (#24152531)
Should your monitor and hard drive companies take a cut of every software purchase you make? Nvidia?
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by Ductapemaster on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:27AM (#24153383)
I see where you are going here, but neither of those items (nor any independent of a comptuer) provides the same utility as an iPhone.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by cma on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:48PM (#24163068)
Should your laptop with 4g modem take a 30% cut?
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by georgespencer on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:02PM (#24151504)
> By any measure, having to hand over half a billion dollars is just an insane cut of revenue to have to give two companies that had absolutely nothing to do with conceiving, designing or developing such a successful game.

Uh, you know Epic makes a 12% cut of all games sold in their store, right?

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by cochne on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:13PM (#24151589)
I think the distinguishing factor here is you can distribute your game to any computer without the epic game store. Imagine if the epic game store was the only way to distribute it :)
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by georgespencer on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:18PM (#24151634)
Parent said that it was unfair for Apple to make money from a game that they had no hand in creating:

> By any measure, having to hand over half a billion dollars is just an insane cut of revenue to have to give two companies that had absolutely nothing to do with conceiving, designing or developing such a successful game.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by user5994461 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:44PM (#24151850)
Actually this makes me realize, I don't think that statement is true.

Epic Games probably got help from Apple to port their game and their engine to iOS. I somehow doubt they did all the work with zero assistance from Apple, it's a whole game engine deeply tied and optimized to the system. They'd probably work with Apple just like they work with Sony/Microsoft on consoles.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by DivisionSol on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:19PM (#24151641)
I think this argument is on shaky ground when Epic Game Store can only be installed on Windows. Rocket League lost MacOS/Linux support when absorbed into the Epic Game Store. Imagine if Windows was the only way to distribute games.

Further, if you want to target mobile devices, you can distribute on Android.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by georgespencer on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:31PM (#24151750)
It's funny that even on a platform where it's possible to distribute software for free by other means, like Windows, Epic charges 12% to do it on their store.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by turndown on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:16PM (#24151619)
All companies are hypocrits, but I will say that the difference here is that there are other options if you want to publish your game - as I'm sure you know. If Apple offered other avenues for publishing apps then I think there would be no leg to stand on i.r.t their fees. Of course, this also glosses over the fact that Apple controls the platform and thus has to be judged differently.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by georgespencer on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:25PM (#24151694)
> If Apple offered other avenues for publishing apps then I think there would be no leg to stand on i.r.t their fees

People are making it seem as if Epic is an underdog with no options here. They make hundreds of millions of dollars from distributing Fortnite on the app store -- and it's a free download. Apple doesn't make a cent from helping to market and distribute this game (and I'd imagine 90% of users are free only).

Epic has the following choices:

1. Don't offer IAP at all

2. Offer microtransactions via web browser

3. Accept Apple taking the 30% cut of current pricing

4. Increase their pricing to accommodate Apple's cut

5. Withdraw the app

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by turndown on Thursday August 13, 2020 @09:44PM (#24152243)
Of course, there is a sixth option, in which they sue Apple for their behavior ;). Regardless, Epic is the underdog here, because they are at the beck and call of Apple no matter how you view the situation: Apple controls everything.

Also, I disagree that a person/company that runs a platform is entitled to being able to run the only native app store simply because. Want to know why Apple has set up the App Store in the way that they have? Because it is most beneficial to them that way. This doesn't mean that we have to tolerate it so.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by georgespencer on Thursday August 13, 2020 @10:24PM (#24152495)
> Apple controls everything

Epic can walk away and deprive Apple of hundreds of millions of dollars of revenue. Epic can increase their prices. Epic can accept the margins.

> I disagree that a person/company that runs a platform is entitled to being able to run the only native app store simply because

It's not "simply because". It's demonstrably a superior experience for consumers.

> Want to know why Apple has set up the App Store in the way that they have? Because it's most beneficial to them that way.

