News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by AbrahamParangi on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:36AM (#24083011)
Unemployment was and still is a mistake because it creates perverse incentives. It should be UBI instead.

The government has spent $10,000 per US resident propping up banks, hedge funds, dog-shit junk-grade corporate debt, etc.

Do you think that money was well spent propping up braindead investment funds, or would you have used it better?

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by epistasis on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:39AM (#24083045)
What perverse incentive is that?

We are at ridiculously high unemployment numbers, so whether people are "incentivized" to work or not doesn't mean much.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by pwinnski on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:43AM (#24083092)
There seem to be perverse incentives at play in several states, pushing them to re-open even as cases and weekly deaths rise, seemingly with the primary purpose to getting people off state unemployment rolls.

Not sure it's the right term to use for people, since as you say, the jobs aren't there. But for state governments, for sure.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by slg on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:06PM (#24083415)
I think a lot of people envision workers being given a choice to go back to work or stay on unemployment, but that is seldom a choice. You can't legally turn down your old job and stay on unemployment (at least in every state of which I'm aware, but every state's unemployment system is slightly different). Certainly there will be some people who do it, but you would basically have to commit fraud to do it.

This causes the states' perverse incentives that you mentioned. Many people believe a big push to reopen has been motivated by states trying to get people off unemployment as they know some workers would rather stay safe at home and lose unemployment benefits than return to work in an unsafe environment.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by Nasrudith on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:15PM (#24084271)
Really the "avoiding work" is fundamentally a motivated lie because they don't want to pay period but especially not during the retail and tourist apocalypse that is covid-19. It is as usual incredibly short sighted and stupid as the impatient reopeners think if they ignore the fire it will just fizzle out and people will continue shopping like normal.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abfan1127 on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:14PM (#24083516)
I know a ton of employees who have declined employment because of unemployment paying better. If Employers rat out these employees, then they come back angry. its a nasty spot to be in.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by slg on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:25PM (#24083673)
Like I said:

>Certainly there will be some people who do it, but you would basically have to commit fraud to do it.

Also the extra unemployment benefits expired so anyone still doing this is not making more than they would at their job. Their only incentive to continue this fraud is for their own personal safety. You can't call a preference for one's own personal safety "perverse".

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abfan1127 on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:29PM (#24083726)
While it wasn't my statement, I think its perverse as the "free money" distorted those employees from making "normal decisions". For those employees, its a perfectly reasonable (short term) decision to prefer the larger payout. I'd argue its a bad long term decision.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by slg on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:46PM (#24083922)
The money isn't "free" if you have to commit fraud to get it. I get that the temporary boost in benefits skewed the incentives a little bit more towards committing unemployment fraud and that might have been enough to sway some people who wouldn't do it under "normal" circumstances, but unemployment fraud is not a new option and this incentive to commit fraud has always existed.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by adamsea on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:28PM (#24083720)
I wonder if that says more about the employer than anything else.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abfan1127 on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:33PM (#24083768)
what would it say about employers? They don't want to jeopardize relations, but they need employees back... I personally know small mom/pop restaurants, a small private security (rent-a-cop) firm, and a large casino that can't get people to come back because the $600/week bonus. These aren't 6 figure engineering jobs. these are low skill jobs where the most important skill is showing up on time consistently.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by paulmd on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:41PM (#24083858)
the $600/month is already gone and businesses still can't get employees. It's not the boogeyman you're looking for, you need to take a deeper look at why that might be.

two of your three examples are plague-pit jobs that will involve the employee interfacing with the public and getting sick, probably bankrupting themselves with medical bills. that's the real problem.

it's a free market, and if you can't retain employees that's because you're not offering enough. Offer someone $1m a year to work in your casino, they'll take it (even during a pandemic) and you know it. Now we're just negotiating over the price.

Start offering $60k, maybe $70k, and full health coverage to balance out, you know, risking your life and long term financial health so Karen can get her gyro, and people will take it.

The real underlying problem is that a lot of these businesses are essentially bankrupt already, they are the walking dead, their business model will no longer work due to the pandemic (they relied on not paying for their employees' health care and that's no longer a viable scheme with the pandemic on) and they're demanding what amount to subsidies (artificial reductions on the cost of labor, for which the clearing price has risen due to increased personal risk) in order to stay afloat.

taking away unemployment benefits isn't going to bring customers back to your subway, it's over for a significant number of businesses and the owners are pleading to delay the inevitable. This is the economic impact that people wanted to pretend didn't exist, there is no reason the stock market should be bouncing against an all-time high when our economy dived 33% annualized rate this quarter and the pandemic is spreading faster than ever.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by scarface74 on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:40PM (#24084541)
Anecdote. Where I live a lot of the school bus drivers were doing it just for supplemental income not for their livelihood. Many quit. My wife was a bus driver and we decided for her not to go back to work. They could have paid her double or triple and the answer would be no.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abfan1127 on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:46PM (#24083930)
the $600/month just ran out, and now they are returning. But its been months. plague pit? risking your life? that's pretty dramatic. They're not mid 90s LA inner city police officers. They're not 1900s sky scraper metal workers. The drive to work is about as risky as the work itself. Many of these businesses will die (if they haven't already), and these people will have no jobs to go back to...
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by paulmd on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:02PM (#24084118)
The unemployment boost isn't going to fix the economy. Unemployment only distorts the economy by competing for labor if we're at full economic output, which we're not. The economy is collapsing at a 33% annualized rate, the fastest in recorded economic history.

