News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by goalieca on Thursday July 16, 2020 @08:42AM (#23858380)
I'm not a sophisticated sociologist or anything by any means but I'd wager that social media originated and continues to drive the trend in popularism. The "upvote", "like", "retweet", and "share" buttons are a huge enabler for popular content to rise up and drown out all other. The only editorial review are the algorithms which are designed only to proliferate it even further.

Yesterday I suggested that we need to get rid of the downvote button. I see a problem where prevailing opinions only become reinforced with double the efficiency. It may even be greater because of the psychological effect of "grey = bad" or "collapsed = bad".

edit: typo desired->designed.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by benlumen on Thursday July 16, 2020 @08:49AM (#23858434)
I agree - the system gamifies conversation and literally rewards saying the popular thing with points. That's great for funny comments on memes, but it's not ideal for politics.

Obviously, we're doing it here right now, which brings me onto a second point - I have found that Hacker News is frequented by similar-minded people who will take my ideas in good faith, so I take time to post here. But I no longer bother with other platforms that would downvote me for saying the same thing.

And so, we're becoming inexperienced with ideas we disagree with.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by pjc50 on Thursday July 16, 2020 @09:27AM (#23858734)
I'm very experienced with the opposing views .. and I find it increasingly difficult to assume that they're both held in good faith and also willing to take my views as held in good faith.

There's a "iterated prisoner's dilemma" thing going on, where the side that plays "defect" all the time has got the upper hand.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by qqn on Thursday July 16, 2020 @09:54AM (#23859004)
Yes to the "defect" thought. Learning about Karpman's triangle[0] helped me understand this. In conflict, people flit between three identities: the villain who tries to force their way, the hero who tries to save the situation, and the victim who accepts loss and points out their difficulties. And everyone's trying to be the victim because that's who ultimately gets their way, through manipulating the "don't kick someone when they're down" mentality. Fascinating stuff, and now that I've seen it I just can't unsee it almost everywhere.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karpman_drama_triangle

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by qqn on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:47AM (#23859511)
I should add that the tendency of adopting the hero role ("let bygones be bygones, but we need to get this done") isn't ideal since it leaves a power imbalance in its wake. A more effective response lies in Nonviolent Communication,[0] so saying, "When you say this I feel this because I value this. Would you be willing to do this?" This way emotions are managed and both parties begin exiting the dialogue understanding each other, and on equal footing.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonviolent_Communication

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by watwut on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:55AM (#23859592)
And then I tell you that I am not responsible for your feelings, you are. Which is very common thing to say these days. Or I say you that you are oversensitive and emotional.

I agree that "hero" in original framing basically favors status quo.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by qqn on Thursday July 16, 2020 @12:47PM (#23860808)
You're right. In the case of a narcissist or someone looking to argue (or someone very emotionally invested and stirred up), the "broken pop machine" method is better. They try to press your buttons but you don't react, saying things like, "Gee, I can't help you with that," and they eventually disengage.

Applying Karpman's triangle assumes both parties genuinely want to (and can) move forward.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by tomjen3 on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:55AM (#23867510)
Nonviolent communication seems to be reasonably popular here, but I must admit that that quote comes of as extremely condescending and manipulative to me.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by qqn on Friday July 17, 2020 @11:15PM (#23878592)
I have found it helps assuming kindness and sincerity from the other end. When this works, it works well.

I was reminded of this thought: "No matter how considerate you are, or how much effort you put into avoiding my triggers, the total freedom in the world does not increase until I learn to release the grip they have on me." (https://twitter.com/RichDecibels/status/1197769030880419841)

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:35PM (#23862948)
The KDT is a brilliant insight, but it only really works if people have some ability to distance from a situation and their own emotional framing of it.

I recently dropped a link to the KDT into a rather mad online flame war that took a Facebook forum by surprise.

It may have made a few participants stop and think, but overall it was a low EQ mistake and didn't go well. I don't recommend it.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by ReptileMan on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:38AM (#23859405)
We live in crazy times. No one takes any argument that they don't agree at good faith. It is all about the zinger.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by mrfusion on Thursday July 16, 2020 @07:53PM (#23865265)
I really liked slashdots system. It seemed to work well too.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by newen on Thursday July 16, 2020 @08:57AM (#23858509)
Hacker News has a very specific techno-libertarian Silicon Valley type outlook and you get downvoted pretty quickly when you express other types of views, especially in politics and controversial topics.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by Bjartr on Thursday July 16, 2020 @09:24AM (#23858722)
I find that if such opinions are communicated civilly, they are much, much less likely to be downvoted. It's not like no one here will knee jerk downvote, but most often I see aggressive posts downvoted much more consistently than "merely" controversial ones
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by mellosouls on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:08AM (#23859124)
I agree that uncivil comments are down-voted more often, but there is clear "I don't agree with you even though you've made your point intelligently, so I will see if I can make it disappear" which is really unfortunate and not conducive to civil discourse.

