News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by rplnt on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:48AM (#23701266)
Don't know about 1983, but a lot of software is definitely slower than it was 10, 20 years ago.

Something that used to result in 2MB application with 5MB in memory requirement is now done as half a gigabyte of resources that will spawn dozens of processes totaling at least 1GB of memory. Sure, computers are faster, but not by that much apparently.

Looking at all those electron (et al) apps. Cheap to write beats user experience I guess.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by lordCarbonFiber on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:06AM (#23701445)
If 5MB of memory means swaping out to a floppy disk 30 years ago and 1GB usage doesn't today because your macbook has 32gb of ram the older program is still going to be slower. I think there's an important distinction between "modern programs could be faster" (which is unambiguously true) and "modern programs are slower than older programs or even analogue equivalents" which ends up often relying of invalid comparisons or rose colored glasses about what computing was like.

Often times what's being optimized for isn't even the speed of experience and maybe that's ok. Chrome spawns a million processes so if a tab crashes it doesn't end your browsing session, VS code being written in electron means writing plugins is a breeze and thus has built a thriving ecosystem in a record amount of time. If nothing else the world of software is a lot more flexible in 2020 than 1990 and maybe people prefer that to raw speed (given there's not a huge demand for native terminal based applications there's an argument to be made)

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by jonhohle on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:28AM (#23701703)
Has document writing or spreadsheet creation changed much since the 90s? Word and Excel 6 were significantly faster than current versions and were running on PCs with 8 or 16MB of RAM and, at least for my use cases, did effectively the same job they do today. In some cases they did it better.

How has document creation changed in two decades that justifies two orders of magnitude more RAM and CPU performance, 10x power draw, etc.?

If your house was built with 100x the resources and consumed that much more power, and it took longer to turn on the lights or cook a meal would it be justified because the building process was easier and you could add new light fixtures more easily? That would be lunacy, but for some reason we think it’s OK in software to avoid the craftsmanship the profession demands while treat users like fools who should just accept that computers are faster so their apps should be slower. It’s garbage reasoning. The ergonomics of developers should always come second to providing the best for customers.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by philipkglass on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:09PM (#23703857)
It's hard to stay in business offering a product that touts "fewer features, but smaller memory footprint and snappier UI response" vs. its competitors. There are a few exceptions to this rule, but they are exceptional. That's why organizations pay for big, slow Slack instead of using fast, free, svelte IRC clients.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by jonhohle on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:32PM (#23706252)
In other industries these are things that become commodities. They aren't thrown out and replaced with something new, the business move into a different phase (or shed that business to someone else willing to take the role).
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by selectodude on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:41AM (#23701862)
>10x power draw

I can run xlookup functions on a 1000 row excel spreadsheet on my cell phone.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by jonhohle on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:08AM (#23702236)
Amazing, isn’t it? Yet somehow a 100w i9 is doing things at nearly the same perceived speed as a 10w Pentium.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by rplnt on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:56AM (#23702053)
The random numbers were just that, random numbers. Startup times are noticeably slower. Even with fast SSDs, many multi-GB apps that run in background can get swapped out, and that's still slower than RAM decades ago.

> Chrome spawns a million processes so if a tab crashes it doesn't end your browsing session

This one is funny, because

1) before Chrome pages didn't seem to crash (js could, but not the whole "page")

2) Chrome still crashes completely loads of times

(also it's not really related; Chrome is a fast application written relatively effectively)

But I get your point, and you are not wrong. I just wouldn't discount "cheap development" to be the primary reason.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by misterS on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:05AM (#23701435)
I'm not disagreeing, but just because something uses more memory does not mean it's slower per se.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by morganvachon on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:10AM (#23702265)
It may not be slower, but it's definitely less efficient.