You're looking at a crashing economy and suggesting that the real problem is the only brace still propping it up, and suggesting that we knock it out.

Many of these businesses are going to die regardless, because of the failed pandemic response, the failure to enact a sufficient degree of stimulus, and because these businesses are no longer viable with an ongoing pandemic.

And yes, I said plague pit. How in the world do you think it's reasonable for an employee that is not provided with any health insurance (or a bronze plan or whatever) to risk an infection that can stick you with a $1.1m bill, for $7.50 an hour? Employees are, shall we say, not going to respond to that economic incentive, that's not a reasonable trade from any perspective.

https://www.marketwatch.com/story/breaking-down-this-miracle...

Instead, they will stay at home, and 33% of renters are going to miss their payment this month, just as the article says. As they said in 2008: if you don't pay your mortgage this month, you have a problem. If 33% of people don't pay their mortgage this month... the bank has a problem.

The reality is that businesses that require interfacing with the public are going to see a downturn in customers no matter what, and are going to have to start paying for their employees' health care, no matter what. You can't expect people to take on a near-certainty of an extraordinarily expensive hospital stay for $7.50 per hour. People won't do that, and customers aren't coming into the business at the same rate they used to anyway. Those businesses are walking dead and forcing employees to accept sub-market wages to get them back to work won't help that.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abfan1127 on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:10PM (#24084215)
I agree the boost isn't going to fix the economy and that it distorts it. I also agree that the crashing economy has real problems well beyond this boost. I agree these businesses will die. I agree the response was wrong. I think the stimulus was the wrong way to go.

The drive to work can get you a $500k doctor bill, and at similar risks for Covid $500k doctor bill. Both of which these demographics will not pay at all. They will either just leave it in collections or use bankruptcy to eliminate it.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by nitrogen on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:44PM (#24084577)
Getting in a car accident doesn't risk causing exponentially increasing car accidents in your family and community though.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by paulmd on Friday August 07, 2020 @02:05PM (#24084798)
Your argument is "people tolerate some risk, therefore they will tolerate a hugely increased amount of risk at the same clearance price". That's not how the market works.

It's how business owners paying minimum wage want the market to work, but it's not how it does. Shit, a lot of businesses aren't even trying to mitigate the risks, not providing PPE, etc - they just expect minimum-wage workers to absorb all that risk and cost if they don't want to die.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abfan1127 on Friday August 07, 2020 @02:26PM (#24084980)
That's not my argument at all. I agree with you that some businesses are trying to "do as they did" and that may not work in the new workplace. However, they aren't competing in a marketplace when the alternative is "not work and get paid".
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by adamsea on Monday August 10, 2020 @10:04AM (#24109343)
1. The drive to work is a known risk. Much is still unknown about Covid-19 plus it is novel and (legitimately) scary.

2. It's not just you, you could infect your friends and family and children.

3. If someone actually compared the actual odds (i.e. real numbers) of getting in a card accident with getting Covid-19 working in one of these public-facing jobs we are discussing, under current conditions, then we'd be able to tell if the comparison you're proposing is reasonable or not.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by didibus on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:59PM (#24084090)
Serious question, do they even have customers?

Everyone is talking about the employees not wanting to go back to work, but as far as I can tell, I don't think the customers want to go to the businesses either.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abfan1127 on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:05PM (#24084148)
of the employers I know - Restaurants - low levels of demand, but not zero. private security - still high demand for services. casino - regular gamblers + all of the people with new money ($600/wk).
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by didibus on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:44PM (#24084584)
Interesting. My feelings are, restaurants just don't have the demand anyways, and if private security and casinos do, why can't they raise their wages?

I still personally think the crux is lack of demand. I don't think the customers exist anymore that would be willing to pay enough to account for the extra cost of the business given Covid. And one of those cost include safety precautions to their employees.

As an example, Amazon was able to hire 175000 additional workers through the pandemic, even though they were getting unemployment checks.

So I think it's naive to think that removing unemployment is what will save those business. But I'm not a zealot on this, that's just my current rationale. I'm welcoming counter points.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abfan1127 on Friday August 07, 2020 @02:31PM (#24085037)
I don't think removing unemployment will save these particular businesses. I just acknowledge the moral hazard of paying such high unemployment. I also think many (if not most) people would rather work. I also know personally many people (but not most) who would rather sit on the butts than work.

I recall (long time ago) that Germany's unemployment included a list that employers could use to find workers. If an unemployed person was offered a job, they were cut from unemployment. Our current system has people claiming unemployment, getting more money that working. This created a situation that employer could complain to the government, but then the employee feels "cheated" and brings those negative feelings back to work... not exactly a good situation.

The current system has all sorts of moral hazard and unintended consequences. I could provide a policy recommendation, but that's really out of scope for a small discussion forum.

I do appreciate your discussion though!

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by adamsea on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:41PM (#24083857)
Well, cry me a river for the casino, which could afford to pay a living / more competitive wage, but I see your point about the other ones.

Maybe then it says more about our current economic system as a whole.

But my point was it seems like if $600 / week is enough for folks to choose not to work, that says more about the work not being meaningful or the employer being unable to (or choosing not to) pay the worker well.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abfan1127 on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:49PM (#24083967)
while I can't speak for other casinos. This particular one paid them full wages for the 6 weeks they were originally shut down. it wasn't $600/wk. It was $600/wk plus UI.

