It's expensive and slow to hire a photographer and a studio and a model, and you have to ship the clothes there ahead of the launch on your website to have them spend all day getting in and out of different outfits while stylists keep their hair tidy, then the photographs go to the art direction team to be photoshopped to match the site aesthetic...
If you can just get someone in the factory in China to snap a photograph of the latest batch of dresses and tops and skirts as they come off the sewing table, then you can just send them into a GAN, and have style-matched 'photographs' generated showing the clothes on a selection of different models, each of whose appearance is perfectly tailored to appeal to different market segments.
You can have high quality creative on your website and in the product feed to Google the same day, and start taking orders before the inventory starts piling up.
Then next week, you can do it again with the next set of designs.
Just a simple photo of the garment will not tell you how it behaves on the body (how "malleable" it is, how it bends, wrinkles etc.) and how it interacts with the light. Just ask any artist about the nuances of painting clothing materials - it's a big subject in its own right. I suspect that only shooting photos on a in-factory models, in various lighting conditions MIGHT be enough to train the AI.
Even just being able to shift skin tone, and not show a face will work and will add to profitablily because people do want to know that clothing will work with their complexion
IMO, modeling is one of those things that will never go away because of how cheap this labor is compared to hiring someone to make a software solution. Just like how it is cheaper to stock a fast food joint with a few minimum wage people worked to the bone than a sleek robot with a pricey service contract, even if the latter is sexier.
https://web.archive.org/web/20141230115206/http://www.cgsoci...
Granted, there may be a new generation of agents that specialize in AI models and royalties may still exist (with shrinking margins), but if nothing more, AI is likely to opt downward pressure on wages/jobs/contracts some of the non-minimum-wage models. Once it's bootstrapped, it will either become more appealing (for the reasons I mentioned above) or turn out to be complex and not worth the cost/risk. Only time and experimentation will tell.
I'm not envisioning a future in which some company creates a full persona for their AI models, and we get a full Tay[1] moment out of it, and then we've come full circle.
I'm reminded of the (aweful) film Simone (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simone_(2002_film)), and a Ben Bova novel (possibly Starcrossed) in which CGI gradually replaces human actors.
Lots of typos for me today... :/
Am also agreeing with you and extending the notion. AI is by no-means outrage-proof.
This sounds vaguely similar to initial discussions I remember with self-diving cars. It begins with "I look forward to the day we don't have fallible humans at the wheel" and end with the realization the AIs are going to be more fallible and in different, strange ways.
I mean, hypothetically, suppose you had a system that could constantly monitor world fashion trends, world clothing markets, the routes of hip and average people and so-forth. In the case you might create a system that produced a variety of still and moving images that satisfied all the constraints that today's fashion industry satisfies just with a few written or spoken suggestions from executives. Then you'd eliminated no just models but a large chunk of the industry.
But let's look at what "AI" is now (and what it seems likely to be for a while without any "revolutionary" changes). What you have now is a way to extrapolate typical objects out of a stream of similar objects. Just GPT-3 does a great job create texts that sound vaguely right, you can create a vaguely plausible looking set of still and moving images of one or another "typical" model. Moreover, these extrapolations require constant training by professional much more highly paid than actual models now (as the GP notes).
Further, without being in the fashion industry, I'm pretty sure there's a lot more to a useful set of images than "looking about right". I suspect you could generate a model-image that would "work" with a kind of clothing (since both clothing and image can be trained). But generating a model-image that suits a given demographic, that expresses "what's becoming hip right now" and so-forth would be extremely hard. It may not be impossible but it would require lots of high paid labor by AI engineers, defeating the entire purpose once the novelty wears off. And all this is to say that these "replace human activity" approaches wind-up with the problem of doing an "90%" of the activity right and then foundering on corner cases - like self-driving cars that are easy-yet-impossible AI tasks.
I mean, when I picture the problem, I imagine taking a single panorama-like photo capture with a smartphone, circling repeatedly around a human being whose likeness you want to use; and the phone using its barrage of sensors and ML cores to spit out a pre-rigged and textured high-poly 3D model of that person, that you can then drop into Blender and throw your clothing designs onto (i.e. the very same digitally-simulated designs that your designers prototyped with before getting the design made for real — presuming there was any amount of industrial design going into the object, which there certainly is for anything as complex as e.g. glasses frames, or a handbag.)
The pre-rigged 3D model output from such a body-scanning app would have a standardized rigging, such that 1. you'd know how your digital clothing items would interact with it before attaining the body-scan itself; and 2. allowing you to throw some posing "behaviour" scripts on it (that target said standardized rigging.) So this could all be parallelized.