I'm a former Apple employee and I can tell you that this is true insofar as it's beneficial to Apple to not have shitty apps, viruses, and malware on iPhone.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by turndown on Thursday August 13, 2020 @11:25PM (#24152940)
>Epic can walk away and deprive Apple of hundreds of millions of dollars of revenue. Epic can increase their prices. Epic can accept the margins.

And Apple could be honest brokers and not skim off the top of something they are only superficially entitled to in the first place. We can go back and forth offering our "perfect world" options all day. Both companies have options which solve this problem unilaterally, neither will take them since there is so much money involved.

>It's not "simply because". It's demonstrably a superior experience for consumers.

OK, then the demonstrably best policy for Apple is to both provide a safe platform for consumers which somehow doesn't involve price gouging the people that provide software for their platform. I do not advocate separate stores, I only mention alternative stores as a method to headoff these issues while conserving their current skimming policies. Removing the skimming policies is far superior, clearly, for the reasons you mention.

>I'm a former Apple employee and I can tell you that this is true insofar as it's beneficial to Apple to not have shitty apps, viruses, and malware on iPhone.

The idea, though, that "massive profits" didn't enter into the minds of of those who set these policies, whether as a first or last reason, is not realisitc. Apple literally makes hundreds of millions of dollars off of a product they had 0 to do with developmentally; don't try to tell me they do this in the name of not having shitty apps, viruses, or malware. They do it to profit off of it.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by georgespencer on Friday August 14, 2020 @06:01AM (#24155940)
It feels like quite a lot of your points here are either highly subjective or coming from a bad faith position. It's not a criticism -- you're super articulate and you are being generous with your time and in explaining things to me, so thank you. But for example:

> Apple could be honest brokers

There is nothing dishonest about what Apple is doing, as far as I can see.

> superficially entitled to

I went to some lengths to imagine the infrastructure costs Apple experiences for the App Store here.[1] People seem to quite quickly move from a position of "Apple does nothing to merit a cut of revenue from their marketplace" to "Apple doesn't deserve that much revenue" which again feels subjective.

> neither will take them since there is so much money involved

And because neither side has done anything materially wrong in my opinion. Epic is, I guess, within its rights to openly try to break the rules of the app store and then file a law suit when their game is pulled. It's tough for me to imagine that they're coming at this from "above the line" because they released a fucking video about it minutes after the suit was filed, but whatever. Apple is within its rights to pull the game, contest the law suit, win, and continue charging 30%.

> OK, then the demonstrably best policy for Apple is to both provide a safe platform for consumers which somehow doesn't involve price gouging the people that provide software for their platform.

This is not price gouging as far as I can tell. That would be opportunistic pricing which the developer or consumer has no option but to pay. (In the US the term has been in the media a lot lately because of toilet paper pricing after quarantine started.) For more than a decade, Apple has had the same policy of a 30% cut from IAP in its marketplace. Epic has been on Apple's platform for a while and accepted these charges, and (just checked) charged more for V-Bucks on iOS than PC. I think they were aware of the situation, and again they've earned hundreds of millions of dollars from the arrangement.

> Removing the skimming policies is far superior, clearly, for the reasons you mention.

Again this is not skimming. It is totally fair for Apple to charge a fee for an app to appear in its marketplace. I don't think even you believe that they should charge nothing at all, I think you just disagree with the cut that they take, right?

> The idea, though, that "massive profits" didn't enter into the minds of of those who set these policies, whether as a first or last reason, is not realistic.

The genesis of the App Store is pretty well known: Steve resisted it, hated the idea, wanted people to build web apps (which Epic still can, and can charge as much as they like for with Apple making nothing from). He was eventually persuaded by his exec team and at the announcement he said:

"We don’t intend to make any money off the App Store. We’re basically giving all the money to the developers and the 30 percent that pays for running the store, that’ll be great."

So: the policy was set pre-launch. I think it's clear that nobody at Apple expected it to get this big ("Maybe it'll be a billion dollar marketplace some day" sounds so quaint now, looking at $50bn of payouts to developers in 2019).