If $600/wk is enough not to work, then it can also speak to the quality of the worker and their lack of skills. Spending time complaining about how hard life is, rather than doing something about it. Not everyone is like that, and not no-one is like that either.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by smileysteve on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:09PM (#24084190)
> it wasn't $600/wk. It was $600/wk plus UI

Severance is counted against eligibility for unemployment in most states.

Source; had a friend not understand this, to wonder where their unemployment was, to get their first check after their severance ran out.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abfan1127 on Friday August 07, 2020 @02:32PM (#24085050)
these particular people were furloughed with pay. I won't speak for all people because obviously there are many diverse situations.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by Nasrudith on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:18PM (#24084301)
It says that the jobs and/or payment are bad enough that people would procrastinate actually taking them when unemployment is sky high.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by hogFeast on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:37PM (#24083815)
Not your point but I think there is a definite issue here with perceptions around workplace safety.

The US has a very good level of testing/mask usage. And, to be blunt, just wear a mask and wash your hands...you will be okay. I understand why some groups of people are very worried: if you are obese, if you are over 60, if you work in a hospital/care home...but if you work in an office, it isn't a "Hunger Games" situation.

I don't think furlough/unemployment schemes necessarily created that incentive though. People in some places are clearly being very cautious (I am in the UK, people aren't wearing masks and not being cautious at all...I have seen larger crowds at pubs than ever...no masks) anyway.

So I think the solution to the unemployment problem is a change in message from govt. If you take precautions, you will be okay (again, where I am the message was very urgent and serious...this worked at first but some people are ignoring totally and others are staying at home terrified of their own shadow...so who knows? But I think it would have success generally).

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by humaniania on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:57PM (#24084059)
That's not true. I know several people that work in the restaurant industry who have gotten COVID-19 while wearing PPE, probably because of how many people refuse to wear masks, or don't wear them properly. And it isn't just about getting infected yourself. How would you feel if you got infected and ended up accidentally infecting someone you love who ends up dying? There needs to be a national mandate and actual enforcement of mask wearing to stop the spread.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 07, 2020 @03:13PM (#24085468)
Enough research is showing that aerosol covid is a major risk. If they weren’t wearing N95 masks...
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by hogFeast on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:09PM (#24086487)
Correct, which is why I didn't say that no-one should be worried. I am saying that this doesn't apply for most people in most situations.

And you want a national mandate to wear masks but you said that people wearing them got infected. Interesting take.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by pseudalopex on Friday August 07, 2020 @08:38PM (#24087924)
A surgical mask protects other people more than the person wearing it.[1]

[1] https://www.bryanhealth.com/app/files/public/4953/wear-a-mas...

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by powerslacker on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:39PM (#24084529)
> There needs to be a national mandate and actual enforcement of mask wearing to stop the spread.

That assumes that the masks are as effective as claimed, that mass enforcement is even feasible, and that the Federal govt. has the right to create such a mandate. I don't believe we have enough data to know the efficacy of masks, especially handmade masks out in the field. Mass enforcement of mask wearing, even if it was somehow cost affordable to task law enforcement with, would likely be met with heavy protest or open revolt in the United States by various civil rights groups.

There's nothing wrong with being concerned about safety, especially these days. However, it's not so simple as 'pass a mask law', and if you really think about it ... there's a silver lining there. Do you want to be ruled by a government who can tell you what to wear, when to wear it, how to wear it — even if you dissent? Once there is a precedent for a national mask law, the Federal government can use that to push for further loss of freedoms for individuals and states. I'm not saying the mask law concept is intentionally being pushed to erode freedoms, rather, that it has the potential to do so.

Businesses can already refuse service for any reason not protected by Federal/State law. That's plenty of grounds to kick out a non mask wearer. I don't see the need for additional laws, enforcement, or government spending. Let businesses and employees decide the level of risk they are willing to take.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by slg on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:49PM (#24083961)
>The US has a very good level of testing/mask usage. And, to be blunt, just wear a mask and wash your hands...you will be okay.

If this is true, why is the outbreak here so much worse than basically any of our peer countries?

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by refurb on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:54PM (#24084022)
How do you define worse? Number of deaths? If so, the US is doing better than many countries.

https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/08/05/8993658...

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by ModernMech on Friday August 07, 2020 @02:36PM (#24085079)
There are about 50 countries with cases over 50k, 40 of which are missing from that chart. Being 8/50 is I think indicative of being worse. I think the statistic that shows just how bad the US is doing is that they account for 23% of the world's total Covid deaths but only 3% of the world total population. How can a country doing a good job have those kinds of numbers?

But as you said in your other reply, we understand Covid to be a regional disease that comes in waves, washing over a region and then subsiding. For smaller, denser countries in Europe, it is easier for this disease to reach all regions. America is vast with a much lower population density, and the virus is taking its time finding its way around.

However, if you break the US down into regions you can see how bad it is. NY state has a comparable population density to Italy (162 vs 200 for Italy), and both were hard hit at the beginning of this thing. New York state suffered 1,687 deaths per million, while Italy only suffered 582 deaths per million so far. This I think provides a more nuanced picture rather than just looking at deaths per million by country. Population density is really a factor here.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 07, 2020 @03:18PM (#24085521)
Exactly this, we need heat maps that are per capita focused so people can gauge risk.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by slg on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:06PM (#24084165)
Totals are misleading due to each countries varied handling of the initial pandemic. Our peers are not still struggling with this the way we continue to struggle. I did some quick math based off the numbers here as an example[1][2]. The UK has had 3.0 COVID-19 deaths over the last three days per million people. The US has had nearly four times that many deaths with 11.8 per million people in that same 3 day time frame.

