News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by alexander1100 on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:07PM (#24013312)
I personally lost $6000 dollars, is there any way I could prove that I was a victim and get my crypto back?
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by creato on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:10PM (#24013347)
You sent $6k in bitcoin to Elon Musk because you thought he'd give you $12k back?

Assuming this isn't a joke, consider that $6k a lesson to not be such a gullible mark.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by SahAssar on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:14PM (#24013398)
If you want legal recourse and refunds why would you use a currency that explicitly does not allow for those?

Seriously, if you want the protections of the legal system, then use currency controlled by the legal system.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by shuntress on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:20PM (#24013485)
Bitcoin is actually explicitly designed to enable recourse and refunds. Every single transaction is permanently and immutable tied to a verifiable identity.

Through common practice, these identities are treated as disposable and therefor generally ignored. But stating that the currency is explicitly designed to disallow accountability is not an accurate representation of reality.

--

Edit to add a practical example for clarification because this is being downvoted.

If the FBI conducts an effective warranted search + seizure of a mob safehouse, seizes a large safe, opens it up, and finds either:

A) Gold bricks

or

B) Bitcoin wallet private keys

In case (A), they can maybe correlate records, reports, statements, and other evidence to possibly determine the rightful owner of the gold or goods laundered for gold.

In case (B), they can check the BTC ledger against fraud reports that contain bitcoin wallet public keys, then publish a public statement asking people to prove they own any matching public keys -- because bitcoin, by it's fundamental nature, is more accountable in a way that enables recourse and refunds.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by SahAssar on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:30PM (#24013613)
Transactions are not reversible by legal authority in bitcoin, only by the receiving party willingly doing the transaction in reverse.

What you are talking about is establishing reputability, not about refund-ability or the ability of authorities to reverse illicit transactions. You can see that as a feature of bitcoin or not, but if you want protections from a system you need to act within that system.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by alexander1100 on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:37PM (#24013688)
I am saying I know I made a mistake and if they truly caught those who are responsible, then I don't see why they won't be able to get access to the stolen funds. My eth is in that collection of stolen funds. I'd rather prove it's mine and have the government return it to me vs them auctioning it off.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by SahAssar on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:45PM (#24013803)
I understand what you are saying, and I'm sorry you are in this situation. But I can also see that because you acted outside of the reach of the legal system then there is less chance of it being able to help you.

Sorry if I'm being heartless here but I'd also argue that the funds were not stolen, they were given in a system that provides almost no legal recourse.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by wmf on Friday July 31, 2020 @05:12PM (#24014166)
Cryptocurrency is not outside of the reach of the legal system.

"the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas ... ordered Trendon Shavers to pay more than $40 million in disgorgement and prejudgment interest, and a civil penalty of $150,000 related to [Bitcoin scam] BCS&T." https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/texas-man-sentenced-ope...

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by SahAssar on Friday July 31, 2020 @05:17PM (#24014227)
Right, when the person is identifiable and within that jurisdiction. I'm saying that if I pay X bitcoin to someone on the internet for a service I have less change of recourse within the law if I don't get that service (in this case a back payment of x*2). If it was a normal digital/creditcard/whatever transaction it'd be easier to reverse and deal with.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by shuntress on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:48PM (#24013839)
This is like saying that gold coins are explicitly designed not to allow recourse and refunds and that transactions in gold are not reversible by any legal authority.

In both BTC and solid gold, reversibility is not a property of the currency. It is a part of the system which uses that currency.

However, with Bitcoin (unlike with gold) the currency is explicitly designed with verifiable identity being fundamental to every transaction.

With Bitcoin, an individual can prove that they participated in a transaction that was later determined to be fraudulent. This is a fact of the currency. It is explicitly built in to Bitcoin at a foundational level.

Whether existing systems use that specific aspect of the currency to do anything meaningful is a separate matter.

But the fact is that bitcoin itself has more accountability than other currencies. Not less.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by SahAssar on Friday July 31, 2020 @05:05PM (#24014091)
What I said was "not reversible by legal authority". That's true for both gold coins and bitcoin if the legal authority don't have them to give.

I'm not saying bitcoin is less accountable and giving 6000$ in gold coins to a stranger promising to double them would only be slightly more responsible since then you'd at least know a physical jurisdiction.

What I'm saying is that when bitcoin X leaves wallet Y to wallet Z the only way to get back X into Y is for the holder of Z to willingly give it, while "normal" digital transactions can be reversed by the transactor or by law. So if you want a transaction to be reversible by law you probably don't want it in bitcoin. Please let me know if I'm wrong.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by shuntress on Friday July 31, 2020 @05:22PM (#24014306)
You are not wrong but you are glossing over the fact that by "digital transactions" you seem to actually mean "transactions brokered by a third party".