What you could accuse Apple of is sizing their 30% fee proportionately to their expected transaction volume (e.g. "We think it'll do $1bn in transactions at maturity, so we'll get $300m a year. That's enough to pay for all the infrastructure and give us a margin for error.") and then not changing that fee even after the proceeds from the store becamse so great that they outstripped the increase in costs ("We do $50bn of business a year and now make $15bn in revenue from our cut. Our infrastructure costs are far higher than we initially anticipated, but we're making way more money than we ever thought we would.").

But what's clear is that the policy was not incepted in bad faith, has not been changed to reflect the massive growth in the store (other than reducing Y2 subscription rake), and is totally consistent with the prices other marketplaces charge.

> Apple literally makes hundreds of millions of dollars off of a product they had 0 to do with developmentally

Which is exactly how marketplaces work. If you want to sell your product to the folks in this store, you pay the fee that the market sets. The great news is that if you don't want to pay Apple's 30% fee, you can distribute your app in other people's stores on other platforms (PS4, Xbox, Switch Store), allow people to install it directly where the computing device is open (Android phones, Windows), or through your own store (Epic Store).

Reverse the situation and pretend for a sec that Apple can't get any revenue from the App Store. Their arguments would be that Epic uses them for distribution, updates, tech support, app review, and that Apple incurs all of the cost of acquiring iPhone customers. Epic is making hundreds of millions of dollars from the success of a platform and store that they had 0 to do with developmentally.

Neither is true: Apple has helped Epic, and Epic has helped Apple. Everyone has a different interpretation of the value derived from both sides of the arrangement, but the only job the courts have is determining whether Apple has either created and then abused monopoly power (very unlikely I think) or is guilty of some other antitrust breach.

> don't try to tell me they do this in the name of not having shitty apps, viruses, or malware. They do it to profit off of it.

They really do. Imagine a fictional regulator gives Apple two choices:

1. Be the only App Store on the platform, exactly the same as today, but the store must be a proper not-for-profit (so Apple doesn't lose money in any area -- even things like the apportionment of App Store revenue which contributes to marketing) -- let's say $500m of revenue,

or

2. Be one of many App Stores on the platform, and make exactly the same revenue as they do today ($15bn revenue per year) with the same margins, and let developers distribute apps any way they please,

Apple will absolutely pick option 1 every day of the week, and twice on Sundays. The moment the iPhone becomes complex, more susceptible to viruses, or less secure in the eyes of its users, it becomes much less valuable and they lose money hand over fist in hardware sales.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24151913

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by turndown on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:46PM (#24163050)
I agree that what we are arguing here is subjective, if only because in this portion of business there is little that is clear cut.

Ideally, Apple would charge a fee proportional to what it costs to hosts the apps on their store, software vetting, etc. I do not think that having no charge is realisitc, in that expecting Apple to pay for all of that is not sustainable, or fair. That said, a 30% fee approaches price gouging when other stores charge around %3, if the Epic filing papers are accurate in this regard.

If you, as a developer, pay ~$200M to Apple for the simple right of access to a market, along with other niceties the App Store may provide, it is hard to say that you help Apple out and they help you out, since the disparity in gain is so large.

I don't disagree that Apple has other incentives for their App Store, only that in this case, and in many others like it, the overwhelming focus is on the revenue stream. $15B is nothing to sniff at.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by georgespencer on Saturday August 15, 2020 @08:22AM (#24168362)
> Ideally, Apple would charge a fee proportional to what it costs to host the apps on their store, software vetting, etc.

Presumably Apple believes it's proportional, but doesn't share their cost base, and many people think it's disproportional, without seeing the cost base.