Perhaps less than other platforms but certainly a thing - often with no counter comment to explain. All seems a bit small-minded.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by bluGill on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:12AM (#23859159)
If you are civil you get less down votes, but some opinions will automatically get you a few down votes no matter how insightful and well worded.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by skissane on Thursday July 16, 2020 @06:42PM (#23864698)
Some people downvote because a silent downvote is risk-free, a response isn't. Especially on a controversial topic, why respond and run the risk of being downvoted by those who disagree with you when you can just downvote and move on?
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by iagovar on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:43AM (#23859452)
I'm a utilitarian social democrat and I don't think I ever been downvoted because of that, despite living in a world completely different from SV. I'm not american, I'm not rich, and some of the problems that SV like to focus at seem childish and/or absurd to me, but here I am, still thinking that HN is probably one of the best communities.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by _jal on Thursday July 16, 2020 @09:17AM (#23858665)
If this is the sort of thing you like, you'll like it here. Choose your bubble.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by andrepd on Thursday July 16, 2020 @09:36AM (#23858799)
Case in point, this very comment!
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by malandrew on Thursday July 16, 2020 @11:39AM (#23860081)
I downvoted it because it's anecdotal and furthermore not accurate based on my own anecdotal experience. i.e. I'm using my downvote for my anecdotal experience to cancel their anecdotal experience. Likewise I expect downvotes on this comment for being anecdotal as well (except in the circumstance that some of the additional commentary below garners upvotes)

I'm probably one of the people that would be categorized as a techno-libertarian (even though I don't live in SV), but I get downvotes all the time as well.

This community is a lot more diverse than just the techno-libertarian crowd. There's no lack of people in opposition to the techno-libertarianism as well downvoting the techno-libertarian comments and upvoting those in opposition to the techno-libertarian comments.

Basically I downvoted this comment for presenting the situation as one where only their views are getting downvoted excessively because they believe themselves to be in the minority when my experience clearly falsifies the assumption that it's only non-techno-libertarian comments being downvoted.

Furthermore, HNers tend to downvote comments that speculate on why things are being downvoted. The truth is that you have absolutely zero knowledge into why a comment was downvoted unless someone replies to say they downvoted and explains exactly why they did so like I just did. Anything other than that is pure baseless speculation and that doesn't get you very far in a community that prefers statements based on evidence.

Also, complaining about downvotes is known to get you downvoted because it's generally been observed to contribute negatively to the quality of discussion. You shouldn't complain about downvotes and instead you should add a comment where you argue your point better and try to gain karma with a new better comment than complaining about downvotes on a previous one that didn't succeed.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by mellosouls on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:10AM (#23859139)
I can't help wondering if some of the down-voting in this case is intended as ironic.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by Smithalicious on Thursday July 16, 2020 @11:49AM (#23860196)
As the old adage goes, "it's still shitposting even if you're being ironic".
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by prepend on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:09PM (#23866232)
Perhaps my longest internet commenting rule is “downvote people complaining about downvotes”
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by mellosouls on Friday July 17, 2020 @06:46AM (#23869184)
Its sometimes a fair complaint (if against HN guidelines) in an environment like this where you hope for a little bit more thought in when to down-vote.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by prepend on Saturday July 18, 2020 @09:23AM (#23881250)
Perhaps. But always off topic and almost always boring. When I think I’m unfairly downvoted, I just try to reply with more detail and accounting for more possible interpretations. Or I move on.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by edanm on Thursday July 16, 2020 @09:41AM (#23858848)
I don't know. People were sharing ridiculous and untrue stories via email, via sms, etc.

Is it the "buttons" or the "gamification" that is driving the change in scale? Or is it just that there are more people online, with easier access to sharing content, and perhaps also - easier access to creating content?

I really don't know the answer to this, but it seems like everyone always blames social media, whereas I think the problem is basically a people-problem, not a tech-problem - give more people a voice, and you might not like what you hear.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by coffeefirst on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:56AM (#23859604)
Correct. If you signup for newsletters or read the news on their websites, or open their in-house app, the GP comment is wrong, there are lot's of newsrooms doing solid work, and what the article is circling is the burden of proof for stating "this official lied" as a fact.

If you're looking at social media newsfeeds all day, the algorithm is going to emphasize the things people are passionate about sharing. The people you follow become your front-page editor.

In the end, GP's perception is more about what he's reading and how he's receiving it than what real reporters do every day.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by p1necone on Thursday July 16, 2020 @05:47PM (#23864182)
Without the downvote HN would descend into flame war bullshit pretty quickly (imo). Things that don't outright break the rules can still be low effort and subtly hostile.