USD also works the way you describe. I may write someone a check based on a fraudulent premise then later demand my money back. If they have already cashed that check and run then the money is gone from their account and there is no way to reverse the transaction. The bank may charge them, cancel their account, pay me back anyway, etc. These are all actions taken by the third party broker.

With USD the accountability of my_account -> check -> fraudsters_account -> cash is all part of the third party's (the bank's) system.

With BTC, this chain of accountability (my_wallet -> transaction -> fraudsters_wallet) is part of the currency itself.

If the fraudster is later caught and their fraudulent gains seized, with BTC I can prove which of those fraudulent gains came from my wallet and be reimbursed with potentially little technical fuss.

My point is that your point may be true of the systems built to handle transactions made with bitcoin but is not true of bitcoin itself.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by SahAssar on Friday July 31, 2020 @05:32PM (#24014430)
Agreed, but the financial system we have is set up to handle one of those scenarios and not the other. Bitcoin could be as good or better at this use-case, but for now that is not the case.
[dead]
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by shuntress on Saturday August 01, 2020 @12:45PM (#24021871)
I was excited by Bitcoin when the whitepaper came out and I just think it's neat.

The huge explosion in Bitcoin popularity with daytrader "lambo" jerks led to a ton of people (even technically inclined people) talking about Bitcoin without understanding it too well. So now it sort of sets me off.

Plus, it's way easier (and more fun) to fight about something frivolous like Bitcoin than it is to fight about things that are actually important.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by advisedwang on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:15PM (#24013420)
You can probably find the blockchain transaction of you paying them. So long as you can prove you own the sender, that's you proof right there.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by null0pointer on Friday July 31, 2020 @06:26PM (#24014937)
I think it's unlikely you will get any recourse here. However what you can do is the following.

1) Find one of the input addresses for the transaction(s) you sent to the scammers

2) Use that address to sign a message like "alexander1100 owns this address" (but use your legal name) to prove ownership of the address.

3) Attempt to follow up with the FBI about recovering your lost funds. This is the step that you will have the most trouble with.

Good luck.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by daseiner1 on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:09PM (#24013335)
I don’t mean to be rude, but I have to ask - what were you thinking?
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by rocqua on Friday July 31, 2020 @07:03PM (#24015305)
In EVE online, many doubling scams would actually pay out the first few times. This to encourage others to commit bigger sums. Hence, if you 'get in early' it might be worth it to try and get your money doubled.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by dtech on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:22PM (#24013512)
Unassuming it's not a troll, $ signs in the eyes.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by cordite on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:19PM (#24013480)
Good luck.

This is how bitcoin works. You send value to somewhere else of your will. There is no outside party here.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by shadowgovt on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:45PM (#24013798)
Practically speaking, at this point the government is probably in possession of the private keys and could authorize reverse transactions to restore the stolen crypto.

The larger question is a question of policy and law... Does the government even consider entries in a blockchain ledger to be "returnable stolen property?"

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by wmf on Friday July 31, 2020 @05:13PM (#24014181)
Yes, crypto scammers have been forced to give money back before.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by boring_twenties on Friday July 31, 2020 @06:05PM (#24014768)
> is there any way I could prove that I was a victim

Sure, you just need to find the transaction hash, and prove that you own the sending address.

> and get my crypto back?

Now that the government has control of the wallets, my guess would be probably, eventually.

Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by Jasper_ on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:19PM (#24013474)
I thought Bitcoin's biggest feature was No Chargebacks
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by rocqua on Friday July 31, 2020 @07:03PM (#24015312)
No central party can issue chargebacks. But if the FBI got the funds, they can just send the funds back.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by mrtksn on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:27PM (#24013576)
Can you please tell us how did you fall to this scam? I find it fascinating when something seems obvious to me but not to someone else and vice versa.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by superhuzza on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:43PM (#24013776)
Wow, if true your "contribution" was around 5% of the total amount scammed.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by spoopyskelly on Saturday August 01, 2020 @07:37PM (#24024895)
I can help you, but you need to send me $6k for verification and I'll send it back + the other 6k you lost.
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by paulpauper on Friday July 31, 2020 @05:21PM (#24014300)
assuming not a troll, there is a possibility the money will be seized and returned to victims . i assume if the stolen coin are on coinbase, they have been frozen,
Re:Tampa teen accused of being ‘mastermind’ behind Twitter hack by neatze on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:21PM (#24013493)
this must be a joke.