We get into shaky ground here IMO. Imagine it's possible to distil the app store into a single P&L (it's not because it touches so many aspects of Apple's revenue halo), and it ends up as an endeavour which looks something like this for Apple:

  Revenue:
  GMV           $50bn
  Net revenue   $15bn

  Costs:
  People        ($100m)
  Hosting & IT  ($450m)
  Overheads     ($75m)
  --
  Net profit     $14.375bn
  Net margin     95.8%

A 95.8% net margin is presumably something you consider to be usury. If you change Apple's cut to 3%:

  Revenue:
  GMV           $50bn
  Net revenue   $1.5bn

  Costs:
  People        ($100m)
  Hosting & IT  ($450m)
  Overheads     ($75m)
  --
  Net profit     $875m
  Net margin     58%
Is that now too much? What if Apple is able to reduce its overheads by a factor of ten, and they move to c. $65m which pushes margin to 99%?

What if Apple isn't willing to make concessions on healthcare plans or working conditions which 3% marketplaces are?

How do you -- and how does anyone -- make determinations about what is appropriate here?

For me the nail in the coffin for this line of argument is: we've done the exercise of supposing that we can distil one specific aspect of Apple's business into an isolated P&L. Now do the same thing for Fortnite.

What margin do Epic make on IAPs? We know it's 70% on the app store + whatever the tiny, tiny cost is of the few people making the texture packs and models which kids buy in droves (billions of dollars). I'd imagine that if you consider the revenue they take before their payment to Apple as "GMV" and then do a margin analysis on their net revenue, you end up with % margin getting towards Apple's levels for the App Store.

So: can I sue Epic and force my own content, using my own payment infrastructure, into their game? They have a 100% monopoly on loot sold in-game in Fortnite right? They're charging users predatory prices when you look at the margins they make.

Nobody seems to be able to specifically quantify what's unfair here. I'm not criticising you but I don't see in any argument a clear articulation of what Apple does which is unfair in a way that is easily remedied throughout the software world (i.e. what % rake are Epic paying on Xbox store?)

> If you, as a developer, pay $200m to Apple for the simple right of access to a market

From the interaction we've had I have found you to be really articulate and bright, and this seems like a very basic misrepresentation: it's not paying for right of access to a market. Fortnite made $2m USD per day on the day it launched to Apple's customers on the app store. They also became Epic's customers, but when we talk about a "disparity in gain", Epic is making $1.4m USD per day that they weren't making before.

> the overwhelming focus is on the revenue stream

I think we agree on this but on slightly different terms: Apple prioritises its overall revenue, and I would imagine that if regulators tell it to either reduce their cut or face adding other app stores or alternative payment methods into the existing app store if they want to keep their 30% cut, they will preserve the user experience and reduce their cut.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by wccrawford on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:21PM (#24151658)
Not all games. If you make the game with Unreal Engine, it's free.

UE4 itself is free until you make $1mil lifetime per game, and then 5% after that, IIRC.

But unlike Google and Apple's store, there are plenty of other stores on Windows, and making your own store is really easy. It can literally just be a website with downloads.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by georgespencer on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:29PM (#24151724)
OP's point is that it's unfair for Apple to take a cut when they didn't have anything to do with creating the game.

My point is that Epic does the same thing.

Apple created the app store. The iPhone brand is built on security, reliability, and ease of use. I can completely understand why Apple strongly resists people trying to disrupt that. It's not in Apple's interests because it'll diminish the appeal of their devices, and it's not in consumer interests either.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by wccrawford on Friday August 14, 2020 @06:32AM (#24156141)
Apple is providing a service that distributes the game and does some marketing for it. If you want to use that service, it's fair that Apple gets some cut, and I'm okay with them setting how large that cut is.

What is not fair is that they are the only service allowed on Apple devices. They place themselves in a situation where they can set the cut without any negotiation allowed.

I find Google's situation more fair (because it's at least possible to load apps/games with other stores or no store at all), but they still actively work against third-party stores by degrading the experience that the user has with those stores compared to Play's store.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by georgespencer on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:41AM (#24158520)
> If you want to use that service, it's fair that Apple gets some cut, and I'm OK with them setting how large that cut is

So you draw a distinction between the fairness of Apple making money from your use of their marketplace and the fairness of Apple making money from your use of their device? I don't see it. Apple made the app store and you think it's fair that if you want to use it you should pay. Apple makes the iPhone but it should not be the case that if you want to use it you should pay?