Last step: pick a 3D-recreated environment, set the viewpoint camera and lighting, and snap screenshots at will. (This part doesn't need to be a science; you can just put a trained photographer in VR goggles, and have them circle around the digital model taking digital pictures with their field-of-view at time of trigger-press being the composed shot.)
The important part of this, from a cost perspective, is that you can then reuse this model for a combinatoric number of "shots", without ever paying the original body-scanned person again, or taking time to organize a new physical shoot with them. You can "re-shoot" them in localized advertisements for every target market you're launching the product in, all without needing to leave the room, let alone paying them to come back in. If you launch accessory products months later, you don't need to retain their talent; you have them "on file." Likewise if you need to dredge them up 10 years later for an anniversary "shoot."
Just generate a spread of different looks, test them on different audiences, and measure engagement. Feed that back into the parameterization for generating the next set of images.
I think this is the crux of the issue.
A GAN generated face textured onto a convincing 3D model means you can just keep clicking or adjusting until you got a truly beautiful model, without needing to pay extra for it, and you know your exposure is capped in entirely predictable ways. This model won't unexpectedly cause trouble for you, or demand you take a particular stance you may not agree with in order to employ them.
If you're a big outfit looking to control risks, it might be very tempting.
Stock photography probably does have some effect, for some websites where they might have hired a model. Suppose stock photography gets better, more flexible? What could a more ambitious stock photography company do to help clothing retailers find a different way to sell clothes?
While there will likely always be added commercial value for (human) celebrity campaigns – e.g. Kanye and Gap, Jennifer Lawrence and Dior – I'm not sure how Old Navy/Banana Republic/Uniqlo/etc. would suffer much at all by having digital models for their website and in-store photography.
Is that AI-able? Not yet. Making edited images look seamless is still a moderately skilled job, and AI is still struggling with basic object recognition, never mind the semantics of object presentation.
It might be possible one day, but not for a good few years.
High end modelling is about celebrity, and that's not going to be replaced any time soon.
Likewise for high end fashion photography. You can't hand something like Nick Knight's work over to an AI, because no AI has the creativity or imagination needed to make images that look like that, and engage the viewer like that.
It might be possible in principle to automate some of the more obvious fashion cliches - intensely aesthetic people with cheek bones in a variety of exotic locations - but it's harder than it looks, and the quality of manual production values will make it very hard for AI efforts to cross uncanny valley without getting stuck in it.
Attempts will also suffer from the CGI problem, where CGI turned out to be more expensive than modelling for most movies. And the results end up looking plastic and rather soulless no matter how much detail they have.
The Mandalorian begs to differ.
The problem was that the actor couldn't see the CGI in real-time.
Once they built full wall displays so the actors could see what they were acting to, everything improved quite dramatically.
That will be covered by the top 100 models of the time. Those are the ones that have millions of IG followers.
The next tiers down will absolutely be replaced. The model interviewed about it has the exact same opinion because she actually lives that industry.
That said, I don't think you're right to place big companies that provide most of the media presence of fashion scenes in that category. Big clothing companies care about selling clothes, not about art, and they'll follow the cheapest, most effective way to do that. A marketing scheme based around supporting artists might happen, but if it happens it will be because market research says it plays well with target demographics, not because of some sense of charity. And it will likely be a token gesture, not a core strategy.
Look at what has already happened in fashion in the past: nods to fat shaming have been laughably tiny "plus sized" models, nods to race issues have been light-skinned black women with primarily European features, nods to skin not being perfect have been un-photo-shopped pictures of women who, from what I can tell, have perfect skin to begin with. And the vast majority of the time the gigantic Broadway/Lafayette billboard is a slender white photoshopped woman.
The cost of doing this stuff with AI is only going down. Why would you pay a whole photo crew and model when you can send a few low-rez photos of the clothes to a team in Bangalore and get back a video of a "model" with exactly the body specifications you request, doing exactly what you want, for $200?
In some way, the demand for modelling has probably gone up, but it's more long tailed. The internet also allowed for more "democracy" in this area and less gatekeeping
The different tastes and long-tailed nature probably contributed to less emphasis on "top models"/attention being focused on a sole person and/or mainstream beauty standards
The latter seems to be bound to be replaced by AI eventually. I could see something similar happen like to orchestral music for movies and games where since years only few players, especially soloists, are recorded live and the rest is entierly made up by virtual instruments good enough to trick most people into thinking there is an full orchestra.
