News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by pjc50 on Friday July 31, 2020 @07:16AM (#24007561)
Well, this is easy: remove the news. Also deals with all accusations of bias at the same time.

> pay Australia media companies ~$1b

This is Rupert Murdoch, isn't it.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by Mandatum on Friday July 31, 2020 @08:07AM (#24007848)
Murdoch is the Australian Bezos - except he has way more political clout in a larger area of the world, and has been running his empire for 30+ years. Bezos is building those relationships with his expansions, and he's obviously got more cash to fund them - but Murdoch's empire shouldn't be underestimated.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by monkeynotes on Friday July 31, 2020 @10:32AM (#24008899)
His organization also has significant clout in the US and UK where he owns big media corporations. He's long influenced British politics, and through Fox US politics. This bill looks to be sponsored, and crafted by Murdoch.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by ehsankia on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:25PM (#24011045)
At least Bezos provides us with an arguably useful service. What the hell has Murdoch provided the people other than FUD?
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by afterburner on Friday July 31, 2020 @02:51PM (#24012338)
Weird way of putting it. People in North America who pay attention to politics have known about Murdoch for decades because of Fox News, before they bounced Bezos' name around nearly as freely.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by montjoy on Friday July 31, 2020 @11:11AM (#24009386)
It’s right there in the article.

> Media companies including News Corp Australia, a unit of Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp (NWSA.O), lobbied hard for the government to force the U.S. companies to the negotiating table amid a long decline in advertising revenue.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by ardy42 on Friday July 31, 2020 @10:02AM (#24008654)
> Well, this is easy: remove the news. Also deals with all accusations of bias at the same time.

Not so easy, since if you do that, you've just given an opening to a competitor that people will start using when they want to search for a news article.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by falcolas on Friday July 31, 2020 @10:18AM (#24008781)
A competitor who would be equally obliged to pay rent for the news. That’s a pretty big regulatory hurdle for a startup to cross.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by boring_twenties on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:52PM (#24011415)
Unless I've grossly misunderstood, it seems that the bill would apply only to Google and Facebook right now.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by pankajdoharey on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:42PM (#24011284)
Would this payment also apply to a news startup which shows links from other news agencies and shows up on google. Is google obliged to pay this news site under the law? If so I just found my new internet startup and paying client.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by chillfox on Friday July 31, 2020 @08:12PM (#24015947)
There’s some language in there so that they only have to pay large news corporations that hire professional journalists.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by ardy42 on Friday July 31, 2020 @10:29AM (#24008869)
> A competitor who would be equally obliged to pay rent for the news. That’s a pretty big regulatory hurdle for a startup to cross.

Maybe, but Google's interest is in maintaining its search monopoly, not creating opportunities for its destruction in fits of pique.

I'm also skeptical about how much of a hurdle this would actually be, since businesses typically have to pay suppliers (e.g. by licensing content). These rules probably only seems like a big thing because SV tech businesses have been weirdly allowed to opt out of paying in situations like this for a long time. It's not like the necessity of paying royalties prevented Netflix from taking off.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by dodobirdlord on Saturday August 01, 2020 @05:44AM (#24019138)
> fits of pique

"Fits of pique" like being extorted for $1 billion dollars per year? That's something like 4% of their global profit that they're being asked to fork over for the privilege of continuing to provide a just one search functionality in a small and isolated market. They'll just disable news searches in Australia lol.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by csallen on Friday July 31, 2020 @02:04PM (#24011586)
I don't see any reason why Google itself couldn't simply spin off a competitor. They wouldn't have to own it. They could simply provide know-how, discounts on infrastructure, investment, and/or acquire the company at a later date.

