News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by 01100011 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:16PM (#24124665)
I know there are a whole host of issues, racial inequality, climate change, pollution, etc, which I consider to be 'one percenter problems' now. I'm just trying to save enough to retire one day and keep a roof over my family. Fixing global issues is a luxury. Maslow's hierarchy and all that...
Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by save_ferris on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:31PM (#24124872)
That’s not the only issue, non-profits and foundations apply all kinds of political pressure in opaque ways. There are many non-profits funded by elites that operate to advance societal good superficially while pushing ulterior political motives.

For a concrete example, a tremendous amount of money has recently flowed into sex education advocacy, some of which doesn’t have donor names attached to it.

Organizations that aim to provide resources around things like consent and healthy sexual behavior find that courting this new money involves adopting an abstinence-only approach as a mandate. As a result, it’s hard to know if the organization you’re donating to is actually doing the advocacy work they used to advertise, and they’re not always inclined to be transparent around who calls the shots from a donor perspective.

We like to think that political money lives only in super PACs and lobbying efforts, but this isn’t the case, and in some ways this makes the non-profit situation even more insidious. To be clear, I’m not denigrating all non-profit work, there are just some major transparency issues that need to be addressed.

Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by DontGiveTwoFlux on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:42PM (#24125051)
This comment hits on one particular issue of ulterior motives in the actions of a non-profit.

But more generally, there is a whitewashing going on. Look at the Sackler family, which for decades got to put their names on museums, hospitals, etc. they get to go around spreading a story about how good they are while rotting out communities with their dirty opioid pushing. They got called out, sure, but how many other Sacklers are out there with their reputations unburnished?

Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by blaser-waffle on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @11:22AM (#24132947)
I'd imagine this would be most billionaires.

"Money talks, wealth whispers."

Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by growlist on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:41PM (#24125039)
> There are many non-profits funded by elites that operate to advance societal good superficially while pushing ulterior political motives.

George Soros and his 'Open Society Foundation' is another example.

Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by DontGiveTwoFlux on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:36PM (#24124950)
Racial inequality isn’t a one percenter problem if your child was Killed by the police. Pollution isn’t a one percenter problem if your kids all have asthma from inhaling coal fumes or have been drinking water with lead. I could go on.

These problems sound like they have nothing to do with wealthy people standing up for one cause or another. The issue is that the wealth is so often created or amplified by greedily outsourcing these problems to the powerless. The wealth begets more power, and institutions that launder the story of that wealth into a whitewashed canvas of do goodery.

Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by viklove on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @11:40AM (#24133138)
I think OP is just talking about how only one-percenters have time/money to care and act on these issues. The rest of us are too busy running the rate race to lift our heads up and even notice what's going on in the world.

Look at how much more political activism there is in the US during the COVID crisis. People have more time since they're working from home, and they're able to actually participate for the first time in a long while. Imagine how many more people would be able to vote if election day was a national holiday. It's honestly criminal that it's not.

Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:29AM (#24131857)
Calling racial inequality a “one percenter” problem makes sense if you consider non-White people to be not real, but only an abstraction of concern to Whites (and, only, apparently, White elites.)

And a lot of those other issues have immediate, near-term impacts on the immediate prospects for families outside of the elites, (and without regard to divisions like race), so even from a narrow short-term self-interest standpoint don't make a lot of sense tongues as one-percenter problems even as much as political messaging from the Right paints them as elite distractions from immediate economic concerns.

Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by kazinator on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @06:18PM (#24126676)
No one percenter can solve racial inequality, pollution or climate change if you and I are not on board.
Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by star-trek-fleet on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:55PM (#24125203)
Nothing you cited are one percenter problem, they were branded as such to keep you from emotionally involved, which in turn might give you the mental strength to push for the right things to happen.

Any of these problems, can directly affect your children.

Let me tell you one example, my parents generation suffered much higher cancer rate than normal. That's caused by 40 years of rapid industrialization in China.

Think about it, these issues let limbo, will very likely make your retirement miserable in 20-30 years...

Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by 01100011 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @05:30PM (#24126216)
Branded as such? What? I'm constantly pestered by messaging which is telling me to get involved in these issues. The point is, I care, but I have more pressing issues to work on. Yes, my family members getting harrassed because of their skin color is an issue that affects me, but if I am getting kicked out of my apartment for not paying the rent then it is not an issue I can spend time or money on. Even if I did spend time or money on these 'one percenter' issues, the negative impact to my life would be great while my contribution would have a negligible impact on the issue.

I have no time to virtue signal by participating in meaningless social activism. I will help individuals where I can because that is somewhere where I can meaningfully affect change with my actions.

Maybe it's my age. Maybe I'm cynical, I don't know. I used to care about these things. I bought a crappy house in a crappy neighborhood to save gas. I wasted money on a solar panel system. I planted native plants, composted and grew my own fruits and vegetables. I was worse off for it, and no change came from it. If I managed to save any resources, they were quickly consumed by some other wasteful excess of society.

Unless your activism is effective, it is useless. It is basically religion at that point.

Re:Elite do-gooders 'fixing' the world are part of the probl... by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:31AM (#24131879)
> Branded as such? What? I'm constantly pestered by messaging which is telling me to get involved in these issues.

You are also constantly bombarded by messaging telling you not to and to focus narrowly on short-term self-interest, from the opposite side of the political spectrum.

The one you view as “pestering” is just the one you haven’t internalized.