Long term society by establishing that Uber doesn't get to write the law and dodge their responsibility as an employer. It's about time they get knocked down a notch after their campaign against DeBlasio.
Right now is a terrible time to wipe out the gig economy. So many people are turning to it and it is creating value. Economic/employment changes like this one are best suited when the market is strong because people job mobility is higher etc.
The court doesn't have an option to "wait" just because it's a recession.
Uber doesn't have a choice to "wait" because this ruling is going to go into effect in ~10 days unless the stay is extended.
[0] - https://scocal.stanford.edu/opinion/dynamex-operations-west-...
If you drive delivering beverages, whether you're an employee or contractor under AB5 depends on whether or not that beverage is milk.
I don't see why they couldn't have anything in there for rideshare.
https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
A private company trying to sort of ddos the mayor with spam mail is ridiculous, regardless where you stand on the politics of the particular case.
[1]https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-07-16/uber-inje...
I see nothing wrong in this.
They could easily survey drivers to determine how many hours a day they work, who's doing it full time, and if they are, why. However, it's just easy to make a new broken law to add to the already broken laws.
I think this is a good point and is correct.
But if society has failed the drivers, shouldn't new regulation be the solution?
Uber ignored local laws to force their way into the taxi market without having to compete on the same terms as existing businesses.
Uber also classified their drivers as contractors to avoid having to pay fair wages and provide benefits.
They've been criticized for this (and many other things) for years. They could have changed course any time, but they didn't want to. They were too busy using internal tools to avoid scrutiny from regulators (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greyball), threatening journalists who wrote articles they didn't like (https://www.theverge.com/2014/11/18/7240215/uber-exec-casual...), and trapping drivers with predatory auto loans (https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/dec/05/uber-l...).
This is 100% Uber's fault.
It's not unreasonable that someone who is driving for Uber/Lyft (especially if, as you claim, they have no better alternatives) is aware of the deferred costs that they are incurring.
You mean unlikely. It is absolutely unreasonable. But these arguments just don’t stand up. In the early days, perhaps this is true. But everyone is massively aware of these arguments now and what you’re still arguing is that people need to be protected from themselves.
Think about what you’re saying: your back-of-the-envelope conjecture without any empirical evidence should be taken over the millions of people who work in these industries, not just for a month before realizing they’ve been hosed, but for years and years.
How about this: let’s presume all of what you say is true. What if after all those costs are accounted for, it’s still profitable for many people to drive for Uber.
What is egregious about uber is that they themselves are tapping into the clean water source, extracting the best part for themselves and then leaving only brackish water for all the uber drivers.
If you believe the end goal of a society is to extract every last bit of value from its members, then yes, Uber is great.
If you believe the end goal of society is to provide some sort of dignified life for its members, then I don't see how you can justify what Uber does.
> How about this: let’s presume all of what you say is true. What if after all those costs are accounted for, it’s still profitable for many people to drive for Uber.
There have many studies done about what someone can earn from Uber. Even without the externalities nobody is going to get rich from Uber. With the externalities, they are barely making a subsistence wage.
Lastly, I would argue that even if working for Uber is a net negative, in the short term (even years) they can extract some value from an assets they already have (their vehicle and their time) against costs in the future. For someone who needs cash today, this is a acceptable tradeoff.
Please explain this. Uber is wildly unprofitable. Whether or not you think Uber drivers should earn more, they’re certainly not losing money. Between the drivers, the riders, and Uber...Uber has by far the worst position in this game. Now, they wrote the rules so I certainly won’t lose a wink of sleep over it, but this idea that Uber is making out well in all of this is ludicrous.
The riders make out the best and any future changes will be zero sum between riders are drivers. Uber simply can’t absorb more losses than they already do.
Sometimes I actively look forward to the tech job market collapsing.
Then it would seem applying more pressure to their already unprofitable employer is an unwise move...
Most people dont work for uber because it is fun. They are doing it because their other options are worse.
I think you've answered your own question here.
What makes something a fair wage?
Or, they have very limited other options.
The entire concept of Minimum Wage laws are put in place to address the points you're making.
As FDR stated in 1933:
> It seems to me to be equally plain that no business which depends for existence on paying less than living wages to its workers has any right to continue in this country.
You can argue about what you think a fair wage is, but it has been decided that the absolute floor value you are allowed to argue for is set as the minimum wage.
It is unclear, that after accounting for all time spent "driving", and paying all expenses related to driving, that drivers are always paid even minimum wage.
I also don't see who benefits from this. You had a well functioning service for the users that will be disrupted. You had a flexible way to earn for drivers that will be disrupted.
I chat with drivers a lot (to practise my English) and lots of drivers really like chatting too ( A lot of them were recent immigrants as well and perhaps like to practise their English with a non native). Many drivers were doing this as a part time thing. Or doing this before they went on to better things. One for example was studying Architecture. I have even had a Porsche pick me up and the driver just wanted to get out of his house.
A lot of drivers were sure forced to drive for Uber for lack of other alternatives but that is not Uber's problem. They did not add to the problem. Society failed there. This law helps no one and is a clear example of no skin in the game virtue signalling trumping common sense.