I certainly have. It usually leads to 3-4 wasted years of dev time on the brand new architecture that will never match all the features of the old stack, and during that time the old stack has fewer and fewer resources and the tech debt piles up.
It is absurdly easy to come up with a better plan in 10 minutes if you have absolutely no idea how it really works or how complicated it really is.
However, I don't accept this answer. I think most of the time the government's plan is so bad, so glaringly flawed, that even from my position of ignorance, I'm confident I can beat it without hardly trying.
Because the edge cases often take more than ten minutes to reveal themselves?
See: "Tough on crime/drugs" policies, lead in gasoline and paint, etc.
The point of "hidden complexity" is that it's hidden. Talking to an expert in public policy in the specific area in question might well reveal the "glaring flaw" is actually a known thing, with a good but counter-intuitive reason behind it.
I've seen precisely that in software; big precautionary comments in code that say "this seems weird, but here's why it exists; you can try and fix it, but you'll just increment the 'leave this code alone' counter again".
Simply put, you can make better decisions because you don't have to negotiate.
However, it also appears to me to be objectively better for society at large, in as much as I'm able to be objective.
the problem is that one of the political parties has it as an ideological point that government doesn't and can't work, and sets out to sabotage everything to prove that they're right. Like how florida deliberately makes it impossible to get your unemployment.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast
There is, unfortunately, not a good fix for this, as similar parties exist worldwide. But banning Murdoch media and de-consolidating media control in general (returning local stations to local management, etc) would be a good start.
Cause right now this is your local news station: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hWLjYJ4BzvI
A large part of the problem of "why doesn't government produce good outcomes" is exactly this - people who have a vested personal interest in producing bad outcomes, because that's what they run on.
How do you fix it? Not easy obviously, but certain propaganda networks are a large chunk of the problem. Murdoch's networks specifically, and Sinclair's network controlling local broadcasting.
Winston S Churchill, 11 November 1947
https://winstonchurchill.org/resources/quotes/the-worst-form...
Yes.
Authoritarianism is fast and exceptional, because only everyone that matters gets a voice.
Problem is that fast ‘large decisions’ can be catastrophic, and those without a voice eventually rise up...
Because your plan doesn't please campaign funds, interest groups, and voters in a bicameral legislature and a long electoral college selected President .... and skate past 200 years of federal and state laws.
There's a reason why Caesar, Napoleon, Hitler, Stalin were able to achieve things quickly.
I'm starting to think that the outcome of our political systems in the West produces suboptimal compromises engineered by politicians who are quite frankly ignorant, incompetent, corrupt, and really just not good specimens of the species. It's like the system is designed to be mediocre.
What's the alternative though?