Seems cheaper and more fruitful than simply forking over $1B. Then again, the risk to doing so might be scarier than a billion-dollar fine, especially if you factor in that the move (if discovered) would piss off legislators.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by dodobirdlord on Saturday August 01, 2020 @05:50AM (#24019179)
$1 billion / year is a lot of money. They'll just not serve news results for Australian-origin searches. Most searches are not for news, and news searches are not product searches and probably don't draw much ad money. People can use Bing for their news until the government wises up and adds Microsoft to their list of applicable companies (currently just Facebook and Google), at which point I'm sure Microsoft will also disable news search results in Australia.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by monkeynotes on Friday July 31, 2020 @10:32AM (#24008906)
Cheaper to pay $1bn to Murdoch than loose all the ad revenue from Australia.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by ehsankia on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:27PM (#24011075)
That's assuming that they won't coming back begging once they realize that they need Google much more than Google needs them. Ad revenue from news sites from Australia is a slice of a slice for Google. For the news company, it's probably 90% of their traffic.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by libertine on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:46PM (#24011326)
Uh-oh... if all news sites had a drop of 90% of traffic pretty sure the monopoly bells would start ringing!

If this is being done on purpose to make a case, it's a goddamn genius move - next level chess.

Google could be in a tight spot.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by Nasrudith on Friday July 31, 2020 @09:40PM (#24016545)
I don't get it - isn't that giving them exactly what they claim to want?

"You say we are unfairly dominating? Fine we'll leave and let competitors take our place." Not competing at all in a market (barring reciprocial cartel territory divisuon) is the exact opposite of anti-competive behavior. They aren't even existing there to harm them!

At worst it would be monosopy and again they provided the remedy, reducing their "buying share" of the market to 0%.

It is essentially the ultimate calling of a bluff by not sticking around to be their scapegoat.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by ehsankia on Friday July 31, 2020 @05:39PM (#24014503)
I'm not an expert, but I'm not sure if that applies here. Google isn't in the business of making news, and isn't competing with these news companies directly. If you get 90% of the traffic to your portfolio from my blog, does that make me a monopoly too?
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by kmeisthax on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:01PM (#24013258)
Is it ordinarily the case for competition law in Australia to require someone with monopoly power to do business with someone when their prices increase dramatically?
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by kortilla on Friday July 31, 2020 @10:47AM (#24009087)
Once a protection racket works, it doesn’t tend to discourage others.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by kelvin0 on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:28PM (#24011082)
Yes. One giant extorting another giant.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by nwsm on Friday July 31, 2020 @11:30AM (#24009627)
Many people google topics to find news articles. That traffic may be worth $1B to Google.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by majani on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:33PM (#24010383)
Not really. There's never been a lot of search ads on news search terms and news carries with it headaches that Google might be relieved to be rid of. Most likely scenario is that Google just deletes news from Australian searches, and Australians just find another aggregator for their news, which will probably be another large American platform that doesn't pay publishers
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by wutbrodo on Friday July 31, 2020 @02:31PM (#24011994)
> There's never been a lot of search ads on news search terms

The searches don't need to convert themselves in order to be valuable; if they affect user behavior enough, they'll affect it for commercial queries too. Ie, if someone switches to Bing because they never get good results on Google, they'll probably just switch to Bing period, instead of jumping back to Google for their commercial queries.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by dodobirdlord on Saturday August 01, 2020 @05:53AM (#24019197)
It's $1 billion / year, and it's just news searches in Australia. Some database queries will figure out whether it's more profitable to pay up or to disable news searching in Australia, and I'd bet it's gonna be disabling news searches.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by wutbrodo on Monday August 03, 2020 @03:32PM (#24042267)
It's very possible that the math works out to be , but I disagree that the value of "disabling news searches in Australia" is tightly captured in a database. It's going to require some non-trivial modeling of the effect of removing news on the habits of Australian searchers, and how that may affect commercial queries: it's a very non-trivial part of most people's usage of Google.

Some relevant things to consider:

1) The Australian market provides Google about ~$5B/yr in revenue, so a 20% revenue loss would be required

2) The global PR impact of disabling news searches, even in a local market

3) The future costs of setting the precedent of giving in to rent-seeking mafia tactics from a specific government; if they think it's likely to embolden other governments to do the same thing, it may be worth drawing a bright line despite the revenue costs

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by throwaheyy on Saturday August 01, 2020 @12:22PM (#24021660)
There is no way news searches are worth $40 per potential customer. Assuming every single person in Australia searched for news on Google.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by onetimemanytime on Friday July 31, 2020 @08:17AM (#24007915)
No love lost between Google and newspapers. Money is gonna from their ads to Google. So have readers.