I am completely with you conceptually, but from experience I can tell you that even if there is a commercial incentive to allow for local communication it takes a few days to get it working with the cloud and months to do it locally only. And you really need to know what you are doing to make it safe and reliable in all eventualities.
No it isn't. We were doing it for years before "the cloud" or even the modern Internet even existed using Bluetooth, RF, IR, and cables. Have you ever looked at a .fit file on a Garmin watch? It's a binary format, but is straightforward to convert to CSV, and doesn't contain much beyond timestamp, latitude, longitude, altitude, heart rate, cadence, and a few other fields. Calculating distance, duration, training effect, calories burned, etc. is simple summarization and arithmetic, plotting course on a map just requires an offline map and a plotting library. It already does all of this ON THE WATCH itself without needing any connection to anything else, so there's nothing stopping an app from doing the same thing locally on a much more powerful iPhone or Android phone. The Garmin cloud is only inserted in the process here so they can monetize your data.
Using a third party transfer app. and then viewing it with another third party app, directly on my phone. no battery complaints, but those ANT transfers were pretty flakey.
I dont think you can browse files on the watch through bluetooth, but an OTG cable would do the trick.
Even if that were true (and it's not), it's not how Garmin sync works. The website isn't cloud based middleware, and the watch and phone sync over bluetooth. It really is as dumb and frustrating as the OP describes.
Before syncing with the watch, over bluetooth, the app connects to the Garmin website. If the web connection fails then the transfer fails.
> make it safe and reliable in all eventualities
You mean precisely like it isn't now?
I'd much rather have something fail locally based on conditions that I can affect, than fail remotely and be completely out of my control.
[1]: https://hackaday.com/2017/12/29/34c3-fitbit-sniffing-and-fir...
And we'll, there seem to be ready to use libraries, you can use without signing the NDA: https://github.com/search?q=fit+garmin&type=
It was 100% about user expectations, the data was never mined for anything.
People use multiple phones, replace their phone, delete apps to free up space, and still expect their data to be there.
Running a cloud infrastructure for PII isn't exactly low cost, and bundling a life time subscription with a one time device purchase is horrible economics. It isn't done for no reason.
Oh I wasn't implying what's generally seen as "data mining". But for such a company to offer many of the features in the paid services they need that data. They don't have to sell it to others, they only have to sell it back to the users as added services even included in the price of the hardware itself. Those added services can be as simple as sync between multiple phones or sharing on social media, or premium features like advanced analytics.
On the other hand this kind of data can be also sold entirely anonymized. Strava does this and many cities' urban planners buy the data to understand better how the city infrastructure is used by the people (running, cycling, etc.) and how to develop it.
I'm not saying there's no value in it, just that without it the value of the product decreases significantly. So it's in the manufacturer's best interest to have it as part of the basis of their offering.
I just wanted to point out that since cloud based communication is so easy nowadays, doing sync without cloud support is a significantly larger effort. Not unachievable though.
Another reason is that if you still want to sync with the cloud, you need two synchronisation systems that have to be kept in sync too.
Leslie Lamport
Just imagine how much more $$ one can elicit in an acquisition if potential buyers may add tolls to an already established and well-traveled gate.
Fortunately the watch appears as a usb device when connecting with a charging cable. So it is possible to get data out without relying on accounts and social features.
You really wonder that? I'm sorry, how stupid are you? It's obviously to harvest data and control users. We've been warning and educating people about this for decades. When are you guys starting to wake up and voting with your wallet? Open services! Open software! Open formats! Own your data! Own your devices! Your life will be full of such disruptions if you keep using products that let corporations dominate you.
No one likes to admit that they screwed up, though -- and we all know that the truth can hurt sometimes.
---
Unfortunately, you were (likely) downvoted mostly because your blunt, honest statement comes across as condescending and rude: "Maybe you're right, but you didn't have to be such an asshole about it."
What those people are either not realizing or conveniently choosing to forget is that, just as you said, we've all been warned about this exact thing* for decades! Apparently, though, the message isn't geting through. When that happens, this type of "tone" becomes necessary in order to get people to pay attention.
Unfortunately, most will still choose not to heed the warnings. Evntually, when it (inevitably) happens to them, they'll say something like "Meanwhile ... users (like me) are wondering how it is that [this could happen]" and, of course, they'll avoid admitting any responsibility for their choices. They would much rather play the part of "completely innocent victim who could never have imagined something like this might happen".
---
It reminds me a lot of a small child that is told, repeatedly, "don't do 'X' because 'Y' will happen" and, later, is absolutely SHOCKED when they "learn" -- the hard way, typically -- that, when they do 'X', 'Y' happens.
If a child learns the hard way that X -> Y I don't berate them and call them stupid for not listening. It doesn't make them more likely to listen the next time. Same with adults, really.
Unfortunately, a much stronger tone is often needed in order to to get people to pay attention.
For a different industry, is there an open source e-reader I can support instead of Amazon/kobo/nook?
Maybe I'm stupid as you say, but I genuinely don't know if these things are out there and a quick Google search didn't turn up anything I'd call usable.
- https://codeberg.org/jannis/FitoTrack
Hardware cycling computers, like the Garmin 830 or Wahoo Elemnt Roam, are physical hardware designed for the use case of being strapped to handlebars and being used in a wide range of environments. The battery life and performance is tuned towards always on GPS and Bluetooth for connecting to sensors. They utilize a wider range of GNSS constellations. They have physical buttons as touchscreens don't work well when wet. The screens are designed to be visible in sunlight.
Like the GP, I'm not aware of any open hardware cycling computers.
https://www.goldencheetah.org/
Among others reads .fit data directly from Garmin.
Some solution where I can track my runs, swims, cyclings, treks just like Strava (et al) does does but I can choose to keep the data wherever I wish - local, or sync to an app on computer or to a self hosted server.
Maybe not Garmin but I would love to use such an iOS Strava alternative with similar accuracy and detail.
[1] https://runalyze.com/ [2] https://github.com/Runalyze/Runalyze/
Meanwhile Garmin watches users (like me) are wondering how it is that syncing my watch that I have bought with an application on my smartphone that I have bought requires presence of some distant online service.
I can understand that some parts like "social" stuff might depend on some central service but, hey, something simple like syncing ones excercise achievements between phone and watch? Really? Who has designed that?