[1] - https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/uk/

[2] - https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by refurb on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:14PM (#24084251)
Sure, that might tell you how it’s going right now, but in the end you just care about the total impacted.

And looking in the last 3 days is misleading since we know the pandemic hits in waves, at different times, across different countries.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by slg on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:20PM (#24084325)
>Sure, that might tell you how it’s going right now, but in the end you just care about the total impacted.

The problem is we aren't at the end yet. Any time frame you use is therefore going to give you an incomplete picture. I used the last three days because it shows that the US is clearly in a worse current position. That means we will continue creeping up that initial per capita list you linked. Maybe the UK, Spain, France, or Italy experience a second wave at some point down the line, but at least they have gotten past the first wave that the US still hasn't been able to stop.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by refurb on Friday August 07, 2020 @09:29PM (#24088186)
Gotcha. I agree we're not at the end (or even close) so it's premature to start naming winners and losers.

Instead of saying "better" I should have said "has fewer per capita deaths so far".

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by clairity on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:12PM (#24084230)
moreover, many office workers, those with seats roughly 6 feet apart or with a partition of some sort, don't even need the mask. the people who need masks are front-line workers of all sorts, from grocery clerks to medical workers, who interact with strangers for extended periods of time, not people sitting at computers for most of the day. sure, when you have a meeting, wear a mask, but an LED screen won't give you covid.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by saltminer on Friday August 07, 2020 @03:53PM (#24085836)
If everyone in the office is clean, sure, but what about the HVAC technician you had to call in? The UPS driver who interacted with the mail room employees? What if your cube neighbor is exposed by a family member who is asymptomatic and ends up spreading it to half the row before they get their results back? Unless you want to test your employees every day and hope the test is accurate, you need masks.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by Wowfunhappy on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:07PM (#24086476)
What my company has said (when the office is currently slated to reopen in September) is that you need to wear a mask while walking around the office or talking to people, but not when you're sitting at your desk/computer. Our seating arrangements will be laid out such that everyone's desk has at least six feet of space.

I'm... not sure... whether the science on this holds up, but it struck me as a good compromise. People expressed concern that wearing a mask for nine hours straight, without any breaks, would become very uncomfortable.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by clairity on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:03PM (#24086446)
no, none of those potential exposures are significant enough to warrant anything more than some distance. the virus falls to the ground and dies (even in the air) in droves all by itself. these aren't hardy viruses.

you'd need to take an unnecessary risk like eating lunch in a group to create a significant exposure in that environment.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by BoxFour on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:09PM (#24084191)
something like 1/3 to 1/2 of the US is obese, so...
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by cortesoft on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:53AM (#24083240)
I think the perverse incentive they are talking about is that all benefits are cut once someone gets a job, even if the job doesn't make as much as the benefits gave.

If the benefits were instead given to everyone, then you wouldn't lose money by getting a job.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by newacct583 on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:06PM (#24083416)
Yes, but that only matters when the worker in question is faced with the choice of whether to work or not. Right now unemployment is through the roof because effectively all the service jobs have evaporated. There are no jobs. No one is sitting home savoring their cushy $600 benefits bonus instead of working, because there is nowhere to work anyway.

The argument against generous "unemployment insurance" vs. "UBI" is valid enough. But it's based on an assumption of near-full employment that doesn't hold right now.

Basically: this is not the time to have that argument.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by jchrisa on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:37PM (#24083818)
I hear from multiple of my small business owner friends, that they are unable to get people to come back to work due to this. It's hard to know what the overall distortion is, but it's definitely a good illustration of the welfare trap where most jobs offer negative marginal utility.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by newacct583 on Sunday August 09, 2020 @11:34AM (#24100246)
$600/week unemployment, even when including state benefits, is well under minimum wage in almost all urban areas. I don't know which small businesses your friends own, nor where they are, but jobs that pay that low aren't representative of a significant fraction of the real economy (and, let's be honest: the ones that really sit in this realm tend to be staffed by undocumented workers anyway who wouldn't qualify for these benefits).

Broadly: I think this is mostly spin, and would want to see a real study instead of anecdotes from friends.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by ponker on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:10PM (#24083468)
The fact that the benefits are more than some people’s pay shows how low the pay was.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by phalangion on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:18PM (#24083565)
Absolutely, and that's a problem that needs to be addressed, but we can't fix everything at once.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by beamatronic on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:43PM (#24083894)
Some say that if you fix that problem first, almost everything else will just shake out
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by phalangion on Friday August 07, 2020 @02:18PM (#24084912)
And that would be awesome. But I suspect that fixing that with our current administration is unlikely.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by matthewaveryusa on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:54AM (#24083246)
Ridiculously high? It's a _bit_ high. 10% is not the end of the world, but it does put the US at european levels.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by save_ferris on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:21PM (#24083609)
It plays into the argument that people will be lazy and refuse to do any kind of work if they have an alternate source of income, when the market doesn’t actually see as much of that. People like to have multiple sources of income (hello, passive income.)
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by voldacar on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:10PM (#24084210)
The perverse incentive is that people are forced to choose between the benefit and going back go a job that might not pay much more, thus distorting the supply curve for labor. If the benefit were unconditional like UBI, the supply curve would remain smoothly continuous.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by abarringer on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:53PM (#24084016)
I know six people that lost their jobs and were not looking for new ones because they were making more money on unemployment than employed. That is a perverse incentive.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by bobthepanda on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:06PM (#24084164)
in this scenario is unemployment what demands a correction, or low wage levels?
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by djsumdog on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:53AM (#24083222)
There are some people who don't want to go back to work even when their jobs are returning. There might legit safety concerns in places like meat packing plants, but they can be addresses by those places spending the money on PPE and small modifications the plants. Musk has done it with his own companies.