Most heavily downvoted posts I see on here tend to be people transparently arguing in bad faith, or being unnecessarily rude in ways that aren't quite obvious enough to attract proper moderation.

Sure sometimes it's just opinions that most people disagree with, but overall I think the downvote button is a positive force (and the comments are still there, you can judge for yourself if they were worth it).

(If you want to see all the terrible comments that get posted, turn on the showdead option on your user profile. Otherwise you get an unrealistically sunny view of the quality of discourse here).

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by andrepd on Thursday July 16, 2020 @09:38AM (#23858815)
Of course. What purpose does the downvote button serve? If the post is breaking the rules, you should report/flag it. If its not, you shouldn't downvote.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by peatmoss on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:13AM (#23859163)
I think the idea is that downvotes require a minimum level of karma (and thus ideally habituation to Hacker News norms around not simply downvoting content that you disagree with).

But... I don’t always see that being applied. I regularly upvote graying content that I vehemently disagree with if the commenter is making an earnest point in a respectful way. I do sometimes wish that the downvote button came with a selection box for what norm was being violated, because I think downvotes should require more thought and carry a little more friction.

That said, a friend asked me just yesterday if HN was the last place on the Internet I still comment, and I realized it is. On balance, I find the discourse and application of voting to be generally acceptable and better than other forums that I’ve mostly given up on.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by elliekelly on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:04AM (#23859087)
What about when a post isn’t breaking the rules but is factually incorrect?

If I comment that the earth is flat or that the sun revolves around the moon I would expect that comment to be filtered out by the community rather than something to bother the mods about.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by goalieca on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:12AM (#23859162)
I've seen downvotes that are applied to factually correct information but that goes against the herd. A simple rebuttal would suffice as we tend to do in the technical stories. Political stories on this site are insufferable.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by malandrew on Thursday July 16, 2020 @12:12PM (#23860423)
Regardless of where you stand on a situation, advocacy is unavoidable in political stories. You can be 100% factually correct, but still commit sins of advocacy and partisanship like omitting factual information or misrepresenting factual information.

About the only comments that remain factually accurate without committing sins of advocacy in political stories are those that acknowledge that the issue is complicated, that there are many sides and that there isn't anything conclusive.

The more certain/convicted about an issue a commenter comes, the more likely they are going to get downvoted in political stories. My observation is that those comments that practice the principle of charity with their interlocutors are those that are more likely to be upvoted. How you say something is more important than what you're saying if you're trying to reach common understanding in earnest.

Technical stories generally don't have positions and advocacy except advocacy in favor of intellectual curiosity.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by MisterBastahrd on Thursday July 16, 2020 @04:29PM (#23863486)
There's data that is factually correct but contextually useless in a vacuum to the point of being harmful when cited for advocacy reasons. It's not difficult to figure out when people cite that data and why.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by bluGill on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:15AM (#23859184)
What about claims that small rocks fall at the same speed as heavy rocks? That is something true that everybody incorrectly thinks is false.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by fsflover on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:25AM (#23859281)
If you show proofs, you typically will not get downvoted.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by acheron on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:12AM (#23859157)
It's to cut down on the tedious arguments. If someone posts something stupid, you could get into a long, drawn-out argument with them that goes nowhere and clutters up the comments, or you just click downvote and move on. Same reason for upvoting rather than "posting 'me too' like some brain-dead AOLer". [0]

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpMvS1Q1sos

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by dpifke on Thursday July 16, 2020 @07:12PM (#23864960)
I downvote comments which I think don't add anything to the conversation. Lately I find myself downvoting comments which try to interject U.S. politics—of any ideological stripe—into discussions of non-political topics.

I don't think the commentators are "breaking the rules," per se, but they aren't contributing positively. I'm sure they feel their political opinion is being suppressed, but my votes reflect that I come here for technical insights, not politics.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by prepend on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:11PM (#23866245)
In face to face situations there’s way to express disapproval. Downvotes let people express their displeasure with a comment.

When only upvotes exist, it’s very difficult to remove bad content. It also favors vapid, pleasing posts that will easily get upvotes.

Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by p1necone on Thursday July 16, 2020 @07:06PM (#23864911)
It's an important stand in for what would happen in real life conversation, but can't in the same way online. Awkward silence, confused/upset looks, a muttered "what the fuck dude" etc.
Re:How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion by malandrew on Thursday July 16, 2020 @11:30AM (#23859976)
I still want downvotes to exist, but I'm especially interested in being able to identify comments that oscillate in the sense that they get many competing votes.

I have a fair amount of karma on HN, but in the past few years that karma plateaued and I find myself getting as many upvotes as I did before, but now more downvotes.

I'm sure that I'm not the only one that has experienced seeing their comments oscillate between black and grey.