Think we are going to have real models for the magazine covers and expensive ads for a long time. But for e.g. online clothes shopping, to be honest, I would prefer to be able to switch out and modify the models to something closer to my body than what they usually are.
At some point it will just be simpler and cheaper to replace Photoshop and in fact the entire photography/imaging pipeline by some AI.
If you can put your clothes on a virtual model in photoshop -and be done right there - that will be it.
I think this will start to happen in the next 5 years.
First for the 1/2 of fashion that is low-end and it will look a little off - but as colour and lighting and sets improve, it will make its way into other brands.
Once they can start generated images 'for free' they will, and it may not even be the unit expense, it may be the operational expense.
Chicago Tribune now sends reporters out with iPhones instead of having staff photographers.
Our food supply is full of filler and garbage ingredients.
Fashion brands are constantly dying, where there is a way to lower costs, it will happen.
I doubt that the "brands" do any "finegrained" optimization, it's "make shirt or have no food"; the actual subcontractors probably do, but not in any rigorous way except introducing slavery.
They are viscously price-sensitive industries, always flirting with commercial problems, running on very thin margins with ugly working capital requirements.
These are exactly the kinds of companies that will use nearly-free AI instead of real models.
And FYI, they are excessively optimised for efficiency, more so than most industries. When an item doesn't sell, it goes on clearance right away. They adapt faster than any other industry to trends, down to the micro level. 'Home Base' knows exactly what is going on in every store and everything they make, cost & labour is a key consideration: 'this kind of seam -> this kind of cost' , 'this pattern doesn't fit well onto sheets of material leading to XYZ amount of waste, implies ABC extra cost'. Their online data is mapped to local inventories etc..
That's the only way 'fast fashion' exists, and it's a function of their scale, reach, adaptability etc.. In many ways, they are 'exemplary'.
The interesting question is whether the cost of the technology solution can be brought down below the cost of the human solution. If it can, then it's not a question of "if" the humans will be replaced but "when". I don't know enough about the cost structure to give an answer.
Good luck replacing that with expensive AI developers to produce fake stuff.
For most of us, photography is just point the phone and tap the screen, without really giving much thought to lighting (colour/s, fill/spot combinations), scene composition, lenses, and probably a lot of things I don’t even have names for given the stuff I’ve listed is stuff I only know about from 3D modelling.
And conversely, the end users of a future AI synth of a model won’t be paying directly for expensive AI developers, any more than the average visitor of thispersondoesnotexist.com
Yes, but there's no shortage of people who know all the involved stuff...
High-skill as in "you need to know lotsa stuff", yes.
High-skills as in "the skills are rare, and require a special degree or years or training", no.
They're not that rare (there's an overabundance of both skilled and non-skilled photographers), and they're not that hard to pick up (to the point that 18 year olds can know all there is to it with a little determination and practice).
Or let's just say that "high skill" is relative, and being a pro photographer is hardly like being a pro coder or a surgeon...
I’m really not sure this is the case. I know more about cinematography than photography (I direct) but here in China a decent cinematographer can charge for a day what some workers might earn in a year. And you can tell the difference between their work and someone cheaper. That would suggest to me their skills are rare.
This is where I strongly disagree. Becoming good at composition, setting up shots, etc is an art and can take a lifetime to perfect. No less high skill than programming.
Render the clothes on the model before production to test demand. Render the model in the outfit the customer has in their cart right now.
I've lived in NYC for the last decade+. Had many friends that had legitimate careers as models. Some lasted a year with just a few shoots and a self-funded trip to Paris fashion week before they quit or went into debt over it. Some have been going at it for more than a decade and you would recognize if you flipped through a fashion magazine even semi-regularly.
I also work in media, date someone in fashion and have knowledge of what actually gets paid to models.
While there are a rare few who find a real career out of it and rise out of the traps of shitty agencies and contracts, usually by branching out and establishing a self-brand, none of them that I know made something they can comfortably retire on just with what we would consider the job of a model.
There are certainly exceptions to this but in general, if you're a fashion brand, digital or print magazine offering any type of exposure, hiring a model is inexpensive. Rarely if ever livable wages. That goes for most of the people who work on sets or for fashion shows.
So with all of that preamble out of the way, what I am getting at is...
1. Coordinating an AI model, that has to wear these clothes, and that bracelet, and be on this location, or pictures with this lighting sounds complex and expensive when hiring a set to produce the real thing is a known quantity and cost virtually minimum wages. 2. There are still people who deeply care about the art of the whole thing and do most of their work for free to be supported in anyway to keep doing it. I am looking on the not so bright, bright side here but I'd like to think AI is little more of a thread than stock photography.