Politicians like Ocasio-Cortez actively told people they shouldn't go back to work even as places open back up. This is problematic because if enough people believe that, there is a risk of shortages for things like food. We over produce quite a bit in America, farms are heavily subsidized, and it's mostly school/restaurant food chain products that are being dumped right now (and many Americans are realizing for the first time we get totally different qualities of products than restaurants do), so it's not affecting us too badly yet.

Hopefully it won't, but there needs to be a balance between any proposal for UBI or continued unemployment and restarting production systems that produce domestic goods we need to survive.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by jakogut on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:07PM (#24083426)
> and many Americans are realizing for the first time we get totally different qualities of products than restaurants do

This is interesting, can you clarify what you mean?

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by hogFeast on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:43PM (#24083892)
The only way that UBI can work is if you have a very strong labour market with high levels of flexibility.

This is one of the tricky things about economic policy. If you are proposing UBI, you are likely to be the worst person possible to implement it. All the proponents see are upsides without the deep understanding of the downsides.

A country which manages this well is Denmark. They have high levels of union membership, they have a true contributory unemployment insurance scheme that functions like UBI but they are also very savvy about capitalism/markets, and have one of the most flexible labour markets in the world (one of the few places on par with the US, maybe even ahead of). They understand that capitalism is the way you pay for all this stuff, it is the solution, not the problem. Very few political systems can make this leap.

The same applies to the discussion around restarting. Lots of countries went hard on the lockdown rhetoric...and now, it is pretty hard to roll back.

It is very concerning though. I don't think this is going to be some huge decade long disaster, things will get better. But there is a real possibility that a lot of supply gets destroyed in the meantime as the middle-class cocoons themselves at home out of fear.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by cowmoo728 on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:48AM (#24083157)
A financial collapse on top of a demand shock wouldn't have helped. This is speculation but Wells Fargo and Deutsche Bank were probably at risk of collapsing, thereby tanking the market for CLOs and sparking a wave of corporate bankruptcies and bank failures. In order to prevent this and restore confidence, the fed went all out. There's always waste involved but I'm hesitant to call the whole thing a waste without knowing what the Fed knows.

Do agree on unemployment though. The overhead of administering the program is nonsensical. Florida purposefully designed its systems to deny as many claims as possible. The idea of designing government systems as terribly as possible so that people hate the government is holding us back in times of crisis.

UBI payments simplify the whole thing.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by t0mbstone on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:19PM (#24083572)
They wouldn't have needed to bail out the banks if they had just bailed out the people.

Trickle up economics!

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by bravo22 on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:58PM (#24084077)
They're both real problems. Most of growth in the last decade has been from leveraging. A lot of people have BS jobs as a result of leveraging. Giving people money to avoid starvation (which is good), isn't going to change your leverage problem when it comes to businesses and banks.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by eloff on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:49AM (#24083166)
Why is it that whenever the government does something, it takes me about ten minutes to come up with a better plan? I've considered that I could be wrong that my plan is actually better, or that I'm missing something (I surely am) but I don't find that compelling.

I'm starting to think that the outcome of our political systems in the West produces suboptimal compromises engineered by politicians who are quite frankly ignorant, incompetent, corrupt, and really just not good specimens of the species. It's like the system is designed to be mediocre.

What's the alternative though?

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by doorstar on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:44PM (#24083911)
Have you ever worked at a company where they bring in a brand-new CTO or Lead Architect and they decide after a week or so that the entire dev org has been Doing it Wrong and it's only them, with their clear outsider's view, that can see the true way forward.

I certainly have. It usually leads to 3-4 wasted years of dev time on the brand new architecture that will never match all the features of the old stack, and during that time the old stack has fewer and fewer resources and the tech debt piles up.

It is absurdly easy to come up with a better plan in 10 minutes if you have absolutely no idea how it really works or how complicated it really is.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by eloff on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:16PM (#24086005)
Yes, I agree that the fair default assumption is I just don't understand the true complexity of the problem. And this is certainly true.

However, I don't accept this answer. I think most of the time the government's plan is so bad, so glaringly flawed, that even from my position of ignorance, I'm confident I can beat it without hardly trying.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by ModernMech on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:27PM (#24088696)
The plans Congress comes up with look like shit from your perspective because to you, a good plan is one that solves problems for regular Americans. Congress does not work for regular Americans. The plans they come up with are great plans for the people they work for. They are highly effective and channeling money to the rich and their corporations. Just look at the trend lines of the past 40 years - consistently increasing inequality between rich and poor. That kind of consistent performance is by design. As always, the purpose of a system is is what it does.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by ceejayoz on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:05PM (#24083402)
> Why is it that whenever the government does something, it takes me about ten minutes to come up with a better plan?