What if alternative app stores on iPhone had to pay a 30% cut of all revenue to Apple?

> What is not fair is that they are the only service allowed

Are you at risk of conflating 'equal' and 'fair'? It's definitely not equal, but it doesn't seem unfair to me. It seems fair that Apple should be able to build a platform they would want to use and ensure that it is safe, secure, and held to the standards they like.

There is a good analogy here around sovereignty of nations. One common legal argument for war is that a nation has violated its own sovereignty somehow -- usually by attacking another or hurting its own population.

Apple the Nation has a high tax rate for corporations and individuals who live there. It is non-negotiable and there is no way around it. But citizens can come and go freely, and if they are unhappy living in Apple land they can move to a different country.

What is it that makes Apple's behaviour unfair?

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by Aissen on Saturday August 15, 2020 @05:48PM (#24172716)
You know 12% is much smaller than 30%, right?
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by redm on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:03PM (#24151510)
They develop the platform, including the API's, the toolkits, X-Code, updates, and the stores themselves (bandwidth billing etc). I wouldn't say they do nothing. Putting a value on that is harder, but you at least have to look at what they provide holistically. Its not just the app store.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by Panini_Jones on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:29PM (#24151719)
Quick question: Do console developers like XBox and the Switch take ~30% cuts of every game sold for their platform? Genuinely curious.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by threeseed on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:36PM (#24151792)
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by Panini_Jones on Thursday August 13, 2020 @10:26PM (#24152511)
That article mentions publishers but not Nintendo specifically at all AFAICT. Is Nintendo considered a publisher?
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by grogenaut on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:04AM (#24153219)
Nintendo is a publisher.

Also publishers FUND your game as well which is why they take a larger cut, like how a vc would.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by vitaflo on Thursday August 13, 2020 @11:10PM (#24152831)
Yes, the norm everywhere is 30%. It's 30% on Steam, PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo eShop, etc. Only Epic's store is less (12%).

https://www.ign.com/articles/2019/10/07/report-steams-30-cut...

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by handmodel on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:28PM (#24151718)
I've always wanted to see a breakdown of Apple's value just based on the apps. For instance, Apple gets 30% of all money Tinder brings in. Tinder has to spend a lot of money on engineers and hosting the app - but Apple has close to no cost for this. If MTCH is worth 30B dollars based on apps that will indefinitely pay Apple 30% - how much extra market cap can you assign to Apple based solely on this? It must be at least 10 billion. Same must go for Fornite and dozens of other apps that gross huge numbers.

(I know Tinder is on other phones and the percentage could change - but you get the idea).

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by hn_check on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:04PM (#24151514)
"Epic gave Apple over $360 Million dollars in the last twelve months just to list the game in it's app store"

The stat you cited was for two years, not one. Further, they paid $99 for a developer account "just to list the game" (and any other games they want to list). The fees you are mentioning are only for transactions that occurred on the Apple device. Their "v-bucks" can be bought on other platforms and are cross platform (for some platforms - Switch and PS4 do not allow cross-platform in-game currency). But strangely Fortnite gave no discount on their Windows app, for instance... (almost like they set up this whole ridiculous charade just to play the crowd).

Now add that anyone assuming Apple is actually getting that full 30% is deluded. Apple sells iTunes cards at Costco often $100 for ~$80. They have lubricated the market to encourage grandparents, etc, to give their relatives gift cards, and created a system where people feel confident enough to buy. Those gift cards become vbux. Without Apple's and Google's system, they would never have made a fraction of what they've made.