You can really see the loss of efficiency in modern software by using the same program/application on a modern machine vs a 10 or 15 year old machine. I have a couple of older laptops (2001 era Dell Latitude CPx with a PIII 500MHz, 2011 Lenovo Ideapad netbook with the Atom N450 1.6GHz) that I will occasionally play around with. I've found that most of what the article author said applies; textual interfaces with minimal or no mouse usage runs perfectly well on either of those old beasts, even with code written in 2020 and optimized for modern hardware. The "suckless" suite of tools in particular (dwm, st, surf, etc.) make those otherwise unusable machines into something approaching modern workstation utility. You don't want to even try to run any modern graphically rich software on those devices as you'll be frustrated immediately, and it will be clear just how bloated and unnecessary a lot of modern design has become.

I feel as long as we keep advancing in raw computing power, the software can be allowed to grow and make use of the extra power, but we will eventually reach a standoff where the hardware stops advancing and at that point we will need to focus on reducing, not increasing, software bloat if we wish to maintain efficiency.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by abiogenesis on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:57PM (#23708307)
Actually it does albeit indirectly, because you are not running a single application on a modern computer. When they all start starving for memory they get slower.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by timw4mail on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:17AM (#23701560)
Memory speed does not increase as fast as CPU performance.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by ourlordcaffeine on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:04AM (#23702172)
Some colleagues of mine were having ram issues:

Running slack, rstudio, atom and a browser was almost maxing out an 8gb machine.

Why does an IM client need over a gig of ram?

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by celeritascelery on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:43PM (#23703498)
Because electron. Developers have become so focused on ease of development they forget about delighting their customers.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by The_Colonel on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:59AM (#23701382)
I miss some concrete examples.

What exactly was faster to do 20 years ago than now?

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by burntoutfire on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:09AM (#23701465)
Scrolling text in text editors. Was always buttersmooth on 7 MHz Amiga. Is choppy in many of today's IDEs. I get that IDE does more than a text editor, but it would be great if adding extra features would not compromise existing ones.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by The_Colonel on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:15AM (#23701539)
So apples to oranges.

Adding features will almost inevitably make software slower. Sometimes the difference is smaller, sometimes larger.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by new2628 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:23AM (#23701653)
I guess the underlying point is that in the same time period CPU speed has increased thousandfold, so you'd expect that to compensate for the few extra features that were added.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by The_Colonel on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:25AM (#23701671)
IDEs don't have "extra few features", they have massive amount of functionality added.

"extra few features" would fit more to likes of vim.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by rplnt on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:48AM (#23701942)
Bare syntax highlighting in a text editor on a large file. Nothing extra fancy like indexing or analysis. Not an issue 15 years ago, in VS code you can scroll faster than that.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by The_Colonel on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:53AM (#23702009)
Which editor did you use? I mean I definitely remember scrolling issues 15 years ago on a large file with syntax highlighting.

I used e.g. gedit (linux) and pspad (windows) during that time and both completely froze on larger files.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by rplnt on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:09AM (#23702248)
Let's go with emojis in Slack. That was not an issue in any chat sowftware offering them decades ago. In 2020 I can't have them enabled on MacBook Pro, because if someone were to use many of them, the CPU usage would spike (A LOT), even on background. Since this has been the case for at least three years now, I don't consider it a random bug, but rather an issue with the technologies used.

As mentioned in a reply bellow, syntax highlighting is a feature that was (and is) blazingly fast in every software except atom-based editors. Startup times are atrocious too.

Spotify.

And as mentioned in my comment, speed can be influenced by the size or memory requirements. And that becomes issue on its own when you want to use multiple of these applications. I constantly run into full ram and swapping with 16GB. Mostly caused by web applications, but the root cause is the same. Size on disk (or when updating) also matters on phones a lot.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by andi999 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:13AM (#23701511)
Here is one: when you switched on a C64, the booting(startup) took probably less than 3 seconds. Booting a notebook these days takes longer (luckily it is not as bad as when we didnt have SSDs).