Because the edge cases often take more than ten minutes to reveal themselves?

See: "Tough on crime/drugs" policies, lead in gasoline and paint, etc.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by eloff on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:17PM (#24086016)
I understand edge cases and hidden complexity very well as software engineer, see my comment above for why I don't accept this take.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by ceejayoz on Friday August 07, 2020 @05:07PM (#24086478)
You don't have to accept it for it to be true.

The point of "hidden complexity" is that it's hidden. Talking to an expert in public policy in the specific area in question might well reveal the "glaring flaw" is actually a known thing, with a good but counter-intuitive reason behind it.

I've seen precisely that in software; big precautionary comments in code that say "this seems weird, but here's why it exists; you can try and fix it, but you'll just increment the 'leave this code alone' counter again".

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by eloff on Friday August 07, 2020 @09:27PM (#24088176)
I understand that well, and it surely applies in some cases. In others, I think the government did such a bad job that it is not only possible, but quite way to come up with better alternatives, that are actually better considering the full complexity of the problem.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by cheschire on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:51AM (#24083195)
If you're a software developer, consider how the first 90% of any project is the easiest.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by renewiltord on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:07PM (#24083428)
Well, assuming you are competent, the answer is obvious. Unless your outcome preference vector and mine are the same, any decision for policy made by both of us will be less optimal for one of us than a decision made by that person.

Simply put, you can make better decisions because you don't have to negotiate.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by eloff on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:19PM (#24086030)
Yes, it's very clear that my solution would be better liked by me because it fits my preferences.

However, it also appears to me to be objectively better for society at large, in as much as I'm able to be objective.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by paulmd on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:49PM (#24083965)
> I'm starting to think that the outcome of our political systems in the West produces suboptimal compromises engineered by politicians who are quite frankly ignorant, incompetent, corrupt, and really just not good specimens of the species. It's like the system is designed to be mediocre.

the problem is that one of the political parties has it as an ideological point that government doesn't and can't work, and sets out to sabotage everything to prove that they're right. Like how florida deliberately makes it impossible to get your unemployment.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast

There is, unfortunately, not a good fix for this, as similar parties exist worldwide. But banning Murdoch media and de-consolidating media control in general (returning local stations to local management, etc) would be a good start.

Cause right now this is your local news station: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hWLjYJ4BzvI

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by eloff on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:20PM (#24086042)
I don't accept your leftist explanation that the problem is the right. It's much more nuanced than that.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by paulmd on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:32PM (#24086144)
If you went to work for a company that you didn't like and you sandbagged all your work you would be fired. Somehow this is considered acceptable when your employer is the taxpayer.

A large part of the problem of "why doesn't government produce good outcomes" is exactly this - people who have a vested personal interest in producing bad outcomes, because that's what they run on.

How do you fix it? Not easy obviously, but certain propaganda networks are a large chunk of the problem. Murdoch's networks specifically, and Sinclair's network controlling local broadcasting.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by eloff on Friday August 07, 2020 @09:28PM (#24088181)
I'm not saying that behavior is ok, but neither is it the exclusive domain of the right. Both parties engage in this kind of nonsense.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by adamsea on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:30PM (#24083740)
‘Many forms of Government have been tried, and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.…’

Winston S Churchill, 11 November 1947

https://winstonchurchill.org/resources/quotes/the-worst-form...

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by poulsbohemian on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:17PM (#24083552)
>I'm starting to think that the outcome of our political systems in the West produces suboptimal compromises engineered by politicians who are quite frankly ignorant, incompetent, corrupt, and really just not good specimens of the species. It's like the system is designed to be mediocre.

Yes.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 07, 2020 @03:21PM (#24085558)
Democracy is slow and average, because ‘everyone’ gets a voice.

Authoritarianism is fast and exceptional, because only everyone that matters gets a voice.

Problem is that fast ‘large decisions’ can be catastrophic, and those without a voice eventually rise up...

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by eloff on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:23PM (#24086066)
I've heard it said that a benevolent dictatorship is a better government than democracy for that reason (e.g. Singapore) until it stood being benevolent because the leadership changed or the leader grew corrupt. There's some truth there. That's not an argument in favor of authoritarianism, of course.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by smileysteve on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:17PM (#24084292)
> it takes me about ten minutes to come up with a better plan?

Because your plan doesn't please campaign funds, interest groups, and voters in a bicameral legislature and a long electoral college selected President .... and skate past 200 years of federal and state laws.

There's a reason why Caesar, Napoleon, Hitler, Stalin were able to achieve things quickly.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by eloff on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:24PM (#24086070)
Yeah, this is a big part of it.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by calvinbhai on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:53AM (#24083238)
If UBI is the way, do you agree or disagree that there should be no minimum wage?

Decide minimum wage, then give UBI to adults based on that.

If $15 per hr is minimum wage, UBI should be $2600 per month.

Once someone is getting this UBI, it should be legal to have jobs that pay $1 per hr or $0.5 per hr.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by shadowgovt on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:56AM (#24083288)
To a first approximation, I'm inclined to agree with this reasoning. The main point of minimum wage (in the US) was to back-stop a buyer's market for labor from leading to mass deprivation among American workers. If UBI can guarantee a dignified minimum standard of living, minimum wage becomes redundant.