I hardly think Apple is innocent in this -- their position on cloud gaming is absolutely wrong -- but the horde that is suddenly falling in line behind Epic is uproarious. Sweeney is playing this crowd like a fiddle.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by DivisionSol on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:48PM (#24151343)
But did have everything to do with developing the hardware capable of running the game on a handheld device?
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by sturgill on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:51PM (#24151386)
Which they then “sold” to an end user. (Scare quotes because my I don’t believe for a second my iPhone belongs to me; but Apple is kind enough to rent it to me...)
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by kohtatsu on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:41PM (#24151820)
That's a pretty cynical outlook imo, these aren't the new John Deere tractors.

If/when my 11P EOL's half-way through the 20's I hope we'll have good enough homebrews to get Linux running like people do now on the 7.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by ifmpx on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:10AM (#24153261)
I think it's a fair take given how locked down these devices are. Until I can install any software I want on my phone, it's not really my phone.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by eganist on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:50PM (#24151367)
You say this as if the devices don't have profit margins and the companies aren't constantly adding to their cashpiles.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by DivisionSol on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:58PM (#24151464)
They're tacking on a recurring revenue stream (App Store) onto their one-time sale (iPhone). Margins on both fund the innovation machine.

Also, with the outrage over companies needing to layoff/cut hours during(now) Covid-19 because they didn't have a warchest saved up... Having a cashpile seems like a fiscally responsible thing to do for a company.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by eganist on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:01PM (#24151493)
> They're tacking on a recurring revenue stream (App Store) onto their one-time sale (iPhone). Margins on both fund the innovation machine.

How does Samsung's devices division manage it?

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by user5994461 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:18PM (#24151637)
Samsung put together hardware to make a phone. They don't develop the software (OS, API, directX equivalent, iCloud/GoogleDrive, etc...). It's maybe one tenth of what Apple does all things considered.

edit: Samsung does a bit of software, trying to push its own applications with subscriptions and bundling crapware pre installed with the phone.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by m4rtink on Thursday August 13, 2020 @10:21PM (#24152466)
IIRC Samsung is the author and main contributor to the F2FS filesystem used on many Android devices, so the do contribute, even to low level core functionality.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by eganist on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:21PM (#24151661)
> Samsung put together hardware to make a phone. They don't develop the software (OS, API, directX equivalent, iCloud/GoogleDrive, etc...).

Precisely, and they also profit off the phone.

And yet Apple double-profits off both the phone and the apps, and they shovel the cash away.

The protest by these companies is entirely sound.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by user5994461 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:31PM (#24151752)
Apple provides the entirety of the operating system, API, directX equivalent for games, complete set of development and debugging tools, authentication and much more.

If Samsung were to make a whole development and gaming platform, they would charge developers on their platform too. and they'd really need the money because that's truly a ton of work.

The protest is only about the service fee, 30% is too much.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by zepto on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:16AM (#24153892)
Not to mention that their cashpile is a hedge against very serious geopolitical risk, which Apple are taking making and distributing a device globally.

Is Epic taking that risk, or doing any of that work to reach this vast market?

No.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by ashtonkem on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:20PM (#24151655)
There is no concept of a “fair” margin beyond which companies may not charge more.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by zepto on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:10AM (#24153836)
This isn’t an accurate representation.

Epic gave nothing to Apple. Apple gave Epic $840 in proceeds from sales it couldn’t have made without Apple’s work.

I think you know that the margins Apple charges for the apps they retail are not a listing fee, and pay for a significant collection of services.

I’m not commenting on whether Apple’s margin is too high or not. Just that this comment is a misrepresentation.

Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by efficax on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:57PM (#24151452)
jesus christ they're clearing 1.25 billion+ a year on v-bucks????
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by ecf on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:14PM (#24160510)
Epic Games has absolutely no moral authority here as long as they charge a royalty fee to games made with their Unreal Engine.
Re:Fortnite seems to have been removed from the Play Store a... by ctdonath on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:41PM (#24151822)
And how hard is it for Epic to sell in-game v-bucks?

And Epic is making how much ... off what, beyond the game itself?