But generally I do not think the premise is correct. Loading a game from a datasette took easily 15 minutes (later there was acceleration only a few minutes)

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by marcosdumay on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:24AM (#23701663)
Loading a game from a floopy was much faster than loading a modern game as soon as floppies became popular enough to carry games.

Loading a game from a cardigde (what was usual at the time) was much faster than anything we use now, but this is not a fair comparison.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by pdimitar on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:38AM (#23701827)
Why isn't it a fair comparison? If my mother's only criteria is how fast does something load then why should she care about anything else?

It's a fact that nowadays a lot of apps are very slow, on computers and phones alike -- and socially and culturally that's unacceptable for non-technical people.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by The_Colonel on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:43AM (#23701882)
If the speed is the only criterium then you can just play old games.

It's not fair comparison since the games are completely different beasts today - huge open worlds, detailed textures, complex AIs.

Game studios could design games which are super fast to load and play but some other aspect would suffer instead. It's a trade off and it looks like users are OK with waiting a little bit if it means better gameplay.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by pdimitar on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:55AM (#23702031)
Okay, but how did games enter this global thread's discussion? That's definitely way off-topic.

My mom simply wanted instantly loading calendar and grocery list apps. I know that's achievable because I've done (parts of) such apps in the past and they were faster than others.

It's not such a stretch to imagine people being frustrated with lags everywhere (and those lags do objectively exist). And I've met a good amount of people frustrated with the current breed of software as well.

Modern apps don't bring almost anything new or improved to the table. They should be lightning fast but they are not.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by marcosdumay on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:32PM (#23704129)
> Why isn't it a fair comparison?

Cartiges don't have a loading time, and are a technology that is available today, but that people abandoned because they are expensive and difficult to update.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by pdimitar on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:52PM (#23704335)
All true. I just feel we lost something along the way of ditching the old tech. Responsiveness, less input lag, stuff that you don't dread will spit out a cryptic message while rebooting... And another metric ton of these.

:(

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by marcosdumay on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:24PM (#23706135)
Oh, by all means, things should load faster today than what we got with floppy disks, and response should be faster than what we got in an interpreted program in a 8MHz machine.

It's just the load time of cartiges that aren't a fair goal.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by miltondts on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:38AM (#23701824)
Visual studio startup and debugging. Source: https://youtu.be/GC-0tCy4P1U
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by The_Colonel on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:10AM (#23702264)
IDEs are I think a good example. There were IDEs in the 80s and 90s but they are very different from now.

For example back then they did not index files at startup since there was no function for that (like "find references"). These days IDEs provide a lot of "intelligence" and static analysis for which you need memory, a lot of reads and processing.

So yeah, I guess VS got slower but it's because it's now doing much more (useful) things.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by vivab0rg on Thursday July 02, 2020 @12:53PM (#23715229)
Golden video. Thanks for this.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by hazz99 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:15AM (#23701534)
> Cheap to write beats user experience I guess.

I think it'd be more accurate to say value to the user beats the cost to write the software, which then beats user experience.

Something can offer a lot of value and use but still be a pain to use.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by programAgaib on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:07AM (#23701454)
As I write a program in react native, I realize the problem is at least half attributed to Apple.

Having to make Apps that will get published and not banned, all while trying to keep costs low forces developers into JavaScript solutions.

If it was low cost to develop a native iPhone app, this would not be an issue.

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by rbrtl on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:18AM (#23701579)
As you "program" in React Native, are you really qualified to speak on who "at least half" of the issues are attributed to?

What do you mean when you say that the problem is half Apple's fault? Or, like every other comment your account hasd made in the last 24-48 hours, is it just an attempt to start an Apple flamewar?

Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by oarsinsync on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:18AM (#23701570)
What's the high cost to develop a native iPhone app? Having to learn the language?
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by rbrtl on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:19AM (#23701591)
Or perhaps the $100 Developer account fee
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by jsymolon on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:29AM (#23701721)
Constant hardware upgrades.
Re:Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower tha... by abiogenesis on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @08:02PM (#23708342)
Buy a Mac?