Hell, in a world of UBI, I'd anticipate volunteer organizations to flourish.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by calvinbhai on Saturday August 08, 2020 @11:22AM (#24092318)
That’s just the first of the what if’s I ask.

Next would be, are they up for removal of all subsidies / free programs (e.g., SNAP / food stamps)?

How can health care costs be addressed with fixed UBI?

I can see UBI succeeding or at least not failing in countries like Canada since healthcare costs are zero for individuals, no matter how poor or moneyless they are.

Without having a similar Healthcare system, how can UBI be even implemented?

Ps: I’m neither strongly for/against UBI yet, but curious to see how it can solve the problem. I just have a lot of unanswered questions when asking them to UBI supporters.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by AniseAbyss on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:26PM (#24083694)
Social safety nets were designed to keep society from unraveling when desperate people take to the streets in the endless boom-bust cycle of capitalism. Many of the wealthiest countries in the world have found it economically more desirable than the alternative even when you ignore the ethics

Opponents of UBI often ignore the word BASIC.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by justinator on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:04PM (#24083394)
You can't pay for UBI without taxing wages (well everyone's taxes 'cause how you going to pay for it?), so actually the best scenario would be a higher minimum wage than now, plus UBI. Removing minimum wage but just providing UBI would be particularly crippling to the poor who already now have little hope on moving up financially.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by AbrahamParangi on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:56AM (#24083270)
Maybe. States and municipalities should figure it out. Diversity is good, and allows us to experiment & learn ethically and inexpensively.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by newacct583 on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:09PM (#24083454)
I could get behind that. Again, though, UBI is sort of a fantasy legislation for neoliberal wonks to argue about. It's not relevant to the current situation, really, at all. There's no way to make that kind of bureaucratic change on the kind of schedule we're forced into at all. It only seems simple to software geeks in HN threads.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by true_religion on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:31PM (#24083746)
You know people said the same thing about social security, and on a more recent note... desegregation and the end of Jim Crow.

Change always seems fast and overwhelming until it’s done, then we realize that support for it had been growing bit by bit, and all that was left was that final leap.

Even if the UBI is impossible to attain tomorrow, we should still lobby for it so it will be attainable someday.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by smileysteve on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:12PM (#24084225)
> though, UBI is sort of a fantasy legislation for neoliberal wonks

Did the U.S. not send $1200 to every citizen (under a means test) in May?

And several European nations.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by nickthemagicman on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:54PM (#24084026)
I think they're speculating prepare for something like this in the future because this is not the last time this will happen.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by ed25519FUUU on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:56AM (#24083283)
Have you thought about the psychological impact of what you’re describing? Why would someone work 40 hours a week to earn $2680 a month when they can earn $2600 a month sitting on their couch and playing video games?
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by Drakim on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:13PM (#24083500)
Isn't that part of the point?

Right now there is an incredible power imbalance between employers and employees, where for the employer it's an inconvenience if they lose the employee, while for the employee it's loss of access to food, shelter and medicine if they lose their employer.

This means that the employer can squeeze the employee, allowing them to pile on with abusive working conditions, bad pay, and poor compensation. Lots of workplaces outright steal out of the paychecks for the employees in plain daylight and get away with it because the employee knows that if they raise a fuss they might get fired.

Nobody would work for 1 dollar an hour, as you say. So companies will have to offer more to attract workers. And the workers have the option of saying "no" if what they offer just isn't good enough. So they would be two equal parties, bargaining over what the labor is worth, without neither having a gun pushed against their head if they say "no".

Weirdly, a lot of people seem to think things are as they should be. People should starve and be homeless if they aren't willing to work under unsafe condition, or being blackmailed into working for bottom wages just to have food to eat tomorrow. I'm not a fan of that sort of Social Darwinism though.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by ryandrake on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:45PM (#24084590)
Yes! With a robust, livable UBI, even without a minimum wage, you wouldn't see $2/hr jobs. Can you think of a job you'd personally take for an extra $2/hr if your needs were already being met by UBI? Wages would have to be set to a level that incentivize working. Shitty jobs would actually have to pay more than fun or easy jobs, because "not taking the job" is always a realistic option.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by dragonwriter on Saturday August 08, 2020 @07:07PM (#24095949)
> Can you think of a job you'd personally take for an extra $2/hr if your needs were already being met by UBI?

Yes, if it prepared you for better jobs. Low wage dead-end jobs might not exist (then again, they might, different people have different utility functions), but low-wage on-ramp jobs that cannot exist now certainly would.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by ed25519FUUU on Saturday August 08, 2020 @07:01PM (#24095922)
“Shitty” jobs wouldn’t have to pay more. Those jobs wouldn’t exist.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by shadowgovt on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:57AM (#24083302)
They wouldn't. They might work 40 hours a week because they believe in the cause; I know people who are independently wealthy or otherwise not in need of paid employment who put that time in for volunteer projects.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by munificent on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:32PM (#24084455)
People are downvoting this, but I think you point to a real problem.

Yes, people are generally good and want to do meaningful things and contribute to society. But we're also lazy, selfish, and good at convincing ourselves to make short-term choices with poor long-term consequences.

I think with UBI, there would be a whole lot of couch potatoes. I don't think that's necessarily morally a bad thing, but if the ratio of couch potatoes to people producing economic activity that pays into the UBI fund is bad enough, it can make UBI simply economically unsustainable whether you think it's a moral good or not.

So there is a balance between:

A. Keeping UBI low enough to incentivize people to produce labor such that UBI is financial self-sustaining.

B. Keeping UBI high enough that people who do not work are not destitute.

I think fans of UBI have a tacit assumption that A is well above B, but I am not so certain.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by jellicle on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:03PM (#24084134)
Your figures are wrong. If they worked (and received UBI, because that's what UBI means), their monthly income would be $5280 vs. $2600 for playing video games.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by dustingetz on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:25PM (#24083676)
Source on "spent" $10k/resident or is that in repayable loans? Huge difference
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by patentatt on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:42PM (#24083875)
The whole point of the 'loans' though is that they don't need to be paid back if used for the purposes they are supposed to be used for.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by dustingetz on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:52PM (#24084005)
$10k per 330M residents is $3.3T which is too big to be the SBA loans, those are bailout size numbers but the bailouts get repaid
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by adamsea on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:38PM (#24083829)
Agreed, but is this really the right time? A discussion about the benefits of UBI seems like an excellent discussion to have after making sure all the folks who will be in serious trouble once the $600 payments stop get some help from their government ...
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by nrmitchi on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:47PM (#24083938)
I think it is the right time. The problem I have with the $600 weekly unemployment bump is that while it helped some people, a ridiculous amount of people slipped through the cracks. We look at it and think "17M unemployed, we are helping 17M people!" but that is just not true. Even if it was, that is overall a very small portion of the population who (likely) needs assistance.

A big argument _against_ UBI is that "people wont work, and won't do productive things". This unemployment is actually worse than that; the fact that it "all goes away" when you exceed your state weekly income cap means that people can't do safe, productive "work", even if they want to. If your passion is selling art, and you sell a painting for $200, you most likely just excluded yourself from ~800$ in unemployment that week.

This isn't even touching on the difference in social-economic situation impacting ones ability to even apply/qualify for unemployment benefits in the first place, and fact that many state unemployment systems are designed to prevent people from actually being able to collect.

The way that the $600/week is talked about it completely ignores everyone (a substantial amount) of people who fell through the cracks. The unemployment system is not designed for distributing catastrophe-relief, and it's a disservice to literally everyone involve by pretending it is.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by adamsea on Monday August 10, 2020 @10:01AM (#24109304)
> The way that the $600/week is talked about it completely ignores everyone (a substantial amount) of people who fell through the cracks. The unemployment system is not designed for distributing catastrophe-relief, and it's a disservice to literally everyone involve by pretending it is.

I see. On that I agree with you. Replacing the $600/week with something better - yes!

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by claydavisss on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:11PM (#24083485)
UBI combines your paymaster with your legislator.

That sounds like a great idea until UBI is treated like a driver's license...something that can be taken away...if you, for example, are seen at a "riot", or "interfere" with law enforcement, or stay out past 10pm.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by jpindar on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:45PM (#24083918)
I'm in favor of UBI, but I agree, it's not likely to stay universal for long.

It won't start with protestors though, but with people who owe child support, or who are convicted of drunk driving or drug offenses.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by Nasrudith on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:24PM (#24084362)
Isn't that what the universal part is for? That they can't pick and choose?
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by ideals on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:53AM (#24083225)
But then people would have no incentive to work anymore so people would abuse the system. This is why the government has to give the money to corporations, they will spend that money wisely to keep good jobs around and not abuse this money. There's way too much accountability in corporations for it to ever get abused unlike regular people collecting Ubi forever.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by MegaButts on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:54AM (#24083249)
Is this satire? You can't honestly believe there's meaningful accountability amongst US corporations. And if you do, well why do you think that?
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by doopy-loopy2 on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:57AM (#24083291)
I'm just a single data point, but I'm a "high income" earner who would immediately quit there job if UBI was ever offered.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by nend on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:05PM (#24083401)
I feel like that depends on the UBI amount. Unless you're currently living well below your means, it's likely you couldn't support your current life style on just a UBI.

I'm an advocate for a UBI, and I'd use it to shift from working 5 days/week to 4 or 3 days/week. A move that many argue wouldn't effect the economy's output much at all, considering other countries economies do fine with less average working hours.

Additionally, a UBI would let more people participate in the economy and increase purchasing power of the less wealthy, which would help the economy.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by anonAndOn on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:14PM (#24083520)
You'd be willing to trade your high income for basic (poverty) level income just so you didn't have to work?
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by doopy-loopy2 on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:38PM (#24084518)
I own pretty much everything I need/want (paid off house, car, etc).

So now I usually just work to pay bills and spending money, stashing away for a rainy day, etc. Most of it goes to taxes.

Given UBI, I probably wouldn't even need to bother.

Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by lm28469 on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:58PM (#24084072)
I'd do it on the spot. My monthly spendings are already less than the min wage in my country. If everything else stays equal I'd gladly give up work for 75% of the min wage.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by fifnir on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:05PM (#24083400)
That will just incentivize companies to pay better salaries. Let the market decide what job positions are worth existing
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by headsupernova on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:42PM (#24083877)
good. maybe we can get back to doing work that brings meaning to people's lives.
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by evmar on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:55AM (#24083261)
(This comment is a nearly flawless example of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law , well done!)
Re:One-third of American renters expected to miss their Augu... by AbrahamParangi on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:59AM (#24083324)
Endless bailouts mean we already have UBI for corporations, why not actual Americans?

(to paraphrase)